Is objectivism consequentialist?

I must say, I can’t see any hint of consequentialism in Objectivism. Unless taken in the casual sense, of directing one’s actions towards their due consequences. But isn’t this the idea that results and ends are all that count, regardless of how one arrives there? The Objectivist would not compromise his virtues or sacrifice values to attain an objective. He couldn’t “cheat reality” nor his own reality. In itself, an important source of self-esteem is ~how~ he reaches his goals.

4 hours ago, whYNOT said:

The Objectivist would not compromise his virtues or sacrifice values to attain an objective. He couldn’t “cheat reality” nor his own reality.

(leaving aside the dubious notion “his own reality”)

This hides (albeit poorly) a implicitly held contradiction.  That somehow virtue and principle are beyond the achievement of a flourishing life.  That the ideal is beyond, above or apart from the practical… above or beyond reality and nature and consequences. This is not the case for Objectivism.

There is no dichotomy between rational and objectively identified means and ends.  There is no dichotomy between the practical and the ideal, no dichotomy between virtue, principle, and reality.  Morality is OBJECTIVE.  It’s standard is firmly rooted in reality, and every virtue, principle, and action of a moral man are purposefully adopted and taken according to that standard. 

As is hinted at it is impossible to “cheat reality”.

4 hours ago, whYNOT said:

In itself, an important source of self-esteem is ~how~ he reaches his goals.

This also contains a latent error.  It implies a man may reach “his goals” in ways which can either thwart or strengthen his self-esteem, when in fact self-esteem (being instrumental to his ultimate and on-going goal) is part of the goal.  Self-esteem is simply unimportant to a man who does not choose to live, does not adopt life as the standard, or is misguided and not fully understood value, but to a man who fully understands the value of self-esteem to the achievement of life, he understands that it is crucial for long term flourishing to have a strong sense of self-esteem, and that it is an important means to the ultimate end.  Each and every goal along the way and contributing to the ultimate goal of life, thus incorporates the goal of flourishing, staying mentally fit and healthy to continue pursuing the ultimate goal of life.

 

IF a man sets as a particular goal the achievement of building a pyramid in the long term, taking a shortcut which requires the severing of his arm, may achieve some immediate short term goal but it thwarts achievement of his ultimate goal.  A rational man does not shy from severing his arm because of some higher sense of self beyond reality, self, goals and life, he is neither irrational nor a supernaturalist, he shies away from severing his arm because such a thing WOULD be life defeating in general.

 

It is not “how” one reaches goals that is crucial here, but whether or not he actually is reaching or thwarting his ultimate goal…

48 minutes ago, StrictlyLogical said:

(leaving aside the dubious notion “his own reality”)

 

 

 

It would seem you gratuitously dropped in “the ideal” (with the motive of uncovering my “implicit” and ‘latent’ premises) when in fact I made no mention of the ideal, and would not imply it. Nor, of course, that there is any dichotomy between the moral and the practical.

And of course, “it is crucial for long term flourishing to have a strong sense of self-esteem…”!

Was that not what I said (or implied)?

If one doesn’t know one’s “own reality”, then how does one know one’s consciousness? “Reality” is the reality of oneself too… How else would an individual know at which point he begins sacrificing his values, virtues and character for his ‘flourishing’?  If ‘a goal’ (of sorts) demands altruistic sacrifice, then it is not a rational goal, nor is it likely and possible he will flourish. That, explicitly, would appear to be “the case for Objectivism”.

I stand by what I said, and repeat that I don’t see that consequentialism, the ends justifying the means, is anywhere evident in Objectivism. Do you know different?

All in all, a good lecture which shouldn’t go to waste. 

7 hours ago, whYNOT said:

I stand by what I said, and repeat that I don’t see that consequentialism, the ends justifying the means, is anywhere evident in Objectivism. Do you know different?

The ends, life, long range, is not required to “justify” anything.  In fact “justice” itself is only validated because life requires it.  Does life justify the virtue justice?  No… life is first, justice (only one of many other things) follows as a requirement.

