Here we have an example of someone simply lashing out at the role ideas play in life, IMHO. Rand sought to understand the role that ideas played in history, seeking out explanations for what made era’s such as the Dark and Middle ages possible (and more), Corvini seeks to integrate the method of concept formation, that Rand identified, and apply it to number, and does the best job of if I’ve every encountered.
Without listening to the materials Corvini offers, (or from what I can tell, Harriman either), andie proceeds to try to generate blind attacks on something she clearly does not understand. Sun Tzu would probably not consider this a very good tactical move,
Ideas play a role in life in two ways:
- Independent of empirical experience. This would apply to the math that we do today. It is not an extension of arithmetic.
Now my understanding of Corvini, based upon what you’ve presented, is that he is wrong. So to complain that i really haven’t read him belabors the point. He’s not worth reading until you can demonstrate otherwise. my ‘attacks’, as it were are as ‘blind’ as the information that you’ve provided.
- Ideas are related to empirical experience in an aleatory, indirect way. The notion that most ideas bear some sort of relationship to what we experience has been around since the origin of Greek philosophy, some 2700 years ago.
To this end, Rand’s model of ultimately deriving ‘concepts’ from sensory input is an interesting, adequate summary of received wisdom. However, she seems to say more–that all knowledge is based upon this empirical-conceptual nexus. Here, she is wrong.
This is because much of what we use today in a practical sense cannot be directly traced to empirical verification. For example, Copernicus’ heliocentric solar system. as he presented the argument, was not any more ‘empirical’ than the older, earth-centered model.
So I suppose that by Rand’s standards, we’d throw him out, too?
So to return the subject to Planck: yes, he and Kirchoff had precisely this ‘problem’, too. Again, to base truth- of -science on a strict empirical>conceptual framework would abolish 99.9% of what we know as science.
That you’ve given an adequate exposition of randism vis a vis science is not in doubt. You’re a star student. Going forward, however, I’d strongly suggest that you investigate the consequences of what you’re saying in terms of how real science is really done.
This would (perish the thought!) involve actually reading and coming to understand the science in question, in its own terms
AH