John A. Allison takes over as CEO of the Cato Institute

Atlas,

Peter Schwartz’ point that “amount of government” would not be a principle giving genuine unity to a political philosophy is correct. When “limited government” libertarians use that adjective to distinguish themselves from individualist anarchist libertarians, they are talking about limited proper functions of government. Defending the country could at times require a whole lot of government, but the number of proper functions of government would still be limited to its constant few. That is what was in the books on this political philosophy in the ’70’s written by Robert Nozick, by Tibor Machan, and by John Hospers. What those proper functions were coincided with Rand’s conclusion in the matter.

The preeminent libertarian political philosopher of that decade was Robert Nozick. His book Anarchy, State, and Utopia towered above all others in libertarian philosophy, in content and in public recognition. That is still so today. I know, I know, some folks attached of the political philosophy of Murray Rothbard may not like to admit that; some also do not like to admit the importance of Ayn Rand’s writings in political philosophy to the existence of the modern libertarian movement. Nozick’s book is studied in classrooms today, and it will be studied a hundred years from now. It is a modern classic of political philosophy.

In the ’70’s the other writings influential with libertarians were free market economics books, Rand’s literature and essays, Tibor Machan’s Human Rights and Human Liberties, and John Hosper’s Libertarianism: An Idea Whose Time Has Come. On the anarchist branch of libertarianism, there was Murray Rothbard’s For a New Liberty and David Friedman’s The Machinery of Freedom. Rothbard’s The Ethics of Liberty issued in ’82. Those are the books one would need to discuss in order to genuinely discuss libertarian political philosophy of the ’70’s and early ’80’s. The Schwartz criticism you mentioned might have some traction in connection with David Friedman’s approach, but to his alone. He is a utilitarian and is concerned to maximize liberty with an eye to utility, as I recall. All the others come from the perspective that individual rights is a valid moral concept and that the sole proper function of government would be to protect them. Rothbard and his followers would argue further that there is no proper function of government because such an institution necessarily violates individual rights.

A few years after leaving the Libertarian Party in ’84, I stopped studying and writing about political philosophy. I returned to what I had studied in college (late ’60’s), which was metaphysics and epistemology. In 1990 I created the journal Objectivity * (subscription, hardcopy) from which political and social philosophy more generally was excluded. Finally there was a place to focus in print on the other areas of philosophy, at a level of interest for both academics and independent scholars. There was also much history of philosophy and science education in the journal. It was not limited to Objectivist contributors and readers. Anyone friendly toward rationality, objectivity, and modern science (standard, no reactionary or basement science) was at home in that clean calm place, made so in part by the exclusion of political philosophy and cultural commentary.

My statements about libertarianism and about the LP in those days are from personal memory, not from reading about those days. My impression that Rothbard was not in attendance at the founding national convention of LP was from my memory of the report at the time by an acquaintance who had attended. My memory of such a detail could easily be mistaken. I was a delegate from Illinois to the LP national convention in New York in 1976. I would say most delegates were in the limited government side the divide. Rothbard, Raico, and Childs were delegates and were active on the floor in attempting to put anarchist planks into the party platform. I remember one of their attempts, concerning national defense, failed after Nozick got up, identified the sneaky move that was afoot and the unacceptability of its ultimate implication. There was a big struggle going on at that convention. Anarchism seemed concentrated in the New York delegation. There was only one anarchist in our Illinois delegation as I recall.

Objectivist political philosophy is a type of libertarianism, which is the view that the only proper function of government, if any, is to protect individual liberty. That is the paramount political value. In Rand’s political philosophy, the proper purpose of government is to protect individual rights, and the purpose of individual rights is to protect the free exercise of the individual mind in the conduct and service of his or her life in a social context. That is a type of individual liberty. Well, Atlas, I better close. One more memory. Some generous people had put some money into that New York convention. There was a brief sound and light show that had been created for the occasion. The music was a song I had not known till then. It was “Won’t Get Fooled Again” by The Who. On a screen were flashed various images, but I only remember some of the photos of faces of intellectuals important in the political movement and political philosophy. Rand’s face flashed on the screen, and he crowd went wild.

1 Like

“In practice [schwartz’s article] has meant guilt by association and has led to suffocating insularity among ARI affiliated Objectivists.”

ARI affiliated intellectuals have been working in various capacities with non-anarchist ‘libertarian’ intellectuals (mostly economists and policy people) for at least the last 15 years. So I don’t know what you’re talking about.

Names please.

Rothbard and the LP. See previous post. He was a member of the founding committee, along with anarchist Roy Childs. Rothbard was the dominant figure in 70s and 80s libertarianism.

