The socialists have been shouting for quite a while now that the health care system needs reform. I know that socialized medicine is not the answer. However, I have no rebuttal when it comes to their cries for reform. The problem is I don’t know squat about health care. What is wrong with the current system? What caused it?
It’s not free and people prefer handouts.
Nearly all politicians, Republicans and Democrats, agree that not enough people have health insurance. The Democrats want to fully socialize the health care system; the Republicans want to keep it semi-socialized and provide tax incentives and the like to employers to “encourage” them to provide health insurance. They are assuming that health care is a right. The most simple rebuttal is that it is not a right, but a privilege limited to people able to pay for it.
Really, the biggest problem with the health care system is that it is not free. The government provides health insurance for a variety of groups (just look at the mess that is Medicare/Medicaid!) and screws with basic market mechanisms like competition.
It isn’t often one has the perfect response to a question. This is a long but invaluable read:
As a shameless plug, for more information on health care please feel free to visit the website for Freedom and Individual Rights in Medicine.
In addition to the longer article that Steve already linked to, there are also a couple of short articles that I like to recommend, including:
“Health Care Is Not A Right” by Leonard Peikoff
“The Right Vision of Health Care” by Yaron Brook
There are also regular updates and commentary (at least 3-4 times/week) at the FIRM blog.
Brian Schwartz runs a good health care blog at PatientPower.
Richard Ralston also has good information at Americans for Free Choice in Medicine (AFCM).
Hope this helps!
It’s no coincidence that the more government gets involved in a given industry, the more screwed up that industry becomes. Healthcare, banking, autos, etc…
Today Obama told 100,000 people in Missouri, “I think every single American has a right to affordable accessible health care.”
The socialists have been shouting for quite a while now that the health care system needs reform. I know that socialized medicine is not the answer. However, I have no rebuttal when it comes to their cries for reform. The problem is I don’t know squat about health care. What is wrong with the current system? What caused it?
This is the most succinct explanation I’ve seen so far of why the system is so screwed up today:
Because a person’s health, or lack of it, lies increasingly within his own control, many, if not most health risks, are actually uninsurable. “Insurance” against risks whose likelihood an individual can systematically influence falls within that person’s own responsibility.
All insurance, moreover, involves the pooling of individual risks. It implies that insurers pay more to some and less to others. But no one knows in advance, and with certainty, who the “winners” and “losers” will be. “Winners” and “losers” are distributed randomly, and the resulting income redistribution is unsystematic. If “winners” or “losers” could be systematically predicted, “losers” would not want to pool their risk with “winners,” but with other “losers,” because this would lower their insurance costs. I would not want to pool my personal accident risks with those of professional football players, for instance, but exclusively with those of people in circumstances similar to my own, at lower costs.
Because of legal restrictions on the health insurers’ right of refusal–to exclude any individual risk as uninsurable–the present health-insurance system is only partly concerned with insurance. The industry cannot discriminate freely among different groups’ risks.
As a result, health insurers cover a multitude of uninnsurable risks, alongside, and pooled with, genuine insurance risks. They do not discriminate among various groups of people which pose significantly different insurance risks. The industry thus runs a system of income redistribution–benefiting irresponsible actors and high-risk groups at the expense of responsible individuals and low risk groups. Accordingly the industry’s prices are high and ballooning. - Source: http://mises.org/freemarket_detail.aspx?control=279
This also addresses some pretty good myths that are often regurgitated by lefties:
The state is trying to shut down a New York City doctor’s ambitious plan to treat uninsured patients for around $1,000 a year. Dr. John Muney (pictured above) offers his patients everything from mammograms to mole removal at his AMG Medical Group clinics, which operate in all five boroughs. His patients agree to pay $79 a month for a year in return for unlimited office visits with a $10 co-pay.
“I’m trying to help uninsured people here,” he said.
But his plan landed him in the crosshairs of the state Insurance Department, which ordered him to drop his fixed-rate plan - which it claims is equivalent to an insurance policy.
There are so many issues not addressed in arguments against some form of public funds being put toward a national health care programme that proponents of a privatized proponent just doesnt take into account.
I live in Canada, not a perfect system by any stretch of the means, but I’d much prefer to pay an extra few dollars a year in tax dollars to know I will never go bankrupt from health crises, thus allowing me to get back to work and continue to be a contributing producer.
