Take two

Hi,

It has come to my attention that sarcasm does not carry well over a forum, so I introduce myself again.

My name’s Joel and I’m a history student with left wing tendencies. I found this forum actually doing searches for Rome’s origins and found this place. Seeing the high levels of debate I tought I’d stick around and see how it goes.

Now, one thing remains to be cleared up -

I am not, nor have I ever been a member of the communist party. Marx had some neat ideas with unimplementable plans, Lenin should have gotten laid more, Michael Moore is an idiot and Howard Zinn needs a shrink.

I am not in favour of exploiting the third world despite its legality, I support palestinian nationalism (to a point), I don’t see why value does not come from labour, people’s love is no business of the state, and altruism is not an evil.

There, now everyone should know where I stand, at least for now.

Well then, welcome to the forum. :lol: I would hope that one of the positives of you frequenting this forum will be that in time you will come to understand that altruism is actually one of the most evil ideas in the history of mankind, and when implemented fully always leads to mass death. In the meantime, enjoy!

Only mass death??

That’s a pretty minor fear, get over it.

Only mass death??

That’s a pretty minor fear, get over it.

Ummm, okay, whatever. :lol: Anyway, welcome to the forum and I’m glad you dropped the “Marxist” thing. I was wondering whether that post was a joke or not…

Dude, you really need to drop the sarcasm. If you read the Forum Rules it says that people should avoid posts with sarcasm. (or something to that affect) I suggest you read the rules, and quit posting with so much sarcasm. You’re confusing alot of people.

Other than that, Welcome to the forum. :lol:

Zak

It has come to my attention, GWDS, that you have not read the forum rules:

(1) This site supports discussion of, first, the principles of Objectivism, as defined by the works of Ayn Rand and supported by the Ayn Rand Institute; and, second, their application to various fields. Therefore participants must not use the website to spread ideas contrary to or unrelated to Objectivism. Examples include religion, communism, “moral tolerationism,” and libertarianism. Honest questions about such subjects are permitted. However, since the focus of this forum is the philosophy of Objectivism, such questions are not encouraged.

(2) This forum will not tolerate posts which contain personal insults or are otherwise devoid of intellectual content. Examples of personal insults include: (a) sarcastic comments directed at a particular person’s character, and (b)accusations of irrationality or immorality.

That being said, the owner of this forum does not require that you advocate Objectivist ideas. This does not mean, however, that he allows you to openly piss on Objectivist principles without presenting a single argument that supports your positions.

What I mean is, if you are going to state a position which obviously counters the principles of Objectivism, please support your position with an intellectual argument–do not waste our time by posting what amounts to senseless noise.

After your first introduction was deleted, you should’ve taken the opportunity to read the forum rules. Since you apparently haven’t, this serves as your first and only explicit warning.

If you wish to spew your corrupt positions openly without the need of backing them up with facts, I’m sure there are other forums that fit your needs (the Democratic Underground comes to mind).

Until you submit posts worthy of intellectual scrutiny, your posts will have to be approved by a moderator before they are published.

So that applies to the introdoctory thread?

That applies to any thread where you state particular philosophical positions. You would’ve been fine if you just said “I lean towards Marxism.” But rambling off all your particular positions without explaining why you hold them is not welcome here.

So the ideal would have been to spend an hour and ten pages explaining my beleifs in full, just to say ‘Hello’.

I gathered from the forum rules, which I read, that such was not required. Perhaps I was mistaken, if so, could you show me an example in this section where this was done that I can do likewise.

The purpose of the introduction section is to introduce yourself, not explain your entire life story or elucidate us with all your views on life. Typically, people do one or all or some of the following: state their name, how they found the forum, how they discovered Objectivism, what their general philosophic leanings are, and what they do in life for fun and money. There are other specific topic sections within the message board where people can raise particular questions, such as why you think Palestinians deserve a state.

Here are some of the many examples of typical introductions:

Hello to all,

I am new to the forum, if not to Objectivism – I discovered Ayn Rand in 1986. Despite my enthusiasm for Objectivism I haven’t really moved in Objectivist circles for some time now, although I did give a series of lectures at the last summer conference, and a forum like this seems to be a good way to interact with other students of the greatest philosophy ever penned.

By way of background: I’m an art historian and amateur aesthetician, trained (Harvard Ph.D.) in Islamic art and architecture and currently working at the Victoria & Albert Museum in London. In addition to art I am especially keen on languages, the more “exotic” and out-of-the-way the better (currently obsessed with Georgian).

Hope to show up on a forum or two sometime soon. In the meantime I’ll try to think of a cool signature.

Barry Wood

Just wanted to say Hey i am new to the forum as well. here goes a brief history about myself. I found my way to Objectivism through the Terry Goodkind and being exposed to his ideas. Being a young writer and enjoying the way he wrote i mailed him a letter asking him about tips on writing. In reply he sent me to The Romantic Manifesto and The Art of Fiction. After checking these out of Marquette University’s Library. I became intrigured. Also during this time the fulfillment of living a catholic/irrational life came crashing down around me in the terms of some personal problems with a roommate and a GPA of 1.15 for that semester. I vowed to myself never to allow this to happen to me again and began to explore the philosophy of Objectivism even more. It made sense to me to begin living my life according to a philosophy founded by an author.  :lol:

Hi, I go to high school in Evanston, IL where I publish an unofficial (“underground”) newspaper that I steer towards Objectivist principles.  The URL is rightstuffnews.com

There are lots of good posts here that answer some of my questions about Objectivism.  I’m going to try to read OPAR soon.

I am not in favour of exploiting the third world despite its legality, …

Something worthy of a separate thread. You’d need to define what actions constitute exploitation and what don’t. Does every commercial relationship between two entities with different amounts of wealth and power entail a degree of exploitation? Is there some quantity of difference that is relevant? Is there some other way to put it?

Another thread… if you’re interested.