My third post is just my view on homosexuality, a reply to the OP. It isn’t directed at anything you said.
I didn’t realize that your analogy was trying to prove that we can choose who we are attracted too. I thought you were trying to say that if one thinks its ok for someone to be an active homosexual because they have no choice but to be attracted to men, then it is ok for someone to be an active pedophile if they have no choice but to be attracted to children. An analogy, that people have made before.
I don’t believe though, that the premise that sexual desires are uncontrollable leads to the conclusion that we should let rapists out of jail. Fire doesn’t have a choice either, but that won’t stop firefighters from putting them out. We don’t hurt the fire by putting it out though. While putting a rapist in jail will cause him anguish for acting on his uncontrollable sexual desires. But letting him out with cause some women anguish. Even if fire did feel pain, you wouldn’t let it spread and cause other people pain just because it’s in its nature to spread.
You said “If in fact, one’s sexual orientation was beyond his control, then the specific types sexual desire that one fulfills by raping someone, molesting a kid, or looking at nude kids would be an integral part of their identity. If that’s the case, then they should definitely not be punished for acting within their nature.”
Just because its in their nature to want something, doesn’t mean they can rightfully have it. Plus, putting people in prison isn’t just for punishment, it’s also for prevention and sometimes for help. You can also turn this around and say we should punish rapists because we have the natural desire to punish rapists and we’re just acting on our nature.
And let me be clear about what I think most of you think I don’t realize:
I don’t think that people can choose whether or not to have sexual desires, I just think that people can choose which sexual desires to have (And for the record, if I had to choose right now, I think that a heterosexual relationship, where the man is strickly a man and dresses like a man and where the woman is strictly a woman and dresses like a woman is the most preferable).
Grant Williams
Hey now, speak for yourself. You may be able to choose to like guys, but I sure can’t. No more than I can choose to like green eggs and ham.
I agree. That’s why I’ve said time and time again that it’s not in their nature to desire raping someone or molesting kids or stealing someone’s food or having sex with someone of the same sex. It’s a choice. Whether it was conciously arrived at or subconciously arrived at as the result of some previous, more fundamental choice. It’s still a choice.
Are you forgetting that I wasn’t advocating the premise that people were hopelessly susceptible to their desires? I was taking it to it’s logical conclusion.
Because they’re not hopelessly susceptible to their desires, they have the choice to not only act or not act upon those desires, but also to create, destroy, or alter the desires themselves.
You say that since they are “not hopelessly susceptible to their desires” that they “have the choice to not only act or not act upon those desires, but also to create, destroy, and alter the desires themslelves”.
How exactly did you come to that conclusion? Why can they change what they desire just because they have a choice to not indulge those desires? Not doing something you want to do, and completely destroying your desire to want to do something, are two completely different thing. Just because you can choose to not break into a girls house and rape her doesn’t mean you can also choose not to want to in the first place. Actions taken and desires felt are very different. I am not hopelessly susceptible to the desire for chocolate milk, I can choose to drink or not drink it. But how does that suggest that I can also create, destroy, and alter my desires for chocolate milk?
Btw: Can you really create a desire for men if you choose? Are you being completely serious about that? :blink:
It’s a choice. Whether it was conciously arrived at or subconciously arrived at as the result of some previous, more fundamental choice. It’s still a choice.
You completely ignored that statement.
That’s a psychological issue that I’d rather not get into.
I suggest books by Nathaniel Branden to help you gain the concepts to understand where I’m coming from.
Your BTW question is interesting though… I don’t think you can create that desire only because it seems like it would require a high-degree of rational thought and a deep understanding of psychology to be able to change deep-seated sexual desires. And it seems to me that the more rational and the knowledgable of human sexual psychology one becomes, they will start to desire a heterosexual lifestyle simply because it’s a more rational, reality-oriented, rewarding lifestyle.
So you are saying that my desire for chocolate milk is a subconscious decision that I make? While taking a drink of it is a conscious decision? Are you saying that all desires are subconscious decisions that we make, such as eating fruit and meat instead of grass like a cow?
You say that being attracted to the opposite sex is more rational? Well, what about being attracted to the opposite gender? And not everyone is one or the other sex, or one or the other gender. Sometimes they are mixed, so what is rational for them?
And how is a heterosexual lifestyle a more rational, reality-oriented, and rewarding lifestyle? People are hetersexual because males are designed to like females and vise verse because that is how we spread and mix our genes, not because it’s rational or reality-oriented. Being rational is a way of thinking, not a way of feeling. It’s not as if I don’t like to eat grass because I feel that it’s not rational or reality-oriented. And I don’t think other animals such as dogs are attracted to the scent of a female instead of a male because it’s more rational either, they just are. Desires are present in rather stupid lifeforms that don’t know what it is to be rational, but their desires still make sense as far as their survival is concerned. You won’t see a squirrel happily chewing on a rock or anything. Well probably not anyways, heh.
People have certain desires, some of them were conciously accepted, some of them subconciously (as the result of previously accepted ideas).
Most important and personal things, like sexual desires, were accepted at an early age. That’s why they’re subconciously held. They were accepted at a time when the person was less critical and much more impressionable. They guide a person’s actions even if he doesn’t realize that they’re there; much less understand them.
This does not mean that once someone realizes that these desires are there, he is stuck with them. He can study them, talk with others about them, read about them, and come to understand them. Then he can evaluate them. He decides whether or not they are good for him and help him become the type of person he wants to become. Then he can either try to adjust, replace them with something different, or get rid of them completely.
As for all of your ballyhoo about how just because someone accepts the reality that a meeting of the male and female genetalias results in a “spread(ing) and mix(ing) of our genes” isn’t reality-oriented and about the parallels between dog psychology and human psychology. I don’t know what to tell ya other than Humans have a specific type of brain, and dogs have another. And if pointing out and being concerned for what actually happens isn’t reality-oriented, I don’t know what is.