Really? This is the first time I’ve heard that Rothbard was actually present at the founding. It doesn’t jibe well with a lot of other things I’ve read. Oh great, there’s no citation for it in the Wiki article. See, the ubiquitous “citation needed”? Either way, I wrote:

And no, Rothbard wasn’t a “founder” of the LP, that was above all David Nolan, though Rothbard became involved from quite early on, and was in and out too many times to bother keeping track of.

Now I’d like you to explain something, if you can. Since Rothbard was so “dominant”, how many Libertarian presidential candidates have been “Rothbardians”? There ought to be a good percentage, right? How many can you name?

Respect for Rand. I take it that respect for Rand means respect for Rand. What’s Dave Harriman have to do with anything?

I bring up David Harriman to allude to the notorious John McCaskey episode. Is that the kind of culture Cato is going to have? I sincerely doubt it, I was giving an extreme example by way of framing the issue: will “respect” for Ayn Rand really mean bowing and scraping to one of Peikoff’s flunkies? Even within ARI that didn’t go over well, so, no way, obviously. Then I moved on to two other examples, material closer to what we’re likely going to be dealing with. Do you have anything to say about those?

But the other—the continual “good laugh” and ridicule of Rand and of Peikoff—that is bizarre. This audience is not a joke. Life is not a joke.

I suspect that you misjudge the “good laugh” as “bizarre” because you misinterpret it as being ridicule of Rand and Peikoff rather than more precisely what it is, which is ridicule of mistaken ideas and bad behavior by otherwise good people.

And “life is not a joke”? What IS life to you, Stephen? Grim seriousness, uptight reverence for certain heroes, and flashes of anger directed at those who question some of the behavior of your heroes?

The hatred of the good for being the good is not a monopoly of traditional ideologies. There are plenty of so-called Objectivists or supposed sympathizers with Ayn Rand’s ideas who enjoy plenty of sneering at Ayn Rand and her philosophy, especially if they can get away with doing it by sneering at Peikoff.

So, is this how it works: Leonard Peikoff is by definition “the good,” and therefore laughter at him or anything he has ever done is “hatred of the good for being good”? How far does that extend? Could Peikoff go out and randomly intiate force against someone, and if Ninth ridiculed him for doing so, he’d be expressing “hatred of the good for being good” in your eyes? And, to you, someone’s ridiculing Peikoff for initiating force would be an act of “sneering at Ayn Rand and her philosophy” rather than an act of following Ayn Rand’s philosophy?!

J

Really? This is the first time I’ve heard that Rothbard was actually present at the founding. It doesn’t jibe well with a lot of other things I’ve read. Oh great, there’s no citation for it in the Wiki article. See, the ubiquitous “citation needed”?

This ought to settle it:

http://mises.org/jou…973/1973_04.pdf

Ever since the national Libertarian Party and its state affiliates had been founded a year ago, the editor of the Lib. Forum, while tempted, had held aloof. But to this old political warhorse, the firebell of a Convention proved too much to resist. As the time for the Convention drew near. I made my decision, propitiated the Spirit of Robert LeFevre and took the plunge: I joined the Party.

Murray Rothbard,

The Libertarian Forum

, April 1973

Which are you going to trust, an unsourced Wikipedia entry, or the horse’s mouth? According to him, he joined in time for a convention that was held in NY in late March 1973, well after the conclusion of the Hospers campaign, and over a year after the founding.

I think your knowledge of libertarian history is deficient.

Whose knowledge of libertarian history is deficient, again? Try sharpening up your research skills before nitpicking with people who’ve been involved in this for decades.

I‘m not seeing how this dovetailed into hatred of the good for being the good, laughter as self inflicted wound, or some celebrity grudge match. I thought it was about Peikoff and the traditionally well documented Objectivist stance on Libertarianism versus the contradiction implicit in today’s willingness to deal with libertarian forums. As someone who has been perplexed at the blanket packaging dealing of all libertarians as anarchist I’m glad to see this trend but confused as to the silent change of course.

I suspect that you misjudge the “good laugh” as “bizarre” because you misinterpret it as being ridicule of Rand and Peikoff rather than more precisely what it is, which is ridicule of mistaken ideas and bad behavior by otherwise good people.

And “life is not a joke”? What IS life to you, Stephen? Grim seriousness, uptight reverence for certain heroes, and flashes of anger directed at those who question some of the behavior of your heroes?

