Is objectivism consequentialist?

3 hours ago, StrictlyLogical said:

Against what, other than the consequences to life, long range, does one judge the morality of action according to Objectivist ethics?  Against what, other than the standard of morality, does one set as the standard for judging the rightness or wrongness of conduct?

The above are perfectly fine accordingly Objectivism, as long as one does not import into the concepts “conduct” or “consequences” invalid or improper meanings.

Believing that consqeuences matter for moral assessment is not enough to make you a consequentialist. Any plausible moral theory is going to hold that consqeuences matter at some level. What distinguishes consequentialism from other moral theories is its claim that consequences are the _only thing that matter. This is a much stronger and much less plausible claim. Take some positions of Rand: think that it’s important that people get what they deserve? Think you have some reason to keep your promises simply because you made them (and not because of the good that you expect to produce by keeping them)? Think that it’s better for guilty people to be punished than innocent people (again not just _because the consequences are better)? Then you’re not a consequentialist.

Consequential (and deontological) considerations do play into morality some point for various reasons, but they are justified in terms of what constitutes flourishing, and flourishing will manifest because of, and partially in terms of, your character development, which is ultimately the primary focus for Rand’s normative ethics.

Rand, however, did hold to the Greek “unity of virtue” theory, just as all the Socratics did. She did not consider prudence to be a virtue, or at least did not comment on it, but this is where Aristotle shines. Consequentialist considerations are in reciprocal determination with the virtue of prudence (which is the virtue of employing phroenesis or practical reasoning), which is in reciprocal determination with the others, such as justice and benevolence and honor, and so forth. That is why a virtue ethicist does not have to worry about importing into “consequences” invalid meanings.

32 minutes ago, 2046 said:

Take some positions of Rand: think that it’s important that people get what they deserve? Think you have some reason to keep your promises simply because you made them (and not because of the good that you expect to produce by keeping them)? Think that it’s better for guilty people to be punished than innocent people (again not just_ _because the consequences are better)? Then you’re not a consequentialist.

 

When you say “not just_ _because the consequences are better”, then what is the alternative? Some other way (to know) is better? or …

better is not what matters?

How can you “ever” make consequences irrelevant?

1 Like

57 minutes ago, 2046 said:

think that it’s important that people get what they deserve?

By “important” do you mean in my self-interest?  i.e. in furtherance of my life, long range?

57 minutes ago, 2046 said:

Think you have some reason to keep your promises simply because you made them (and not because of the good that you expect to produce by keeping them)?

By “reason” do you mean some effect upon my self-esteem and therefore my ability to sustain myself.. i.e. in furtherance of my life, long range?

59 minutes ago, 2046 said:

Think that it’s better for guilty people to be punished than innocent people (again not just_ _because the consequences are better)?

By “better”, do you mean it is in my self-interest to act (directly or indirectly, by persuasion, voting, or whatever means) such that in reality guilty people are more likely to be punished than innocent people.. i.e. that such action is in furtherance of my life, long range?

 

Is my life, long range, the consequence to which my morality of self interest is directed, including virtues, principles, and actions… the answer is yes. 

Is the choice to adopt an Objective morality and to live according to it JUST for achieving the self-interested purpose which is my life… of course.  What else is morality for?

1 hour ago, StrictlyLogical said:

Is the choice to adopt an Objective morality and to live according to it JUST for achieving the self-interested purpose which is my life… of course.  What else is morality for?

I’m not sure what you’re arguing. The first post in this thread is a good explanation of why consequentialism doesn’t mean just caring about a consequence.

56 minutes ago, StrictlyLogical said:

 

Is my life, long range, the consequence to which my morality of self interest is directed, including virtues, principles, and actions… the answer is yes. 

Is the choice to adopt an Objective morality and to live according to it JUST for achieving the self-interested purpose which is my life… of course.  What else is morality for?

The original question in the thread is about the structure of moral judgments and the relationship between moral terms, not that there is something outside of your life which morality is for. The point is, as many philosophers from Epicurus onward have pointed out, that this conception of “living according to the objective morality” (i.e. virtuous character) that you’d have adopted will end up being part of what “living your life” is.

