Existence exists subsidiary thread

It’s very problematic to work with “Existence is Identity” because there are no rules of logic for this statement, which is both a logical identity and an implication, it’s both one value and two values. Very confusing. We know, from Peikoff, that existence is everything, and at the same time we know that existence is something. If it were a pure implication, then we could say that if existence, then everything, or not everything, therefore not existence. But existence is Identity, so we cannot use modus tollens here. We cannot say that something is Identity, even though we know that Identity is something. Do you see my confusion now? Or does this all pass you by without a tingling of fascination?

Existent, then, is not existence, but existence is existent. Can you explain to me what’s the extra in existence that is not existent?

“Existent” is a singular, existing thing.  “Existence” is the sum of every existing thing, treated as if it were singular even though it really isn’t.

 

Maybe so. It is peculiar, though, that a true statement will be: everything is not existence.

No; that’s false.  The accurate statement is that “not every thing is existence”. 

“Everything” can mean the sum of everything (which is “existence”), but sometimes means any thing.  If you exploit that ambiguity (and negate “existence” instead of the quantifier) then it essentially means that “nothing exists”.

 

It’s a cheap gag that hinges on deliberately brutalizing the English language.

 

So, maybe you can teach me some, as well.

 

No.

“Existent” is a singular, existing thing.  “Existence” is the sum of every existing thing, treated as if it were singular even though it really isn’t.

 

No; that’s false.  The accurate statement is that “not every thing is existence”. 

“Everything” can mean the sum of everything (which is “existence”), but sometimes means any thing.  If you exploit that ambiguity (and negate “existence” instead of the quantifier) then it essentially means that “nothing exists”.

 

It’s a cheap gag that hinges on deliberately brutalizing the English language.

 

 

No.

Peikoff wrote that everything is something, paraphrasing existence is existent. So we have implication that existence is everything, and existent is something, not the other way around.

 

However, now you are saying that “the sum of everything” is existence. If that’s the case, how is that different from my Premise 1: All existents are existence?

 

P.S. And stop making your false conclusions about me. If you had read the thread on Integrating Objectivism and Science, you would have learned that I defined “everything” as not every (one) thing. This metaphysical stupidity of making everything into something is purely Objectivist, not mine.

You’re equivocating on the relationship between existents and existence.

 

While all oranges are existents, only some existents are oranges. The units of existence are all existents, including the existents that are not oranges.

 

Do not take this as denying the existence of an orange. The existence of an orange only demonstrates that an orange is one existent of existence.

 

If you are really interested in learning about ontologically based logic, I would recommend Peikoff’s “Introduction to Logic”. At 35¢ per minute, it’s cheaper than a new automobile buys you at ~50¢ per mile (based on amount of time to walk a mile vs. drive one at 60 m.p.h. or a mile a minute [calculated around 1985]).

I will check out Peikoff’s course. But before I do, would you please explain, in light of your two definitions, whether my definitions are wrong?

 

Your definitions:

  1. All oranges are existents.

  2. Some existents are oranges.

 

My definitions:

  1. An orange is an existent.

  2. All existents are existence.

However, now you are saying that “the sum of everything” is existence. If that’s the case, how is that different from my Premise 1: All existents are existence?

 

It removes the ambiguity which allows you to come to the conclusion that one orange is the universe.

As an aside to anyone else who’s spending their time on this, when Rand talked about ‘attaching a clear and specific meaning to the words you use’, this is an excellent demonstration of why.

It removes the ambiguity which allows you to come to the conclusion that one orange is the universe.

OK. Then the sum cannot be broken down into specific existents to be called existence. And this is exactly the view of my philosophy, not yours, because in my philosophy spacetime plays a role that no existent can have.

 

You say that existence is the universe. Is the universe existence? Existence is the universe or any other existent, since existence is the sum of everything (in your definition) or something (in Peikoff’s definition). But in reverse, the sum of everything is existence, but not something is existence. Does it make perfect sense to you that your “definitions” are not equal?

By what you are telling me, Harrison, the following is an example of the necessary way you think:

 

Allow the fact that the following definition is exhaustive:

Rich (adj.) is “having wealth or great possessions.”

 

Say a poor person works his whole life and finally is, by imitating the definition above as closely as he can, “having wealth or great possessions.”

 

If you do not contradict yourself, you say that the person who began poor is NOT rich. Your implicit reasoning is that a definition cannot precede the percept it defines. Your logic: existence first, then definition; percept first, then definition.

I will check out Peikoff’s course. But before I do, would you please explain, in light of your two definitions, whether my definitions are wrong?

 

Your definitions:

  1. All oranges are existents.

  2. Some existents are oranges.

 

My definitions:

  1. An orange is an existent.

  2. All existents are existence.

I didn’t provide any definitions. Those are propositions, or premises as you accurately identify in the previous quote following this one.

