Identifying Sense of life of Musical Pieces

So, according to you, generally, minor scales are more “dim” while major ones are more “bright”.

In a way, yes. If you play a WHOLE scale you will hear “happy” from major & “sad” from minor. Of course it gets more detailed than that because any given melody does not necessarily use all the notes from a scale; some melodies use notes from each scale. But, depending upon which scale a melody (or part of a melody) is BASED will result in this effect.

Just as importantly, the harmonies (resultant chords) formed/implied by the use of various scales give a more complete picture.

Major chords are more consonant (lower ratios=pleasant) & minor chords more dissonant (higher ratios=unpleasant). Unisons (octaves, C to next higher C) are the most consonant interval (1:2), the fifth (C to G) is the next (1:1.5), the MAJOR (C to E) third next (1:1.25). The MINOR third (C to E flat) is (5:6). So the notes of a MAJOR chord (C-E-G) form a combined ratio of (4:5:6) & a MINOR chord (5:6:7). Dominant 7 chords, diminished chords, & contain a lot of dissonance, so they are typically used to build tension toward the end of a phrase. Then comes a major chord (or even minor) to release the tension because they are more consonant (or conversely, less dissonant).

Here’s a way of symbolizing it:

  1. consonance-solid sound

  2. less consonance-less solid sounding

  3. dissonant sound-tension builds

  4. more dissonant-MORE tension

  5. consonance returns-tension released

I take it then that generally Half-cadence suggests a question and full-cadence an answer. Do you know any exceptions to this?

When HC & FC are used their function is to provide the Q&A phrasing. One w/o the other is also widely used. For example, some melodies are based on modes & therefore do not necessarily contain “traditional” cadences. But there can still be a sense of direction to the melody. When a five chord happens without resolving to a one chord it is not necessarily “bad”; it can provide tension that is not resolved.

Since each half cadence represents a change in frequency by 2 raised to root 12, this would mean that human ear regards a frequency change by 2 raised to 12 times a question and a frequency change of 2 raised to 6 times an answer as a rule.

I think you are confusing half-cadence with half-step & full-cadence with whole-step. Half- & whole-steps are interval distances between notes. Cadences are musical chord sequences (involving at least two voices) moving to a harmonic close or point of rest, thereby providing a sense of harmonic direction or completion. The ratio between the frequencies of any two notes a half step apart is 1.05946309436. Using the musical alphabet, if C is 435Hz then:

435 times 12th root of 2 (1.05946309436) = approx. 460Hz (or the note C sharp)

HC is ending a phrase on the five chord (using scale notes 5, 7, 2) (& 4 if it is a full dominant 7 chord) meaning that the melody notes should be one of those scale notes. FC is ending a phrase on the one chord (using scale notes 1, 3, 5) meaning that the melody should be one of those scale notes.

This site is good at describing/playing cadences:

http://www.music.vt.edu/musicdictionary/ap…ce/cadence.html

So, Does the human ear automatically regard a certain frequency as a black note or is it because we are so used to hearing C at 435~440 Hz that we automatically assign a white note to it? I think this is a crucial question because the answer would establish whether only the change in frequency is regarded as meaningful or the frequencies which we hear themselves have a meaning to them. I am inclined towards the former view.

“Black & white notes” are merely results of the way a standard piano is layed out. The ear/mind does not care if a black key or white is played. What matters are the intervals between the notes (sequentially in a melody, concurrently in a harmony)regardless of whether or not they are accidentals (sharps, flats, black keys). The “change in frequency” is definitely where the meaning comes in (along with how consonant versus dissonant, dynamic level, timbre, etc.).

If the former view is correct it means that the black notes and the minor scale give a grave picture only because it is a 12root2 change from the white notes. And this would lead to the conclusion that a 12root2 change represents uncertainty/graveness and a 6root2 change represents a finality.

Again, I think you are confusing half-cadence with half-step & full-cadence with whole-step. The 12th root of 2 is a half-step interval & the 6th root of 2 is a whole-step interval. But both scales have EQUAL amounts of half-step & whole-step intervals. The crucial difference is WHERE in the scale they occur.