In other words the purpose is constiuted by the means adopted.This would then contradict your claim that virtue could be “JUST” for your self-interest, a la Hobbesian egoism. In other words, the means can sometimes be part of the end, rather than simply a strategy for bringing it about. Once you’ve committed to it, then you’re committed to it for its own sake, since it is part of what the end is.

Both consequentialists and virtue theorists can be egoists. A consequentialist would say virtues or rules only have instrumental relationship to bring out about our self-interest, whereas a virtue egoist, such as Rand, would say living virtuously is just part of what your true self-interest is.

 

Consequentialism makes for an intriguing concept. It illustrates well the different approaches to concept formation.

On one hand, you have the Consequentialist with a few layers of depth (in an ITOE approach) that pragmatically looks primarily at the result. If the desired result is not achieved, sure look at the approach for what might have gone wrong, but not necessarily from a principled standpoint. No time for that. Another approach needs to implemented as soon as possible in order to try again for the stated result.

If you look at the concept in terms of what gives rise to the necessity for consequentialism, the few layers of depth (again, in an ITOE style approach) begins to examine the subsequent abstractions in depth, find still other abstractions the examined abstractions rely upon. On this basis, consequentialism has merit as an objective term, albeit, not an Objectivist term. This is similar to the term Existentialism, a brief contender as a proper noun for Objectivism, albeit dismissed after consideration of the baggage it carried along with it.

Unlike the term selfishness, the common usage of selfishness, properly understood, is an aberration in concept formation. As such, Miss Rand decided it was the proper term, even though the redundancy of “rational” often precedes it in order to draw attention to how Objectivism applies it in accordance with a properly formed concept, rather than how it is often pejoratively used.

In a world where language is embraced primarily as a tool of thought rather than communication, where man is regarded as the “conceptual animal”, where the “rational animal” is regarded as one of the earlier stepping stones to grasping “man qua man”, consequentialism (or consequentialist) may be regarded as a close synonym for rational egoism (or rational egoist).

Until such time, it can easily serve as a good ice-breaker to explore potential common grounds on a not so common plateau.

1 Like

On 9/22/2009 at 6:55 AM, aequalsa said:

Would it be fair to characterize Objectivist ethics as consequentialist in the sense that if one wants to live a flourishing life one ought to behave in a self interested way?

The first Post starts with a question. 

1 hour ago, Eiuol said:

The first post in this thread is a good explanation of why consequentialism doesn’t mean just caring about a consequence.

 

According to other definitions brought up, it seems to

9 hours ago, whYNOT said:

Consequentialism is the class of normative ethical theories holding that the consequences of one’s conduct are the ultimate basis for any judgment about the rightness or wrongness of the conduct. [Wiki]

Consequentialism is the view that normative properties depend only on consequences. [Stanford]

I would be interested in knowing what you define “consequentialism” to be?

At some point, you’re brought up that it means that Any Means are Justified which to me renders it irrational so I am assuming you mean something other than what I understood.

1 Like

9 hours ago, 2046 said:

This would then contradict your claim that virtue could be “JUST” for your self-interest,

How could it not ultimately be, just for one’s self-interest.  What ELSE would it ultimately be for?

 

9 hours ago, 2046 said:

In other words, the means can sometimes be part of the end, rather than simply a strategy for bringing it about. Once you’ve committed to it, then you’re committed to it for its own sake, since it is part of what the end is.

This seems to be an argument claiming that the kind of actions taken have consequences other than the consciously held one… or beyond what a person might know without thinking about it… these are still other consequences which may impact upon the ultimate one.  Have you read my posts above?

The ultimate end is achieved by a string of means and ends, actions and goals, practices, virtues and character.  What makes any of these along they way moral, is that they are consequential to the ultimate end. 

Anything, to the extent to which is not of consequence to life, long range, is outside of ethics, it is amoral.

 

9 hours ago, 2046 said:

Rand, would say living virtuously is just part of what your true self-interest is.

Self-interest according to what standard?

 

Your argument is that there is something other than life long range which is of ultimate importance… please be specific.  Provide an example of something else which “matters” but which does not ultimately derive its own importance from its supporting life long range.   