 

Peikoff wrote that everything is something, paraphrasing existence is existent. So we have implication that existence is everything, and existent is something, not the other way around.

 

However, now you are saying that “the sum of everything” is existence. If that’s the case, how is that different from my Premise 1 : All existents are existence?

 

P.S. And stop making your false conclusions about me. If you had read the thread on Integrating Objectivism and Science, you would have learned that I defined “everything” as not every (one) thing. This metaphysical stupidity of making everything into something is purely Objectivist, not mine. <– and the irony increases. (added)

I do find a certain sense of irony in the postscript. 

1 Like

By what you are telling me, Harrison, the following is an example of the necessary way you think:

 

Allow the fact that the following definition is exhaustive:

Rich (adj.) is “having wealth or great possessions.”

 

Say a poor person works his whole life and finally is, by imitating the definition above as closely as he can, “having wealth or great possessions.”

 

If you do not contradict yourself, you say that the person who began poor is NOT rich.

 

That’s actually the opposite of what I would think (although if you’d like to try again, I don’t mind being the subject of a dissection).

 

Your implicit reasoning is that a definition cannot precede the percept it defines. Your logic: existence first, then definition; percept first, then definition.

 

Yes.  I’ll make that explicit right now, for you:  you can’t define a damn thing that you’ve never seen or heard of before.

 

If you do not contradict yourself, you say that the person who began poor is NOT rich. Your implicit reasoning is that a definition cannot precede the percept it defines. Your logic: existence first, then definition; percept first, then definition.

 

So you believe that I believe that poor people can never become rich, regardless of how much they earn, because that would contradict the fact that perception is the basis of all knowledge. . .

 

You’re wrong, though, because the answer is 42!!!

I didn’t provide any definitions. Those are propositions, or premises as you accurately identify in the previous quote following this one.

 

I do find a certain sense of irony in the postscript. 

OK, premises. If all existents are either a sum of existents or are some existent, as you imply in interpreting my Premise 1, then, by restricting “all” to a “sum,” not “any,” we can get Premise 2: An orange is an example of existent (as in “an orange is an example of something,” but “something is not an orange”). Would conclusion then be: An orange is an example of existence? Bah, all of this is ridiculous, since you avoid any logic whatsoever with all of your neither-true-nor-false (but both) premises. Aristotle never intended his logic to become a (neo)religious faith, like in your case.

 

That’s actually the opposite of what I would think (although if you’d like to try again, I don’t mind being the subject of a dissection).

 

 

Yes.  I’ll make that explicit right now, for you:  you can’t define a damn thing that you’ve never seen or heard of before.

 

 

So you believe that I believe that poor people can never become rich, regardless of how much they earn, because that would contradict the fact that perception is the basis of all knowledge. . .

 

You’re wrong, though, because the answer is 42!!!

Nah, Peikoff said that symbolic logic is corrupt and does not reflect reality, not realizing that by that statement he flouted Aristotelian logic as well. Your premises are not logical, they are arbitrary. Your position is to avoid logic, to retain the state of meaninglessness of your premises that you reify into something, which it’s not.

From Peikoff’s presentation on Logic:
Lecture 1: “If you hold a contradiction, you deny identity to the subject matter that you are discussing. A contradiction is the violation of identity.”
What about the new identity that is created? If it has no identity, it is nothing. Why can’t identities change from one thing to another (e.g., from tissues to organs, or bodies to groups)?
Law of contradiction: “nothing can be A and non-A.”
How come everything can be (the sum of) everything and something “at the same time”?

You advocate the premise of existence, but at the same time you say you cannot know all of reality. What really happens in your logic is that you irrationally know the Truth and are somehow not omniscient. The entirety of the premises of Objectivism are self-contradictory. The only time when you may be consistent is when you do not deal with your premises.

You advocate the premise of existence, but at the same time you say you cannot know all of reality. What really happens in your logic is that you irrationally know the Truth and are somehow not omniscient. The entirety of the premises of Objectivism are self-contradictory. The only time when you may be consistent is when you do not deal with your premises.

Poor Ilya. Did you not read the titles of the books that comprise Atlas Shrugged and realize two of them were Aristotelian principles of logic and one was the Aristotelian principle of identity?

Now, you claim:

P1: All existents are existence.

P2: An orange is an existent.

Concl: An orange is existence.

Now, P1 may be read in at least two different ways. One is: If x is an existent, then x is existence itself. Clearly this proposition is false. However, this is the exact way you use this proposition to conclude that an orange is all of existence.

Another way of interpreting P1 is: If x is the class of all existents, then x is all of existence. This formulation is more plausible, but in no sense is an orange the class of all existents. Therefore, you did not apply this meaning.

Part of the problem is your loose use of terminology. This common loose use of words is part of the reason for the existence of Objectivism. We can’t get very far if words do not have a specific meaning. Objectivism supposes that there is an objective reality and humans can develope objective concepts. Doing so is part of our means of survival.

