3 hours ago, DavidOdden said:
Now finally there is the pesky problem of “good”, and while I am at it, “all”. Remember, “all good things in the past few centuries”. More accurately, all good things from the Renaissance to the present. I know that you have a special meaning of “all”, namely “most”, so to disprove your assertion I would have to show that most good things from this time period were not created in the Renaissance context. I don’t think that can be done. Here are some examples of good things that have nothing at all to do with Renaissance culture: judo, karate, tai chi, hengao, sushi, spring rolls, bao, kebab, biryani, myriad musical genres and artists such as Altai Hanggai, Huun Huur Tu, Carnatic, Persian, Kurdish, Turkish and Tamazight music to name just a few. Plus, the entire science of linguistics… If you want, you can object that you don’t care about the musical contributions of A.A. Moradi, a well-constructed bowl of muhammara, or linguistics. I propose, however, that no rational being could reject these virtues (maybe an exception can be made for linguistics), that instant rejection with zero experience is the antithesis of reason. My rejection of Western-sourced music such as Scriabin or English mushy peas is based on painful experience. De gustibus, as they say.
No; I wouldn’t deny the goodness of any of those things to come out of the East, and I can think of a few more besides. I am talking about essentials.
There’s a Mongolian folk rock band I very much like called the Hu. They don’t sing in English, many of the themes they sing about have to do with their Mongolian heritage and you can definitely hear the Mongolian folk music influence in their stuff. They do use electric guitars, which are a Western invention, but that is also nonessential.
The microphones and cameras that allow them to record their music, the computers, internet and web companies that allow me to hear it and the productive capacity that gives me leisure time which I can spend discovering new music instead of tilling the fields; even when it comes to my ability to enjoy something good that doesn’t come from the West, all of the essential things that make it possible do come from the West.
3 hours ago, DavidOdden said:
Now maybe you didn’t intend “the West” in a geographical sense, you were thinking in a cultural sense (giving you the benefit of the doubt). Most of Africa is in “the West (only a snippet of Somalia is in “the East”). But then the problem is that “the West” is the wrong term: it is way too imprecise.
Sure; Renaissance civilization is a more precise way of putting it than “Western”.
Australia is obviously a “Western” country despite the fact that it’s geographically anything but. And moreso, I would argue that Japan and South Korea are also “Western” countries nowadays, despite some fairly stark cultural differences and the fact that neither was a Western country very long ago. Israel is a Western country. Russia is not a Western country, despite having much more shared history with the rest of Europe than Japan or Korea, and certain parts of Europe are far more debatable than they should be.
3 hours ago, DavidOdden said:
The Greek instantiation of civilization did not happen in a vacuum, it is a development from Mesopotamian civilization, the true historical source of Western civilization. It all started when Thag and Grog, pre-Sumerian innovative hunter-gatherers, who got the idea of taming pre-sheep and various grasses. Thag said to Grog “Dude, stop stealing my sheep” and Grog replied “Only if you stop stealing my grass”, whereupon they stopped hunting and gathering in random locations, and they built permanent mud huts, and they became farmers. This is the source of everything good.
Not so! For one million years before Thag and Grog discovered agriculture and the division of labor, Ook discovered how to control and extend the natural occurrence of wildfires in South Africa. Therefore all human societies (civilized and savages alike) are really South African societies, building on the techniques first discovered by Ook.
What do all these values (fire, agriculture, law) have in common, that sets them apart from the way that animals survive in the wild? And in which society was that important difference between human values and animal values discovered?
It shouldn’t even be called “Renaissance civilization”. It’s not Greek or Roman civilization, but specifically Aristotle’s civilization that I’m talking about.
3 hours ago, DavidOdden said:
The tougher question, which I address to you, is whether you can identify any similarity in those propositions.
There is none.
If one were to stretch I suppose that most Westerners happen to be white, which is nonessential, although the Groypers would say that “all good things come from white people”. An even further stretch would be that voting is typically a feature of Western countries, which are mostly peopled by whites, and at that point no further similarities are going to be any more useful or precise than a Pavlovian sort of word-association.
They are both sentences in the English language, too, but that fact alone is not helpful in the realm of ideas.