Moreover, explain how such an ultimate importance external to or divorced from supporting life long range, can enter anywhere into morality without diluting “life as the standard”.

13 hours ago, Easy Truth said:

Because his integrity requires that he make a living first. It is a choice between two values. Both valuable in their own context.

From a hierarchy of values perspective, his artistic integrity takes a back seat to his survival (assuming that is what is at stake). He cannot sacrifice. This is not a sacrifice. He is choosing that which is worth more.

If you are saying that based on consequentialism, he will choose to kill the client to build his building, that makes consequentialism irrational. But if he was to see the consequences of his actions, he will rationally choose the most valuable route. As it should be. With integrity.

 

 

Well, who’s to say for him? This is an imaginary “architect”, after all. :wink: One kind may consider his and his work’s integrity to be easily compromised, thereafter to be further compromised, until little remains of his integrity or pride in his productivity. Another, with the highest standards might rather choose work in a rock quarry for the interim. There are, in reality many alternatives for “survival”. 

But exactly. Why should a consequentialist rule out murder? (Taking it to ridiculous extremes). If he appropriates wealth this way and he’s not found out, he must by definition, consider that a moral act. If and when he’s arrested, the moment the police arrive, then he will know the act was unethical.

It is important to avoid conflating causality with consequentialism, imo. It is understood that identity/causation are foundational - and, perhaps the similarities with consequentialism can be attractive. There is a process preceding an effect, began by a volitional consciousness, the cause. Rational selfishness requires one’s reasoned thinking translated into action, then translating into morally selfish consequences. Barring outside interference or unforseen circumstances and accidents, one expects a rational - good - outcome. But the outcome or product isn’t the primary, determining factor of one’s morality (qua consequentialism) the thinking and actions which initiated it are. 

To my way of seeing this, Objectivism’s causation renders consequentialism - in its best, possible light - obsolete or superfluous. 

1 hour ago, whYNOT said:

But exactly. Why should a consequentialist rule out murder? (Taking it to ridiculous extremes). If he appropriates wealth this way and he’s not found out, he must by definition, consider that a moral act. If and when he’s arrested, the moment the police arrive, then he will know the act was unethical.

Sorry for interjecting… your response was to ET, but this is tantamount to arguing against the Objectivist standard of morality itself.

It claims that bad conduct can support life long range… implying that the standard of morality is wrong.  It amounts to saying really, conduct is to be judged as “good” or “bad” according to something which is not the Objectivist standard of morality.  This is an error.  Actions are bad precisely because they are inimical to life, long range, and any action which is not inimical to life, long range simply is not bad.

2 Likes

9 hours ago, Easy Truth said:

At some point, you’re brought up that it means that Any Means are Justified which to me renders it irrational so I am assuming you mean something other than what I understood.

I can’t speak much to the term “consequentialism” in the context of the history of philosophy, but I wonder…

If I said that I planned on pursuing a flourishing life by any means necessary – and that I will judge (and amend) my efforts by their success in winning me a flourishing life – what would we make of it? Would this put me in the “consequentialist” camp? Would it be outside the bounds of Objectivism?

It is potentially a danger to reject principled thinking in the face of some accident. If I stop at red lights because I do not want to get into an auto accident, but one day I stop and… BANG, someone hits me from behind, I would not therefore abandon my strategy of stopping at red lights. But this does not change the fact that I adopt and maintain the approach of stopping at red lights in order to avoid such accidents. What an Objectivist means to do by adopting “principles” – isn’t this according to the consequences he expects through the adoption of such principles?

Maybe that’s not what’s conventionally meant by “consequentialism,” but it is what it is.

2 Likes

Removed hypothetical… beating a dead horse.

19 minutes ago, DonAthos said:

What an Objectivist means to do by adopting “principles” – isn’t this according to the consequences he expects through the adoption of such principles?

Absolutely.

2 hours ago, StrictlyLogical said:

The ultimate end is achieved by a string of means and ends, actions and goals, practices, virtues and character.  What makes any of these along they way moral, is that they are consequential to the ultimate end.

