Just to put something somewhat more fun in amongst the myriad of very involved discussions going on at the moment:
Reading Ayn Rand’s work for the first time was a very fun experience. It continues to be a lot of fun as you re-read it, but like a lot of first times (I say ‘a lot of’ because some people didn’t enjoy their first kiss/car-ride/major felony), the repeat of the experience never quite captures the magic, the emotional high of a discovery. And what could be more thrilling than finding your very foundational beliefs challenged, or morally vindicated?
However, we go on, studying more and more, and we make mistakes along the way. The major thing all of us have met within ourselves and others at some point is some form of Rationalism. We might also worry about how we’re not ‘like Roark’, about how we aren’t productive geniuses, about how we don’t have this or that thing which isn’t actually essential or important to living rationally. Some even try to cut off parts of themselves, such as their humour, or their compassion for other people, because they mistakenly think these aren’t Objectivist.
Needless to say, there’s a lot of things you can do wrong, in Objectivism, as in anything outside Objectivism and the application of it. If you could go back and do it all over again, what mistakes would you avoid? What things would you advise new students to watch out for?
I think I’d say three things:
Avoid the Rationalism. Avoid the ARI/TOC/Branden thing. Read Aristotle.
The first (coupled with advice on what they should do instead) would teach them to learn Objectivism properly and would be the first step to rooting out Rationalism as a method of thought for them. The second would help them avoid a lot of aggrovation about something which isn’t important to understanding Objectivism, which is highly complex and which, historically, will be highly irrelevant. The third would teach them the proper respect for ideas, and an understanding of where Ayn Rand was coming from.
I might also mention that to supplement this third one, that they study History and some basic Philosophy in general, but that would be a supplementary activity. There’s about a thousand things they should supplement these three with, and I’m not going to list them all. I’m interested to know what you think should be avoided as well. These three are rather simple, not exactly to perform, but to understand what they are at the very least.
Go!