Listen to the scales again & keep these formulas in mind (WS=whole step, HS=half step):

Major scale formula:

1 - WS - 2 - WS - 3 - HS - 4 - WS - 5 - WS - 6 - WS - 7 - HS - 1

Minor scale formula:

1 - WS - 2 - HS - 3 - WS - 4 - WS - 5 - HS - 6 - WS - 7 - WS - 1

Major has a WS between scale degrees 2 & 3; minor has a HS. This is part of the reason they are perceived respectively as happy/sad, pleasure/pain.

Wouldn’t this mean that if the conclusion of the piece is at a black/grave note, then the piece has a malevolent/uncertain sense of life?

In some cases that might be possible, but I don’t think it is that simple. I think it has more to do with how well (or not) all of the elements are integrated. To use an extreme example, a piece that had ONLY dissonant intervals (melodically & harmonically) would more likely have a malevolent sense of life. It would also help in classifying it this way if it had screetching timbres, too!

And if this is correct, then would it lead to the conclusion that minor scales having an excess of grave notes allow much less scope for making a happy piece?

The intervals in the scale & their resultant harmonies definitely make minor sadder sounding than major.

Hello All,

Very interesting thread. My regards to Christopher for providing such detailed and well-organized information. Chris, I very much appreciate your approach to defining music. I will need to study what you wrote in more depth and listen to all the music samples you provided.

In the realm of visual arts, I note a difference between true “art” and “design.” All art exhibits elements of design, but not everything exhibiting design is art. I can enjoy some forms of non-representational “modern” art as interesting design, but I do not consider it art. I’m thinking of approaching music in the same way, differentiating music from sound design. I enjoy some techno and rap (particularly for dancing), but I think of it more as sound design than music.

I’ll respond futher when I’ve had time to listen to the music samples.

–Dan Edge

Hello All,

Very interesting thread. My regards to Christopher for providing such detailed and well-organized information. Chris, I very much appreciate your approach to defining music. I will need to study what you wrote in more depth and listen to all the music samples you provided.

In the realm of visual arts, I note a difference between true “art” and “design.” All art exhibits elements of design, but not everything exhibiting design is art. I can enjoy some forms of non-representational “modern” art as interesting design, but I do not consider it art. I’m thinking of approaching music in the same way, differentiating music from sound design. I enjoy some techno and rap (particularly for dancing), but I think of it more as sound design than music.

I’ll respond futher when I’ve had time to listen to the music samples.

–Dan Edge

In the same way that cubism or impressionism are in most cases “bad art,” inasmuch as they do represent reality, but not in the way reality is actually percieved, I think there is music (some techno and rap, but not necessarily all, and many if not all other genres contain some examples) that would fall in the category of “bad music,” if it is periodic (ie, contains what is percieved as melodic, harmonic, and/or rhythmical elements), yet in such a way that it tends toward either sensory-deprivating monotony or unintegratable randomness.

There is also some noise which is compiled by “musicians” or engineers which I think could be described as “sound design,” as you say.

Here’s a way of symbolizing it:

  1. consonance-solid sound

  2. less consonance-less solid sounding

  3. dissonant sound-tension builds

  4. more dissonant-MORE tension

  5. consonance returns-tension released

Christopher,

This might muddy the water a bit, but I’d like to bring up a couple things. (Now, it’s been a few years since I’ve really been in theory, so my memory might be faulty). When we’re dealing with the Major and Minor scales the two notes we’re really focusing on are the third (in the major - two whole steps up from the root, in the minor - 1.5 whole steps up from the root) and the seventh (Major - a half step below the root, minor - whole step below). I was taught in class, that it’s that nice little half step to the Octave that gives you that happy feel (resolution). Which is why we start getting fuzzy when we deal with the Harmonic and melodic minor.

For reference (since I didn’t see it before)

Major Scale - C-D-E-F-G-A-B

Natural Minor- A-B-C-D-E-F-G

Harmonic Minor (raised seventh to emulate a Major ending) - A-B-C-D-E-F-G#

Melodic Minor (Raised sixth AND seventh for a full Major ending, though play Natural minor when descending) A-B-C-D-E-F#-G#

Some of these “confuse” the cadence by making the IV (Melodic) and V(Harmonic and Melodic) chord MAJOR within a minor scale (which they aren’t in the Natural scale). This affects the motion that a melody would have (going minor to major, instead of minor to minor), and certainly the emotional drop (i.e. a larger “emotional” drop from Major to minor, in the resolution, than a minor to minor).

Do we simply percieve these as modes?