John A. Allison takes over as CEO of the Cato Institute

Who thinks that? I gather this is directed at me, and I’d like to know on what basis you think you know how I define my independence, whatever that means.

What an incredibly stupid thing to say. And what a cowardly way to say it.

It’s directed at anyone it fits.

There are many people who bitch constantly about Peikoff as some sort of dogmatist, and flaunt how virtuous they are for not agreeing with him (even if this means abandoning rational principles).

I’m not a coward. Let me know if that sounds like you and I’ll be sure to let you know how much of a bastard you are.

1 Like

I don’t see any hypocrisy going on here.

BTW I’d like to make something crystal clear: I’m not accusing anyone of hypocrisy. Not yet. Rather, I’m pointing out a contradiction. I think I made that perfectly clear in the video (review the last 30 seconds), but I suppose it bears repeating. I’d really like to see ARI repudiate their anti-libertarian position. The final image I chose is a reference to “Panta Rei” and Heraclitus, suggesting that things are in flux, though I didn’t expect many people to get the reference.

ARI can say they had the right position back in the eighties, but the libertarian movement has improved and now they’re willing and eager to engage. It would be bullshit, but fine, they’re going to have to save face. What would be hypocritical is if Allison is planning some kind of undeclared ARI takeover of Cato, with “respect” for Ayn Rand, or absence of “disrespect”, whatever that might mean, becoming criteria for associating with the Institute. Consider that Cato’s highest award is the Milton Friedman Prize, and Ayn Rand despised Milton Friedman. How’s that supposed to jibe?

I’m not a coward. Let me know if that sounds like you and I’ll be sure to let you know how much of a bastard you are.

Tell you what tough guy, if you want to have a flame war, we’re going to have to have it on OL. Here’s a link to the thread.

http://www.objectivi…351#entry167029

I’ve had the experience here of some knucklehead throwing crap like this at me, and when I reply in kind, my post gets deleted. So come on over, hit me with your best shot, and we’ll have it out.

Tell you what tough guy, if you want to have a flame war, we’re going to have to have it on OL. Here’s a link to the thread.

http://www.objectivi…351#entry167029

I’ve had the experience here of some knucklehead throwing crap like this at me, and when I reply in kind, my post gets deleted. So come on over, hit me with your best shot, and we’ll have it out.

So you’re saying you do those things I named, but you’ll only tell me if you’re certain you won’t get banned from this forum?

If that’s the case, you’re a cowardly bastard. Otherwise, I don’t see how we have a problem.

Either way, I don’t think you should take this discussion in the direction you’re taking it. “Tough guy”? “Knucklehead”? “We’ll have it out”? What in the hell?.

Indeed. He was speaking at a public forum, so there’s no reason he should only expect softballs.

So a rational person is supposed to be overly tender and kind and respond only to the obseqious nature of a hostile question? Peikoff didn’t come to the forum to hear that guy talk, it was vice versa.

First of all I wrote that a couple months ago, and hadn’t reviewed the tape in many years, so I was going from memory. Second, if that’s not hitting the roof (I hate to get pedantic here, but you do realize it’s a metaphor?) then I can hardly imagine what is.

Which is it? You’re back-pedaling about your judgment or you’re trying to justify it?

Sounds to me like a distinction without a difference.

Words have meaning; talk != debate.

Ninth,

My source for Allison’s plans isn’t linkable; it’s what he said during a presentation about it, and AFAIK it’s not been put online. During that presentation, Yaron Brook said that Rand’s (and ARI’s) antipathy to “libertarians” has always been antipathy towards Rothbardian anarchists.

Libertarian = Rothbardian. You ask why Schwartz didn’t say explicitly that he meant Rothbard when he wrote about libertarians. In paragraph three of the “Perversion of Liberty” essay: “Murray Rothbard, widely viewed as the father of the movement…” The context of the rest of the essay shows that Schwartz agrees with that view.

