This paper challenges the very derivation of the fundamental assumptions of QM.
Iâll have to say, TLDR, but the introduction. Even that is pretty technical stuff to me.
By applying his law to all cavities, the father of quantum theory detached his equation from physical reality itself. In truth, Planckâs equation was only valid for laboratory blackbodies constructed from highly absorbing materials.
But this makes it sound as if he jumped the gun on his induction.
I didnât think of this before, but according to this excerpt and additional commentary of mine, if the shape of the photon influences the velocity, then, the yardstick just got shorter. The reshaped photon would travel less distance over the same duration of time. While this does not divide the distance in half, it does reduce it by a small percentage. I think it was Planck, back when making his claim, that had also suggested talking about anything smaller than a unit of Planck distance was meaningless.
Iâm going to tell you the Black Box story thatâs understood and told to everyone within the Physics community. This includes even grad-course takers whose field is elsewhere, such as me. This will offer you the context that the article, in its haste to refute Planck, neglects to provide.
In the mid-1850âs, Maxwellâs discovery of The Electromagnetic Band changed Physic as much as Newton and Einstein. By consequence, many other scientists devised research strategies to hypothesize how far Maxwellâs discovery might extend, and the theoretical consequences thereof.
Now since electromagnetic waves were related to the production of heat, several questions arose as to this relationship. One of the large-scale theoretical consequences was the Laws of Thermodynamics.
Within this conceptual box, the two problems arose which constitute the subject to the article as cited, but not clearly described within:
1) How does the injection of heat within a hypothetically closed system behave?
For example, as the Maxwellian equation gives increased heat as a function of diminished wave-length, at which point, going towards the infinitely small, will an inputted âheat waveâ generate infinite energy as an output? This is known as the âUltraviolet Catastropheâ.
2) Can we establish an absolute unit of both temperature output and energy input thatâs set by nature? These are given by âTâ and âhâ.
In both of these cases, Black Box was used as a theoretical construct to designate no escape of heat. What goes in stays in. Enter Kirchoff and Stewart. While the former devised a theoretical model against this non-existant ideal-type, the later said that the real-life differences between black-boxing materials made any talk of a general law moot.
In other words, Stewart is saying that the observed data shows that there can be no natural unit of either electromagnetic input or temperature output. There is no natural T or h; the authors of the article agree, and the case should have been closed around 1860.
The historical fact, however, is that the German Physics community (by far the leaders) ignored Stewart as if he had taken an empirical knife to a theoretical gunfight. The issue, they insisted, was strictly one of mathematical modeling as again, no one had ever said that a Black box could ever really exist!
Enter Planck, some forty years later. Contrary to the article, he did not write in support of Kirchoff because, in the eyes of his peers, Kirchoff had won hands down two generations prior. His law was the context that was assumed by all, and Thermodynamics had moved forward. Steward had become a nobody.
Planck, actually working on the aforementioned Ultraviolet Catastrophe., noted that heat outputs even fell short of Maxwellâs prediction at extremely short wave lengths. Not only would there be no world-ending explosion, but actually the rate of heat output decreased against input.
So Planck hypothesized that only small packets of photonsâparticlesâcould lodge within the surface and not be re-emitted as reflected heat. Furthermore, bouncing particles would interfere with each other, thereby causing a loss of energy. And because waves could not do this, light must itself consist of photons.
Indeed, the data that supported his discovery would not pass modern standardsâŚbut then again, whose would? Whatâs remarkable is that he came very, sufficiently close for Einstein to publish in â05, then Compton, then Dirac, then 1925 with Heisenberg, then WignerâŚall demonstrating how photons behave as particles.
Soon enough, researchers seized upon the notion to honor the father of QM with Planck-ish designations of all the fundamental units that were later proven to exist. This is to say that during the time of Planckâs own research, the existence of these fundamental units was seriously doubted. Now theyâre not.
Part of the history of modern Physicsâeven as a course!âis to learn how Planckâs fundamentals grew out of some great educated guessing into the experimentally-verified numbers that we learn and use today. In passing, yes, Planck wrote of his debt to Kirchoff.
