Good bye Planck?

Kirchhoff’s Law which this paper challenges is neither a "fundamental assumption ", nor is it an “assumption” of QM.

The use of “fundamental” here, I agree, may have been a poor choice of terminology. As a technical paper, I do not grasp all of it’s implications, but this much I do see.

Plank based, in part, his conclusion on Kirchoff’s Law. The paper drew into question the validity of Kirchoff’s Law as it related to the context Plank applied it. If Kirchoff’s Law does not apply in the context Plank applied it, then the conclusion Plank based on it, does not stand on that particular reasoning. How this relates to QM, would require getting, as Paul Harvey used to indicate, the rest of the story.

i don’t have to ‘show’ you how the math of QM violates LOI. Rather, it’s right there, in your face, staring back at you, in all of the equations.

 

Again, taking only this point to respond to: the request was to demonstrate how the science of mathematics violates LOI, not the math of QM. I get the impression that this point is not going to be addressed head-on here. It would be a formidable challenge, and, quite frankly, a futile undertaking, which would fit in with the fact that you continue to evade it here. Until you decide to address it specifically, you will just keep returning to this point.

Kirchhoff’s Law which this paper challenges is neither a "fundamental assumption ", nor is it an “assumption” of QM.

Hi Alex, your input on this topic is welcome. I chose “fundamental assumptions” purposefully for more than one reason. In conceptual hierarchy a concept that is logically presupposed, and to which later concepts and generalizations are predicated, is fundamental to same.

In the paper it is argued that:

Arbitrary cavities do not contain black radiation. Kirchhoff’s formulation is invalid. As a direct consequence, the constants h and k do not have fundamental meaning and along with “Planck length”, “Planck time”, “Planck mass”,and “Planck temperature”, lose the privileged position they once held in physics. […] Within “The Theory of Heat Radiation” [5] Planck outlined the ideas which gave life both to this revolution and to the concept that fundamental constants existed which had universal significance throughout nature. The pillars which supported his ideas included: 1) Kirchhoff’s Law of thermal emission [6,7] , 2) the irreversability of heat radiation, and 3) the adoption of discrete states. ∗ He utilized Kirchhoff’s Law not only to assist in the derivation of his equation, but to infer universality.

Do you have a argument against the development of these points in the paper?

Don, I agree with your last post. I particularly like the point that there is no “Objectivist Physics”…

Physics is physics, chemistry is chemistry, biology is biology. And while Objectivists, as individuals, may have opinions on scientific matters, their opinions may be right or wrong with respect to those matters, just like anyone else, and ultimately must be resolved on the same ground as any other scientific debate – not by pointing to the Law of Identity, but with respect to the extant evidence, hypotheses, testing, and so forth. At the same time, a philosophical conclusion that the Law of Identity somehow does not hold, on the basis of some or other scientific data , is not sensible, is self-contradictory, and is therefore rightly rejected.

Yes, and while the latter is Andie’s avowed, philosophically erroneous position, no one here has made the former mistake.

I chose “fundamental assumptions” purposefully for more than one reason. In conceptual hierarchy a concept that is logically presupposed, and to which later concepts and generalizations are predicated, is fundamental to same.

I read “fundamental” differently. The term can also be used to indicate something as the most important thing. Taken as you present it here, casts a different light on it.

… Do you have a argument against the development of these points in the paper?

OK, let’s start from the beginning. You wrote:

 

>This paper challenges the very derivation of the fundamental assumptions of QM.

 

The paper challenges the Kirchhoff Law and its derivation by Kirchhoff. Now, even if the derivation and/or the Kirchhoff Law itself were invalid, this would have no impact on the validity of QM. QM is based on completely different assumptions/premises.

 

If you disagree, please show me a mainstream textbook of Quantum Mechanics which develops the theory starting from the Kirchhoff Law. I have checked a dozen and found no mention of Kirchhoff’s name, neither in the postulates or otherwise.

