No apologies necessary.
All right.
One of the challenges in discussing matters with me, as no doubt you’re already aware, is that I don’t know very much. (This is also one of the challenges of being me.) Thus, I have to discuss these sorts of things without committing to any particular position, re: photons, or etc., because I cannot make any claim about them with confidence.
So, with that in mind and very generally speaking, I’d say yes. Whatever it is that a photon is, we observe it to have certain properties – and not others. We calculate or predict or model based upon our current understanding, and we must do so within very strict parameters… if we’d like to use those calculations for any good purpose. And this methodology – treating photons like photons, according to what we’ve observed photons to be, and not like anything else – reflects the very Law of Identity under discussion. If we were instead to treat photons as we do… grilled cheese sandwiches, we would not get very far, in trying to build transistors or quantum computers or whatever it is that we aim to do.
I don’t mean to turn this into a discussion of particular people and would like to avoid it if possible… though if you have particular claims to examine, we certainly can examine those – speaking to the ideas, themselves, insofar as whatever knowledge I do have allows me.
But is this problem that you cite really with “certain Objectivists”? Or is it with people generally?
In my experience, it is often difficult to challenge a person’s “common-sense evaluations” of the world, and I think that the history of science, itself, has some prominent examples of reluctance on that score, sometimes even among scientists themselves. That being said, Objectivism recognizes the contextual nature of certainty, so in terms of philosophy, Objectivists ought to be prepared to reassess such common-sense evaluations when confronted with conflicting incoming information (or, as Rand put it, to “check their premises” in the face of contradiction).
The mileage of any given Objectivist, as of any person, will of course vary.
Lastly, I’d ask that we try not to characterize those who disagree with us as morons – especially in the context of an ongoing discussion, where participants might be apt to take it as a personal attack. If we are both intelligent and well-meaning – and I take it that we are – then I am sure that we can manage to disagree and yet be civil.
Don,
No one is a ‘moron’ because the term refers to innate capacities. Rather hee-haw-ness refers to a lack of effort that one has a right to demand of others. in other words, I 'm so hard on Harriman because he knows better.
Now here’s my personal story, which might give an idea of where I’m coming from:
My bestie is a Greco-Hungarian chick named Eva (Ayyy-va). Although i’m in Salamanca and she’s at Emory (Atlanta), we manage to talk at least four hours per week–so yes, i miss her.
We met as pre-teen, high -testing mathoids. She’s now getting her PhD in Research Psy, while my doctorate will be in Spanish Lit. Now because we constantly discuss our work, it’s clear that her hero is Kahneman, from his earth-shattering, 1977 ‘heuristic’ onwards.
Briefly, Kahneman’s heuristic is fast-thinking, rule of the thumb, emotively mixed, intuitional. Real, slow-thought is different, but people in general don’t want to do it, if at all necessary.
Enter Rand. While all academic philosophy forces one to think slowly, most all of the discipline that’s written for laypersons is heuristic, encouraging lazy thought. Yet her’s, remarkably, is different, which is why I absolutely adore her.
Rand demands that one take thought seriously–part of this seriousness being a willful attitude of keeping up with science. in this respect, she regrettably passed away before she had the opportunity to give QM careful examination.
Moreover, in my reading of her, she never confused the formal properties of logic (rules) for that genre of received wisdom which she fought so hard to oppose as intellectually laziness.
in short, she would enthusiastically go with the established data as fundamentally telling the truth. To this end, i really can’t imagine her denying photon-reality of non-locality for the sake of hee-hawing that such a state of affairs violates common sense.
This is because, for the most part, she insisted that common-sense, heuristic thought was wrong: her virtue was to have demonstrated this to laypersons.
Harriman, then, is an embarrassment to Objectivism, and if Rand were alive today, she’d skin him alive.
AH