The journal from which the article came is marginal at best, junk at worse. Itâs neither peer-reviewed nor published with a sitting jury, In other words, the decisions as to what does and doesnât get published is made anonymously. In academia, this is beyond unacceptable.
What the article therefore demonstrates is that there still exist a few PhDâs in Physics that deny QM. To this end, they go after the first individual, Kirkhoff, who proposed absolute values for input and output units of thermal energy. After all, this is the crux of what QM is all about. But theyâre incredibly wrong. Todayâs experimental data supersedes all debate.
That Kirchoff himself had no idea that his application of thermodynamics to a closed system would engender the birth QM is another storyâŚ
AH
Notice that Andie does not even attempt to address anything specifically argued in the paper.
Andie you can tell âstoriesâ-ânarrativesâ all you want but your wasting your time trying to substitute a narration of what your consensus views hold as true for specific detailed arguments on the points actually made by others.
Andie said:
What the article therefore demonstrates is that there still exist a few PhDâs in Physics that deny QM. To this end, they go after the first individual, Kirkhoff, who proposed absolute values for input and output units of thermal energy. After all, this is the crux of what QM is all about. But theyâre incredibly wrong. Todayâs experimental data supersedes all debate.
You repeatedly circumvent the whole point in contention which is the INTERPRETATION of the âexperimental dataâ!
Trying to sell the story that the conclusions of special science are of a self evident nature and therefore not up for debate is a waste of time with Oist Andie. You have the wrong nets in use.
Notice that Andie does not even attempt to address anything specifically argued in the paper.
I think that speak highly to the level of interest in the topic.
You repeatedly circumvent the whole point in contention which is the INTERPRETATION of the âexperimental dataâ!
Try:
You repeatedly circumvent the whole point in contention which is the interpretation of the experimental data!
The subtle difference is that it does deal with interpretation, which in turn makes it quite linguistic in nature. Properly formed concepts are important, even crucial in grasping things.
The experimental data, left out of quotes, should shift the question back to the interpretation. Science Daily does indicate where valid understandings are being put to use. Lasers and quantum chips cannot violate the law of identity. Bad philosophy does not prevent you from stepping out in front of a speeding truck. The recognition, despite anything you think, is that âout thereâ is still out there. Bad philosophy does seem to hinder finding common ground to seek agreement on.
In one of Ashley Brilliantâs illustrations he penned: The biggest obstacle to discovering the truth is being convinced that you already know it.
He was wrong in one sense, but I think quite right in another.
The biggest obstacle to using reason properly, is not having discovered what all gives rise to it.
Notice that Andie does not even attempt to address anything specifically argued in the paper.
Andie you can tell âstoriesâ-ânarrativesâ all you want but your wasting your time trying to substitute a narration of what your consensus views hold as true for specific detailed arguments on the points actually made by others.
Andie said:
You repeatedly circumvent the whole point in contention which is the INTERPRETATION of the âexperimental dataâ!
Trying to sell the story that the conclusions of special science are of a self evident nature and therefore not up for debate is a waste of time with Oist Andie. You have the wrong nets in use.
Youâre free to give your INTERPRETATION of the data, then we can discuss.
Mine is simple: Stewartâs data was irrelevant to the general set of questions posed by Thermodynamics, which Kirchoff, et al were trying to solve. The Black Box was an idealized means to this end, as no one ever said that it really existed.
His errors, as were Planckâs fall within the general domain of making progress towards the stated goal of discovering absolute, naturally -found in nature quantities for temperature and units of radiation.
This effort compares to that of Keplerâs errors, then those of Newtonian Gravity. Likewise, Galileoâs erroneous F=MV, modified to the false Newtonian F=MA, then to Special Relativity.
To amend these errors, we donât say that gravity and force donât exist. Rather, we see progress towards a goal.
AH
In philosophy, we generally stick to examining interpretations qua interpretations, providing explanations, when we can of what make a particular interpretation valid or not. We try to examine how the concepts are formed, what their referents consist of, and, if possible, what measurements are omitted (in the context that the measurement must be present in some amount, but may be present in any amount within a given range.)