 

The above is valid independently of the content of the paper you are pointing to.

I’ve no idea about QM, who’s wrong or right on any particulars, or how even to evaluate the arguments, but I feel the need to interject something here.

There’s no such thing as “Rand-physics,” or Objectivist physics. Ayn Rand was a philosopher, not a physicist. Neither Objectivism nor the Law of Identity, as such, have anything to say about these sorts of scientific particulars; they cannot decide on a given controversy. The Law of Identity means that a thing is what it is, and is not what it is not, but it does not fill in those blanks. That – the filling in of the blanks, and coming to understand “what things are” (and what they are not) – is what science is. But knowledge of the Law of Identity does not do that work, and neither can it interfere with that work being done. Whatever is true is true, and the Objectivist position is that it is our job to discover what is true, with respect to QM or any other scientific subject. So if QM is true, or to whatever extent it is true, rest assured that there is no discrepancy between that portion and Objectivism, qua philosophy.

Physics is physics, chemistry is chemistry, biology is biology. And while Objectivists, as individuals, may have opinions on scientific matters, their opinions may be right or wrong with respect to those matters, just like anyone else, and ultimately must be resolved on the same ground as any other scientific debate – not by pointing to the Law of Identity, but with respect to the extant evidence, hypotheses, testing, and so forth. At the same time, a philosophical conclusion that the Law of Identity somehow does not hold, on the basis of some or other scientific data, is not sensible, is self-contradictory, and is therefore rightly rejected.

Also, if you’d like to respond to any material from this post, as these threads appear to be about the same topic, it would be just as welcome.

Don,

 

My apologies for not having responded to your last missive in “QM…” as the thread was closed on the day I had intended to write. So thanks for the virtual re-post.

 

First, to dispel a misunderstanding, I never said that LoI was false, or that the scientific method wasn’t logical in terms of its own procedures. If I assign properties to one photon, I assign them to all photons.

 

For example, If all photons exhibit a time/space calculus which is probabilistic, then no photon’s calculation is definite (true in terms of content).

 For example, If General Relativity predicts by its field equations that there exists places of infinite mass, then even photons will not be able to escape these ‘black holes’ (False. For 50 years, physics was seduced by the logic until Hawking proved them wrong in 1976.).

 

My issue, rather, is with certain Objectivists who confuse the formal properties of logic with their own common-sense evaluation of what is reasonably true. “It ain’t logical” really means “It makes no sense in terms of the received wisdom of Hee-Haw County, Middel Amerika.”

 

In other words, logic operates only within the context of a particular discipline. Content-wise, there is no logic that is not ‘inner logic’. Much as there seems to be an inner logic to Rand’s thought in the sense that her use of say, ‘epistemology’, is rather unique, proven photon-behavior is agiven, as well.

 

What I also said, and mean, is that the scientific method of hypotheses formation places all right–side identities into question. In other words, given A= something, this something-ness is a compendium all hypotheses that have been proposed. The logic, as it were, says mutually contradictory hypotheses cannot both be true.

 

I also don’t believe that there is no relationship between science and philosophy. The cross-discipline of ‘philosophy of science’, moreover, is quite exciting.

 

This is because philosophy is the study of ‘meaning’-- which offers questions applicable to all disciplines. For example, to Nancy Cartwright, the most meaningful question for QM concerns phase transitions, or why photons perform untraceable ‘leaps’ to different energy levels.

 

Philosophically, she also inquires as to what science means when using the concepts of ‘cause’ and ‘law’. The book of reference her is her “How the laws of physics lie’.

 

AH

Kirchhoff’s Law which this paper challenges is neither a "fundamental assumption ", nor is it an “assumption” of QM.

I’m not sure what you mean by ‘assumption’ or ‘fundamental’ (grundrisse, perhaps?).

