Yaron Brook discusses Health Care
I would like to hear from [O]objectivist individuals who have been bankrupt by health care expenses, even if they had chosen a health insurance policy they thought covered them.
You’re talking to her! I did include the expenses from my broken leg in my bankruptcy when I got divorced. I had $5,000 in out of pocket expenses (that I knew I would have because I read my policy when I voluntarily signed up for it. Reading, shopping around, knowing what you’re getting into…imagine that!) If I weren’t losing more than half my income to taxation, I would’ve had the $5,000 for my out of pocket expenses, including enough to pay off everything else, thus I could’ve avoided bankruptcy…by a long shot!
If 50 states and the feds weren’t regulating insurance companies and if doctors weren’t being sued by so many frivolous idiots, the costs of health care would be significantly lower and as I stated before, in a laissez faire capitalist society, most of us could afford it. Those who couldn’t, could afford to be taken care of by charities or family/friends.
The cost of health insurance policies, deductibles, co-pays, etc., in the US for a family probably negates much of the tax differential between individuals in the two countries.
Even if it does, so what? I don’t want the government stealing my income and spending it for me. I know how to best spend my own income. I can take care of myself if left alone to do so, can’t you?
In addition, the Canadian health care system will go bankrupt. It’s just a matter of time. (I bet it’s running in the red already, whether they admit it or not!)
“The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people’s money.” - Margaret Thatcher
I’ve been having a really long and intense debate with a bunch of people at the philosophy section of a music message board. Most of the posters are obviously liberal and no matter what I say they always retaliate with some thing like my info is wrong or the declaration of independence gives you no rights.
Here’s the portion of the debate. My comments are in blue and hers are in red. I would really appreciate feed back to let me know if I’m going about this debate in the right way. If any of you care to read the entire thread I will post the link. It would be really great to see some objectivsits come over to the philosophy board and even out the liberal bullshit factor.
Tea bag parties are fail (health care debate inside)
While we have high quality of care, we have inflated costs. The high quality comes from the free market, the high costs come from pooled tax funded services.
I provided you statistics which show that in countries where the government pays for health care that the costs are far lower (sometimes half of what we spend by a ratio per person/GDP), so clearly this is just bullshit.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dylan Thomas View Post
Why not let the same economic forces that have improved quality and lowered costs in almost every other industry from cars to computers flourish in health care?
Because people purchase those goods based on their desire to own them, and based on whether or not they can afford them. In the case of health care, it’s generally far too expensive for the free market to apply.
Why don’t you make the connection between government-provided health care and the Department of Motor Vehicles or the way government handled the devastation from Hurricane Katrina. As necessary as health may be, so is food and so is clothing and so is a home. Would you want to eat government made food? Live in public housing? Wear government issued clothes?
Actually, last few times I’ve been to the DMV, it’s been a breeze. There have been times where it’s been a nightmare, but I can say the same about going into Wal-Mart. Besides, the DMV is something that private businesses clearly could not cover, so the analogy doesn’t apply.
The governmental reaction to Hurricane Katrina happened because we elect entirely incompetent people into office, not that government is inherently unable to handle those situations. Had it been Clinton, or even George Bush’s father, I honestly think the federal government would have reacted far quicker.
Why is it that almost without exception, wherever government intervenes to solve a major social problem despite good intentions the given process becomes enormously more complicated and much more expensive for society as a whole?
Again, I gave you examples of health care coverage in every single industrialized country being cheaper than in the United States, so you don’t get to claim this. Do you really think it’s more complicated to get authorization for a medical procedure in the United States than in Germany? Try petitioning a turned down claim by an insurance company. It’s utter hell.
You obviously don’t know where health care comes from.You’re talking about business coverage and the premiums are that high because they cover so many people. Company coverage doesn’t even cover half of where the current coverage comes from and that is government programs like medicare.
From the Wikipedia entry on U.S. Health Care:
Around 84.7% of citizens have some form of health insurance; either through their employer or the employer of their spouse or parent (59.3%), purchased individually (8.9%), or provided by government programs (27.8%; there is some overlap in these figures)."
(I know Wikipedia isn’t a great source, but it references a U.S. Census Bureau report, and I checked the numbers and found them to be accurate)
It would be nice if you stop making stuff up.
