Let us first isolate the most essential components of music: melodic/thematic content, harmonic content, rhythmic content. There are of course other elements. Some secondary components to consider could include: sectional/structural form, timbre & dynamics.
Melodic/thematic content
From the Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary definition of melody:
1 : a sweet or agreeable succession or arrangement of sounds
2 : a rhythmic succession of single tones organized as an aesthetic whole
The second definition is more narrow & precise. But still not enough. Let’s go a bit further. A melody is a succession of musical notes (pure, properly intonated tones) constructed in such a manner as to be perceivable as a self contained unit. A good melody should have these characteristics & in addition should be goal-directed by implying a harmonic context/framework.
It can also be useful to add further qualities in order to refine our definition. A good melody should also have a healthy variety in vertical dimensions (up & down motion, variety of interval steps & leaps) as well as horizontal dimensions (rhythmic values). It can be helpful to have a single high point & or low point but it is not always necessary. Any number of nursery rhymes & childrens tunes are good examples of bare-bones good melodies (i.e.: “Mary Had a Little Lamb”, “Twinkle, Twinkle Little Star”, “London Bridge is Falling Down”, etc.).
They are good examples because they have clear, direct succession of tones, they imply a harmonic progression (even if only one notes at a time is used!) & as a consequence of implying harmonic content, they are goal-directed. There is a healthy variety in various dimensions. For example, they typically have a “question” phrase that ends on a dominant (half-candence) & then an “answer” phrase. This is usually a variation on the first phrase starting similarly but ending on the tonic (full candence). Harmonic implication as a means of providing a goal is essential.
Sometimes a melody is broken down into smaller parts (or phrases or sections) that are altered, variated, used in different manners. These are typically known as themes, motifs, variations, etc. For example, the melody may be fully stated once, then broken down into smaller components. These smaller components are then used in various ways to create variations, developments, new sections, themes, sometimes whole new melodies.
Harmonic content
From the Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary definition of harmony:
2 a : the combination of simultaneous musical notes in a chord
2 b : the structure of music with respect to the composition and progression of chords
2 c : the science of the structure, relation, and progression of chords
These are all very good! However, they do not specify what that structure is & how it relates (i.e. “with respect to”). I did a whole post on Harmony here
http://forum.ObjectivismOnline.com/index.p…indpost&p=64204
For this post I will summarize. The foundations of Tonal Harmonic Theory are based on voice leading & on triadic harmonies built from diatonic scales. I am going to assume the reader has some knowledge of music at this point. Harmonic structure, per se, has a beginning, a middle (some motion) & an end. The goal is the cadence.
The degree to which any piece (or part of a piece) serves to move toward it’s goal (or not) is the degree to which it has successfully integrated it’s harmonic content with it’s other components.
Side note: if a piece or theme does not have a proper cadence, it does not resolve. It is not necessarily “bad” to not resolve or avoid a proper cadence. Sometimes, if done effectively it can add a great deal of tension/suspense (among other possible effects). But the fact remains that if you are going to use tonal tools (scales, chords, etc.) you are by definition using an integrated system of information with a specific nature (i.e. there is a root note, there is a heirarchy of importance among the notes, the cadence is the goal, etc.).
The premise underlying all of harmony is voice leading. Voice leading is regarding all the notes that comprise a chord as one note of a “voice”. As you move to the next chord you regard each note as moving to the next corresponding note in that next chord. “Smooth” voice leading is the “goal” of well-constructed music.
Many theorists & composers also regard voice leading as not merely a chordal analysis tool but an essential way of creating independent & yet interweaving melodies. This is very true in Bach (& Beethoven!). For although at any time you can isolate a chord based on all the notes that are sounding at one time, the more important thing is that each voice carries it own melodic thread. So if you have (like Bach did in many of his classic 4 part chorales) a piece that all the way through uses four note chords it is constructed in a way that if you follow say the top note of every chord (“the top voice”) you will find a complete melody; & likewise for the other 3 voices.
There has been a great deal of nonsense spread about “the rules of music” (usually in regards to counterpoint & harmony in general) being “arbitrary human conventions”. Then, there is a long list of composers that “broke/bent/ignore/re-wrote the rules”. It does not help that some of the very specific classical rules of counterpoint voice leading are not essential to the nature of tonality. These exceptions are frequently held up as examples of why throwing out all the rules is a good idea. Most of the rules exist for a reason; some of them exist for very good reasons; some are non-essential. I can get into this in depth later if someone is interested.
Rhythmic content
Musically, Rhythm answers the question “When?” On a small scale, it deals with the length of the melody notes relative to each other (& ultimately to all the other notes in the piece). On a larger scale it encompasses the tempo(s) & meter(s) of a piece. A healthy variety of rhythmic material is usually desirable, as in other components. The specific characteristics of any given meter should be integrated (i.e. work with & not against) the other components (melody, harmony). The tempo should be within a suitable range of human cognition. I know that last sentence seems a bit Over Obvious. Unfortunately, it does need to be said. There are pieces (mostly computer-rendered) that go so fast the human ear & mind literally cannot comprehend what is happening. On the other end of the spectrum (but the same counterfeit coin) there are pieces that are written such that one note is supposed to be played every 50 years. “Modernists” are always up to something irrational.
