I wanted to add something to this thread that I created, even though it’s been a few months since it’s been active.
In the Objectivist Epistemology, Rand makes it very clear that the last step of concept formation is to name the concept.
In the latest revised edition, with the Q&A at the end, she reiterates this point - the naming of a concept ties together the importance of objective language and concept formation.
There is an article that recently appeared on “spiked-online” (I admittedly am not familiar with this site outside of this one article, so please don’t take this as a promotion for that site) that spoke to the recent trend of “identifying” subjectively with some external aspect of existence as opposed to objectively naming WHAT (who) we are.
http://www.spiked-online.com/spiked-review/article/the-crisis-of-character/17691#.VoQIIjfnbkL
Such is a symptom of the anti-conceptual mentality that refuses to admit the law of identity into it’s consciousness - the refusal to define oneself.
And, as we all know, definitions are of key importance to coming to an understanding both within our own minds and with others.
Thus, those who wish for others not to understand them, those who wish desperately not to be defined, those who “identify” with vague notions rather than explicitly define who and what they are within the appropriate contexts, are desperately revealing a dangerous aspect of themselves.
They ultimately wish not to be.
Or at least, they wish to evade the necessity of making the choices inherent in existing.
They are attempting to entertain contradictions by refusing to name and define themselves objectively.
Unless one excludes so many key characteristics of a conceptual integration that it ultimately resembles nothing and is no longer a concept at all, one can NOT be a woman AND a man. One can NOT be an objectivist and a subjectivist (in definition - errors in cognition will occur). Otherwise, to quote from the article “Feeling is reality. The entirely subjective sentiment becomes objective, legal fact.”
So to bring it full circle, and to add context to my original question - there is no question as to whether an objectivist is an objectivist in name, definition, and concept, or whether an objectivist should make the claim that they are an objectivist (if only within their own mind, at a minimum.).
These are a given for a rational thinker who understands the concept.
The question is whether it benefits the objectivist to share this FACT of their identity (having no reasonable cause to doubt it’s truth) with others.
To sanction an anti-conceptual philosophical opponent by giving them a bulls-eye to target with their brain dead zero-reifications is to sanction their assault on your mind (see my post on Sanctioning Skeptics).
Therefore, the answer to my own question is that I will share the fact of my objectivism with those who will be of greater benefit to my highest values in knowing this information.
My wife, who is open to these ideas and understands them at a high-level and supports my quest to improve myself with a rational, non-contradictory moral philosophy.
My children, who I endeavor to guide towards being the noblest expression of my values.
Friends and strangers, who I induce may be receptive to objectivist ideas and who may latch onto these concepts and improve the world for me through their own efforts, and hopefully, may turn around and educate me on some aspects I haven’t considered myself.
All the rest, I have found, pose the detriment of conflict and misunderstanding when I share Rands theories, and I have not found value in these interactions. These people will not receive the benefit of further interaction with me on this topic, and I find there is no benefit to me in my sharing this objective definition of my self with them.
Please read the linked article and let me know your thoughts.