Good bye Planck?

Here we have an example of someone simply lashing out at the role ideas play in life, IMHO. Rand sought to understand the role that ideas played in history, seeking out explanations for what made era’s such as the Dark and Middle ages possible (and more), Corvini seeks to integrate the method of concept formation, that Rand identified, and apply it to number, and does the best job of if I’ve every encountered.

 

Without listening to the materials Corvini offers, (or from what I can tell, Harriman either), andie proceeds to try to generate blind attacks on something she clearly does not understand. Sun Tzu would probably not consider this a very good tactical move,

Ideas play a role in life in two ways:

 

  1. Independent of empirical experience. This would apply to the math that we do today. It is not an extension of arithmetic. 

 

Now my understanding of Corvini, based upon what you’ve presented, is that he is wrong. So to complain that i really haven’t read him belabors the point. He’s not worth reading until you can demonstrate otherwise. my ‘attacks’, as it were are as ‘blind’ as the information that you’ve provided.

 

  1. Ideas are related to empirical experience in an aleatory, indirect way. The notion that most ideas bear some sort of relationship to what we experience has been around since the origin of Greek philosophy, some 2700 years ago. 

 

To this end, Rand’s model of ultimately deriving ‘concepts’ from sensory input is an interesting, adequate  summary of received wisdom. However, she seems to say more–that all knowledge is based upon this empirical-conceptual nexus. Here, she is wrong.

 

This is because much of what we use today in a practical sense cannot be directly traced to empirical verification. For example, Copernicus’ heliocentric solar system. as he presented the argument, was not any more ‘empirical’ than the older, earth-centered model. 

 

So I suppose that by Rand’s standards, we’d throw him out, too?

 

So to return the subject to Planck: yes, he and Kirchoff had precisely this ‘problem’, too. Again, to base truth- of -science on a strict empirical>conceptual framework would abolish  99.9% of what we know as science. 

 

That you’ve given an adequate exposition of randism vis a vis science is not in doubt. You’re a star student. Going forward, however, I’d strongly suggest that you investigate the consequences of what you’re saying in terms of how real science is really done.

 

This would (perish the thought!) involve actually reading and coming to understand the science in question, in its own terms

 

AH

Given our mutual assessments of each other, thus far, what makes you think progress in this conversation is even possible between the two of us?

 

The only thing I’ve seen you producing with your grasp of your science, have been arguments that I’ve not been interested in addressing.

 

The only enigma I really see left is: Why here? Of all the websites, in all of the internet, why did you choose this one?

 

Why are you here?

Given our mutual assessments of each other, thus far, what makes you think progress in this conversation is even possible between the two of us?

 

The only thing I’ve seen you producing with your grasp of your science, have been arguments that I’ve not been interested in addressing.

 

The only enigma I really see left is: Why here? Of all the websites, in all of the internet, why did you choose this one?

 

Why are you here?

I’ve already stated my interest in Rand. In both her novels & essays, she seeks to define and understand Philosophy’s most important question: What does it mean to be an individual? Furthermore, speaking as a lit-chick, ‘Atlas’ and ‘Fountainhead’ are literary events of the first order, comparable to Quixote.

 

Regrettably, however, if i take her views on science to be those of yours as expressed, then she’s badly mistaken. Please keep in mind that this tentative conclusion is based only upon the consequence of our dialogue. i had no idea of O-isms’  hostility to modern physics going in.

 

Be that as it may, my challenge to all of you is to demonstrate O-ism’s compatibility to any science as it is practiced–your choice. Otherwise, you’re simply free to agree with me and say, “So What? We choose our philosophy over the lived realities of science, because that’s who we are!”

 

So if we can agree to disagree re Planck and QM (your point being that we’re better off without than with), let’s move on. Again, your choice of science and remember, it’s all of you guys against one poor l’il Spanish Lit-chick hiding away in Salamanca among volumes of Sufi poetry and French ballades.