The ends, life long range, in fact require the means, morality: virtue, principles, moral action, only because life long range is a consequence of them.

 

What else could morality: virtue, principles, moral action possibly be for?

 

 

5 hours ago, StrictlyLogical said:

What else could morality: virtue, principles, moral action possibly be for?

What you say is true and all correct as far as Objectivism. “The ends justify the means” sums up consequentialism though. Not just that that there are ends, but that -any- means is appropriate as long as the end is correct. There are modifications to this, but any consequentialist philosophy is only concerned with the ends in principle. That is, ends external to you as a person, only the stuff that we see at the end. Objectivism strongly advocates integration of means and ends - it promotes selfishness because who we are as actors is primary. I don’t think you disagree, I’m posting this as a way to show that I think you and whyNOT mostly agree.

 

On 9/24/2017 at 10:15 PM, Easy Truth said:

But wasn’t Roark “morally complete/grown up” at an early age, a young man? Or was he a work in progress?

I’d argue not, or at least not until the end of a book. Even still, Roark had almost no internal conflicts. Since it was fiction, if anything, showing those conflicts detracts from portraying the ideal. In real life, the ideal takes a long time to form. 

2 hours ago, Eiuol said:

Not just that that there are ends, but that -any- means is appropriate as long as the end is correct.

Based on this definition of consequentialism, it is a_ kind of ethics that is irrational_. If any solution is ethical, then the least efficient, harmful, whim-based solutions that achieve the goal are ethical. Ironically, it would be an ethics (consequentialism) that does not take all consequences into consideration, which is necessary to choose the best “means”. 

The modifications that you mention could change the definition dramatically. There could be a rational and an irrational version of consequentialism. So one could say the irrational version is not compatible with Objectivism but the rational version may be.

7 hours ago, Easy Truth said:

If any solution is ethical, then the least efficient, harmful, whim-based solutions that achieve the goal are ethical. Ironically, it would be an ethics (consequentialism) that does not take all consequences into consideration, which is necessary to choose the best “means”. 

This is not correct.  This would be possible but for the following:

1.  Reality

2.  The nature of Man.

3.  The standard of Morality being a man’s life, long range.

 

Consider any subsidiary (short term, small etc.) goal, which is pursued to serve as a means to the more ultimate goal, it must be in accord with the standard, which is life long range, so it cannot be harmful or an “unethical” means.  Any and all goals, if moral, cannot be unethical in the way you suggest.

Also be careful, virtues and principles, are useful because no one can predict with perfect certainty the consequences of each and every action, rough guidelines are useful, and efficient, because we are not omniscient and cannot take all consequences into consideration (we simply don’t have the knowledge or the time).

Man cannot be judged immoral because he is fallible.

 

Edit:  So in a real sense, because of Man’s nature, one adopts principles and practices virtue, not because they are ends in themselves divorced from the standard of morality, but because they precisely are the most efficient and effective way to bring about, as a consequence of their adoption, the ends.

If Man were omniscient, there would be no need of virtues or principles, he could simply choose actions one by one according to his values and knowing all the consequences.  But that is not the nature of man.

1 Like

20 hours ago, StrictlyLogical said:

The ends, life, long range, is not required to “justify” anything.  In fact “justice” itself is only validated because life requires it.  Does life justify the virtue justice?  No… life is first, justice (only one of many other things) follows as a requirement.

The ends, life long range, in fact require the means, morality: virtue, principles, moral action, only because life long range is a consequence of them.

 

What else could morality: virtue, principles, moral action possibly be for?

 

 

We have an interesting confusion, brought about (first) by our different ideas of consequentialism.

Definitions!

Consequentialism is the class of normative ethical theories holding that the consequences of one’s conduct are the ultimate basis for any judgment about the rightness or wrongness of the conduct. [Wiki]

Consequentialism is the view that normative properties depend only on consequences. [Stanford]

Do you see the point? What is good is what works; what is bad, what doesn’t work. Here is a totally a-principled, amoral, irrational and arbitrary approach to ethics. (And if it happens to “work” the first time, in one context, we’d just repeat it in other contexts until it fails). The contrasts with Objectivist theory hardly have to be mentioned.

