Another Objectivist and I have been following the recent “debates” (what with all the emotionalism) about guns. I can definitely understand the knee-jerk reaction to all these shootings, even after knowing that most if not all of them were gun free zones. I don’t own any guns, I’ve only fired one once in my life. I vaguely understand the difference between semi-automatic and automatic. I’ve been hearing these “debates” filled with proclamations of statistics on both sides, I’ve read that article, I believe it was from Binswanger, and am still not necessarily sure about the whole issue.
I think there should be drawn a line between what are acceptable and unacceptable levels of defensive force (for example guns vs. nuclear bombs). But where does that line lay? Can a military expert tell us this? Ought we listen? Right now, machine guns, I believe, are banned. But why them and not semi-autos like these AR-15’s? Which my Objectivist friend says can be used in pretty much the same fashion, if you know what you are doing. What is the principle defining the line?
What about these NRA members talking about, the second amendment, and defending ourselves against tyranny? Is that legitimate? I can’t see AR-15’s flying in the face of our military’s might, but I also cannot see our military at least near the lower ranks even think about harming U.S. citizens. I can see using them against a Gestapo or a SS like force. I do have to say that I am proud that I live in a country where it is a major issue trying to take people’s guns away from them, unlike many other country’s whose citizens seem to have given up their lives to their governments.
From Binswanger’s article and my friend, I am somewhat convinced that whatever is defined as legitimate, should not be regulated in the sense of registration, etc. But I am hesitant when it comes to the idea of people selling weapons to mentally challenged people.
I’ve read many of the forum’s posts about this but they seemed a bit inadequate addressing this thing. Please respond to my questions and not refer me to another post.
Alex Bott
UIC College of Engineering