In the 70s and 80s, wasn’t the libertarian movement dominated by Rothbardians and anarchists? Rothbard was a founder of both Cato and the LP, and weren’t most of the journals/magazines cited by Schwartz connected to Rothbard? Obviously, the libertarian movement has changed since then. But you can’t look at these things out of their historical context. If in 1985 “libertarian” was mostly associated with Rothbard and anarchist friends, it’s a safe bet that’s who Schwartz was talking about when he criticized libertarians.

And, who were the non-Rothbardian or non-anarchists cited by Schwartz? I’m looking at the footnotes now and no names stand out. Reason is cited, but the article is by Rothbard.

Brudnoy. If Peikoff associates with people like Brudnoy, but not anarchists, isn’t that evidence he means by “libertarian” Rothbardians/anarchists? Why attribute to Peikoff (or ARI) a contradiction when there’s a better supported alternative interpretation of what’s happening? And an interpretation that’s the one the current president of ARI has endorsed, at that!

Edit: Lest I be accused of inventing scuttlebutt, my notes on the Allison discussion show that he said those disrespectful of Rand will change their attitudes or find other employment. Not that they will be fired outright. “Respectful” didn’t have any implication of them becoming Objectivist. Also, Allison said that he will be there for a number of years and in that time he will be grooming an Objectivist replacement. And, he wasn’t going to take the job until Yaron Brook convinced him to.

You’re spot on except for the spelling. It’s Kelley, David Kelley. He spoke at Laissez Faire Books. Timeline: Peikoff did a book signing at LFB when The Ominous Parallels came out. Then Barbara Branden’s biography came out, the LFB catalogue carried a positive review, and they offered signed copies for sale. Then Kelley spoke there. You shouldn’t need to be keeping a rocket scientist on retainer to figure this one out.

Kelley (sp) then was doing the same thing, only it was unpopular with management? Well that’s disturbing. Even if I accepted the premise (which I don’t) then it still does not make sense. If ideas are important then the obvious solution is to have someone go to those you disagree with and properly articulate the right ideas. Communicating the right ideas has always been the benchmark of winning the culture war for society. Pretty much like what Rand did herself her entire life.

1 Like

Atlas,

Thanks for the information from the Brook-Allison presentation. I don’t know what anarchism has had to do with Cato in the past. All of the many times I have seen representatives from Cato on The News Hour through the years it certainly had nothing to do with that.

Rothbard was not a founder of Cato or of the Libertarian Party. David Nolan was founder of LP. I have not been a member or supporter of LP since 1984. I have never been an anarchocapitalist.

As I recall, it was in the spring of 1972 that I noticed a flyer pasted in the fine arts building on my campus, which flyer summoned anyone interested in forming a Libertarian Party in Oklahoma. I gave them a call. (I had learned the name and idea libertarian somewhat earlier through the philosophy journal The Personalist, edited by John Hospers.) They were Frank and Carolyn Robinson (of OKC), a couple of their acquaintances, and their hopes. Frank soon attended the national founding convention in Denver. Hospers, who was not anarchist, became our presidential candidate. Frank reported that Hospers had called Rothbard and had gotten the latter to agree to stop attacking this nascent organization. Rothbard and associates would later join and, by ’76, gain great influence in the party. It would have been some months, maybe many, after the ’72 election, when I learned that Rand condemned us for our political and educational initiative.

By 1976 the Koch family had begun funding LP national efforts. Ed Crane was the party chair at that time. As I recall the Kochs put about a million dollars into the 1980 LP presidential campaign. (Our candidate was Ed Clark.) After that effort, the Kochs decided to stop putting their money into LP campaigns and instead form Cato, with Ed Crane as its head.

