The journalist includes comments such as “There is perhaps something slightly odd about an economic system in a democracy which channels the spoils only to the richest.”
Perhaps income inequality can be the enemy of growth.
It depends on what the cause of the inequality is. If inequality happens as a result of some individuals being more productive than others, by means of their own efforts and exertions and not by wronging anyone, then who could complain about this, and how could it cause growth to decline? I cannot see the logic.
If people claim more and more unearned income, then I can see this as the cause of income inequalities which are an enemy of growth. It is the producers who pay, and when they have more to carry on their shoulders, they will end up on their knees. The government is one culprit. Landowners are another.
The Government taxes producers and takes away part of what they have produced by force (if you refuse to pay tax, you will be imprisoned - so tax is a price of permission to produce and trade in that community). When income inequalities increase, currently governments tend to react by collecting more taxes, which leads to even more sub-optimal outcomes through its effect on the interplay between supply and demand. Less is produced and consumed as a result at the macro level - so unearned redistribution due to taxation is an enemy of growth. Redistributing wealth to those who have not earned it, in order to narrow income inequalities is an enemy of growth.
Landowners also tax producers and take away part of what they have produced by force (if you refuse to pay the landowner, you will be evicted from the land). This is a tax on production and not a trade - it is a payment for permission to be free to live and work on that land. Producing nothing, a landowner can demand more and more unearned income from producers who are creating a thriving community. They get rich while the community of producers - particularly the relatively less productive, have their earnings forced down to the level of subsistence. When this is the cause of income inequality, it most certainly is the enemy of growth.
It depends on what the cause of the inequality is. If inequality happens as a result of some individuals being more productive than others, by means of their own efforts and exertions and not by wronging anyone, then who could complain about this, and how could it cause growth to decline? I cannot see the logic.
Thats because your not rationalizing the world through Marxist “logic”…
The government is one culprit. Landowners are another.
Landowners also tax producers and take away part of what they have produced by force (if you refuse to pay the landowner, you will be evicted from the land). This is a tax on production and not a trade - it is a payment for permission to be free to live and work on that land. Producing nothing, a landowner can demand more and more unearned income from producers who are creating a thriving community. They get rich while the community of producers - particularly the relatively less productive, have their earnings forced down to the level of subsistence. When this is the cause of income inequality, it most certainly is the enemy of growth.
Did you make this thread just to discuss this again?
Did you make this thread just to discuss this again?
Ironically in the previous thread Snerd said:
Consider a journalist trying to prove that land-ownership has caused a huge disparity in wealth that has been compounded over generations. He may start with the ten richest people in the country and demonstrate that their wealth is primarily the result of the original unfair land-ownership granted to their great-great-great grandfather. he would show that this is true of specific billionaires: Bill Gates, Warren Buffet, Larry Ellison, the Koch brothers, the Walton family, Bloomberg, Zuckerberg, the Google pair. Failing here, he might focus on the more moderately rich. he might focus on the 250K + plus crowd. He might try to show that these people who work for banks, and consultancies, and live in New York apartments also own decently large land-holding (more than any modest farmer). That’s the type of reality-check that can make a theory really convincing.
Hilarious, you are calling me a Marxist. How many Marxists are arguing for producers to keep the full fruits of their labours. I thought the Marxist mantra was “to each according to his need, from each according to his ability” - the exact opposite of what I was writing about.
We’re discussing income inequality and growth, not the (im)moral basis of claiming to own what you were not the cause of. But we can discuss again why you think you are entitled to the unearned if you like.
Landowners also tax producers and take away part of what they have produced by force (if you refuse to pay the landowner, you will be evicted from the land). This is a tax on production and not a trade - it is a payment for permission to be free to live and work on that land. Producing nothing, a landowner can demand more and more unearned income from producers who are creating a thriving community. They get rich while the community of producers - particularly the relatively less productive, have their earnings forced down to the level of subsistence. When this is the cause of income inequality, it most certainly is the enemy of growth.
Ah… and I mistook you for an Objectivist… this removes all doubt that you are not.
Someone with the time and patience can explain to you why this analysis of land ownership is wrong on so many levels.
I wish I could find someone who could show me why the arguments I have about land ownership are at odds with Objectivism.
Rand was very clear. The law of causality is the root of ownership. A lot of posters here struggle to comprehend that they were not the cause of something that preexisted them.
If you are saying that because I do not adhere to that irrationality I am not an Objectivist, then you do not know Objectivism. Look at Galt’s speech and find the reference.
Hilarious, you are calling me a Marxist. How many Marxists are arguing for producers to keep the full fruits of their labours. I thought the Marxist mantra was “to each according to his need, from each according to his ability” - the exact opposite of what I was writing about.