There’s nothing that I don’t understand. You just haven’t shown any reason to believe what you are saying other than you said so. For example, you say we don’t have a choice to have sexual desires or not, but that we have a choice what we sexually desire. You just draw up conclusions such as this with no premises.
You also say that what I am saying is wrong, but don’t say why it is wrong. You call it “ballyhoo” but don’t give any reasons why it is. You also ignore certain points that are made. You still haven’t addressed what people who have mixed masculine and feminine attributes should do. You seem too intent on believing in what you want to believe to even consider thinking about it in another way.
I think you’re missing the point that desires aren’t what we choose, but what causes us to choose. I choose to eat breakfeast, because I have hunger, the desire to eat. I don’t choose to have the desire to eat, I don’t choose to have hunger. Hunger is what makes me choose to get up and go get something out of the fridge. Male heterosexuals choose to be with females because they have a desire for them. It’s no secret that male homosexuals have feminine attributes. It seems like a coincidence that all the males with larger corpus callosums for instance, decided to be attracted to males and also decided to not be attracted to females when they were young.
You choose to eat because you desire to live. You can desire to die.
Hunger does not compel you to choose to eat. To be compeled to make a choice makes absolutely no sense.
You choose to make love because you desire to enjoy living. You can choose to not enjoy life.
Sexual desire does not compel you to choose to have sex. And it certainly doesn’t compel you to choose what type of person to have sex with.
Yes, in order to live, a person must have a goal, a desire, a value to pursue. It can either be actually good for them or actually bad for them, but they cannot expect to live by stagnating. “X can be any number, but it has to be some number”.
I already told you why I don’t want to get dragged into an extensive, off topic, discussion about human/rational (not dog/irrational) psychology that deserves a whole other thread.
I gave you references to understand where I’m coming from.
The hermaphordite quagmire? I really don’t care. All I can say is that anyone who has both a penis and a vagina which gender would be the most expeditious, based upon their past experiences, to completely identify with and look into surgery. That’s such a marginal, distracting question.
Being rational is a way of thinking, not a way of feeling.
…the implication being that thought and emotion are totally unrelated, and the cause of emotions is…blank-out. You can call them instincts, the result of hormonal activities in the brain, or primaries of consciousness–but that just evades the actual question. And it is completely wrong anyway, as a bit of introspection on your part will reveal that your emotions do in fact have causes rooted in your premises. Chemical activities in the brain may be a necessary condition, but not a sufficient one.
I think you’re missing the point that desires aren’t what we choose, but what causes us to choose.
You got that from Hume. Which is not the best philosophical influence to have. Try reading some Ayn Rand on emotion and free will, or check out Harry Binswanger’s lectures on emotion and free will. (Choice is an irreducible primary, and if you claim that our choices are caused by our feelings, and our feelings are caused by ?, then we are deterministic puppets of random whims–so what are you doing on an Objectivist discussion board?)
I got that from Hume? Lol, I don’t even know who that is. And my statement was rather simplistic, a lot of people have probably said that before.
I didn’t mean that you got it directly from Hume (although that was a definite possibility), but probably from Humean influences in our culture. Or it is possible that you simply made a mistake in your own thinking, since upon superficial introspection it may seem as though one’s desire “cause” one’s choices.
But that leads you down the road of saying that desires are primaries of consciousness, that they have nothing to do with reason, and that “it is not against reason to prefer the destruction of the world to the scratching of my finger.” (Or in this case, that it is not against reason to prefer having forcible sex with small children to a loving relationship with a consenting adult. In fact, it is against reason.) And I don’t think you really want to go down that road. What awaits one who does (such as Hume) at the end is not pretty.
I would suggest that you study more on the Objectivist views of emotion and its relation to reason and volition.
Hmm… Hume kinda sounds interesting. Especially that whole finger scratching thing.
If, by “interesting”, you mean “demented”, then sure. But I always thought he was kind of a bore, and always get pissed off when philosophy professors waste my time and insult my intelligence by requiring that crap. (Hume also denied causality, the self, and a number of other self-evident phenomena. He claimed that you can’t know that a billiard ball struck by another ball will roll in a certain direction or at all, that eating bread will provide you with nourishment and keep you alive, or that the sun will rise tomorrow. He ended up as a paralyzed skeptic. If that’s what you think is interesting, maybe as a case-study of the psychological effects of accepting bad premises, but I don’t know.)
On the other hand, this thread points to the reason why people should study other philosophies besides Objectivism. It helps them understand Objectivism better, to be able to differentiate it from nonsense like Hume’s, and to see how Objectivism corrected the errors of those other philosophies to help prevent one from making those mistakes themselves and thinking that they are compatible with Objectivism.
As a side note, I’m not even getting into the whole “is homosexuality immoral?” discussion, because at this point, I don’t really know.
I agree, people should study other philosophies aside from Objectivism. I tried in my philosophyclass but my professor kept wasting my time with a bunch of non-Objectivist crap that was absolutely worthless. Professors tend to be too objective when the present a colloquium on the major ideas that have shaped western thought. I HATE NON-OBJECTIVIST OBJECTIVISTS!
I agree, people should study other philosophies aside from Objectivism. I tried in my philosophyclass but my professor kept wasting my time with a bunch of non-Objectivist crap that was absolutely worthless. Professors tend to be too objective when the present a colloquium on the major ideas that have shaped western thought. I HATE NON-OBJECTIVIST OBJECTIVISTS!
Grant Williams
:blink: Huh? I don’t think I quite followed all that. Anyway, if we want to have a discussion about the benefits of studying other philosophies, it should probably be continued in a separate thread.