In 1985 or so, I did read Peter Schwartz’ essay against libertarianism. It contained at least one correct thought about participation in political action, as I recall. But his representation of what was libertarianism was fantastical. He blurred the distinction between the political philosophy and the political party (an ideological political party, to be sure). John Hospers had completed a book surveying libertarianism by the time of his campaign back in 1972, and we in the party had promoted it continually. Beyond that work were three cornerstone works many of us in the party and in the libertarian intellectual movement more generally had read or were reading: Atlas Shrugged; Man, Economy, and State (Rothbard’s big economics book); and Anarchy, State, and Utopia (Nozick). This was the triangle at the center of the political philosophy libertarianism in the ’70’s and early ’80’s (and perhaps to this day). Within that triangle were those of us who subscribed to Rand’s/Nozick’s conception of the propriety of government and those, such as Rothbard, who would replace monopoly government with private competing agencies of law enforcement. The core was not core in Schwartz’ representation. His essay was a smear job, continuing the smears by Rand.

Glad to see the gloss from Brook that you have conveyed in the opening paragraph of #26.

2 Likes

Libertarian = Rothbardian. You ask why Schwartz didn’t say explicitly that he meant Rothbard when he wrote about libertarians. In paragraph three of the “Perversion of Liberty” essay: “Murray Rothbard, widely viewed as the father of the movement…” The context of the rest of the essay shows that Schwartz agrees with that view.

Alrightee, let’s get synchronized, my copy of The Voice of Reason has 353 pages, and Schwartz’s essay starts on page 311. On page 331: “[T]he essence of Libertarianism – “liberty” as a baseless assertion”. I suppose we ought to first translate that into genus/differentia form, but is that not his definition of libertarianism? Now that’s certainly not true of Rothbard, he wrote volumes on his view of the proper philosophical basis for liberty, but hopefully you’re already aware that Schwartz’s essay is an inept smear job. In practice it has meant guilt by association and has led to suffocating insularity among ARI affiliated Objectivists. Schwartz ultimately objects to any kind of “united front” for liberty as a political movement.

In the 70s and 80s, wasn’t the libertarian movement dominated by Rothbardians and anarchists?

How could one determine that? Nathaniel Branden, John Hospers, and David Nolan were representative figures all the way back to the early 70’s, and none of them were “Rothbardians” or anarchists.

Rothbard was a founder of both Cato and the LP, and weren’t most of the journals/magazines cited by Schwartz connected to Rothbard?

I’ll concede that most were, rather than trying to trace so many items, especially since associations have always been in flux. He cites the “Libertarian Party Radical Caucus” for example. That was Rothbard, after he broke with the majority of libertarians in the late seventies or early eighties. Then he split from them and they went kaput, I don’t know exactly when. What a headache. And no, Rothbard wasn’t a “founder” of the LP, that was above all David Nolan, though Rothbard became involved from quite early on, and was in and out too many times to bother keeping track of.

And, who were the non-Rothbardian or non-anarchists cited by Schwartz? I’m looking at the footnotes now and no names stand out. Reason is cited, but the article is by Rothbard.

When he quotes the Libertarian party platform, what does that count as? And how about the last couple quotes, from the “humanist” and then the religious libertarian?

Why attribute to Peikoff (or ARI) a contradiction when there’s a better supported alternative interpretation of what’s happening? And an interpretation that’s the one the current president of ARI has endorsed, at that!

That Yaron Brook has come out with this interpretation is news to me, and it’s just the kind of thing I was prompting for in my video. Now we need the whole shebang in an official public form, so people know where things stand. Based on what you’ve written I’m quite leery of what I’m hearing. Hopefully they’ll spell out what “disrespect” for Ayn Rand means. May one criticize David Harriman’s interpretation of Galileo’s thought process re the concept of inertia, so long as it’s done behind closed doors? Or how about what I’ve seen David Boaz, Cato’s current Executive Vice President, do? He gives an answer to Ayn Rand’s refusing to accept the label “libertarian” by imitating this classic scene from What Ever Happened to Baby Jane?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TTtpDwrKaxo

“But you are one, Ayn, you are”. It’s really funny when he does it, he can get the accent perfect.