First, I said “maybe”…Second, you seem to operate on the premise that one can learn a “mantra” and understand an entire philosophical doctrine. Notice that I did not quote that mantra (from each)so as to isolate that aspect of Marxism. I am referring to Marx’s claim that “all property is theft”. The notion that all governmental structures began with a land grab by force. That “mantra” is historically Marxist. Just so you know, one can tout a philosophical mantra like Galt’s and accept premises that contradict it. Your claims about land are an example of this. What’s more is, a philosopher can create a mantra and then misintegrate it with premises that don’t follow. Lets add the whole “class warfare” between the “have’s an the have not’s” from marxist and we have more than a few similarities here…
Jon said:
Look at the advances in medical science today that was originally made possible by what Nazi scientists did in WW2.
By your logic, you would say those advances are the kind of reality check that would make Nazism “really convincing”.
You just built a huge castle out of thin air. Quote anything I said personally that rescues this arbitrary statement from being dismissed.
Jon said:
Drop the passive aggressiveness Plasmatic.
Drop the pretense of your commands having any significance whatever if you don’t like wasting your time… I was not being passive at all. But I would love for you to start a thread on this alleged distinction between aggression and assertiveness so we can evaluate this premise you seem to give so much weight to.
Edit: I found your thread on this.
CT,
We’re discussing income inequality and growth, not the (im)moral basis of claiming to own what you were not the cause of. But we can discuss again why you think you are entitled to the unearned if you like.
Your OP rest on the very same premise being debated in your other thread concerning land ownership. Objectivist apply Rands Razor
Rand was very clear. The law of causality is the root of ownership. A lot of posters here struggle to comprehend that they were not the cause of something that preexisted them.
You did not create the sperm and egg that caused you to become a zygote. Do you own your own body? The point was made by different people before that all creation involves use of the metaphysically given material used.
Miss Rand said:
A notable example of the proper method of establishing private ownership from scratch, in a previously ownerless area, is the Homestead Act of 1862, by which the government opened the western frontier for settlement and turned “public land” over to private owners. The government offered a 160-acre farm to any adult citizen who would settle on it and cultivate it for five years, after which it would become his property. Although that land was originally regarded, in law, as “public property,” the method of its allocation, in/act, followed the proper principle (in /act, but not in explicit ideological intention). The citizens did not have to pay the government as if it were an owner; ownership began with them, and they earned it by the method which is the source and root of the concept of “property”: by working on unused material resources, by turning a wilderness into a civilized settlement. Thus, the government, in this case, was acting not as the owner but as the custodian of ownerless resources who defines objectively impartial rules by which potential owners may acquire them.
“Here, in small-scale agriculture, the price of land, a form and result of private landownership, appears as a barrier to production itself. In large-scale agriculture, and large estates operating on a capitalist basis, ownership likewise acts as a barrier, because it limits the tenant farmer in his productive investment of capital, which in the final analysis benefits not him, but the landlord.” (Das Kapital, III. Band, 2. Teil, S. 346-47.)[3]
Any claim that property rights (including land ownership) were and are not espoused and completely understood by Rand and her philosophy is a misguided one.
Landowners also tax producers and take away part of what they have produced by force (if you refuse to pay the landowner, you will be evicted from the land). This is a tax on production and not a trade - it is a payment for permission to be free to live and work on that land. Producing nothing, a landowner can demand more and more unearned income from producers who are creating a thriving community. They get rich while the community of producers - particularly the relatively less productive, have their earnings forced down to the level of subsistence. When this is the cause of income inequality, it most certainly is the enemy of growth.
Jon,
I see that you are from London, so maybe things are different? I would say that the overwhelming majority of land in the States has been developed since the end of World War II and that land ownership is not something that is un-obtainable or even particularly hard to come by in the US.
Yes things are different here. Land can be very expensive depending on the nature of the permissions you are buying, and the location.
Though the same is true of locations in America. Take a typical apartment that you may find in many cities, of a similar standard. Is the rent the same in all cities?
If it varies, what is the cause of that variance? We have ruled out the apartment.
Marx is correct in that short paragraph, about the landlord being the beneficiary of owning the land, to the cost of the producer.
If you believe otherwise, then put forward your reasoning.
“All property is theft” More passive aggressiveness.
I’ve always wondered the psychological state of individuals who need to resort to sarcasm and jibes to make themselves feel good. Tells me all I need to know about your nature.
I suspect no reasoning will be forthcoming, maybe a cheap throwaway comment or a crowd pleasing rant - who knows. What’s the best within you capable of?