 

Planck was doing work on and with the Kirkovian ‘black box;’ His conclusions, following measurement, was that only ‘packets’ of photons, not behaving as waves, could cause the discrepancy between radiation input and output.

 

Of course, this was 40 years after Kirkhoff, thereby demonstrating ample evidence as to the experiment importance of his black box.

Don, I agree with your last post. I particularly like the point that there is no “Objectivist Physics”…

Yes, and while the latter is Andie’s avowed, philosophically erroneous position, no one here has made the former mistake.

No, I wrote that the LofI is contradicted by the employ of hypotheses formation, central to the practice of science.  Within philosophy, of course it’s still valid as a cornerstone of logic.

My issue, rather, is with certain Objectivists who confuse the formal properties of logic with their own common-sense evaluation of what is reasonably true. “It ain’t logical” really means “It makes no sense in terms of the received wisdom of Hee-Haw County, Middel Amerika.”

Hmm.

Again, taking only this point to respond to: the request was to demonstrate how the science of mathematics violates LOI, not the math of QM. I get the impression that this point is not going to be addressed head-on here. It would be a formidable challenge, and, quite frankly, a futile undertaking, which would fit in with the fact that you continue to evade it here. Until you decide to address it specifically, you will just keep returning to this point.

Your request was simply misunderstood. So here are my thoughts on math as a science:

 

First, to say that it is a ‘science’ means that mathematical objects are real. This means ‘objective’ in the sense of mind-independent, and discovered within nature, hence ‘natural’. They are likewise ‘real’ in the sense that Realism says that non-material objects are as real as material ones.

 

This, of course, contrasts to ‘Nominalism’ or ‘Conceptualism’. In passing, both Realism and Naturalism mean that math-objects are not invented. In terms of reading real philosophy, this view is best expressed in two books by Penny Maddy: Realism/Naturalism in Math’. 

 

What she observes of mathematicians is exactly what they say of themselves: solutions to math problems are arrived at by hypothesizing alternative answers and testing them by the ways and means within math itself. This alternative-ness again means that A= one of many possible A’s. In this sense, all sciences, without exception, deny the LoI with respect to hypotheses-formation

 

Two examples:

 

To find the Ho;y Grail of differential geometry–the Lie 8-- a team from Columbia /NYU constructed its own computer that would test the compatibility of what turned out to be a NYC phone book number of coefficients-- which could be interrelated in a permutation that ran into the billions. All interrelations would yield up different hypothetical models, but only one solution could be correct.

 

Two weeks later–bingo! What the team also found out was that the hypotheses-testing program was correct. Humans by themselves could not have tested all one billion of the hypotheses. Assuming that the left-hand A could be found to exist,  any posited right-side A had one-billionth chance to match as an ‘identity’.

 

Then there’s the story of Ms Mirzakhani drawing multiple diagrams of the Riemann Manifold with her daughters crayolas, looking for ways to describe it on a curved surface. On receiving Math’s top prize, she thanked her daughter for being such a good sport because there were some days when mommy used up all of the paper!

 

Hypotheses, all.

OK, let’s start from the beginning. You wrote:

 

>This paper challenges the very derivation of the fundamental assumptions of QM.

 

The paper challenges the Kirchhoff Law and its derivation by Kirchhoff. Now, even if the derivation and/or the Kirchhoff Law itself were invalid, this would have no impact on the validity of QM. QM is based on completely different assumptions/premises.

 

If you disagree, please show me a mainstream textbook of Quantum Mechanics which develops the theory starting from the Kirchhoff Law. I have checked a dozen and found no mention of Kirchhoff’s name, neither in the postulates or otherwise.

 

The above is valid independently of the content of the paper you are pointing to.

You need to reference’Thermodynamics’ for direct citation of Kirchoff. Then read how Planck, working on a thermodynamic problem called ‘Ultra Violet Catastrophe’. accidentally discovered quanta,

Hmm.