I agree that health care prices are out of control but government funded health care is not the answer. Government is the reason prices are so inflated!
See above. Plus, the reason why prices are so inflated is that health insurance companies are an unnecessary middle man who’s purpose is to make a profit. Health insurance companies are the definition of waste. You pay them money to be in the business of turning down claims except where they’re legally obligated to (and honestly, they’ve spent of lot of that profit on getting the laws changed so that they can legally turn down more claims).
Quote:
Individuals also do pay for their own health care.
Yes, I said that. But it’s less than 10% of the population.
And the company health care is still coming from individual pay checks. If you have health care through your work you are paying for it with a percentage of your check.
I KNOW THAT! I’VE BEEN SAYING THAT. But the difference is that the health insurance isn’t being paid for by individuals, even if the money is being taken individually. The abettors of who purchases the heath insurance is ultimately the company, not the individual.
But here’s the kicker. This whole time you’ve been arguing that the idea of having a percentage of your paycheck being taken away from you is criminal. Now you’re perfectly fine with it.
Hi There, Am Pam is offline Add to Hi There, Am Pam’s Reputation Report Post
No kidding the supply and demand doesn’t work if there isn’t a supply for the demand, which is why places like Somalia can’t afford health care. But we in the US have the supply and the Demand.
I guarantee you that the supply would be in Somalia if people in Somalia could afford it. You’re not grasping that the problem is that supply & demand functions on people being able to afford it, and even in the United States, plenty of people can’t afford it.
Where does the government get the money to pay for it? Again it comes from individuals.
And isn’t that where business get the money from? So ultimately you have a problem with government health care because it comes from the individual, but you think employee coverage is a-ok because it comes from the individual.
In a free market If individuals cannot afford health care there would be no health care industry. If individuals couldn’t afford insurance there wouldn’t be an insurance industry. The market would have to meet it’s supply with its demand.
There are people who can’t afford health care. There’s a difference between some people able to support an industry & everyone being able to support an industry. There’s an industry built around selling Fabergé eggs, doesn’t mean everyone can afford them.
Why do you think tens of thousands of foreigners come to the US for medical treatment every year? They’re seeking advanced and sophisticated procedures that are simply unavailable or rationed in their home countries. Socialized medicine may seem to work from an outsiders perspective but it has a price and consequence and that consequence is the quality of health care.
Tens of thousands really isn’t a whole lot. Besides, I’m sure tens of thousands of people go to India for medical treatment as well. India is on par in terms of medical technology and innovation as the United States, and their health care is entirely government paid for.
The advancement in treatment largely comes from Universities, which get their money from either private donors or the government. So as far as medical advancement, we get both free market & governmental solutions, so it’s win-win.
We are not currently nor ever have been in a completely free market system so how can you compare the current US health care system to that of a free market system?
Because it would be impossible to have a health care industry that was free market the way buying an iPod is.
Sure free health care sounds great, it’s a utopian promise but health care isn’t free. A government ran health care system is an enormous mistake and like your Germany example is backed up by myths.
For example in August 2008, the British medical journal Lancet Oncology found that America is much better at treating cancer than Europe or Canada. Americans have a better survival rate for 13 of the 16 most common cancers. Among men, an American has nearly a 20-percent better chance of living for five years after being diagnosed with cancer than their European counterpart. American women stand a 7.2 percent better chance of living for five years after a cancer diagnosis than their European counterparts.
Well, I looked up this report, and it’s not really as supportive of U.S. health care as you’re making it out to be. Check out this article on the report
The highest survival rates were found in the U.S. for breast and prostate cancer, in Japan for colon and rectal cancers in men, and in France for colon and rectal cancers in women, Coleman’s team reports.
In Canada and Australia, survival was also high for most cancers.
The kicker here is that it mentions that survival rates in the United States varies widely state by state. There was also a racial gap in survival rates.
The conclusion of the article? These variations largely have to do with when the cancer was detected. It points more to the efficacy of cancer detection programs, rather than cancer treatment levels.
And really, cancer research is heavily pushed in the United States, somewhat because some of the best medical schools in the United States. Not to take anything away from other countries, but there’s a number of excellent Universities (John Hopkins, Harvard, NYU, etc…). This doesn’t have to do with the free market so much as funding from both private sources (such as wealthy alumni) and the government. In this case, it’s win-win.