 

And i promise not to go screaming to my sci-nerd buds for backup.

If I just pick one point to address out of this, if you’re looking for the demonstration of Objectivism’s compatibility with anything. That is something you have to discover for yourself, or find someone that is willing to try to spoon-feed you with it. Near as I can tell, you were not born with a silver spoon in your mouth, and I’ve come to understand that the extraordinary care mine requires, is handled, in part, by my mind.

 

If you walked into a kiosk somewhere, and saw something you liked - how would you go about acquiring it? You might say that you would offer to buy it. “With what?” I would have to ask. Whatever you happen to offer to trade for it, I would have to assess its value to me, by the sole judgement of my mind.

 

Being that this is a forum, what is generally traded here are ideas. Ideas are constructed from concepts. I’ve come to discover that some concepts are genuine specie, while others are counterfeit, and still others are somewhere in between. In physics, methods have been developed to assay gold in order to distinguish it from more base metals. You may not agree with the methods used. That is fine. If guilded trinkets are all that you are pursuing in life - you are the one that sets your own standard(s) for what it is that you are willing to accept in trade.

 

If you come here to simply peddle your trinkets, I believe that the converse to Gersham’s Law will ultimately prevail. To give up a greater value for a lesser value is altruistic in nature. To tie loosely into one of your other points about “What does it mean to be an individual?” is, in part, to ask, “What does it mean to value?” Rand’s allegory using a “vampire” (in Faith and Force) would be hard to improve upon here as a parallel.

If I just pick one point to address out of this, if you’re looking for the demonstration of Objectivism’s compatibility with anything. That is something you have to discover for yourself, or find someone that is willing to try to spoon-feed you with it. Near as I can tell, you were not born with a silver spoon in your mouth, and I’ve come to understand that the extraordinary care mine requires, is handled, in part, by my mind.

 

If you walked into a kiosk somewhere, and saw something you liked - how would you go about acquiring it? You might say that you would offer to buy it. “With what?” I would have to ask. Whatever you happen to offer to trade for it, I would have to assess its value to me, by the sole judgement of my mind.

 

Being that this is a forum, what is generally traded here are ideas. Ideas are constructed from concepts. I’ve come to discover that some concepts are genuine specie, while others are counterfeit, and still others are somewhere in between. In physics, methods have been developed to assay gold in order to distinguish it from more base metals. You may not agree with the methods used. That is fine. If guilded trinkets are all that you are pursuing in life - you are the one that sets your own standard(s) for what it is that you are willing to accept in trade.

 

If you come here to simply peddle your trinkets, I believe that the converse to Gersham’s Law will ultimately prevail. To give up a greater value for a lesser value is altruistic in nature. To tie loosely into one of your other points about “What does it mean to be an individual?” is, in part, to ask, “What does it mean to value?” Rand’s allegory using a “vampire” (in Faith and Force) would be hard to improve upon here as a parallel.

“if you’re looking for the demonstration of Objectivism’s compatibility with anything. That is something you have to discover for yourself,”

 

Well, actually, i’m challenging you to show me  randism’s compatibility with science, and you’re refusing by evading the issue. 

 

So as it stands, your ‘farewell to Planck’ tells us nothing more then we knew going in. My contribution is to demonstrate that your philosophy fails to cohere to any science.

So, my refusal to provide you with a further defense than what I already have found in Rand’s works on your terms, is evidence on your terms, to you, that her philosophy fails to cohere to reality?

 

If that’s all the “evidence” you need, I would submit that you already have it.

Andie said:

So as it stands, your ‘farewell to Planck’ tells us nothing more then we knew going in. My contribution is to demonstrate that your philosophy fails to cohere to any science.

You have done no such thing. You have made ridiculous assertions and then touted them as triumphs. This in spite of repeated requests for substantiation and clarification, all of which you have avoided.

