The Objectivist Rhetoric

To update you guys, I have submitted a completely rewritten, second thesis proposal to my thesis director. For my first proposal I thought I would find metaphorical usage of your axiomatic statement EXISTENCE is IDENTITY (and its corollaries), but my reasoning in this post made me change my mind. Besides, my professors could not understand the abstractions anyway.

 

From my second proposal, following is a piece I wrote. I am posting it here, so you can know that I am not trying to hide anything from you. But please remember that this was written for NON-Objectivists and it is NOT a thesis yet, so you can give your comments/feedback, which may still affect what will go on the thesis.

 


 

Ayn Rand and Her Critics

 

            Since the release of her two major novels–The Fountainhead and Atlas Shrugged–the philosopher-novelist Ayn Rand entered the public scene as a controversial figure–a radical for capitalism, as she called herself (Burns, 2009:Ch.7). She quickly won attention and admiration of the public, but most of the academia did not accept her philosophy of Objectivism. Since then, much criticism has been written, exploring the phenomenon of Objectivism: many biographical accounts exploring her life, both in America and in the Soviet Union, from where she immigrated, and other works related to her philosophy and written by her followers. The literature selected for this project was picked on the basis of balanced and comprehensive coverage of the main topics directly related to Objectivism. The two major critical, professional analyses are: William O’Neill’s With Charity Toward None: An Analysis of Ayn Rand’s Philosophy, which was originally published in 1971 and is one of the earliest works dealing with Objectivism; and Scott Ryan’s Objectivism and the Corruption of Rationality: A Critique of Ayn Rand’s Epistemology, which is a more recent analysis that compares Objectivism with a wide range of other philosophies. The most recent and intriguing biography of Ms. Rand selected is Jennifer Burns’s Goddess of the Market: Ayn Rand and the American Right. There are also three salient articles written by professionals, two of whom were affiliated with Ms. Rand, and two books by Objectivists with uncommon interpretations of her philosophy.

            William O’Neill’s With Charity Toward None: An Analysis of Ayn Rand’s Philosophy was the second book-length criticism of Objectivism written while Ms. Rand was still alive. Its unique stance is a consideration of both logical and scientific entailments of the fundamental principles of Objectivism (O’Neill, 1977:10). The work is written in clear, objective manner with a segmentation of most of the material in numbered parts, and there are many quotes from official Objectivist sources. The analysis is presented as if it was given from a point of view of an Objectivist and does not make ungrounded attacks, although its scientific sources are not exhaustive. The strengths of Ms. Rand’s philosophy, O’Neill writes, are the correctness and relevancy of Ms. Rand’s questions that deal with “alienation, conformity and the deteriorating state of modern philosophy,” her provocative thinking that intellectually stimulated the society, insightful and courageous ideas, her “refreshingly abrasive” view, and her overall formidable accomplishment (ibid., 13ff). These are all strengths of Objectivism that would be otherwise obscured by the negative analysis. “Despite vast and fatal flaws, [Ms. Rand] had succeeded in presenting a philosophy which is simple, original, clearly defined and (at least implicitly) systematic . . . surprisingly comprehensive, coherent and consistent” (16). Nonetheless, although it could have been a masterpiece, Objectivism is judged by O’Neill a failure.

            All the salient points of Objectivism are outlined from the start: 1. Metaphysics: Objective Reality; 2. Epistemology: Reason; 3. Ethics: Self-interest; 4. Politics: Capitalism (18, original emphasis). O’Neill compares Objectivism to the Platonic tradition in contrast to Aristotelianism for two reasons: 1) all truth is discovered by “the perception of essential truth as a process of identification” rather than discovering it by perceptual creation of essential similarities; and 2) “a priori knowledge of ultimate reality exists” (85, original emphasis). Although Ms. Rand was inspired by Aristotle’s laws of logic and his metaphysics of existence, she retained them as the axioms of reality in her implication: Existence is Identity. However, Aristotle conceptualized the law of identity, contradiction, and excluded middle to be used for meaningful and consistent communications, but he did not mean “that a term is a thing–rather that [o]ne thing should stand for just one idea at one time” (126f, original emphasis). Instead, Ms. Rand interpreted Aristotelian implication as an inference and conflated existence and identity through an ambiguity of the verb “is.” This fact makes Objectivist axioms meaningless and impossible to refute.

            Her axiomatic concepts of existence, identity, and consciousness have no “specifiable content . . . [t]hey are merely tautological hyperabstractions (meta-definitions) . . . ultimate [irreducible] abstractions and therefore have no identifiable attributes which allow for further analysis or specification” (116). In contrast to Aristotle, Objectivist axiomatic truths are not only “rooted in metaphysics” but are “determined epistemologically,” making “all additional knowledge . . . essentially secondary and supplementary” (117). Being unable to refute Objectivist truths and having them switch the base of knowledge to metaphysics makes Objectivism into a fundamentally anti-scientific philosophy (12). With a conflation of a posterior rationalizations and a priori truths, “oughtness” and “isness,” fact and meaning, false dichotomies of producers and consumers, egoism and altruism, and self-contradictions on the topic of compromise, O’Neill describes Objectivist philosophy as vacillating between “experiential relativism and mystical intuitionism” (110) and that Rand is oblivious to these facts (186).