I have a surgery planned for later this month, I have two pre-op appointments, a day surgery, and I won’t be out of pocket on top of what I pay in taxes, which is not that much more than individuals who live in California or New York pay. Plus, in economic times like today, no one in Canada is losing a step, having to find an insurer - regardless of pre-existing condition(s).
Plus, I actually feel somewhat good to know that our individuals here in Canada do have access to world class health care, even if they can’t afford it. There are many individuals who would never receive proper treatment, therapy, etc., without the nationalized programme.
Again, no system is perfect, but, for those that will protest what I say, I happen to also believe that access to health care is a right, in the current light for some of the following reasons:
-
Tax dollars pay for hospital infrastructure, in a completely privatized system those without enough dollars couldn’t even get in to see a doctor, i suppose.
-
Tax dollars are used to educate doctors, etc. that work in the hospitals
-
Tax dollars pay for research that result in better treatment, equipment and therapy
-
Without proper health care provided to some individuals, the safety of some of the community would be in question (pandemics, mental health, etc)
-
Although points 1- 4 are not moral issues, from a moral perspective, I lie more on the side of valuing life as a whole. In the system now, in the US or other privatized system, it will always be more expensive to treat someone once a disease appears, rather than to have preemptive and ongoing care.
Go ahead, rip apart my points…
Why is it my (or anyone else’s) responsibility to pay for your health care?
Health care is NOT a right. You have a right to pursue happiness, not a right to force me to provide it to you.
You need to read this and this.
In a laissez faire capitalist society, people and businesses would be more prosperous, health care would be affordable and accessible, and insurance could be tailor made for each client. In addition, charities would receive the funds they need to help the few who are genuinely in need and family members and friends could afford to help their family members or friends in genuine need.
Humans are creative and necessity is the mother of invention. I have no doubt, that when left to themselves, free men would be quite capable of coming up with solutions to their problems. We don’t need a nanny government to take care of us. It never has and they never will.
And finally, if Canadian health care is so great, why are your government officials coming here for care?
Stronach, diagnosed in the spring with a type of breast cancer that required a mastectomy and breast reconstruction, went to California in June at her Toronto doctor’s suggestion, a spokesperson confirmed.
A mastectomy and reconstruction is unusual or difficult to get in Canada?!
Speed was not the issue, MacEachern said – it was more to do with the type of surgery she and her doctor agreed was best for her, and where it was best performed. The type of cancer Stronach had is called DCIS, ductal carcinoma in situ, one of the more treatable forms.
If it’s one of the more treatable forms, why can’t it be taken care of in Canada? You mean in that whole country up there, no doctors could treat this for her or perform those routine procedures?!
Why is it my (or anyone else’s) responsibility to pay for your health care?
Health care is NOT a right. You have a right to pursue happiness, not a right to force me to provide it to you.
You need to read this and this.
In a laissez faire capitalist society, people and businesses would be more prosperous, health care would be affordable and accessible, and insurance could be tailor made for each client. In addition, charities would receive the funds they need to help the few who are genuinely in need and family members and friends could afford to help their family members or friends in genuine need.
Humans are creative and necessity is the mother of invention. I have no doubt, that when left to themselves, free men would be quite capable of coming up with solutions to their problems. We don’t need a nanny government to take care of us. It never has and they never will.
And finally, if Canadian health care is so great, why are your government officials coming here for care?
A mastectomy and reconstruction is unusual or difficult to get in Canada?!
If it’s one of the more treatable forms, why can’t it be taken care of in Canada? You mean in that whole country up there, no doctors could treat this for her or perform those routine procedures?!
Stronach had a choice to go to the US. Just as in the US insurance companies will refuse to pay for some procedures, tests, etc. And I hardly see Stronach as a government official. She went into politics on a whim from a billionaire lifestyle. She was in politics for about two years.
Insurance in the private sector does use the premiums used from the collective (clients) to pay for the pool of individuals who do use the health care system. I’m sure your argument would be that there is a “choice” whether or not to purchase health care insurance, not “forced” by the government at gun point to pony up. It is not your “responsibility” to pay for my health care, but it is definitely in your best interest to understand that a healthy society is a more productive society, economically, intellectually, etc. Part of the problem is the cost of emergency care. It will always be cheaper to have ongoing care than emergency care. Treating heart disease throughout someone’s life will always be cheaper than an emergency by-pass operation.
I would like to hear from objectivist individuals who have been bankrupt by health care expenses, even if they had chosen a health insurance policy they thought covered them. The cost of health insurance policies, deductibles, co-pays, etc., in the US for a family probably negates much of the tax differential between individuals in the two countries.
