Is the afterlife arbitrary?

I realize that the standard objectivist answer is that the afterlife/reincarnation is arbitrary, but is it really? 

After all, we know that consciousness is real, and we don’t have the scientific explanation for it yet. Isn’t it then at least a possibility that, if there’s an entity which contains the essence of your consciousness, that entity might later come into a physical formation that gives you a life as a living being again? 

8 minutes ago, Severinian said:

. . . We know that consciousness is real, and we don’t have the scientific explanation for it yet. Isn’t it then at least a possibility that, if there’s an entity which contains the essence of your consciousness, that entity might later come into a physical formation that gives you a life as a living being again? 

No. The notion is only a childhood brainwashing holdover. More is required for possibility than lack of surface contradiction. Isn’t it possible that cellular life is possible only through attendance by a non-physical life force? No. 

Genuine inquiry about brain/consciousness - real possibilities

 

Sev,

There is another formulation of immortality that does not invoke a conveyance entity and is argued as a certainty, not a possibility. That is Nietzsche’s ‘eternal recurrence’. This is not a situation in which the recurrence of one’s self and same life would be felt as sameness to prior same-existence(s), but the situation of recurrence can be reasoned to. The argument goes that because the future is infinitely long, all the things composing the sequences of the world and one’s life and person in it must eventually recur. Even granting the assumption of Nietzsche’s day, that the chemical elements will be capable of forming the molecules of life for an infinite time to come, the recurrence Nietzsche envisioned is impossible. The failure is not realizing that there are different sizes of infinity. The infinity of real numbers is larger than the infinity of integers, such that the probability that a number picked randomly from the real numbers will be an integer is nil (zero). Similarly, the infinity of future hours (we are going along with as assumption in the setup for the doomed argument) is a smaller infinity of courses of hour-fires I can have in my fireplace and smaller than the infinity of life-courses I can have in front of any particular course of fire in the fireplace. The hour of life I have just now passed will never recur. 

 

Your conclusions don’t seem to follow from your premises. How is it relevant that there are different kinds of infinities? Nietzsche’s eternal recurrence does seem logical, assuming that it’s physically possible for things to turn back the way they were. After all, eternity is eternal… So sooner or later, it will happen.

But that’s also a separate issue than the question of life after death. 

On 10/11/2021 at 6:07 AM, Boydstun said:

Isn’t it possible that cellular life is possible only through attendance by a non-physical life force? No. 

Midichlorions? :wink:

On 10/11/2021 at 5:44 AM, Severinian said:

After all, we know that consciousness is real, and we don’t have the scientific explanation for it yet. Isn’t it then at least a possibility that, if there’s an entity which contains the essence of your consciousness, that entity might later come into a physical formation that gives you a life as a living being again? 

Look at it this way.

 

Although we don’t yet know exactly what consciousness is or how it works, we do know that it lines up almost precisely to brain activity.

We can measure waking and sleeping brainwave patterns, as well as that of various emotions and mental states. Technologies like fMRI imaging look pretty likely to eventually allow us to remote control our gadgets by thought alone, and possibly develop truly reliable lie detection. The reason any of that works is because changes in mental states have a very good correspondence to changes in brain activity.

Furthermore, breaking the brain in various ways leads to permanent mental changes. I assume you’ve heard of Phineas Gage, the railroad worker who survived the loss of his frontal lobe in a workplace accident and went on to be described by his friends and family as a totally different person.

Anyway. So if we can assume that the mind IS what the brain DOES in a certain sense (and I just outlined a few reasons why this seems quite likely) then we have to ask what happens to brain activity upon death - namely, that it all just stops.

 

So all of that taken together provides what I consider to be a pretty good inductive argument against any sort of afterlife. It’s not irrefutably bulletproof, of course - and neither is any kind of REAL knowledge. But I have yet to come across any worthwhile bullets against it.

 

Memento Mori.

On 10/11/2021 at 3:44 AM, Severinian said:

Isn’t it then at least a possibility that, if there’s an entity which contains the essence of your consciousness, that entity might later come into a physical formation that gives you a life as a living being again?

And what is this “entity which contains the essence of your consciousness”? Here you suggest a thing without evidence for that thing, which makes it arbitrary.

