Introduction

Where I am it’s morning. So, good morning. I’m obviously new to this forum, but not to forums in general. I’ve been studying and practicing Objectivism seriously for approximately 2 years. That was basically immediately after my first introduction to the philosophy, which was not suprising as I had been seeking principles that made sense for a long time. I was in Afghanistan at the time, an experience I don’t regret. Much of my understanding was gained on the ground so to speak, before I found a system to integrate it all with. That’s not to say I haven’t engaged in study, I most certainly have, but if “A picture is worth a thousand words” I had seen volumes before a chance encounter with Objectivism set me on the trail of integrating it all into a explict philosophy. Before that there was just sense of life and rigorous sifting through systems looking for truths that made sense. You’ll see a lot more of me here if it’s a productive forum. I like to learn and debate, which is not abundant in my physical area. I look forward to participating here.

Posted via iPhone, apologies for any formatting that gets mangled on the way.

Hello, Ryan, welcome to the forums.

In case you were wondering, I deleted your posts in Seanjos’ “Be My Friend” thread because both of them were rude, the first one because there’s no reason to waste a post on pointless negativity which doesn’t even grant the respect of a reason, and the second one because it’s not your place to dictate to established forum members the conditions under which they can ask for people to be friends with them on social networking sites. You are certainly *not* welcome to use this as an opportunity to try picking a fight by criticizing said established member’s taste in signature quotations.

If you don’t like a given thread because you think it is silly or a waste of time, DON’T POST. If you think it actually violates the forum rules, report it. I normally wouldn’t have said anything, but you were outspoken in speculating on the possible reasons for your earlier post being deleted.

I do encourage you to carefully consider the *content*, not just the *author* of the quote in Seanjos’ sig, because it speaks of an idea that is very important in Objectivism (and has been echoed by other great philosophers such as Aristotle), namely the fact that principles must be applied as absolutes, and one cannot say “this is how I should act” without also considering “this is how ALL men should act”. If you’re unfamiliar with it, I also recommend Leonard Peikoff’s excellent speech “Why Should One Act On Principle?”, which is available free through the Ayn Rand Institute registered user page. It’s one of my personal favorite Ford Hall speeches.

Anyway, I hope you do enjoy this forum and gain some benefit from it, but dial down the hostility a notch or two.

With all due respect, acting on principle is exactly what I did do. I did not dictate any conditions under which the gentleman in question can do anything, I pointed out that the conditions and specifically his stated reason for soliciting were insulting and in poor taste. Nothing I said had anything to do with “picking a fight” unless answering “no” or pointing out that the request has questionable and of insulting intent is “picking a fight”. As to remarking on his quotation, I find a posted quote from a man Rand repeatedly and forcefully labeled the originator of a patently evil philosophy to be of relevance WHEN the person in question is requesting for me to associate my name with his own. I did consider the content of the quote in question along with the context of the author and where it was posted. I found the intent questionable and said so. This is, in fact, how ALL men should act in the face of questionable and insulting actions.

As to acting on principle. I happen to believe a solicitation of the sort request, with the reasons stated, is insulting and deserves to be challenged. I did so, on principle.

While we’re on principles.

“In addition, do not use this forum to promote any other web site or solicit the members of this board without the approval of the moderators.” - Forum rules

Was the thread soliciting facebook ads for the purpose of looking cool and cultured approved by the moderators? Is the solicitation of affiliation with forum members for the purpose of second handing esteem or a cultured appearance from them consistent with the purpose of the site, as per forum participation term 1? If the answer to these questions is “no”, I presume It shouldn’t be necessary to report the thread, as its obviously being watched by the moderators very closely.

“Do not post complaints about the behavior of any member on the forum - report them to the moderators. Public complaints about other members will be treated as a personal attack and may be deleted!”

I respectfully requested a PM from the moderator who was deleting posts to inform me of why. I honestly would have expected that in the first place, if only to let me know what I did so that I wouldn’t do it again. I tried to fix what I thought might be the issue on the second post and afterward reiterated my request for a PRIVATE message informing me of the policy I was violating. If you’ve sensed any sort of irritation from the posts on that thread it has to do with being arbitrarily censored without even being given the courtesy of being told why. I know myself and the courage to simply say “I moderated you because your post was a simple “No”” would have likely stopped this whole mess in its tracks. Instead of the request PRIVATE message detailing the complaint, I find that I did get a PM informing me that the complaint against me had been posted PUBLICLY in my intro thread. It seems an odd choice to publish that sort of thing PUBLICLY in an out of context thread introducing me where anyone reading it would simply read that I’m hostile, pick fights, dictatorial, outspoken (at least that ones true), and apparently from your last paragraph devoid of understanding about principles and their application. So we have that criticism out of context and public. IIRC context is a pretty important concept in Objectivism, it would certainly help anyone reading the complaint you publicly posted against me to know the quote, since “I think your opinion was wrong about the quote.” is apparently relevant to the moderation. Something tells me that the above quoted forum rule’s intent wasn’t to privately report complaints so that they could publicly post them out of context elsewhere. It read to me like the intent was to keep that sort of thing private, which I requested if I was being moderated (which I wasn’t even sure of until now). If I’m correct regarding the forum rule intending to keep complaints off the forum, please explain why you went public?

What were you saying about principles being absolute?

PS - Apologies for the original post, censored for brevity, as well as the second and third, censored for responding to an insulting solicitation on the thread.