Harriman, who claims to possess a masters in philosophy, should know better than to endow the subject (left side) of a logical proposition with truth-value of real content. All logic says is that subject (L) equals predicate ®. 

 

In other words it’s ‘logical’ that photons can’t be in two places at once if and only if the subject is a statement that says, “given, objects can’t be in two places at once.”

 

By contract, the statement, ‘Photons are always in two places at once’ is equally amenable to logic. The identity of any particular photon means that  necessarily it is to be found in two places at once. This is all that the LOI means.

Two examples:

 

My pet peeve has been the Collatz conjecture, and to a lesser extent, Fermat’s Last Theorem, Both of these, as I see them, deal more directly with number theory. Alas, I shall have to wait until I fully consider it with full regard with respect to the final arbiter before I can begin to take either of these into consideration.

You need to reference’Thermodynamics’ for direct citation of Kirchoff. Then read how Planck, working on a thermodynamic problem called ‘Ultra Violet Catastrophe’. accidentally discovered quanta,

Thanks, I know where to look for Kirchhoff law and Planck developments. My point was that whatever happens to those results, the validity of QM is not affected. This is because QM does not logically depend on those results, only historically.

 

I am saying this because Plasmatic started the topic by implying that Kirchhoff law and Planck’s later developments are assumptions of QM, that is that they are QM’s logical premises.

My pet peeve has been the Collatz conjecture, and to a lesser extent, Fermat’s Last Theorem, Both of these, as I see them, deal more directly with number theory. Alas, I shall have to wait until I fully consider it with full regard with respect to the final arbiter before I can begin to take either of these into consideration.

I believe that there’s some autobiographic material available by Wyl as to how he solved Fermat. Again, a large trash basket, lots of paper, and pencils, not pens.

 

To a great extent, my argument for trying to delimit logic as a formal system rests upon behavioristic explanations: in certain instances and ways, a mental ordering becomes necessary, in others not.

 

At one crucial step in doing science, the mental conceptualization of hypotheses, we say, “Null!” Assuming all possible explanations possess internal consistency of the sort that would justify A=A, all mutually contradictory hypotheses have an equal chance of success.

Don,

 

My apologies for not having responded to your last missive in “QM…” as the thread was closed on the day I had intended to write. So thanks for the virtual re-post.

No apologies necessary.

 

First, to dispel a misunderstanding, I never said that LoI was false, or that the scientific method wasn’t logical in terms of its own procedures. If I assign properties to one photon, I assign them to all photons.

All right.

 

For example, If all photons exhibit a time/space calculus which is probabilistic, then no photon’s calculation is definite (true in terms of content).

One of the challenges in discussing matters with me, as no doubt you’re already aware, is that I don’t know very much. (This is also one of the challenges of being me.) Thus, I have to discuss these sorts of things without committing to any particular position, re: photons, or etc., because I cannot make any claim about them with confidence.

So, with that in mind and very generally speaking, I’d say yes. Whatever it is that a photon is, we observe it to have certain properties – and not others. We calculate or predict or model based upon our current understanding, and we must do so within very strict parameters… if we’d like to use those calculations for any good purpose. And this methodology – treating photons like photons, according to what we’ve observed photons to be, and not like anything else – reflects the very Law of Identity under discussion. If we were instead to treat photons as we do… grilled cheese sandwiches, we would not get very far, in trying to build transistors or quantum computers or whatever it is that we aim to do.

 

My issue, rather, is with certain Objectivists who confuse the formal properties of logic with their own common-sense evaluation of what is reasonably true. “It ain’t logical” really means “It makes no sense in terms of the received wisdom of Hee-Haw County, Middel Amerika.”

I don’t mean to turn this into a discussion of particular people and would like to avoid it if possible… though if you have particular claims to examine, we certainly can examine those – speaking to the ideas, themselves, insofar as whatever knowledge I do have allows me.

But is this problem that you cite really with “certain Objectivists”? Or is it with people generally?

