There’s an obvious mistake about half-way through the video, in one of your text graphics. The “Libertarian = Right-Wing” text is targeted at Peikoff, right? But he’s attributing that position to the radio host, and Peikoff himself says that it’s the wrong definition.
This was Peikoff’s spin, or one might call it “interpretation”, of Brudnoy. He even says “this is my understanding of his position” right before equating libertarian with right wing. Brudnoy was as libertarian as Milton Friedman or Penn Jillette, and was even a member of the Libertarian party.
And I don’t think “Nolan Chart” gets to determine the correct definition of ‘libertarian.’ The Nolan Chart says so and so… who cares?
No, it’s Peter Schwartz who doesn’t get to define what libertarian means. The Nolan Chart is as foundational to what libertarianism is as anything can be.
I always took it that Rand, Peikoff, and Schwartz meant by “libertarian” “Rothbardian.”
Then why didn’t they say exactly that?
I suggest you check out “On Sanctioning the Sanctioners”. Anyone who sanctions an anarchist (or whatever), is also not to be sanctioned. Just how far this policy was meant to extend (can one sanction the sanctioner of a sanctioner?) was thankfully never defined, at least not that I ever saw. The joke at the time was that eventually Leonard would excommunicate Harry, then Peter would excommunicate Leonard.
Weren’t all Schwartz’s examples of libertarians examples of Rothbardian anarchists?
Nope.
Allison has promised to remove anarchists and persons disrespectful of Rand from the Cato payroll. Sounds like Cato moving in an Objectivist direction to me.
You’re telling me something I haven’t heard before, that is, that Allison has voiced plans to cut people from the Cato payroll on such grounds. Source please.