Or is it just that these people won’t be welcome anymore (this was filmed in the atrium of Cato’s DC headquarters):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1d0wkKSeCeo

I don’t know about you, but I’m getting braced for the announcement that they’re changing the name of the Friedrich Hayek Auditorium to the Leonard Peikoff Auditorium.

Anyone interested in my replies to #'s 24 and 25 can read them here:

http://www.objectivi…51

Here’s my kerfuffle-inducing video again, since we’re on a new page in the thread:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4jQAiCCEA5A

Rothbard was not a founder of Cato or of the Libertarian Party.

Actually Rothbard was a co-founder of Cato, and credited himself with coming up with the name. But he wasn’t involved for long, he fell out with Crane pretty early on. There was some discussion of why he never was issued his shares while the whole conflict between Koch and Crane was raging.

Thanks for the correction, Ninth.

I really wish you wouldn’t post so many goofy visuals. True, I seldom click on them. They are nevertheless distracting from the seriousness in text, yours and others’ in a thread.

. . .

Glad to see the gloss from Brook that you have conveyed in the opening paragraph of #26.

Atlas, I wanted to add to that last sentence that the important thing, in my view, is that old errors are no longer repeated. I never care whether someone acknowledges their past errors in public. That kind of concern is not mine.

Anyone interested in my replies to #'s 24 and 25 can read them here:

http://www.objectivi…51

Here’s my kerfuffle-inducing video again, since we’re on a new page in the thread:

I disagree with everything you said on Objectivist Living in response to me. And when you start talking like you want to have a fist-fight, I’m not a chicken for telling you to calm down.

When I made my initial post it was in response to someone who responded to you, I had barely read anything you said. I watched the video you posted, I read a few comments back and forth, and I pointed out something I dislike even more than a bad video vaguely insulting Peikoff. Your defensiveness is not proof of me ‘trying to pick a fight’.

You’ve come to a lot of brash conclusions because of a general statement I’ve made, falsely attributed me with being passive-aggressive, then continued to dodge and weave around anything I say. Also you demand that I go to an entirely different forum to even address you, because of supposedly deleted comments. Can’t say there’s much reason for me to keep this going.

I really wish you wouldn’t post so many goofy visuals. True, I seldom click on them. They are nevertheless distracting from the seriousness in text, yours and others’ in a thread.

You know its funny, I was just thinking earlier about telling you to add some humor to your posts. Try and jazz it up! Think more Gershwin Rhapsody, and less Bach Chorale. But I decided I like you fine just the way you are.

BTW, I’m at a loss as to what you’re referring to specifically on this thread. Maybe it’s the Bette Davis/Joan Crawford thing? I should have specified where in the video I meant, it’s at 1:40. It’s a pretty famous scene, so I just assumed people would be familiar with it. And I’m not making this up, I’ve seen David Boaz quote it re Ayn Rand and libertarianism. And it got a good laugh.

Also you demand that I go to an entirely different forum to even address you, because of supposedly deleted comments.

Not supposedly deleted, actually deleted, earlier today. So if you want to have a flame war, let’s go where we can both say what we want and let the OO moderators take a siesta.

Can’t say there’s much reason for me to keep this going.

Indeed, go waddle back to your coop, and in the future kindly restrict your egg laying to the appropriate time and place.

You know its funny, I was just thinking earlier about telling you to add some humor to your posts. Try and jazz it up! Think more Gershwin Rhapsody, and less Bach Chorale. But I decided I like you fine just the way you are.

BTW, I’m at a loss as to what you’re referring to specifically on this thread. Maybe it’s the Bette Davis/Joan Crawford thing? I should have specified where in the video I meant, it’s at 1:40. It’s a pretty famous scene, so I just assumed people would be familiar with it. And I’m not making this up, I’ve seen David Boaz quote it re Ayn Rand and libertarianism. And it got a good laugh.