Oism holds Philosophy to be the fundamental science… ITOE demonstrates in detail the scientific process of concept formation. You evade this repeatedly while spouting vague journalistic generalities. The mathematics of QM is sound and Planck’s is valid for the actual context the paper details, in black boxes with highly absorptive substances lining the walls.

I’ll respond to your blanket statement in kind. Objectivism is compatible with any science that is based on valid concepts.

Here is another paper by one of the same authors applying Prof. Robitaille’s knowledge of signal analysis to COBE and WMAP.

http://vixra.org/pdf/1101.0009v1.pdf

"The COBE and WMAP teams model the Earth as a blackbody source of emission at ~ 280 K. But Robitaille points out that “since the oceans are not enclosed” [8] they do not satisfy the requirements for application of Kirchhoff’s law of thermal emission, and so the emission profiles of the oceans “do not necessarily correspond to their true temperatures” [8]. By means of scattering in steady-state conditions, Robitaille argues: “Consequently, a mechanism for creating isotropy from an anisotropic ocean signal is indeed present for the oceanic ~3 K Earth Microwave Background” [9].

Misapplication of Kirchhoff’s law of thermal emission is far from the only major problem with both COBE and WMAP. Robitaille has shown that both projects are plagued by very serious problems with the performance of satellite onboard instruments and methods of signal processing."

So, my refusal to provide you with a further defense than what I already have found in Rand’s works on your terms, is evidence on your terms, to you, that her philosophy fails to cohere to reality?

 

If that’s all the “evidence” you need, I would submit that you already have it.

No, the law of identity is you peeples’ term. My terms would be to have a discussion w/o its reference.

 

So my claim–again, playing by your rulz-- is simple: since all science violates the LoI in practice, by YOUR terms all science is invalid. 

 

I therefore challenge you to show me one science that doesn’t.

 

Specifically then, yes, both Kirchoff and Planck’s work  violate said LoI. 

Andie you have been told many times that you do not understand what the LOI means to Oist. You are attacking a strawman. If you do indeed think that all sciences are based on ontologically objective contradictions then say so, so that we can laugh at and ignore you.

I therefore challenge you to produce a single existent that is not what it is…

You are claiming that Planck and Kirchoff’s work applies where is doesnt apply and discovered what it did not discover- facts that were not facts…

Andie said:

You have done no such thing. You have made ridiculous assertions and then touted them as triumphs. This in spite of repeated requests for substantiation and clarification, all of which you have avoided.

Oism holds Philosophy to be the fundamental science… ITOE demonstrates in detail the scientific process of concept formation. You evade this repeatedly while spouting vague journalistic generalities. The mathematics of QM is sound and Planck’s is valid for the actual context the paper details, in black boxes with highly absorptive substances lining the walls.

I’ll respond to your blanket statement in kind. Objectivism is compatible with any science that is based on valid concepts.

Despite my personal disbelief that “Philosophy is the most fundamental science”, i have agreed to play by your rules (absurd as they are!). And yes, since philosophy deals in concepts, if your fundamentality were true, any particular science would be valid only to the extent that it agreed with said concepts.

 

My claim, by examples and explanations given as to why, is that no science meets your conceptual terms. Must I repeat? Copernicus, Galileo, Newton, Darwin, the origin of the Periodic Table and its revision by Seaborg…

Andie said:

My claim, by examples and explanations given as to why, is that no science meets your conceptual terms. Must I repeat? Copernicus, Galileo, Newton, Darwin, the origin of the Periodic Table and its revision by Seaborg…

Notice the switch from claiming the LOI is violated by the sciences to the contextual nature of concepts here demonstrates that you are equivocating on the LOI. And you have not stated “why” on any of these topics mentioned in spite of requests.

Andie said:

And yes, since philosophy deals in concepts, if your fundamentality were true, any particular science would be valid only to the extent that it agreed with said concepts.

All language is conceptual! Therefore you must have an understanding of what a concept is and how to form them properly.