I guess noone can force anyone to treat a sick individual, but i do believe that it is a right, in the north american society, to have access to someone (doctor or otherwise) that has been trained using tax dollars to treat a taxpayer.
What happens when the “few” who need economic help for health care are not so few that it exhausts the funds put into such pools of financial resources? The economies of scale work just fine. What happens when individuals with Swine flu/SARS don’t seek medical attention because they can’t afford to go to their doctor, ER, thus putting the entire population of a community at risk for infection?
Don’t get me wrong, I think there is a good balance of a canadian system and some other system, where there is some onus put on the individual to foot the bill for some of their health care choices, to limit the costs by making people in a country like canada think before using or abusing the system.
I guess noone can force anyone to treat a sick individual, but i do believe that it is a right, in the north american society, to have access to someone (doctor or otherwise) that has been trained using tax dollars to treat a taxpayer.
If no one can force anyone to treat a sick individual, how do you propose the government secure your right to health care?
What other personal responsibilities of yours do you think I should be forced to pay for? Car insurance? After all, in today’s society, especially in N. America, one practically needs a car to survive. How about home/renters insurance? After all, doesn’t everyone have the right to a home?
I think what people are missing here is that watson is predicating his alleged right on the fact that government money was used to train the doctor. He is figuring if government paid for the training then “society” owns the doctor.
Never mind the fact that government interference is what has made it almost impossible to do anything without the government being involved; you took the money [because you had no choice], you are now a slave.
*sigh*
Never mind the fact that government interference is what has made it almost impossible to do anything without the government being involved; you took the money [because you had no choice], you are now a slave.
Yes, and to emphasize your point, the situation is even more absurd. The government, acting like a mob boss, forces you to give them money at the point of a gun, and then when you try to get it back by using some of it to become a Doctor, they say: “And now you owe us”.
Yes, and to emphasize your point, the situation is even more absurd. The government, acting like a mob boss, forces you to give them money at the point of a gun, and then when you try to get it back by using some of it to become a Doctor, they say: “And now you owe us”.
The people who live on welfare “owe us” but do they pay us back, NO.
I live in Canada, not a perfect system by any stretch of the means, but I’d much prefer to pay an extra few dollars a year in tax dollars to know I will never go bankrupt from health crises, thus allowing me to get back to work and continue to be a contributing producer.
This argument can be used to support the same type of solution to much more practical problems than health care, do you support those efforts also? I’m sure there are more people in need of food and clothing than health care, so don’t you think that the government should forcibly tax you and everyone else to support those needs? How about college, a home, heating oil, a higher paying job, a car to get to work, dental care, eye care? What you are saying is that, in principle, there is no reason why the government (meaning tax payers) shouldn’t provide these to the needy also, right?
Essentially, you think that the Soviet Union had a better idea than the US, is that right? Perhaps they were just flawed in their execution of that idea, yes?
I happen to also believe that access to health care is a right,
If health care is a right, then Doctors are slaves.
I can accept that taxation is force is immoral when you agree on the fact that the initiation of force is immoral. Objectivists do state that a government is need for protection and to perform Retaliatory Force. Ok, seems logical. So we could state that social health care is immoral.
But that leaves the question if it would “work”, as for example here in the field of medical and health supplies (privatized).
First what do I mean with “work”?
IMO there are two ways to see this.
a) high quality health care
B) high quantity health care
The biggest part of the population in a laissez faire capitalism would earn just a tiny percentage of what the people at the top make, that would lead to a “multiple-class” health care system. In other words very good health care for the rich, likely much better than in a mixed system, while most of the population would have a “medicore” health care.
I’m not sure if this “mediocre” would be better than what we see now in the western world, but it could be so.
But that would also lead to a state where the poor and very poor simply could not get any health care. For them an illness that would be no problem for the richer people, will lead to death (in the worst case).
The same is probably true for people with bad genes (IE lots of cancer cases in the family), too much previous illnesses or any other indication that they have a higher risk of getting sick, even if they had a “normal” income.
It would simply not make sense for insurance companies to sell these groups insurance.
So it could work in a) but fail in B) .
In a worst case scenario one could think about social unrests because of such a situation or danger for society because of the spread of viruses / bacteria among the poor.
In such a case it might be reasonable to spend a part of the government budged (not taxes) for a minimum health care for the very poor, because doing nothing could costs more in the end.