Your usage of the concept âunderstoodâ, your application of the concept of ârefuteâ vs âproofâ, your choice to implement âtheoreticalâ rather than âhypotheticalâ, the notion of âpeer reviewâ in some inexplicable way substituting for âproofâ, are, just to name a few, issues that fail to pass the test of actually grasping these concepts, much less presenting them in a manner consistent with their relationship to the facts which give rise to such noble concepts.
I would have to concur with Plasmatic here. You appear to be barking up the wrong tree. You might want to search on the âking of the sciencesâ and contrast it against the âqueenâ. You may find a distinction that you have not made. . . ., then again . . ., you may not.
In philosophy, we generally stick to examining interpretations qua interpretations, providing explanations, when we can of what make a particular interpretation valid or not. We try to examine how the concepts are formed, what their referents consist of, and, if possible, what measurements are omitted (in the context that the measurement must be present in some amount, but may be present in any amount within a given range.)
Your usage of the concept âunderstoodâ, your application of the concept of ârefuteâ vs âproofâ, your choice to implement âtheoreticalâ rather than âhypotheticalâ, the notion of âpeer reviewâ in some inexplicable way substituting for âproofâ, are, just to name a few, issues that fail to pass the test of actually grasping these concepts, much less presenting them in a manner consistent with their relationship to the facts which give rise to such noble concepts.
I would have to concur with Plasmatic here. You appear to be barking up the wrong tree. You might want to search on the âking of the sciencesâ and contrast it against the âqueenâ. You may find a distinction that you have not made. . . ., then again . . ., you may not.
In any scienceâhere itâs Physicsââinterpretationâ refers to how experimental and observational evidence is understood with respect to a particular goal-normally assumed to be the hypotheses in question.
Otherwise, said âking of scienceâ cannot hope to understand said âqueenâ unless he/she understands the goals of queenâs research.
Of course, it works both ways, many in the sciences feeling that Philosophy gives bullshit a bad name without trying to understand the nature of philosophical questionsâŚ
That does depend on your interpretation of interpetation, doesnât it.
That does depend on your interpretation of interpetation, doesnât it.
In Philosophy, âinterpretationâ is somewhat synonymous with âunderstandingâ because, after all, thatâs what Philosophy is all about.
In science, this is not so. Rather, various interpretations always seem to spring up with respect to the same experimental and observational evidence.
Therefore, scientific understanding means first, to grasp the question as a hypotheses that one might test. To this end, Stewart was simply off-base.
As written, moreover, neither you nor plasmatic appear to understand the basic question: establishing ânaturalâ, or absolute coefficients as discreet values is simply wjhat science tries to do.
To this end, neither of you have offered any assessment of the text qua science in question, as such.
AH
Andie said:
In Philosophy, âinterpretationâ is somewhat synonymous with âunderstandingâ because, after all, thatâs what Philosophy is all about.
In science, this is not so. Rather, various interpretations always seem to spring up with respect to the same experimental and observational evidence.
Therefore, scientific understanding means first, to grasp the question as a hypotheses that one might test. To this end, Stewart was simply off-base.
Therefore, scientific understanding means first, to grasp the question as a hypotheses that one might test. To this end, Stewart was simply off-base.
As written, moreover, neither you nor plasmatic appear to understand the basic question: establishing ânaturalâ, or absolute coefficients as discreet values is simply wjhat science tries to do.
To this end, neither of you have offered any assessment of the text qua science in question, as such.
Translation:
Relativism -subjectivism is the correct philosophy and scientist can âunderstandâ hypothesis without interpretation because the concepts of the special science are intrinsic-automatic revelations from the appearances, which can only properly be expressed mathematically.
âShow me the math!â
Response:
Show me that you have an inkling of where concepts come from and how the language of mathematics is abstracted from experience.
âShow me the concepts!â
Do you have any references to support your claim that Stewart was dismissed as you say? Do you have an argument against the evidence that Kirchoffâs law is only relevant to the specific context where there is a highly absorptive substance inside the box-container? (Not because its an âinfiniteâ type of existent)
Plasmatic, you make that look so easy. Weâve discussed it before. Relativism and subjectivism have different conclusions about how concepts are formed. Subjectivism holds to the notion that the concept is pretty much anything you want to make it. If it doesnât serve your purpose tomorrow, change it.