About the definition of justice-as-virtue I also disagree. There is a “justice” which Rand refers to in the Intro of VoS, that is of a far broader type than the virtue, and which I think you are thinking of and where I completely agree. “Since all values have to be gained and/or kept by men’s actions, any breach between actor and beneficiary necessitates an injustice: the sacrifice of some men to others. […]”

In this reasoning, the actor (in his work effort, and so on) must receive all his due outcomes and rewards (material, intellectual)without interference or penalty - to support his values and life - and that is “justice” to him. I think of this as, roughly, ‘justice in reality’, and we can observe the principle carried into Rand’s individual rights and Capitalism.

Justice the virtue, I will look up and show a link next.

 

6 hours ago, StrictlyLogical said:

If Man were omniscient, there would be no need of virtues or principles, he could simply choose actions one by one according to his values and knowing all the consequences.  But that is not the nature of man.

Agreed, what I mean when I said all consequences, I meant all consequences to his knowledge. Which I realize brings up another question. At what point is it ethical to stop sifting through consequences? At what point is it proper to stop thinking?

12 minutes ago, Easy Truth said:

Agreed, what I mean when I said all consequences, I meant all consequences to his knowledge. Which I realize brings up another question. At what point is it ethical to stop sifting through consequences? At what point is it proper to stop thinking?

You simply do not have all the knowledge, and don’t have the time to gain it all (that would be infinite), you also cannot think of every possible consequence, or outcome, or secondary, or n-ary consequences projecting indefinitely into the future.  How much is enough?  It’s a cost benefit analysis. 

 

You risk your life by stepping into the bustling city streets without any thought put to the risks, you risk missing your life entirely if you stay at home endlessly amassing knowledge about every possible risk that stepping into the city would expose you to.

54 minutes ago, whYNOT said:

Consequentialism is the class of normative ethical theories holding that the consequences of one’s conduct are the ultimate basis for any judgment about the rightness or wrongness of the conduct. [Wiki]

Consequentialism is the view that normative properties depend only on consequences. [Stanford]

Do you see the point? What is good is what works; what is bad, what doesn’t work. Here is a totally a-principled, amoral, irrational and arbitrary approach to ethics.

 

Wow, I can see this going in many directions. If consequentialism is based on “the single incident”, without causality in mind, meaning, what just happened worked so it is ethical, it ends up being arbitrary and irrational. Although to be nitpicky about it, it is not completely amoral as there is still a method to the madness.

If someone told me “think of the consequences”, my mind races all over the place, I see consequences as plural. I see this coming into play regarding hedonism vs. rational self-interest. The goal is always pleasure or avoidance of pain. But when there are other consequences and the long run to consider, the hedonistic goal may or may not be the rational choice (Based on consequences).

 

1 hour ago, whYNOT said:

Consequentialism is the class of normative ethical theories holding that the consequences of one’s conduct are the ultimate basis for any judgment about the rightness or wrongness of the conduct. [Wiki]

Consequentialism is the view that normative properties depend only on consequences. [Stanford]

Against what, other than the consequences to life, long range, does one judge the morality of action according to Objectivist ethics?  Against what, other than the standard of morality, does one set as the standard for judging the rightness or wrongness of conduct?

The above are perfectly fine accordingly Objectivism, as long as one does not import into the concepts “conduct” or “consequences” invalid or improper meanings.

Here’s an example: A man decides consciously he is going to smoke crack or eat a nutritious salad, but that his choice will be determined by purposefully thinking of names of people he hates beginning with the letter “c” and “s”.  Upon determining he hates more people with names beginning with “c” he eats the salad.  What has he done?  Has he simply eaten a salad?  By all accounts of reality, the nature of man an psychology has this person decided to engage in more conduct than simply eating a salad?  and as to the consequences, by virtue of what he consciously decided to do and what he did, are the consequences limited to merely his stomach having a salad in it?  Does he remember that he almost smoked crack?  How does his introspection on his choice to make such a dangerous decision based on arbitrary factors as names of people he hates affect his self-esteem .. affect how he thinks about whether he values himself or his life?