This was in regards to a comment saying that “sometimes you have to violate freedom” locking someone up in jail might be seen as violating somebodies freedom.
Yes we have defined this issue. Nobody should be forced to violate someone’s freedom. You are not free to violate another man’s right to his life.
Yes, but we punish this by taking away a person’s freedom. At some level, you’re forced to take away freedom. Really, my only point is that you can’t say that universal health care is immoral because it takes away people’s freedom to pay for it how they want. Before you said, “The point being you can’t immorally violate somebodies freedom and rights because it is a means to an end.”, which is counter to the idea that your freedom is taken away from you if you violate another person’s freedom. That is a means to an end.
The declaration of independence does not give you the right to take another’s life. If you do so, there are clearly defined consequences in our justice system and you are subject to those consequences should you violate them.
Not again. Did you miss the whole part about how the Declaration of Independence doesn’t give you any rights? I explained this to you and you seemed to miss it completely.
Exactly people should pay for the small portion of government that is set up to protect the rights of the people. I’ve said that from the beginning. I have no moral issue paying for a military, a police force and a court system. The government should not be there to collect money from its citizens and then redistribute it to somebody else so they can have what they want free of charge and without effort. When the government is taking money from one and redistributing it to others, it is playing sides and benefiting one group far more than another and that is not equal representation. You honestly think the government isn’t out of fucking control with it’s frivolous spending? How could you even think that the government today is anything like what the founding fathers had in mind. How can you even argue that the government is not taxing without representation?
Your argument before was that it was immoral to decide for others how their money should be spent. Ok, fine, but you’re also saying that you’re perfectly fine with taxes being collected to pay for the military, police, and other structures. So which is it? Either you think all money collected & spent by the government is immoral because it’s deciding for people how their money will be spent, or that the government deciding how money is spent isn’t immoral (obviously, if the money is spent on immoral actions like puppy kicking machines, but that has to do with the action, not the money).
Military spending quite often takes money and redistributes it to somebody else. There are plenty of private companies which manufacture planes/boats/tanks/trucks for military use. I don’t grasp why you’re perfectly fine with this type of redistribution, but not when it’s something like health care.
Really though, the most important thing here is that you’re ranting about freedom, what the founding fathers intended, and the basis of our system of government… and you have absolutely no understanding of what any of that is.
Even after I corrected you about the Declaration of Independence, you still refer to it as giving you certain rights. While there have been certain court cases which have referenced the Declaration of Independence, it’s not really a legal document. You have Constitutional rights, you have rights that guaranteed by the Bill of Rights, but you don’t have any Declaration of Independence rights.
It’s a common mistake because the document is so revered in our society (and originally, it wasn’t considered to have nearly the importance as it does to us now, there were other, similar documents more important, or just as important to the independence of the Colonies to the British government). But the difference here is that you’re trying to lecture the rest of us about freedom and what our system of government allows our government to do, while not having a clue as to how our government is set up.
Seriously, the idea that the Declaration of Independence gives you certain rights is evidence that you don’t understand even the basics of our government, and especially not what the founding fathers intended. It’s clear that you’re regurgitating lines you’ve heard from other people without knowing the basis for their argument. I’ve heard the arguments you’re using before from other people, but usually they refer to our legal system correctly.
I get mistakes, I get a misunderstanding of a subject. On this forum, people have corrected me on my assumptions of issues that I didn’t understand. But when a person continues to make the same mistake about a simple understanding of a subject, it shows a disregard for really wanting to understand the issue.
(Yes, I get that there is a window of arguing for the idea that the Declaration of Independence has some legal context, but that’s a very small margin, and doesn’t fit the context of refer to the Declaration of Independence as guaranteeing rights.)
Equivocating between people paying for health care through their employer (which is voluntary) and through taxation is just sad. It’s obvious she doesn’t get the meaning of individual rights…
That’s really what you have to go back to all the time. If you turn it into a utilitarian equation with what is cheaper and more effective or whatever, it’s pretty much a lost cause. The only way to oppose these people is by going back to the moral issue, not arguing the specifics of their arguments (that are so complex that it’s pretty much impossible to prove to them that it is because of factor A instead of
.