3 hours ago, DavidOdden said:
The white-voting proposition can easily be remedied by re-stating the fact: “If white are uniformly striving for the deliberate subjugation of all nonwhites, then all whites need to stick together as a racial voting block”. This is a contingent fact, which is true in the context of the current US, where government is determined via elections. If that is your goal, that is what must be done. The premises of the syllogism are stated pretty overtly, at least under the assumption that the reader understands the meaning of the word “need”. You’ll have to separately determine whether the major premise in the syllogism is true (I claim that it is worse than false, it is arbitrary, not to mention reprehensible).
The way Fuentes puts it is “if the white race is to survive then all whites need to stick together as a racial voting block”.
The notion that races have collective interests (which include looting a nation’s treasury and passing oppressive laws to disadvantage all other races) is simply assumed as axiomatic, as is the notion that any race which fails to act as a collective block will simply be outcompeted by all the others. When challenged on either of these assumptions the Groypers’ rebuttal is “race is reality. Anyone who rejects race will lose”.
In this sense they literally are the mirror image of the woke, who also believe that races have collective interests (which include looting a nation’s treasury, having powerful people “look like” racial minorities and passing oppressive laws to regulate the racial makeup of anyone seeking to gain any form of power) and that any race which fails to act as a collective block will simply be outcompeted by the others. Their only difference is in which races they favor.
On 11/26/2025 at 12:20 PM, DavidOdden said:
I don’t blame the cat lady for this, the blame goes further back, to the 60’s when civilization was rejected by the New Left.
Not the cat lady alone, of course.
On 11/28/2025 at 9:54 PM, SpookyKitty said:
In other news today:
Smoke alarms #1 cause of fire.
This is what passes for “reason” in this thread.
I’ve been thinking about it some more today and I mainly have two questions I’d really like for you to answer.
The first, which you’ve already alluded to, is whether you recognize any distinction between the Groypers and any other non-woke person. Judging by your summary that “smoke alarms cause fire” I think you’ve basically answered that one.
The second is that since most Westerners do happen to be white, and since the only difference between your worldview and that of the Groypers is in whether you think white people should be disadvantaged and oppressed - how do you plan to convince them to volunteer for that?
When you’ve already conceded every single one of the premises of literal Nazis except for “and you should be the ones on the trains instead of the ones in uniform” what is your strategy for selling that final premise?
Do you have one at all?
For example, in the “What is Woke” thread you said:
On 11/4/2024 at 7:06 AM, SpookyKitty said:
“Wokism” is a derogatory term used by right-wingers to disparage people who correctly recognize the fact that white supremacists did not simply disappear into the void when the Civil Rights Act passed, but instead weaponized supposedly color blind economic, legal, political, educational, and other social institutions to perpetuate the white, christian, male, heteronormative supremacy that explicitly and openly dominated American life for 300+ years.
Said right-wingers are simply living in ignorance of or even straight up denial of reality.
As to the first point, when you claim that modern American institutions are “supposedly color blind” I assume you mean that they are not in fact color blind; that they have been vehicles for white supremacy ever since the civil rights act.
If we were to get even deeper into it I assume (and please correct me if I am wrong) that you don’t even recognize genuine color blindness as a legal value. I suspect you would say that actually taking no account of race whatsoever can only perpetuate white supremacy, and that the only way to fight such white supremacy is to take legal cognizance of race for the explicit purpose of “raising up” nonwhite people.
All of this is consonant with the notion that you’ve been fighting the Groypers this entire time. So that tracks. Would I be correct in framing your answer to the first question as basically amounting to: there are conscious white supremacists and white supremacists living in denial, but nobody outside of your movement who is not some form of white supremacist?
As to the second point - well, the conscious white supremacists are explicitly rejecting color blindness, so unless you’re in favor of that (and please correct me if I’m wrong about any of these assumptions) you do agree that every aspect of society must explicitly take race into account.
If so then what makes you think the racial majority will do anything other than whatever Fuentes claims is best for the racial majority? How can you possibly be blind to what you were enabling and encouraging when you rejected color blindness? How can you possibly expect to get away with it?