Edit: Im asking you sincerely to explain why and how any of the sciences you mentioned just now “violate the LOI”…

I therefore challenge you to show me one science that doesn’t.

 

Again, picking one semi-relevant point to address, I already did (mathematics), and you simply bushed it aside. This sent me the message that you are not seriously trying to address the matter.

 

Plasmatic is doing a pretty darn good job of identifying your game. I just refuse to play it.

I don’t mind learning more about things that I’m interested in, but I do so either on my own, or from those who I deem qualified to learn it from.

Again, picking one semi-relevant point to address, I already did (mathematics), and you simply bushed it aside. This sent me the message that you are not seriously trying to address the matter.

 

Plasmatic is doing a pretty darn good job of identifying your game. I just refuse to play it.

I don’t mind learning more about things that I’m interested in, but I do so either on my own, or from those who I deem qualified to learn it from.

Please re-state your point re mathematics so i might respond accordingly. Other than having stated clearly that no, math did not spring from counting, i’m afraid I’ve lost that particular thread…

 

AH

I believe you were just about to show us how the science of mathematics violates the LOI.

Andie said:

Notice the switch from claiming the LOI is violated by the sciences to the contextual nature of concepts here demonstrates that you are equivocating on the LOI. And you have not stated “why” on any of these topics mentioned in spite of requests.

Andie said:

All language is conceptual! Therefore you must have an understanding of what a concept is and how to form them properly.

Edit: Im asking you sincerely to explain why and how any of the sciences you mentioned just now “violate the LOI”…

Yes, i’m equivocating on the LOI. Another word would be ‘obiter dictate’. Yet another would be “trying to make some real sense out of what appears to be a meaningless tautology”. 

 

A good example of the LOI gone tautologically  haywire would be that of  Harriman’s ‘revelation’ that QM allows for photons to simultaneously occupy two places. Well… it’s been in all of the equations, staring you right in the face, since 1925-- it’s The Schrodinger and The Heisenberg.

 

His use of ‘fairytale’, then, only tells us that to follow the Randian party line you absolutely must choose LOI over 90 years of experimental data that clearly demonstrate that yes, quanta are observed to be in two places at once. The equations predict reality. LOI doesn’t.

 

Now to digress a bit, reading through the Einstein/Bohr debates, I find that no where did Al call Niels a purveyor of fairytales, or vice-versa. This, by contrast, makes Harriman a boorish twit.

 

Therefore, to do any science, you must say that the left hand A is what is being identified as equal to its stated properties on the right side. for example: the  A   of ‘solar system’) = A  (stated properties). This BTW is what Aristotle intended as to the relationship between essence and identity.

 

Now as I’ve stated, in science the right hand-side A  is unknown, being the subject of inquiry. Furthermore, what makes up A is what is in dispute among the community of arguing researchers, only one of whom will be proven to possess the correct right-sided A.  In this sense, again, to state A=A is meaningless because it gives us no understanding of what will be true of A  in terms of content.

 

Alternatively, you can take the right -hand side of A-ness  as a formal fact, and then judge it as either true or false, based upon its truth-content.

 

For example: 

 

* Although the Copernican model is true because it gives a heliocentric solar system, it’s false because the planetary orbits are neither circular nor concentric.

 

* Although the Newtonian system is true in giving ellipses as the fundamental planetary orbits, and furthermore makes the orbit correctly non-concentric, his A  is false because the mechanism by which he explained gravity is proven false. Bodies do not attract. His attraction equation only seems to work when said bodies are so close together that it just seems that way.

 

*Although Einstein’s gravity refutes Newtonian attraction for a gravitational force-field model,  it’s incomplete because his field equations failed to explain zero mass (deep space) and infinite mass (black holes). The math derived from QM does. 

 

In all three cases, the left- side definition of A  does not match the true content of A  as expounded on the right side.