Equivocating between people paying for health care through their employer (which is voluntary) and through taxation is just sad. It’s obvious she doesn’t get the meaning of individual rights…
That’s really what you have to go back to all the time. If you turn it into a utilitarian equation with what is cheaper and more effective or whatever, it’s pretty much a lost cause. The only way to oppose these people is by going back to the moral issue, not arguing the specifics of their arguments (that are so complex that it’s pretty much impossible to prove to them that it is because of factor A instead of
.
What do you say to someone who says the Declaration of Independence doesn’t give you any rights. How do you argue the moral grounds of property rights and individual rights with a person like this?
What do you say to someone who says the Declaration of Independence doesn’t give you any rights.
I’d say I agree with them. Rights are derived from our nature as beings whose survival depends on our minds being free from the actions of others, not from legal documents.
How do you argue the moral grounds of property rights and individual rights with a person like this?
Make sure that you understand property rights are an extension of the freedom to act to pursue life. Human life requires value-oriented action, and if you cannot decide how to use or dispose of the values you create, those values have no meaning to you - you do not, in such a circumstance, have the right to pursue your own life.
It is best to focus on principles instead of concrete examples. If you’re going to use a concrete, explain the moral significance. Take lower healthcare costs, for example. State run healthcare CAN, in fact, keep costs down, but maybe this is a BAD thing. Low costs in state medical systems are secured through the monsterous practice of healthcare rationing - Gov’t bureaucrats deciding which procedures are available, who lives and who dies. If costly procedures are not allowed past a certain age, GDP is shifted away from healthcare. That’s sound money management - how benevolent! ![]()
-Edited for spelling
Broken record warning…this is still the best intellectual ammo around when arguing about health care.
I just read that thread Rocky Racoon and my best advice would be to leave those keyboard jockeys alone. Instead of arguing with them you should learn more about Objectivism and Health Care. Here is a good article by Thomas Sowell on health care, http://www.creators.com/opinion/thomas-sow…-realities.html
We do not have high quality medical care in the U.S. We may have better medical care than other countries, but that is a relative statement - our health care is still quite poor by objective standards. The drug companies have used the government to distort medical knowledge and create an intellectual environemt which is favorable to their interests and which suppresses competing products and treatment philosophies. Things are so fucked up that it’s not even safe to go to the doctor anymore.
We do not have high quality medical care in the U.S. We may have better medical care than other countries, but that is a relative statement - our health care is still quite poor by objective standards.
I think you’re wrong there. Healthcare for the typical middle-class working person is excellent in the U.S.
The drug companies have used the government to distort medical knowledge and create an intellectual environemt which is favorable to their interests and which suppresses competing products and treatment philosophies. Things are so fucked up that it’s not even safe to go to the doctor anymore.
Not sure what you are talking about! The FDA, perhaps? But “unsafe to go to a doctor”? Hyperbole, but even as hyperbole, I have no idea what you’re talking about. My family and I have seen various doctors, and been in various hospitals over the years. I’ve not noticed any dangers. My only shock the first time at a U.S. hospital was that it looked more like a good quality hotel.
I think you’re wrong there. Healthcare for the typical middle-class working person is excellent in the U.S.
Not sure what you are talking about! The FDA, perhaps? But “unsafe to go to a doctor”? Hyperbole, but even as hyperbole, I have no idea what you’re talking about. My family and I have seen various doctors, and been in various hospitals over the years. I’ve not noticed any dangers. My only shock the first time at a U.S. hospital was that it looked more like a good quality hotel.
