Don,
No one is a ‘moron’ because the term refers to innate capacities. Rather hee-haw-ness refers to a lack of effort that one has a right to demand of others. in other words, I 'm so hard on Harriman because he knows better.
I would think, rather than to try to offer up definitions or defenses for “hee-haw-ness” (or “Middel Amerika”?), it would be more productive to abandon that line of insult entirely, and redirect your efforts towards illuminating or critiquing ideas.
After all, does it matter what anyone’s personal evaluation of Harriman is, or how much “effort” we suspect he’s put in? If that were the subject of the thread, I can’t imagine that anyone would care to participate. If, however, the subject is about the intersection of science and philosophy (or settling specific scientific controversies), then let’s talk about that.
in short, she would enthusiastically go with the established data as fundamentally telling the truth. To this end, i really can’t imagine her denying photon-reality of non-locality for the sake of hee-hawing that such a state of affairs violates common sense.
This is because, for the most part, she insisted that common-sense, heuristic thought was wrong: her virtue was to have demonstrated this to laypersons.
Guessing what Ayn Rand may or may not have thought about QM, I think, says nothing with respect to QM, or to the Law of Identity.
Harriman, then, is an embarrassment to Objectivism, and if Rand were alive today, she’d skin him alive.
AH
When I’d said “I don’t mean to turn this into a discussion of particular people,” what I meant was that I don’t mean to turn this into a discussion of particular people. ![]()
If Ayn Rand were to skin David Harriman alive, I’d hope that she would do so by laying bare Harriman’s specific arguments and showing precisely where they fall apart. That is to say, I would hope that she would direct her efforts towards illuminating the underlying ideas (or towards the science, if that was where the matter of disagreement finally lay).
While I appreciate your sharing your personal context – and I do – the truth is that I saw questions in this thread (edited: or, rather, the _other_ thread) as to whether or not the Law of Identity could conceivably be threatened or overthrown by QM. I’ve argued that it cannot, and I think I’ve found sufficient agreement in your replies to consider that matter settled.
I think I’ve also attempted to address the question of whether or not Objectivism, as a philosophy, is prejudiced against science or whether it is well-situated to reject false, “common-sensical” views when those views are shown faulty through further investigation. While arguing against the former, and for the latter, I’ve contrasted this to individual Objectivists who might yet be mistaken in their understanding of science – which is also true of any other population.
What remains is the actual subject of QM itself, and for that conversation, I am ill-equipped. So I think I’ve contributed what I’m able. Thank you for your time.