Relativism is more complicated than that. Peikoff points out that â[c]ontexualism does not mean relativism. It means the opposite.â So in this case, is it the dropping of the context of how concepts are formed and substituting the intrinsic-automatic revelations from the appearances in itâs stead? Is this what you are looking at here?
Are you pulling that out of just this: âIn Philosophy, âinterpretationâ is somewhat synonymous with âunderstandingâ because, after all, thatâs what Philosophy is all about.â?
Weaver, I hyphenated the two because one who blanks out where concepts come from, the generalizations in deductive hypothesis, could resort to either as a rationalization for their lack of epistemic foundation. How Andie would answer in particular is a little unclear due to their lack of direct statements.
Im reminded of Searlâs comments (in a lecture) about Henry James being disgusted at the notion that he would âstateâ a conclusion. The idea being that lack of literary circumspection and style would be unculturedâŚ
I donât want to come across as a grammar nazi here, but an important distinction here on âone who blanks out where concepts come fromâ might blurred. One cannot blank out where concepts come from - again - itâs out there. The blank-out occurs on the cognitive level. It is the failure to go thru the proper cognitive steps in order to identify what is out there.
Andie said:
Translation:
Relativism -subjectivism is the correct philosophy and scientist can âunderstandâ hypothesis without interpretation because the concepts of the special science are intrinsic-automatic revelations from the appearances, which can only properly be expressed mathematically.
âShow me the math!â
Response:
Show me that you have an inkling of where concepts come from and how the language of mathematics is abstracted from experience.
âShow me the concepts!â
Do you have any references to support your claim that Stewart was dismissed as you say? Do you have an argument against the evidence that Kirchoffâs law is only relevant to the specific context where there is a highly absorptive substance inside the box-container? (Not because its an âinfiniteâ type of existent)
Creating a Black Box scenario is indeed subjectivist because itâs a mental construct called an "ideal typeâ. In science, this is also called a âheuristicâ, btw. The fact, however, is that the result of this method eventually gave us absolute values for temperature and radiation.
So all youâre saying is that because you donât like the method, youâre throwing away the results.
And no, for the most part, the language of math isnât abstracted from experience. This s easily seen in the symbols that we use to doâŚmath.
Finally. youâre demanding that the concepts unique to Physics be justified by your own version of first-Philosophy concepts. My response is that by your standardsâostensibly those of the article-- absolutely no science will pass the test.
As iâve written before, newton would be the first to be given the heave-ho if your criterion were fairly put to all science.
AH
In this I clearly see the notion that âGod created the integersâ and the rest just seems to, somehow, inexplicably follow.
To understand how man created the integers, one need assess the formation of the concepts âTwo, Three, Four, and All Thatâ. This is where Corviini excels in examining the historical roots of the notions of number and makes a compelling case for their inclusion as a man-made phenomenon of knowledge derived from the experience of relating similarity and difference along the axis of quantity as it relates back to existence. How does this observed, or âexperientialâ quantity of âfourâ differ from this other observed, or âexperientialâ quantity of âthreeâ? Failure to grasp this leads us back to Descartes failed attempt to analyze âfive-nessâ with-in five. Randâs theory of concepts was not derived until much later. Descartes found himself floundering in the mire of mysticism, unable to differentiate the crucial difference that Rand recognized in her later discovery that relationships were key in how concepts were referenced back to reality (existence).
Given the foundation that Corvini rests her notion of number upon, it tends to pull the rug out from under the rationalist-subjectivist notion of number, and provides a much firmer footing to anchor subsequent derivations upon.
Andie said:
Creating a Black Box scenario is indeed subjectivist because itâs a mental construct called an "ideal typeâ. In science, this is also called a âheuristicâ, btw. The fact, however, is that the result of this method eventually gave us absolute values for temperature and radiation.
Is this your neuvo-nominalist way of saying that Kirchoffs law is universal without addressing the papers evidence to the contrary?