The medical community is afflicted with a long list of extremely serious ideological problems which have cumulatively caused the quality of healthcare to deteriorate to the degree that doctors are now one of the leading causes of death in the U.S., with several hundred thousand people dying every year as a result of medical treatment. Doctors are handing drugs out like candy to pallate the symptoms of abusive lifestyle patterns while giving lip service to the paramount importance of diet and exercise, and most of them are just as fat and unhealthy as their patients anyway. Drug companies are lying about both the benefits and the dangers of their products. Psychiatrists are inventing one mental disorder after another and the rest of the medical community tolerates this utter pseudoscience. There is a trend toward anti-intellectuaism in general, argument from authority dominates medical dialogue, and many doctors are glarignly deficient in some of the most basic areas of physiological knowledge. If you have a musculosketal problem, especially a foot problem, you are more likely to be harmed than helped by the average doctor. Walk into any doctor’s office and the fucking place is typically a walk-in billboard for drug companies with pens, clipboards, stationery, posters, cups, models, etc. all provided by drug companies, and it does very much influence their prescribing habits. The FDA is utterly corrupt, now advocates primarily for industry, and data manipulation is standard proceedure. Academic medicine is a sick joke where conflicts of interest are so rampant that any academic research can be called into question simply by virtue of the fact that almost all reserachers are also paid “advisors” to drug companies. They put mercury in our mouths, fluroride in our water, plastic wedges in our shoes, 900 kinds of prescription crack in our kids’ brains, then insist that it’s all safe with literally nothing in the way of convincing proof, then turn around and attack fish oil and glucosamine supplements for not having gone through 5 year FDA clinical trials. The whole medical establishment is fucked up to the core and you can never appreciate how serious the problems are until you’ve been harmed by them.
We do not have high quality medical care in the U.S. We may have better medical care than other countries, but that is a relative statement - our health care is still quite poor by objective standards. The drug companies have used the government to distort medical knowledge and create an intellectual environemt which is favorable to their interests and which suppresses competing products and treatment philosophies. Things are so fucked up that it’s not even safe to go to the doctor anymore.
This is so ridiculous and out there that it barely warrants a response other than :lol:
I am under an allergist care for my nasal allergies. I have taken allergy pills that don’t do much for me, now I take one that does. I couldn’t breathe before, now I can.
When my leg was broke, I went to an orthopedic, had surgery and have since recovered. I can walk without a limp and have had no issues. I couldn’t walk before, now I can.
So why is it not safe for me to go to the doctor? Are you suggesting it would be better for me to never walk again and not breathe through my nose?
Furthermore, I say that most, if not all, of the problems in the medical community are caused by government intervention and frivolous lawsuits, by people that expect it to be free of cost and free of error.
Obama’s health care “reform” plan is shaping up as another big government fiasco. The private insurers, hospitals and drug companies are scared to death of what Obama has the ability to push through Congress so they are pledging to hold down costs in an effort to somehow mitigate the damage of this “reform” plan.
http://finance.yahoo.com/news/Obama-lauds-…set=&ccode=
I heard someone comment the other day that national health care is a true political game-changer because once it happens, elections are primarily about benefit levels as opposed to the legitimate functions of government (i.e. rights protection). The party that pledges to hand out the most goodies is the one that gets its candidates elected. Obama’s health care plan is making me sick.
There are so many issues not addressed in arguments against some form of public funds being put toward a national health care programme that proponents of a privatized proponent just doesnt take into account.
I live in Canada, not a perfect system by any stretch of the means, but I’d much prefer to pay an extra few dollars a year in tax dollars to know I will never go bankrupt from health crises, thus allowing me to get back to work and continue to be a contributing producer.
I have a surgery planned for later this month, I have two pre-op appointments, a day surgery, and I won’t be out of pocket on top of what I pay in taxes, which is not that much more than individuals who live in California or New York pay. Plus, in economic times like today, no one in Canada is losing a step, having to find an insurer - regardless of pre-existing condition(s).
Plus, I actually feel somewhat good to know that our individuals here in Canada do have access to world class health care, even if they can’t afford it. There are many individuals who would never receive proper treatment, therapy, etc., without the nationalized programme.
Again, no system is perfect, but, for those that will protest what I say, I happen to also believe that access to health care is a right, in the current light for some of the following reasons:
Tax dollars pay for hospital infrastructure, in a completely privatized system those without enough dollars couldn’t even get in to see a doctor, i suppose.
Tax dollars are used to educate doctors, etc. that work in the hospitals
Tax dollars pay for research that result in better treatment, equipment and therapy
Without proper health care provided to some individuals, the safety of some of the community would be in question (pandemics, mental health, etc)
Although points 1- 4 are not moral issues, from a moral perspective, I lie more on the side of valuing life as a whole. In the system now, in the US or other privatized system, it will always be more expensive to treat someone once a disease appears, rather than to have preemptive and ongoing care.