Not quite. The point is that the means of attaining those ends must be understood in terms of one’s nature. Not only are virtues instrumental (means to an end), they are the means as dictated by your nature. This would be teleology, where we also look at the nature of an agent. 

4 hours ago, Eiuol said:

Not quite. The point is that the means of attaining those ends must be understood in terms of one’s nature. Not only are virtues instrumental (means to an end), they are the means as dictated by your nature. This would be teleology, where we also look at the nature of an agent. 

If one chooses a consequence that is in conflict with one’s nature, it leads to nonexistence. We are free to choose poison.
The ultimate goal of a living entity is existence.
A volitional being using reason will rationally consider consequences “as a guide” to survival.
Isn’t existence the desired and proper ultimate consequence that one is after?
(I’m not trying to open up the flourishing vs. survival argument)

“Virtue consists of allegiance to existence”. OPAR (p. 250).

4 hours ago, StrictlyLogical said:

Sorry for interjecting… your response was to ET, but this is tantamount to arguing against the Objectivist standard of morality itself.

It claims that bad conduct can support life long range… implying that the standard of morality is wrong.  It amounts to saying really, conduct is to be judged as “good” or “bad” according to something which is not the Objectivist standard of morality.  This is an error.  Actions are bad precisely because they are inimical to life, long range, and any action which is not inimical to life, long range simply is not bad.

I was hypothetically taking the (extreme) consequentialist position. Wasn’t that clear? You’ve made the contrast clear, from an O’ist position. Thanks.

[The Pragmatists] declared that philosophy must be practical and that practicality consists of dispensing with all absolute principles and standards—that there is no such thing as objective reality or permanent truth—that truth is that which works, and its validity can be judged only by its consequences—that no facts can be known with certainty in advance, and anything may be tried by rule-of-thumb—that reality is not firm, but fluid and “indeterminate,” that there is no such thing as a distinction between an external world and a consciousness (between the perceived and the perceiver), there is only an undifferentiated package-deal labeled “experience,” and whatever one wishes to be true, is true, whatever one wishes to exist, does exist, provided it works or makes one feel better.

“For the New Intellectual,”

If the Pragmatist epistemology is “truth is that which works”, is consequentialism the ethics of Pragmatism?

(“Human actions derive their moral worth solely from their outcomes and consequences”)

On the face of it there is an interesting parallel/intersection. Would a scholar here inform me? I hardly know anything about that philosophy.

1 hour ago, whYNOT said:

On the face of it there is an interesting parallel/intersection. Would a scholar here inform me? I hardly know anything about that philosophy.

1

I am not a scholar but I saw this :

Consequentialism  (or  Teleological Ethics ) is an approach to Ethics that argues that the morality of an action is  contingent  on the action’s  outcome  or  consequence. Thus, a  morally right  action is one that produces a  good outcome  or result, and the consequences of an action or rule generally  outweigh  all other considerations (i.e. the  ends  justify the  means ).

It is  distinct  from the other main types of ethical system: Deontology (which derives the rightness or wrongness of an act from the character of the  act itself  rather than the outcomes of the action), and Virtue Ethics (which focuses on the  character of the agent rather than on either the nature or consequences of the action itself). Consequentialist theories must consider  questions  like “What sort of consequences count as  good consequences?”, “Who is the primary  beneficiary  of moral action?”, “How are the consequences  judged  and who judges them?”

Agent-Neutral Consequentialism  ignores the specific  value  of a state of affairs  for the individual , so that their own  personal goals  do not count any more than  anyone else’s  goals in evaluating what action should be taken.  Agent-Focused Consequentialism , on the other hand, focuses on the  particular needs  of the individual, so that (although they may  also  be concerned with the  general welfare ) they are  more  concerned with the immediate welfare of the individuals’ self, friends and family.

The  term  “consequentialism” was coined by  Elizabeth Anscombe  (1919 - 2001) in her 1958 essay  “Modern Moral Philosophy” , as a  pejorative  description of what she saw as the central error of certain moral theories (she was a Virtue Ethicist). It then came to be adopted by  both sides  of the argument.

http://www.philosophybasics.com/branch_consequentialism.html