Taking into full account all that “conduct” or “action” means, and all the “consequences” are as they pertain to life, long range… there is no room for attempting to claim that the consequences of “bad” action are sometimes “good”.  By definition of morality having a standard the conduct is good or bad because the consequences (long range) are good or bad.

1 hour ago, whYNOT said:

Do you see the point? What is good is what works; what is bad, what doesn’t work. Here is a totally a-principled, amoral, irrational and arbitrary approach to ethics. (And if it happens to “work” the first time, in one context, we’d just repeat it in other contexts until it fails). The contrasts with Objectivist theory hardly have to be mentioned.

This is an equivocation and in a sense backwards.  All what “works” means is that the desired ends are achieved.  There are reasons man needs morality in the first place, Objectivism is precisely about what kind of morality works for that purpose.  The goal is life, long range, and applies to a fallible mortal man.  Objectivist morality works and it is the opposite of the a-principled, amoral, irrational and arbitrary.

 

Imagine a supposed virtue and a set of related principles that would not have any positive consequence on a man’s life, long range (which happens to be the standard of morality), then a man’s adopting them would precisely constitute an a-principled, amoral, and irrational approach to ethics.

12 minutes ago, Easy Truth said:

Wow, I can see this going in many directions. If consequentialism is based on “the single incident”, without causality in mind, meaning, what just happened worked so it is ethical, it ends up being arbitrary and irrational. Although to be nitpicky about it, it is not completely amoral as there is still a method to the madness.

If someone told me “think of the consequences”, my mind races all over the place, I see consequences as plural. I see this coming into play regarding hedonism vs. rational self-interest. The goal is always pleasure or avoidance of pain. But when there are other consequences and the long run to consider, the hedonistic goal may or may not be the rational choice (Based on consequences).

 

The definitions do not include a limitation that the consequences specifically be “single incidents”.  Knowing the probability of winning with a certain hand at poker leads to a rational choice/bet if the desired consequence is winning.  Built into the game (similar to life) is the absence of omniscience (not knowing all the cards in the deck and in everyone’s hand), but using the knowledge of the chances of winning can lead to a player who in the long run, wins more than his buddies.  So here, one form of conduct is rational, long range, repeated action based on probabilities, and a consequentialist view of such conduct would be that it is good for winning at poker… and it is.

52 minutes ago, Easy Truth said:

Wow, I can see this going in many directions. If consequentialism is based on “the single incident”, without causality in mind, meaning, what just happened worked so it is ethical, it ends up being arbitrary and irrational. Although to be nitpicky about it, it is not completely amoral as there is still a method to the madness.

If someone told me “think of the consequences”, my mind races all over the place, I see consequences as plural. I see this coming into play regarding hedonism vs. rational self-interest. The goal is always pleasure or avoidance of pain. But when there are other consequences and the long run to consider, the hedonistic goal may or may not be the rational choice (Based on consequences).

 

“Without causality in mind”. That says plenty. It’s starting to seem more likely to me that consequentialism reverses cause and effect. I.e. The consequence determines future cause. If we can predict every consequence of acts, we would be not man, omniscient a few guys have said. What one does have control over is a consciousness which can conceive of a range of the possible/probable/certain effects of one’s actions, and the volition to re-direct and change them on the fly, where necessary. Remarked on above too, there aren’t any thou shalts here, the O’ist morality is all hypothetical imperative: “If” - “then…” For that, one has to know -why- to value and -what- to value. I want that – therefore, must do this. Finally, the individual should take the responsibility for whatever could not be anticipated and goes wrong, the identical reason he must get the benefits he deserves. 

8 minutes ago, StrictlyLogical said:

The definitions do not include a limitation that the consequences specifically be “single incidents”. 