In my experience, it is often difficult to challenge a person’s “common-sense evaluations” of the world, and I think that the history of science, itself, has some prominent examples of reluctance on that score, sometimes even among scientists themselves. That being said, Objectivism recognizes the contextual nature of certainty, so in terms of philosophy, Objectivists ought to be prepared to reassess such common-sense evaluations when confronted with conflicting incoming information (or, as Rand put it, to “check their premises” in the face of contradiction).

The mileage of any given Objectivist, as of any person, will of course vary.

Lastly, I’d ask that we try not to characterize those who disagree with us as morons – especially in the context of an ongoing discussion, where participants might be apt to take it as a personal attack. If we are both intelligent and well-meaning – and I take it that we are – then I am sure that we can manage to disagree and yet be civil.

Thanks, I know where to look for Kirchhoff law and Planck developments. My point was that whatever happens to those results, the validity of QM is not affected. This is because QM does not logically depend on those results, only historically.

 

I am saying this because Plasmatic started the topic by implying that Kirchhoff law and Planck’s later developments are assumptions of QM, that is that they are QM’s logical premises.

Your welcome.

 

My point is that although all statements ultimately depend upon logic, the article confuses ‘formal properties’ with ‘sensible utterances based upon received wisdom and commonly-held assumptions’. This is what i rather unkindly call ‘The Hee-haw Error’-- ostensibly applied to Harriman.

 

In other words, 'logical premises do not exist. Rather, reasonably acceptable premises based upon received wisdom exists. For example, if unicorns hare horses with horns and Miss Snowball goes ‘neigh’, has four hooves, eats oats and has a horn, by formal logic she’s a ‘unicorn’…but not by assumptions based upon received wisdom.

 

So the logical issue is this: was Planck’s use of black box consistent with that of its creator, Kirchoff? Well obviously, yes. 

 

The real issue raised by Stewart was whether or not those Germans should continue with the employ of a thought-experiment (gedanken) that has no empirical basis. Hence what real philosophy calls ‘epistemology’, or the ways in which truth is justified.

 

Here, the Objectivist mode seems to be that of the Logical Empiricism of Wittgenstein: “Die welt is alles was der fall ist…Wovon Mann night sprechen kann, daruber muss man schweigen”…and all that. So yes, assessed by these standards, QM prior to its own accumulation of evidence was nonsense.

 

But now, clearly not because, to the extent that you accept the epistemological validity of empirical proof, QM is true. To this end, cutting edge math-based gedanken have moved into string theory, braine universes, etc…

 

So here, let’s be clear and emphasize that no one using the Black Box concept ever suggested that it was real.  Conjuring up Imaginary objects as ideal types are just the way Germans like to do science, the Scots, not. Just ask Einstein what it would be like to ride on a photon.

No apologies necessary.

 

All right.

 

One of the challenges in discussing matters with me, as no doubt you’re already aware, is that I don’t know very much. (This is also one of the challenges of being me.) Thus, I have to discuss these sorts of things without committing to any particular position, re: photons, or etc., because I cannot make any claim about them with confidence.

So, with that in mind and very generally speaking, I’d say yes. Whatever it is that a photon is, we observe it to have certain properties – and not others. We calculate or predict or model based upon our current understanding, and we must do so within very strict parameters… if we’d like to use those calculations for any good purpose. And this methodology – treating photons like photons, according to what we’ve observed photons to be, and not like anything else – reflects the very Law of Identity under discussion. If we were instead to treat photons as we do… grilled cheese sandwiches, we would not get very far, in trying to build transistors or quantum computers or whatever it is that we aim to do.

 

I don’t mean to turn this into a discussion of particular people and would like to avoid it if possible… though if you have particular claims to examine, we certainly can examine those – speaking to the ideas, themselves, insofar as whatever knowledge I do have allows me.

But is this problem that you cite really with “certain Objectivists”? Or is it with people generally?

