Gun Control: What should be the limit?

I agree with Nicky that the background check is a rights violation. It is so minor a violation that I wouldn’t make it a big point of contention with most people, but among those with political literacy I am comfortable saying it.

The FFLs must keep a record of all sales, which includes the background check results of all customers. The worry is that, at some future time, Uncle Sam will decide he needs FFLs to turn in those records. Ari Armstrong suggested that we can avoid infringing on the rights of innocent people by getting rid of background checks and instead using a “no gun” list similar to the “no fly” list. That way you only get barred if you have been convicted of criminal activity or have been ordered by a court to seek treatment for a mental health issue. FFLs would be subject to increased liability if they sold to someone on that list a weapon that was later used in a crime.

 

The “no gun” list is an interesting suggestion, but I don’t see how it is substantially different from requiring background checks.  To buy a gun, you would still have to provide your name and proof that you are who you say you are (as is done at the airport), and thus your name is still recorded with the purchase and the serial number of your gun.  The gun dealer doesn’t have the information in your background check under this system, but surely the government could get that information if it desired.  In short, you still have to meet a positive burden of proof that you haven’t been banned from buying a gun, the same as under a background check system.  In either case, providing one’s name and proof of one’s identity is simply what has to happen if we want to stop certain individuals from purchasing guns at the point of sale.

Like I said, the difference is small. But I think that safeguarding against 4th amendment violations (however minor) is a substantial difference. I’m just brainstorming here, so don’t take this as my firm position (I’m still trying to form one).

 

Records would not necessarily have to be kept. Nobody makes a record of my ID when I buy a pint of Dark Helmet Schwartzbier at Titletown Brewery. The authorities could do with guns as they do with beer and periodically “mystery shop” to see if IDs are checked.

 

Otherwise, a restriction on the individual does not necessitate a mandate that gun sellers check IDs. If they were liable for transferring weapons to known criminals/mental health risks, they would have an incentive to protect themselves by asking for IDs and for keeping a record. I doubt this would work very well. This is one of those cases where statistics might be used to decide public policy without violating anyone’s rights. Someone should tell Crow.

What about these NRA members talking about, the second amendment, and defending ourselves against tyranny? Is that legitimate?

It is legitimate because self defense is legitimate. The very existence of this country originated in the several states defending themselves against tyranny with individually owned and voluntarily wielded weapons. An attack on the second amendment is an attack on the legitimacy of the entire idea of America.