            Another major critical analysis of Objectivism is Scott Ryan’s Objectivism and the Corruption of Rationality: A Critique of Ayn Rand’s Epistemology. Published in 2003, it is one of the most elaborate philosophical analyses that draws on a list of previous criticisms, the most comprehensive bibliography of Objectivist works, and many other philosophical volumes. Ryan explores Objectivism from the point of view of rationalist philosopher Brand Blanshard, whom Ms. Rand had read and “somewhat approved” of his views on reason (25). However, Ryan states that the philosophies of Blanshard and Objectivism are incompatible and opposite in key points.

            The main issue that Ryan finds in Objectivism is the unresolved problem of the universals. Instead of facing this as a metaphysical problem, Rand put it under her epistemology, ignoring the fact whether her implicit concepts required existence as real universals. By real universals, Ryan means “features of reality that are actually ‘inherent in things’” (36). Because of this issue, there is a major confusion of concepts and referents in Objectivism. In other words, Rand “conflates the question what constitutes knowledge with the question under what conditions knowledge becomes psychologically possible” (33). “[A]xiomatic concepts,” Ryan claims, “are an exception to Rand’s usual rules for concepts: concepts don’t change, but axiomatic concepts do” (190; cf. Rand, 1990:Ch.6). Her axiomatic premise “existence exists” is basically meaningless and cannot be used to infer the existence of matter independent of our minds (250). However, Rand “must presume the existence of real universals in the very process of trying to demonstrate that we do not need them” (91), and, so, “her allegedly ‘epistemological’ account depends on a good deal of implicit metaphysics” (107). Concepts, for Rand, are formed for all time and refer across time and space to all entities, and “this approach affords a handy way to become instantly omniscient” (113). Fundamentally, although Objectivists deny it, Ryan conjunctures that Objectivism was made to avoid theism (23ff, 141). This lack of theism is rationalized by Ryan as “an unbridgeable chasm between mind and reality,” an inconsistency that is ignored (209).

            A common argumentative trait of Rand is that she “attaches a ‘rider’ to a position, rejects or refutes the ‘rider,’ and seems to think she has thereby rejected or refuted the position itself” (37). This way, Rand can impose her own meaning and misrepresent ideas of others without exposing the flaws or inadequacies of her own philosophy. Just as it was for O’Neill, it is very hard to categorize Objectivism. The kind of oblivious vacillation that O’Neill noticed about Objectivism is also present in the analysis by Ryan, namely, that “Rand repeatedly shifts back and forth between the contents of her own mind and the contents of ‘objective reality’ without ever noticing the difference” (208).[1] But in contrast to O’Neill’s logical and scientific analysis of Objectivism, Ryan uses a deep theistic and philosophical criticism. Ryan identifies Rand’s philosophy as “a sort of nominalistic, materialistic empiricism,” used to criticize everyone else, especially theists, and “rationalistic objective idealism/quasi-Spinozism,” used to protect her from criticism (231, 350f). Overall, Ryan states that Rand’s “commitment to atheism has seriously affected and undermined her philosophical judgment” (231f). Her philosophy is anti-religious, although she borrowed a “flavor” of religion by replacing the term “God” with her reality as “the authoritative absolute” and termed “man” as “the object of worship” (328). Among strengths, Ryan sees Rand’s work on the free market–Capitalism: The Unknown Ideal–to be the best of her non-fiction (305), but her philosophical writings are “a muddle of confusion, misunderstanding, and bad introspection” (316). She also had “an undeniable ability to portray her foils vividly and to make the reader loathe them as much as she did” (346).

            Jennifer Burns’s biography of Ayn Rand, Goddess of the Market: Ayn Rand and the American Right, explores Rand’s strained and virtually nonexistent relationships with her peers in school, her academic prowess and genius in argumentation (e.g., pp.22, 30, 164f), her negative attitude toward her mother and removed admiration of her father, her inclination to cut ties with her family after she moved to the U.S. (e.g., pp.58, 326), and her abandonment of friendships with people who influenced her ideas and whom she met in America. For example, the conflicts she had with Isabel Paterson, a popular journalist who helped Rand in many ways and was one of her teachers, caused their relationship to weaken, end, and never to rejuvenate againt because of Rand’s anti-theistic views, her independence and self-sufficient nature (146, 152). Burns also stresses the influence of Nietzsche’s “transvaluation of values and his call for a new morality” (330, Ch.2) on Rand throughout her career, even though Rand and her followers claimed that she had abandoned Nietzsche’s philosophy in her early thirties (Ryan, 2003:310ff). “Translated by Rand into fiction, Nietzsche’s transvaluation of values changed criminals into heroes and rape into love” (Burns, 2009:37). Burns’s main thesis shows that Rand wanted to create a rational alternative to religion and intended, after Nietzsche, her writings as scripture (ibid., 307). Although Burns’s book is somewhat critical of Objectivism–a religious mood can be found in lines such as: “Objectivism as a philosophy left no room for elaboration, extension, or interpretation, and as a social world it excluded growth, change, or development” (15)–Burns nonetheless argues that Objectivism is historically significant. Rand had inspired a large following, started new movements and greatly influenced other philosophies, such as libertarianism, and her ideas are now selectively applied by conservatives.