Go ahead, rip apart my points…
I’m pretty new to objectivism; but such a position as yours seems absolutely counter to what objectivism is. The items you list above can be used to justify intrusion and confiscation of individual property on a multitude of levels. For example you say Tax dollars are used to educate doctors; but one can also say that since tax dollars are used to educate school children in Canada; those children’s earnings as adults can be taxed at 80% heck even 99% to ensure that their neighbors have free healthcare, heating oil, food, clothing, cars, the list goes on. This response is getting much longer than I intended, but you get the drift. whew.
I’m pretty new to objectivism; but such a position as yours seems absolutely counter to what objectivism is.
Yes, of course you’re right. As far as I remember, Watson regularly argues against Objectivist positions.
It is common for the argument to be framed the way he did it: “I … feel … good to know that our individuals… have access to world class health care”.
But, actually he means he feels good about using force to take money from people, to provide that healthcare to others. it’s a common view, held by folks on the left and right, but no, its not Objectivism.
The socialists have been shouting for quite a while now that the health care system needs reform. I know that socialized medicine is not the answer. However, I have no rebuttal when it comes to their cries for reform. The problem is I don’t know squat about health care. What is wrong with the current system? What caused it?
Healthcare vouchers + Allow insurance to be sold across state lines, then allow the freemarket to work from there.
There are a lot of market-based “reforms” that could be implemented. Unfortunately, it seems that the party in power is intent on giving us “reform” that ultimately leads to a single-payer system. The Republicans are so clueless they can’t even bring themselves to offer a free market alternative that is seen as viable or that gets any publicity.
There are so many issues not addressed in arguments against some form of public funds being put toward a national health care programme that proponents of a privatized proponent just doesnt take into account.
I live in Canada, not a perfect system by any stretch of the means, but I’d much prefer to pay an extra few dollars a year in tax dollars to know I will never go bankrupt from health crises, thus allowing me to get back to work and continue to be a contributing producer.
I have a surgery planned for later this month, I have two pre-op appointments, a day surgery, and I won’t be out of pocket on top of what I pay in taxes, which is not that much more than individuals who live in California or New York pay. Plus, in economic times like today, no one in Canada is losing a step, having to find an insurer - regardless of pre-existing condition(s).
Plus, I actually feel somewhat good to know that our individuals here in Canada do have access to world class health care, even if they can’t afford it. There are many individuals who would never receive proper treatment, therapy, etc., without the nationalized programme.
Again, no system is perfect, but, for those that will protest what I say, I happen to also believe that access to health care is a right, in the current light for some of the following reasons:
Tax dollars pay for hospital infrastructure, in a completely privatized system those without enough dollars couldn’t even get in to see a doctor, i suppose.
Tax dollars are used to educate doctors, etc. that work in the hospitals
Tax dollars pay for research that result in better treatment, equipment and therapy
Without proper health care provided to some individuals, the safety of some of the community would be in question (pandemics, mental health, etc)
Although points 1- 4 are not moral issues, from a moral perspective, I lie more on the side of valuing life as a whole. In the system now, in the US or other privatized system, it will always be more expensive to treat someone once a disease appears, rather than to have preemptive and ongoing care.
Go ahead, rip apart my points…
You pay 40% of your tax dollars into a black hole called “health care” in Canada that doesn’t offer the same quality of care as a free market system. Even the U.S. offers, all other things being equal, faster wait times (or maybe that’s lower wait times).
Your “facts” as they are, aren’t really facts at all. They’re simply wrong - factually. You’d pay no where near what you do in taxes and thus for health care under a free market system. A close example would be 1920s America. Of course, it’s not a perfect example as there is a discrepancy in technology between then and now, but like I said, all other things being equal, your health care would be cheaper under the free market (or something closer to it that what you have). AND, your care would be better.
You’d pay no where near what you do in taxes and thus for health care under a free market system. A close example would be 1920s America. Of course, it’s not a perfect example as there is a discrepancy in technology between then and now, but like I said, all other things being equal, your health care would be cheaper under the free market (or something closer to it that what you have). AND, your care would be better.
So true. I’m constantly amazed at the faith people place in government’s ability to deliver goods and services when there is very little evidence that the government can run anything efficiently. If you want to see how well bureaucrats manage a healthcare program, you don’t need to look beyond Medicare. Medicare is headed toward insolvency even faster than Social Security.
http://online.wsj.com/article/BT-CO-20090512-718085.html
That’s what we have to look forward to under government healthcare.