Is objectivism consequentialist?

3 hours ago, Easy Truth said:

Was this put to rest?

In what way? If this is what you mean, no debate around here (or as far as I can tell, in the world) is ever settled such that all parties are agreed.

3 hours ago, Easy Truth said:

My understanding was that initiation of aggression was immoral.

It’s easy enough to say that, from the point of view of the innocents harmed, blowing up a bus is immoral. But ethics, per Objectivism, are based upon self-interest. The moral prohibition against the initiation of the use of force is meant to be as self-interested as anything else – not fashioned to protect “others,” or the wider world, but for the sake of the person who abides by it.

But does the suicidal man stand to gain anything (in reason) by refraining from hurting others upon his exit? (I say that he does.)

3 hours ago, Easy Truth said:

I can see the logic, that a moral code is like a playbook in order to play football to win. When you are never going to play football again, the plays have no relevance. So morality only applies only when you want to play the game of life.

Right, that’s the way the logic goes. So when you’ve decided that you’re no longer playing to win (or that you cannot play football), then you can run any formation you’d like; you may even blow up the stadium. It’s anything goes from there on out.

In theory, this should also mean that a person with a terminal illness is no longer bound by morality (because they understand that they are never going to play football again, no matter what play they run). Some suggest that such a person will continue to drift along on their habits… and so we shouldn’t expect too much chaos. However, someone who has given these matters sufficient thought (and with the proper philosophical perspective) ought to be able to recognize their changed context…

3 hours ago, Easy Truth said:

But what about the issue of leaving a legacy, as in living the future in the now? “Anyone who fights for the future, lives in it today.” (Romantic Manifesto)
 Is forfeiting one’s life for a better society in the future, enjoying it now? If so, the decision to be remembered and honored for taking the hemlock instead of committing the slaughter of innocents is a moral act, to live the “pride” now. It has some reasoned moral significance.

Yes – this is my essential answer. “Legacy” runs the risk of implying that this is “for others,” but then you continue to identify the true root of it: that it is the experience of value in the present, the pride, the pleasure, the happiness that moral action brings, which continues to make our decisions morally significant, even in the face of (nigh) instantaneous death.

In another thread, discussing this same issue, I raised the Buddhist parable "The Monk, the Tiger and the Strawberry " as an example of moral action in the face of extremity. I believe that, so long as there is a self – so long as life remains, so long as choice remains, and so long as our choices matter to our experience of life – then there is the possibility of moral action, to wring out for ourselves the best possible experience of life, whatever our present context happens to be.

1 Like