There has been a great deal written in musical history texts about musical rhythm & dance. There is probably a lot of interesting info from which to learn if it was approached in an objective manner. I don’t know much about it from that angle though. I know Rand had interesting things to say in The Romantic Manifesto. Perhaps someone on the forum can contribute.
Sectional/structural form
This relates to the manner in which all the sections (or melodies if more than one) are structured in what particular order. Again, the purpose is to create a satisfyingly integrated whole. For example, in classical music, the “gold-standard” of structural form was Sonata-Allegro. In the widest sense this consisted of an Exposition (statement of themes 1 & 2, or more), Development (variation on themes), Recapitulation (restatement of themes 1 & 2, more). The form was highly plastic, though, allowing many different possibilities for variation & alteration. There were other forms: Rondo, Minuet & Trio, etc. Larger forms were the symphony, the concerto, etc.
There are some modern day musicians who claim to “hate the rules” of all that “stuffy classical” music. First, it is ironic; think about any standard pop song’s structure: verse & chorus, optional bridge/solo, repeat verse & chorus. This (on a much smaller scale) exactly mimics sonata-allegro form. Aren’t they a rebellous lot? Next, the richness in integrated components (themes, harmonies, rhythms, etc.) of the simplest Haydn piano sonata (for example) is well beyond anything any pop song has ever achieved. Don’t get me wrong here. There is some pop music which I think has great value; there is some pop music I personally enjoy. I am not saying it is all useless or evil. By it’s nature, I think it has to be more brief & to the point (i.e. use less musical tools & info available to a composer). Finally, consider the vast majority of what exists as pop songs. How much variety in form & structure has been achieved in that genre compared to classical with it’s “overbearing & striaght-jacketing rules”? Please, stop, it hurts.
Anyway, there’s more structural form variation & integration in ONE Beethoven sonata than in the last 50 years of pop music.
Timbre
Timbre (pronouced “tam-ber”) is characteristics of the sounds employed by a piece. For example an oboe has a woody, nasal tone, a violin can have a lyrical, flowing, singing tone (or a hoarse, scratchy tone). The composer’s intentions are carried out in this regard by which instrument(s) he of she specifies to play the notes of the piece.
This is a very important issue in ensemble playing. Especially when scoring for orchestral resources.
As usual, the timbres involved in the piece should be (everyone say it together!) integrated with the other components of the piece. So, a delicate melody should be played by an instrument capable of expressing the proper context. A theme (or harmony) of “noble” quality might be best represented by brass (particularly a french horn). The electric guitar is a very interesting case (one that especially fascinates me, I am primarily a guitarist & grew up playing electric guitar). It has the ability to “sing” expressively like a violin, the ability to sound glass-like transparent with a clear ringing bell-tone like a harp. It also has the ability to sound incredibly ugly & noisy like an industrial machine that is disintegrating.
Side note: Timbre & scoring is one aspect of Beethoven that really gets me. Often it is pointed out that Beethoven was “deaf, but still wrote great music”. Well, that’s true & must have been hard for him to deal with emotionally. But, having said that, I can write music all day long without hearing a note of it, & I know how it will sound. Any decent musician can do this. What I consider amazing is how, years after having gone deaf, he could still imagine, conceptualize & project how to orchestrate. It is easy enough to write down on paper a C major chord. What gets difficult is: which note of the chord do you assign to which instrument to get the proper effect? Without being able to actually hear the possible combinations? Beethoven wrote his last 3 symphonies under those conditions (among other works, like the C-sharp minor quartet). That is mind-boggling!
Dynamics
Dynamics relate to issues such as volume, attack, decay, etc. One more time, (all together!) the dynamics involved in the piece should be integrated with the other
components of the piece. This includes elements such as crescendos and diminuendos, as mentioned by tommyedison.
These are what I would consider to be valid criteria by which to objectively identify the characteristics of a piece of music. I am, of course, only a musician/composer. I can offer suggestions & ideas as to how these musical elements are perceived & processed by a human mind. But, ultimately, we may need more specialized help (are there a psychologist & a physiologist in the house?). There are a number of decent texts & sources on the physics of sound & human hearing out there. I have read about 10 such books on this topic. I did read Helmholtz’s “On the Sensation of Tone as a Physiological Basis for a Theory of Music” years ago. I may have to find another copy of it & re-read. There are a number of decent websites that summarize & reference it.
Now that we have established some foundation premises about the components of music, perhaps we can use them to delve into why/how/where any specific piece (or one/some of it’s components) has a good or bad sense of life.
Christopher Schlegel