Not supposedly deleted, actually deleted, earlier today. So if you want to have a flame war, let’s go where we can both say what we want and let the OO moderators take a siesta.

Indeed, go waddle back to your coop, and in the future kindly restrict your egg laying to the appropriate time and place.

I don’t want a flame war. I want to know if you think Peikoff is a dogmatist and if you spend time bashing him.

. . .

Maybe it’s the Bette Davis/Joan Crawford thing? . . .

Precisely. I see that sort of image and don’t bother to click on it. Now you confirm I was right not click on it. The entry of the image and the expectation of what is under it is distracting enough and is an undermining of sober thought. And look what you had right under it. I did click on that one. It was serious, and it was pertinent to your subculture concerns over changes at Cato.

But the other—the continual “good laugh” and ridicule of Rand and of Peikoff—that is bizarre. This audience is not a joke. Life is not a joke.


[Related](http://www.objectivistliving.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=8121&#entry98676)

> In _Zarathustra_ laughter is often emblematic of Nietzsche’s campaign against “the spirit of gravity” (Z I “On Reading and Writing;” IV “On the Higher Man” 16, 18, 20; “The Awakening” 1). There is some of the laughter against the spirit of gravity in the laughs of Roark. However, in laughter against the spirit of gravity, Nietzsche includes laughing at oneself and indeed at anything serious (Z IV “On the Higher Man” 15; “The Awakening” 1; GS 1, 382; BGE 294). This is something Rand speaks against in _Fountainhead_.
> 
> Roark seldom laughs (ET IV 253). He laughs as the face of an associate reveals a dawning comprehension of something in Roark’s motives (PK XV 202). He laughs over the prospect, when he has to close his architectural practice, that his enemies will gloat over him being reduced to tradesman work (PK XV 207). He laughs soundlessly at turns in his first bedding of Dominique (ET II 225, 230). He laughs soundlessly upon learning, from Joel Sutton, that Dominique is the one who has persuaded Sutton to decline Roark as his architect and that Dominique told Sutton to tell Roark she was the one (ET VII 288). He laughs softly when Keating finally comprehends that to be able to say “I built Cortlandt” is a gift possible only from oneself and is worth more than any money, fame, and honor that one might receive from others on account of the accomplishment. That soft laughter “was the happiest sound Keating had ever heard” (HR VIII 630).
> 
> Robert Mayhew observes that right after Roark’s laughter at the opening of the novel, there enters something arresting of attention and laughter. “He did not laugh as his eyes stopped in the awareness of the earth around him. . . . / He looked at the granite. To be cut, he thought, and made into walls. He looked at a tree. To be split and made into rafters” (PK I 9–10; Mayhew 2007b, 210). When it comes to his work, his life-meaning, and his essential person, Roark does not laugh.
> 
> Rand gives to villain Ellsworth Toohey the idea that an ability to laugh at oneself, and at anything one holds to be important, is a good thing (ET III 242, 246–47; IV 251, 257; IX 326; XIII 385). Shortly before Roark’s soliloquy in the courtroom for the Cortlandt destruction, Rand gives Toohey a soliloquy, which includes the following: “‘Kill by laughter. Laughter is an instrument of human joy. Learn to use it as a weapon of destruction. Turn it into a sneer. It’s simple. Tell them to laugh at everything. Tell them that a sense of humor is an unlimited virtue. Don’t let anything remain sacred in a man’s soul—and his soul won’t be sacred to him. Kill reverence and you’ve killed the hero in man. One doesn’t reverence with a giggle’” (HR IX 636).
> 
> Rand was not the first to note that laughter can be used to kill. Nietzsche has the ugliest human (he who had been the object of pity for his ugliness and who had taken revenge for it by murdering God, who had super-pitied him) say to Zarathustra “‘But I know one thing—it was from you yourself that I once learned, oh Zarathustra: whoever wants to kill most thoroughly _laughs_. / “One kills not by wrath, but by laughter”—this you once spoke’” (Z IV “The Ass Festival” 1). But Nietzsche’s Zarathustra, unlike Toohey, has not the slightest intent to kill, by laughter or otherwise, the truly sacred in men’s souls, the hero in man. It is an earlier writer who observes the thoroughly vicious use of laughter we find admitted in Toohey’s soliloquy.
> 
> In _The Man Who Laughs_ (1869), Hugo’s Gwynplaine takes his stand for humanity in a speech in the House of Lords, and these his most serious, most sacred words are laughed into dust. When the mountebank Gwynplaine had been in shows, performing as a freak, laughter had applauded him; but here, on solemn matters of real life, elevated to Lord and addressing his peers, “here it exterminated him. The effort to ridicule is to kill. Men’s laughter sometimes exerts all its power to murder” (VII 610–11).
1 Like