At this point of the conversation, I can see that some of the definitions render consequentialism as irrational.

  1. Any solution/means that reaches the goal is “good, right, okay, etc.”

2.The ethical way can be extracted from a single incident that worked without any more thinking.

1 hour ago, whYNOT said:

Consequentialism is the class of normative ethical theories holding that the consequences of one’s conduct are the ultimate basis for any judgment about the rightness or wrongness of the conduct. [Wiki]

Consequentialism is the view that normative properties depend only on consequences. [Stanford]

 

The problem is that the Wiki and Standford definitions don’t eliminate the possibility of the two I mentioned.

A definition that emphasizes that a goal, encompasses other subgoals that also need to be reached and that other consequences  should not harm the ultimate goal and that we have to consider “why” what we did works, then consequentialism (based on definition) gets close to a rational way of life.

3 minutes ago, Easy Truth said:

A definition that emphasizes that a goal, encompasses other subgoals that also need to be reached and that other consequences  should not harm the ultimate goal and that we have to consider “why” what we did works, then consequentialism (based on definition) gets close to a rational way of life.

This does not require the redefinition of consequentialism.  They become part of the package as soon as the consequences of the particular normative ethical are as broad and as absolute as “life” itself. 

When the choice, i.e. the chosen consequence, is life, reality itself including man’s nature, automatically dictates the “shoulds” and the “have tos” you speak of. 

4 minutes ago, StrictlyLogical said:

This does not require the redefinition of consequentialism.  They become part of the package as soon as the consequences of the particular normative ethical are as broad and as absolute as “life” itself. 

When the choice, i.e. the chosen consequence, is life, reality itself including man’s nature, automatically dictates the “shoulds” and the “have tos” you speak of.

If so, doesn’t this make the case that Objectivist ethics is consequentialist?

1 hour ago, Easy Truth said:

If so, doesn’t this make the case that Objectivist ethics is consequentialist?

In the same way we use terms such as “selfish” and “morality” according to rational concept formation… (and which differ from mentally sloppy common usage) so too I believe (all things considered) Objectivist ethics is consequentialist is the broadest, most rational and absolute meaning of the term “consequence”.  .. and afterall what is more consequential than life itself?

2 hours ago, Easy Truth said:

If so, doesn’t this make the case that Objectivist ethics is consequentialist?

 

I think this debate all turns on one thing. That the “consequences” are indeed, rationally-moral goals. But what does consequentialism show us about what is moral or provide any guide? Nothing. Everyone has been presuming upon ‘good consequences’ - from the standpoint of Objectivism. Therefore, rational consequences imply consequentialism, which it does not.

Consequentialism:

  1. the theory that human actions derive their moral worth solely from their outcomes or consequences.

  2. the theory that ethical decisions should be made on the basis of the expected outcome or consequence of the action.

Which is mere pragmatism.

Your goal as an architect is to be successful and wealthy. A potential client arrives, and all he asks is that you change your proposed drawings of a skyscraper to accomodate his love of Gothic churches. You are struggling, so it goes without saying that you do so.  After all, by your doctrine the consequence (success) you seek determines your actions, and as such, is an “ethical decision”, with “moral worth”. Why should the integrity of the building and the designer matter?

The concept, consequentialism has been around much longer. I think we can’t adopt the notion into Objectivism (except to use it idiosyncratically - and so weaken or collapse its premise).

28 minutes ago, whYNOT said:

Why should the integrity of the building and the designer matter?

Because his integrity requires that he make a living first. It is a choice between two values. Both valuable in their own context.

From a hierarchy of values perspective, his artistic integrity takes a back seat to his survival (assuming that is what is at stake). He cannot sacrifice. This is not a sacrifice. He is choosing that which is worth more.

If you are saying that based on consequentialism, he will choose to kill the client to build his building, that makes consequentialism irrational. But if he was to see the consequences of his actions, he will rationally choose the most valuable route. As it should be. With integrity.