Libertarian = Rothbardian. You ask why Schwartz didn’t say explicitly that he meant Rothbard when he wrote about libertarians. In paragraph three of the “Perversion of Liberty” essay: “Murray Rothbard, widely viewed as the father of the movement…” The context of the rest of the essay shows that Schwartz agrees with that view.
Alrightee, let’s get synchronized, my copy of The Voice of Reason has 353 pages, and Schwartz’s essay starts on page 311. On page 331: “[T]he essence of Libertarianism – “liberty” as a baseless assertion”. I suppose we ought to first translate that into genus/differentia form, but is that not his definition of libertarianism? Now that’s certainly not true of Rothbard, he wrote volumes on his view of the proper philosophical basis for liberty, but hopefully you’re already aware that Schwartz’s essay is an inept smear job. In practice it has meant guilt by association and has led to suffocating insularity among ARI affiliated Objectivists. Schwartz ultimately objects to any kind of “united front” for liberty as a political movement.
In the 70s and 80s, wasn’t the libertarian movement dominated by Rothbardians and anarchists?
How could one determine that? Nathaniel Branden, John Hospers, and David Nolan were representative figures all the way back to the early 70’s, and none of them were “Rothbardians” or anarchists.
Rothbard was a founder of both Cato and the LP, and weren’t most of the journals/magazines cited by Schwartz connected to Rothbard?
I’ll concede that most were, rather than trying to trace so many items, especially since associations have always been in flux. He cites the “Libertarian Party Radical Caucus” for example. That was Rothbard, after he broke with the majority of libertarians in the late seventies or early eighties. Then he split from them and they went kaput, I don’t know exactly when. What a headache. And no, Rothbard wasn’t a “founder” of the LP, that was above all David Nolan, though Rothbard became involved from quite early on, and was in and out too many times to bother keeping track of.
And, who were the non-Rothbardian or non-anarchists cited by Schwartz? I’m looking at the footnotes now and no names stand out. Reason is cited, but the article is by Rothbard.
When he quotes the Libertarian party platform, what does that count as? And how about the last couple quotes, from the “humanist” and then the religious libertarian?
Why attribute to Peikoff (or ARI) a contradiction when there’s a better supported alternative interpretation of what’s happening? And an interpretation that’s the one the current president of ARI has endorsed, at that!
That Yaron Brook has come out with this interpretation is news to me, and it’s just the kind of thing I was prompting for in my video. Now we need the whole shebang in an official public form, so people know where things stand. Based on what you’ve written I’m quite leery of what I’m hearing. Hopefully they’ll spell out what “disrespect” for Ayn Rand means. May one criticize David Harriman’s interpretation of Galileo’s thought process re the concept of inertia, so long as it’s done behind closed doors? Or how about what I’ve seen David Boaz, Cato’s current Executive Vice President, do? He gives an answer to Ayn Rand’s refusing to accept the label “libertarian” by imitating this classic scene from What Ever Happened to Baby Jane?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TTtpDwrKaxo
“But you are one, Ayn, you are”. It’s really funny when he does it, he can get the accent perfect.
Or is it just that these people won’t be welcome anymore (this was filmed in the atrium of Cato’s DC headquarters):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1d0wkKSeCeo
I don’t know about you, but I’m getting braced for the announcement that they’re changing the name of the Friedrich Hayek Auditorium to the Leonard Peikoff Auditorium.