Arbitrary: there is an afterlife in Heaven where we will be reunited with our loved ones, or where God will meet our justice.

Wild speculation: maybe the huge filaments of galaxies we can see are analogous in scale to what sub atomic particles are to the human brain, tiny fundamental components of some greater superstructure, existing within the universe and still bound by the laws of the nature capable of recording and recreating the fact of an individual human consciousness. 

Logical conclusion: there is no reason to believe anything other than that your consciousness is extinguished upon your death.

On 10/11/2021 at 6:44 AM, Severinian said:

After all, we know that consciousness is real, and we don’t have the scientific explanation for it yet.

How do we know it’s real if you don’t have a scientific explanation? I’ll make a comparison to.. intelligence. We can predict intelligence using IQ, but it is not one definable thing. If you want my personal diagnostic, intelligence is the group effort of many different function occurring in our brain systems, but as always, that’s debatable. Maybe consciousness makes sense, it can accurately explain physical events and actions, but it is not proven. Doesn’t this remind you of god? God says he made plants, animals, and humans. and wow, it’s true! around us, we see plants, animals, and humans, so God must have made these things? see, it explains easily why these things exist, but because there is no proof, it is not true

A scientific explanation presupposes consciousness, @OfficerBacon .

 

1 Like

@dream_weaver I’m not sure what you mean. In order to prove consciousness, you must first believe it to exist?

Recognizing consciousness in oneself is implicit in every act of cognition.  Thus any attempt to deny or question it is self-contradictory.  We summarize this by saying consciousness is axiomatic.

Thus recognizing consciousness in oneself precedes any proof or explanation of anything.  This is implicit at first, but should eventually become explicit.

Inferring consciousness in others is different.  So is scientific study aimed at understanding how consciousness is possible and how it works.

 

 

1 Like

2 hours ago, OfficerBacon said:

@dream_weaver I’m not sure what you mean. In order to prove consciousness, you must first believe it to exist?

Consciousness is required to perform the conscious act of proving/proof. Consciousness is required to perform the act of consciousness identified as belief.

1 Like

On 1/24/2022 at 12:00 PM, dream_weaver said:

Consciousness is required to perform the conscious act of proving/proof. Consciousness is required to perform the act of consciousness identified as belief.

Is it? Define consciousness 

On 1/24/2022 at 10:18 AM, Doug Morris said:

Thus recognizing consciousness in oneself precedes any proof or explanation of anything.  This is implicit at first, but should eventually become explicit.

This also applies to verbal definition.

Axiomatic concepts like consciousness must be defined ostensively.

For a fuller explanation, I recommend Ayn Rand’s Introduction to Objectivist Epistemology, especially the section on axiomatic concepts.

 

1 hour ago, OfficerBacon said:

Is it? Define consciousness 

That too, would require consciousness to perform.

As a starting point, try the 1913 Webster’s definition of consciousness.

On 1/19/2022 at 6:14 AM, OfficerBacon said:

On 10/11/2021 at 3:44 AM, Severinian said:

After all, we know that consciousness is real, and we don’t have the scientific explanation for it yet.

How do we know it’s real if you don’t have a scientific explanation?

Introspection. If you’re like me then you are aware of your own consciousness. You know that you’re aware of this sentence. You don’t need people in lab coats to perform an experiment on you and publish a paper on it. Science is for stuff that cannot be known introspectively, like the airspeed velocity of an unladen swallow.

21 hours ago, dream_weaver said:

That too, would require consciousness to perform.

As a starting point, try the 1913 Webster’s definition of consciousness.

I don’t think this definition aligns with what OP was implying consciousness is. This is meta thinking, and it is scientifically proven. 

7 hours ago, MisterSwig said:

Introspection. If you’re like me then you are aware of your own consciousness. You know that you’re aware of this sentence. You don’t need people in lab coats to perform an experiment on you and publish a paper on it. Science is for stuff that cannot be known introspectively, like the airspeed velocity of an unladen swallow.

I disagree with you. Our minds are too unreliable to just say and make true, all things must be proven

3 hours ago, OfficerBacon said:

I don’t think this definition aligns with what OP was implying consciousness is. This is meta thinking, and it is scientifically proven. 

I was addressing your reply to Severinian.