But the other—the continual “good laugh” and ridicule of Rand and of Peikoff—that is bizarre. This audience is not a joke. Life is not a joke.

The hatred of the good for being the good is not a monopoly of traditional ideologies. There are plenty of so-called Objectivists or supposed sympathizers with Ayn Rand’s ideas who enjoy plenty of sneering at Ayn Rand and her philosophy, especially if they can get away with doing it by sneering at Peikoff.

Given my profile image it may go without saying, but I liked your quote, especially the part from The Man Who Laughs.

The entry of the image and the expectation of what is under it is distracting enough and is an undermining of sober thought.

I included that to illustrate the example I was making. Does this “disrespect” business mean no more humor on the subject of Rand, such as when a speaker is explaining his disagreement with her on something? It’s a serious question.

I’m not going to deny that I generally use humor much more than you do, and this may be a generational thing, or more likely, a difference in basic temperament. Sanguine vs. melancholic, or even Cynic/Epicurean vs. Stoic. But it’s not relevant in this case. Imagine these are lines from a speech at Cato, you tell me if it’s “disrespectful”:

“Ayn Rand used to deny that she was a libertarian. Well, like Bette Davis said in Whatever Happened to Baby Jane, ‘but you are, Ayn, you are’”.

Cast said speaker out on ear, and set dogs on?

Catching up on the thread…

Stephen and Ninth,

I think your knowledge of libertarian history is deficient.

The first sentence of the wikipedia article on Cato: “The Cato Institute is an American libertarian think tank headquartered in Washington, D.C. Founded as the Charles Koch Foundation in 1974 by Murray Rothbard, Ed Crane and Charles Koch.”

The first paragraph from the History of the Libertarian Party article: “The Libertarian Party was formed in Colorado Springs in the home of David Nolan on December 11, 1971, after several months of debate among members of the Committee to Form a Libertarian Party, founded July 17. […] This group included John Hospers, Edward Crane, Manuel Klausner, Murray Rothbard, Roy Childs, Theodora (Tonie) Nathan, and Jim Dean.” I recognize two anarchist names.

If one is worried about sanctioning Rothbard (or other anarchists), one would rightly be wary of groups he helped found.

Ninth,

“In practice [schwartz’s article] has meant guilt by association and has led to suffocating insularity among ARI affiliated Objectivists.”

ARI affiliated intellectuals have been working in various capacities with non-anarchist ‘libertarian’ intellectuals (mostly economists and policy people) for at least the last 15 years. So I don’t know what you’re talking about.

Rothbard and the LP. See previous post. He was a member of the founding committee, along with anarchist Roy Childs. Rothbard was the dominant figure in 70s and 80s libertarianism.

Respect for Rand. I take it that respect for Rand means respect for Rand. What’s Dave Harriman have to do with anything?

Stephen,

You mention Nozick and Hospers. Part of the Peikoff/Schwartz argument is that there is no valid concept the CCD of which is “amount of government”. Do you agree with that, and classify Nozick’s, Hospers’, and Rothbard’s political philosophies together on some other grounds?