Andies said:
So all youâre saying is that because you donât like the method, youâre throwing away the results.
What results Andie? The paper challenges your âstoryâ of the methodâŚ
Andie said:
And no, for the most part, the language of math isnât abstracted from experience. This s easily seen in the symbols that we use to doâŚmath.
Lol, symbols are not concepts Andie! Try again?
Andie said:
Finally. youâre demanding that the concepts unique to Physics be justified by your own version of first-Philosophy concepts. My response is that by your standardsâostensibly those of the article-- absolutely no science will pass the test.
Another vague generalized statement about the paper with no evidence you have even read it. Your in an Oist forum Andie. Here Oist epistemology is the given. You offer no arguments for your dismissal of the Oist epistemology, only vague comments about alleged historical precedents with no attempt to substantiate your pronouncements.
You can reverse this time wasting trend by, say, providing an example of how the Oist view of concept formation would make a standard no science would be able to follow. What does that even mean? I doubt, from your posts, you understand anything about Oist epistemology on concepts.
In this I clearly see the notion that âGod created the integersâ and the rest just seems to, somehow, inexplicably follow.
To understand how man created the integers, one need assess the formation of the concepts âTwo, Three, Four, and All Thatâ. This is where Corviini excels in examining the historical roots of the notions of number and makes a compelling case for their inclusion as a man-made phenomenon of knowledge derived from the experience of relating similarity and difference along the axis of quantity as it relates back to existence. How does this observed, or âexperientialâ quantity of âfourâ differ from this other observed, or âexperientialâ quantity of âthreeâ? Failure to grasp this leads us back to Descartes failed attempt to analyze âfive-nessâ with-in five. Randâs theory of concepts was not derived until much later. Descartes found himself floundering in the mire of mysticism, unable to differentiate the crucial difference that Rand recognized in her later discovery that relationships were key in how concepts were referenced back to reality (existence).
Given the foundation that Corvini rests her notion of number upon, it tends to pull the rug out from under the rationalist-subjectivist notion of number, and provides a much firmer footing to anchor subsequent derivations upon.
Yes, ârationalistsâ believe that qualities and quantities exist apart from concrete objects, while ânominalistsâ believe that only said concrete entities exist. For example, âwhiteâ and âfiveâ have no meaning apart from five white objects.
So Corvini is coat-tailing on a scholastic debate that goes back some 1000+ years. How interesting.
By the same token, Corvini would say that âpiâ would not exist without the existence of real circles, or perhaps that a the origin of a taurus began with the invention of the doughnut. Interesting, as well.
Indeed, for thousands of years, thatâs all we had in Egypt and Mesopotamia: specific problem-solving became more and more exotic, but not integrated as a whole.
Then Greece came along and platonizedâŚerrr.. rationalized the process by devising mind-dependent, abstract forms. Therefore we have the birth of math as we presently know it, only using arithmetic as a calculation.
Suffice it say that the entire German community of post-Maxwelliam Thermodynamics employed this strategy, For example, all energy is conserved, regardless of quantity, and all energy is entropic, regardless of quantity, etcâŚSo letâs toss these out too,shall we?
In brief, like most âoriginâ ideas, Corviniâs on math developing out of counting quantities is totally irrelevant. It fails to explain to what extent the creation of ideas is mind-dependent in ways far other than the empirical.
To reject science that does not have a visibly empirical origin is not just to reject QM, but rather 99.9% if science. So welcome to the dark ages, randians, where rationalism vs nominalism is considered âmeaningfulââŚin an interpretive sort of way, of course.
AH
Here we have an example of someone simply lashing out at the role ideas play in life, IMHO. Rand sought to understand the role that ideas played in history, seeking out explanations for what made eraâs such as the Dark and Middle ages possible (and more), Corvini seeks to integrate the method of concept formation, that Rand identified, and apply it to number, and does the best job of if Iâve every encountered.
Without listening to the materials Corvini offers, (or from what I can tell, Harriman either), andie proceeds to try to generate blind attacks on something she clearly does not understand. Sun Tzu would probably not consider this a very good tactical move,