 

Therefore, again, A=A is either a meaningless tautology which says, ‘Be it true or false, A  is exactly what i say it is at the time that i say it’…

 

…or…

 

…left-side  A  as defined only equals right-side  A  as content if and only if said content is true.

 

Otherwise, you’re simply dealing in a world of fantasy in which our hero, Gorth, needs the magic spell of queen-witch Rea in order to slay the fire-breathing dragon. In other words, fantasy is fun because we’re seduced into the particular logic that’s woven inside of a story whose content is false. Here, A=A because the content of A is not called into question as real.

 

This is called ‘pretending’. Doing science is different.

andie,

You state: “The equations predict reality. [The] LOI doesn’t.”

 

Barring showing how mathematics contradicts the LOI, if the equation predicts the reality cited, then the mathematics simply substantiates it, unless’ons, of course, the equation is not based on the LOI, which - of course, as of this moment - remains yet for you to demonstrate.

1 Like

andie,

You state: “The equations predict reality. [The] LOI doesn’t.”

 

Barring showing how mathematics contradicts the LOI, if the equation predicts the reality cited, then the mathematics simply substantiates it, unless’ons, of course, the equation is not based on the LOI, which - of course, as of this moment - remains yet for you to demonstrate.

i don’t have to ‘show’ you how the math of QM violates LOI. Rather, it’s right there, in your face, staring back at you, in all of the equations.

 

For example, take two of the oldest:

 

* The Heisenberg’s left hand calculus–change of position against change of time-- is clearly written as a probability. (A probably equals A?).

 

** Because the only limit to measurement is h/2, the photon can travel at speeds approaching infinity, giving it the capacity to be everywhere at once. A is not necessarily in A-sih position, going A-ish fast

 

*** The Born revision to obtain mathematical proof clearly violates the Commutitive Principle of AxB=BxA. Rather, they vary by h which as a Planck unit, isn’t a absolute value in Rand-physics, anyway.

 

**** Within the Schrodinger, there’s that little ‘i’ which, in terms of advanced-placement high-school senior math, means ‘two solutions’. 

 

And gosh, have i left out the accidental discovery of negative matter by Dirac? 

Rather, they vary by h which as a Planck unit, isn’t a absolute value in Rand-physics, anyway.

I’ve no idea about QM, who’s wrong or right on any particulars, or how even to evaluate the arguments, but I feel the need to interject something here.

There’s no such thing as “Rand-physics,” or Objectivist physics. Ayn Rand was a philosopher, not a physicist. Neither Objectivism nor the Law of Identity, as such, have anything to say about these sorts of scientific particulars; they cannot decide on a given controversy. The Law of Identity means that a thing is what it is, and is not what it is not, but it does not fill in those blanks. That – the filling in of the blanks, and coming to understand “what things are” (and what they are not) – is what science is. But knowledge of the Law of Identity does not do that work, and neither can it interfere with that work being done. Whatever is true is true, and the Objectivist position is that it is our job to discover what is true, with respect to QM or any other scientific subject. So if QM is true, or to whatever extent it is true, rest assured that there is no discrepancy between that portion and Objectivism, qua philosophy.

Physics is physics, chemistry is chemistry, biology is biology. And while Objectivists, as individuals, may have opinions on scientific matters, their opinions may be right or wrong with respect to those matters, just like anyone else, and ultimately must be resolved on the same ground as any other scientific debate – not by pointing to the Law of Identity, but with respect to the extant evidence, hypotheses, testing, and so forth. At the same time, a philosophical conclusion that the Law of Identity somehow does not hold, on the basis of some or other scientific data, is not sensible, is self-contradictory, and is therefore rightly rejected.

Also, if you’d like to respond to any material from this post, as these threads appear to be about the same topic, it would be just as welcome.

1 Like

This paper challenges the very derivation of the fundamental assumptions of QM.

Kirchhoff’s Law which this paper challenges is neither a "fundamental assumption ", nor is it an “assumption” of QM.