So what you are saying is that your ‘theory of relations’, clashes with, i.e., cannot be integrated into the framework of Objectivism, so therefore, Objectivism must be holding the contradiction(s).
What makes this dubious is that you don’t appear to have grasped the basis for identifying, much less recognizing contradictions.
Did Peikoff say a new identity is created? No.
If something has no identity, then it is nothing. True.
The concept of change presupposes identity - For A to become B, A is A prior (hence presupposes) to any change (causal processes taking place).
How come everything can be (the sum of) everything and something “at the same time”? Are you implying that (the sum of everything) is not something?
Your group of statements, after the line break, is poorly worded to me, at best.
I wouldn’t put it that Objectivism is holding contradictions in consciousness and that’s why you clash with my theory. No. I meant that you choose to be at stage 2, even though there is evidence that you ignore that would put you at stage 3. What’s missing is the change, as you correctly identified in my other comment. Your self starts with a relationship to your body (“A prior”) besides making and/or breaking relationships with others. The overall concepts do not change existentially, but your specific contents do. For example, your body ages and thus changes, and your mood may change about yourself. One day you may be happy with yourself, and at another day - upset. This is still an identity - your relationship fundamental to yourself, and it changes not existentially but content-wise. Remember that existence is not content, but a form, an “essential” quality that for you metaphysically overshadows any specifics (your identifying process of what exists and does not contradict its own existence). I deem that Objectivism describes the first two stages of my theory, and so there is no conflict there. My theory simply adds a new stage that is essentially ignored by Objectivism. This stage not only retains the integration of body and consciousness, but also adds a contextual relationship to other bodies/consciousness whom you value. Is it an essential stage of human development? You decide. I cannot decide for you, so my job simply amounts to persuasion.
As Harrison has shown with his argument, the sum of everything is not every thing, which means that the sum of everything is not some thing. If the sum of everything is taken as something specific, then “all existents are existence” is true, but it’s false in this interpretation. So, Rand implied, when she said that existence is existent, that the existent is an indivisible entity. This is only possible when it is an abstract, metaphysical sum of concepts (as seen in her definition of existent), but not an actually specific sum, since a real sum is composed of separable things. The question remains: what makes the sum possible? Again, there is nothing on the topic of contextual relationships that I have so far found in Objectivism.
P.S. Concerning the Universe, it should be clear that it is not definite or specific. It exists, but noone yet knows about the Universe as a specific, identifiable whole. Thus, the Universe is really an incomplete concept.