 

How come everything can be (the sum of) everything and something “at the same time”?

 

I’m done.

Poor Ilya. Did you not read the titles of the books that comprise Atlas Shrugged and realize two of them were Aristotelian principles of logic and one was the Aristotelian principle of identity?

Now, you claim:

P1: All existents are existence.

P2: An orange is an existent.

Concl: An orange is existence.

Now, P1 may be read in at least two different ways. One is: If x is an existent, then x is existence itself. Clearly this proposition is false. However, this is the exact way you use this proposition to conclude that an orange is all of existence.

Another way of interpreting P1 is: If x is the class of all existents, then x is all of existence. This formulation is more plausible, but in no sense is an orange the class of all existents. Therefore, you did not apply this meaning.

Part of the problem is your loose use of terminology. This common loose use of words is part of the reason for the existence of Objectivism. We can’t get very far if words do not have a specific meaning. Objectivism supposes that there is an objective reality and humans can develope objective concepts. Doing so is part of our means of survival.

Atlas Shrugged: Part 1: NON-CONTRADICTION; Part 2: EITHER-OR; Part 3: A is A. All three are the logical laws of Aristotle, but shuffled.

 

Thank you for your analysis and help with my problem, though.

 

Let the class of all existents be the universe. Here are the definitions of the universe from dictionary.com:

  1. the totality of known or supposed objects and phenomena throughout space; the cosmos; macrocosm.

  2. the whole world, especially with reference to humanity: “a truth known throughout the universe.”

  3. a world or sphere in which something exists or prevails: “his private universe.”

  4. Also called universe of discourse. Logic. the aggregate of all the objects, attributes, and relations assumed or implied in a given discussion.

  5. Also called universal set. Mathematics. the set of all elements under discussion for a given problem.

  6. Statistics. the entire population under study.

 

Here are some more from British Dictionary:

  1. (astronomy) the aggregate of all existing matter, energy, and space

  2. human beings collectively

  3. a province or sphere of thought or activity

  4. (statistics) another word for population (sense 7)

Please pick one, so I can know the specific meaning of existence. Now, in my definition, the Universe (our universe) is Cosmos. Cosmos includes black holes, black matter and energy (which comprise 95% of the mass of the universe and are seen as vacuum), all stars and nebulae, etc. Today, astrophysicists do not know exactly the shape of the universe or how it looks exactly. All we know is the metagalaxy, also known as the observable universe. However, scientists know that before the Universe there was nothing, so this does not match with Objectivist assumtion that there was always something.

Here is an excellent presentation on how the Universe came from nothing (and that completely avoids the question of God):

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ImvlS8PLIo

From Peikoff’s presentation on Logic:

Lecture 1: “If you hold a contradiction, you deny identity to the subject matter that you are discussing. A contradiction is the violation of identity.”

What about the new identity that is created? If it has no identity, it is nothing. Why can’t identities change from one thing to another (e.g., from tissues to organs, or bodies to groups)?

Law of contradiction: “nothing can be A and non-A.”

How come everything can be (the sum of) everything and something “at the same time”?

You advocate the premise of existence, but at the same time you say you cannot know all of reality. What really happens in your logic is that you irrationally know the Truth and are somehow not omniscient. The entirety of the premises of Objectivism are self-contradictory. The only time when you may be consistent is when you do not deal with your premises.

They must have changed the course from when I acquired it. (Actually, I know better than that.)

 

Rand identifies logic as the fundamental concept of method. She also indicates that it has to be volitionally adhered to. It is also self-evident, implicit in every percept, to be abstracted from the evidence of the senses. It even has to be used in any attempt to deny it.

 

These four points were quite adequately dealt with in the first lecture. Also pointed out, was the fact that this is a standard introductory course on logic. With the exception of two logical fallacies, the section on definitions, and part of the portion dealing with induction, - it is what would be taught in any introductory course on Aristotelian logic. While Objectivism agrees with the material presented, so do most other philosophies that adhere to ontological logic. 

 

As I indicated earlier, logic is not my forté. I know, if knowledge is my goal, it must be used to the best of my ability. The act of intentionally trying to undermine that process would be an anathema to me. I find it incomprehensible why anyone would willingly do so. It would have to be akin to administering on one’s self an intellectual frontal lobotomy. Like any frontal lobotomy the procedure is, by all practical means, irreversible.

Here is an excellent presentation on how the Universe came from nothing (and that completely avoids the question of God):

There is some discussion on his book of the same title here.

There is some discussion on his book of the same title here.

I see Krauss contradicting Objectivism because Objectivism does not take something that does not definitely exist as a part of existence.

Lecture 3:
Peikoff claims that “human knowledge is contextual.” And then Peikoff claims that “obviously there is nothing other than or outside the Universe to operate as its cause.” Is Peikoff omniscient to make such a claim? And if so, how is his knowledge contextual?