Your logic has one fatal flaw (probably more, but I’m just focusing on one). You are making the mistake of equating getting healthcare with getting insurance. In a free system the average (and even the below average) person would easily be able to afford routine procedures and care without insurance playing any role, which is as it should be. The solution is to have insurance packages with less coverage, not more. As more and more people pay for medical procedures a la carte like one would buy any other service, supply and demand will equal out and prices will drop drastically. The true purpose of health insurance is to cover catastrophic injury, and a fairly bare-bones insurance package would be dirt cheap in a free society. Therefore you would not have to worry about going bankrupt from being run over by a bus.
Also, a free system would eliminate the so-called “gold plating” of medical care, another reason it is so expensive. Imagine if the next time you had an infection, you could just go to CVS, get diagnosed by a nurse or some other comparable medical technician, and pick up your antibiotic on the spot. A doctor wouldn’t even have to factor into the equation. Competition from alternative healthcare sources as I have just described would force doctors to lower their prices to market levels.
It is true that people with more money will be able to afford more and/or better care, but how is that different from anything else in the market? In a free system even extremely poor people would be able to afford the most basic care and drugs.
I can accept that taxation is force is immoral when you agree on the fact that the initiation of force is immoral. Objectivists do state that a government is need for protection and to perform Retaliatory Force. Ok, seems logical. So we could state that social health care is immoral.
But that leaves the question if it would “work”, as for example here in the field of medical and health supplies (privatized).
First what do I mean with “work”?
IMO there are two ways to see this.
a) high quality health care
B) high quantity health care
The biggest part of the population in a laissez faire capitalism would earn just a tiny percentage of what the people at the top make, that would lead to a “multiple-class” health care system. In other words very good health care for the rich, likely much better than in a mixed system, while most of the population would have a “medicore” health care.
I’m not sure if this “mediocre” would be better than what we see now in the western world, but it could be so.
But that would also lead to a state where the poor and very poor simply could not get any health care. For them an illness that would be no problem for the richer people, will lead to death (in the worst case).
The same is probably true for people with bad genes (IE lots of cancer cases in the family), too much previous illnesses or any other indication that they have a higher risk of getting sick, even if they had a “normal” income.
It would simply not make sense for insurance companies to sell these groups insurance.
So it could work in a) but fail in B) .
In a worst case scenario one could think about social unrests because of such a situation or danger for society because of the spread of viruses / bacteria among the poor.
In such a case it might be reasonable to spend a part of the government budged (not taxes) for a minimum health care for the very poor, because doing nothing could costs more in the end.
The biggest part of the population in a laissez faire capitalism would earn just a tiny percentage of what the people at the top make, that would lead to a “multiple-class” health care system. In other words very good health care for the rich, likely much better than in a mixed system, while most of the population would have a “medicore” health care.
In Mexico there are private hospitals and doctors, along with a mish-mash of local, state and federal health care systems. I know a fair deal about both. So:
-
Private hospitals come on many levles. there are some who aim for middle class customers, others for low-income customers (surprised?), charitable hospitals that charge little or nothing. There are none that cater only to the rich, but there are some in the better parts of town who have fancier rooms for richer customers.
-
A fancier room is about all a richer hospital patient gets that other people wouldn’t. The hospitals I know, and I know several, don’t ahve more doctors or nurses on call for such patients, nor are the abs, imaging equipment or ORs reserved for the rich (they get apportioned in the order doctors request them, or on the medical urgency of the patient).
-
The people who run the government hospitals and clinics by and large, when they can afford to, buy health insurance for themselves adn their families, even though they have free access to government health services. What does that tell you?
-
This is anecdotal, but very instructive. One time my boss had a meeting at a government medical center, a complex of five hospitals taking up an entire city block. Next to this center there’s a general government hospital taking up another city block. Behind these two there’s yet a third government hospital specializing in pediatrics. My boss’ driver fell ill and was rushed all the way accros town to his government appointed clinic. Imagine that, during a minor emergency, when there are eight hospitals right accross the street with well over a hundred doctors all told. But that’w how the system works in government health care. To be admitted or treated at a hospital you need to be refferred by your local clinic (there are some government hospitals that will take in emergency patients, but only a few and only if they qualify).
-
Most of the population relies on government hospitals or charitabel institutions. Sharities have very little luck setting up hospitals and clinics for the poor, because prospective donors assume the government takes care of such things.
-
The level of care at government facilties isn’t bad, but it’s limited. Ergo the exclussion of even mergency patients without referals.