            The “cult” that Rand created and maintained in the 60s–called The Nathaniel Branden Institute (NBI)–was at the height of her career. The nature of this “cult” had been criticized in many accounts, two of which were written by former Objectivist members. Murray Rothbard’s The Sociology of the Ayn Rand Cult mainly deals with the negative aspects of Rand’s establishment and how “the grim, robotic, joyless Randian Man emerged.” Rothbard was a libertarian economist who was at first very interested in Objectivism and praised Rand’s genius, as did many others, but whose conflicts with Rand and her right-hand man at the time, Nathaniel Branden, made him despise it (Burns, 2009:198). Rand also broke up with Branden and even consequently closed the institute they both formed. Branden’s The Benefits and Hazards of the Philosophy of Ayn Rand: A Personal Statement was published after Rand had passed away. It deals with the flawed psychology employed by them together at the institute–how they caused their followers to repress emotions, encourage dogmatism and Rand’s “scientific conservatism, a suspicion of novelty”–but nonetheless he defends the positive nature of her philosophy, “a powerful message of hope in her work,” affirmation of existence, and glorification of human potential. After he broke with Rand, Branden created his own, and also quite popular, self-esteem movement. On the other hand, helping some people avoid Objectivism, a review of one of Rand’s philosophical books was written by an anti-communist philosopher Sidney Hook–it was called Each Man For Himself. Hook was one of philosophers to whom Rand previously reached out, but he was disappointed by “Rand’s desire for complete agreement with her ideas and her single-minded focus on consistency” (Burns, 2009:200). Hook wrote the review as a rebuttal of her ideas. His criticism was comprehensive, albeit short. Among some memorable lines, he compared her axiom of “existence exists” to “the law of gravitation is heavy and the formula of sugar sweet.”

            The 90s saw the first schism among Objectivists after Rand had passed away. David Kelley was ex-communicated by the fundamental Objectivists, led by Rand’s intellectual heir–Leonard Peikoff. However, Kelley continued being devoted to Objectivism and even created his own Objectivist institute, but he differentiated himself as an “open” Objectivist versus “closed” ones like Peikoff. Surprisingly, Kelley also found that the “closed” Objectivists showed “tribalist[ic]” tendencies and complete intolerance toward non-Objectivists of similar beliefs, such as libertarians (Kelley, 2000:Ch.5). In his book, The Contested Legacy of Ayn Rand: Truth and Toleration in Objectivism, Kelley puts forward his own interpretation of truth and moral judgment, deeming it not in conflict with Rand’s original views, and differentiates his views as more open to correction by science than the “closed” Objectivism.[2]

            One of the most recent books published on the topic of Objectivism is Marc Gerstein’s Atlas Upgrades: Objectivism 2.0. Gerstein, an Objectivist aficionado, puts forward new arguments and ideas against Objectivism, but instead of abandoning the philosophy altogether, he reinterprets it as politically moderate. There are three stages that Ryan associates with Rand: Rand number One, the novelist, whom he judges to be “an inspirational genius,” Rand number Two, the philosopher, who “had some decent ideas,” but was lacking in terms of conclusions and vulnerability of imprecision, and Rand number Three, the policy maker, who “is the most troublesome . . . shallow at best and disastrous at worst” (Gerstein, 2013:11). In contrast to Scott Ryan, Gerstein claims that Rand’s fiction works are the best and her ideas in the nonfiction book Capitalism: The Unknown Ideal are “hopelessly flawed” compared to her other philosophical works. From the jurisprudential and economic backgrounds, Gerstein disagrees with Rand in implementation of her philosophy without “a strong economic foundation” and criticizes her grey area in politics that she calls “philosophy of law” (224). He opposes the gold standard due to its material limitations on economy and supports mixed economy for its mature growth and interconnectedness. He favors psychological egoism, or altruism, which he believes, similar to O’Neill, she misunderstood. On the basis of The Fountainhead and Atlas Shrugged, Gerstein changes Rand’s “four pillars”–“Metaphysics, Epistemology, Ethics, and Politics” to “Process, Ethics, Politics, and Economics” in his own, more balanced vision of Objectivism (65).

 

[1] This vacillation, as these critics see it, is perhaps due to Rand’s way of integrating rationalism and empiricism, similar to what Immanuel Kant had attempted to do. While Objectivism leans more toward rationalism, Kantianism leans more toward empiricism.

[2] Roderick Fitts, with some help of others, countered Kelley’s arguments by calling him a skeptic, reinterpreting the closed system as open to applications, and noting Kelley’s “frozen abstraction” fallacy of taking religious totalitarianism to be the abstracted closed system (“Closed System vs. Open System: Why the Open System Fails,” available at <http://umso.wordpress.com/2008/08/04/closed-system-vs-open-system-why-the-open-system-fails-part-1-of-5>).