In my experience, it is often difficult to challenge a person’s “common-sense evaluations” of the world, and I think that the history of science, itself, has some prominent examples of reluctance on that score, sometimes even among scientists themselves. That being said, Objectivism recognizes the contextual nature of certainty, so in terms of philosophy, Objectivists ought to be prepared to reassess such common-sense evaluations when confronted with conflicting incoming information (or, as Rand put it, to “check their premises” in the face of contradiction).

The mileage of any given Objectivist, as of any person, will of course vary.

Lastly, I’d ask that we try not to characterize those who disagree with us as morons – especially in the context of an ongoing discussion, where participants might be apt to take it as a personal attack. If we are both intelligent and well-meaning – and I take it that we are – then I am sure that we can manage to disagree and yet be civil.

Don,

 

No one is a ‘moron’ because the term refers to innate capacities. Rather hee-haw-ness refers to a lack of effort  that one has a right to demand of others. in other words, I 'm so hard on Harriman because he knows better.

 

Now here’s my personal story, which might give an idea of where I’m coming from:

 

My bestie is a Greco-Hungarian chick named Eva (Ayyy-va). Although i’m in Salamanca and she’s at Emory (Atlanta), we manage to talk at least four hours per week–so yes, i miss her.

 

We met as pre-teen, high -testing mathoids. She’s now getting her PhD in Research Psy, while my doctorate will be in Spanish Lit. Now because we constantly discuss our work, it’s clear that her hero is Kahneman, from his earth-shattering, 1977 ‘heuristic’ onwards. 

 

Briefly, Kahneman’s heuristic is fast-thinking, rule of the thumb, emotively mixed, intuitional. Real, slow-thought is different, but people in general don’t want to do it, if at all necessary.

 

Enter Rand. While all academic philosophy forces one to think slowly, most all of the discipline that’s written for laypersons is heuristic, encouraging lazy thought. Yet her’s, remarkably, is different, which is why I absolutely adore her.

 

Rand demands that one take thought seriously–part of this seriousness being a willful attitude of keeping up with science. in this respect, she regrettably passed away before she had the opportunity to give QM careful examination. 

 

Moreover, in my reading of her, she never confused the formal properties of logic (rules) for that genre of received wisdom which she fought so hard to oppose as intellectually laziness. 

 

in short, she would enthusiastically go with the established data as fundamentally telling the truth. To this end, i really can’t imagine her denying photon-reality of non-locality for the sake of hee-hawing that such a state of affairs violates common sense.

 

This is because, for the most part, she insisted that common-sense, heuristic thought was wrong: her virtue was to have demonstrated this to laypersons. 

 

Harriman, then, is an embarrassment to Objectivism, and if Rand were alive today, she’d skin him alive.

 

AH

Harriman, then, is an embarrassment to Objectivism, and if Rand were alive today, she’d skin him alive.

I would consider this an arbitrary assertion. The supporting claims raised to draw this conclusion do not rest on the same style framework of integration that Harriman provides in either his book or his lectures - offering to tie the various developments into their relevant philosophic principles. In this case, in the end, it is relying on the game of “what if” to try to lend credence - in essence by relying on a recipients ignorance of Rands finer points and relying on a positive assessment of  Rand’s merits grasped thus far, in order to superficially lend credibility to this style of an attempt to try and discredit Harriman.

 

For someone who is reportedly interested in Rand for her contributions to literature, I see little pursuit of that here. In the matter which instead seems to have you drawn like iron filings to a magnet or Newton’s offer to raise no hypothesis with regard to the what that gravity may be, I have to note a seemingly relentless alternative pursuit.

 

As to demonstrating specifically how the science of mathematics violates the LOI, all I’ve seen is a couple of examples cited with which I am not familiar, with little or no effort to demonstrate their validity or invalidity as to how they tie, or fail to integrate with to the materials provided by man’s senses.

 

On these grounds, you are sincerely trying my benevolence here.