So, is this how it works: Leonard Peikoff is by definition “the good,” and therefore laughter at him or anything he has ever done is “hatred of the good for being good”? How far does that extend? Could Peikoff go out and randomly intiate force against someone, and if Ninth ridiculed him for doing so, he’d be expressing “hatred of the good for being good” in your eyes? And, to you, someone’s ridiculing Peikoff for initiating force would be an act of “sneering at Ayn Rand and her philosophy” rather than an act of following Ayn Rand’s philosophy?!

J

Get more information on everyone involved. Unless you already have, then to hell with you.

Get more information on everyone involved. Unless you already have, then to hell with you.

Okay, I’ll take that as a very emotional “no” to my question.

So, I then have to assume that by claiming that someone is exhibiting “hatred of the good for being the good,” you must mean that asking questions about a person’s apparent double standards and laughing about his hypocrisy – his exempting himself from following the same rules by which he fiercely condemns others – is an example of “hatred of the good,” and, therefore, we must logically conclude that you believe that having double standards and displaying hypocrisy is “good.”

J

All right, gentlemen, please tone down the emotional rhetoric. Let’s all try to remember that civility helps others understand what we are actually trying to say; incivility encourages the amygdala to conjure up illusory strawmen.

All right, gentlemen, please tone down the emotional rhetoric. Let’s all try to remember that civility helps others understand what we are actually trying to say; incivility encourages the amygdala to conjure up illusory strawmen.

Sounds good to me. Everything was going fine until #19, which was totally inappropriate yet earned a “like” from a moderator. I will continue to reply in kind to that sort of thing, and when my posts get deleted, there are other places where they’ll be reproduced. I think the moderators need to be more objective, and not let the fact that they enjoyed an inappropriate shot aimed at someone they don’t like keep them from recognizing that it was inappropriate, and wouldn’t be allowed if it were aimed at them.

Here’s a really good video that seems relevant here. Warning to Stephen, it mixes serious points with some goofy visuals!

1 Like

Sounds good to me.

Good. For the record, I have no qualms with invitations to flame wars at other forums. It helps us keep the threads here on-point. Speaking of which, how about that Cato institute?

Speaking of which, how about that Cato institute?

What about it? Far as I know Allison hasn’t actually taken over yet. I’m inclined to doubt that he’s imbibed enough ARI kool-aid (and I use this metaphor in the Ken Kesey, not the Jim Jones sense) to make a real mess of things. One member of the Cato board, Frank Bond, is also a TAS trustee, FWIW. I’m still going with what I said in my first post on this thread.

http://forum.objecti…55

I highly doubt this will put Cato under ARI control; I can’t imagine anyone here expects that. The prospect of Allison at the helm raises the interesting (and likely, in my opinion) prospect of a better relationship between the organizations - possible cooperation, even.

I highly doubt this will put Cato under ARI control; I can’t imagine anyone here expects that. The prospect of Allison at the helm raises the interesting (and likely, in my opinion) prospect of a better relationship between the organizations - possible cooperation, even.

Sure, TAS has done quite a few events with Cato, I’ve even attended, so Cato has never had a problem with hosting, or co-hosting Rand themed events. They’ll probably do those kinds of things with ARI now, and no longer TAS, though with the movie coming out in a couple months who knows? I haven’t read Gary Weiss’s book Ayn Rand Nation, but I’ve read that in it he reports on the meeting between John Aglialoro, John Allison, Yaron Brook, and David Kelley, a couple-three years ago. He says it that it amounted to a bait and switch, planned as a discussion about cooperation, but was really about Allison trying (and failing) to woo Aglialoro away from TAS. Is he one to hold a grudge? Would it be right for the libertarian movement? Is he not, now, responsible for the health of the libertarian movement, to a greater extent than any other individual?

For anyone who hasn’t seen it yet, here’s my über-controversial video making debut. Watch it, then join in on all the speculation about my psychology. I’ve got quotes from Rand’s The Psychology of Psycologizing all ready to go to add that extra punch to my rebuttals.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4jQAiCCEA5A

It’s too bad that this devolved into a flame war. I was actually interested in whether people think Allison’s appointment at Cato will cause problems within ARI (and the Oist community as a whole), or whether they think he’ll make some much needed improvements over at Cato and transition the place towards greater acceptance of and appreciation for Ayn Rand’s philosophy. Personally, I’m concerned that this is a bad move for Objectivism as it will confuse the public as to the differences between libertarians and Oist (focusing on end-game policy and not on philosophical principles). I’m happy to be proven wrong, and I’d love to know what others think. Can’t we all just get along?

Personally, I’m concerned that this is a bad move for Objectivism as it will confuse the public as to the differences between libertarians and Oist (focusing on end-game policy and not on philosophical principles). I’m happy to be proven wrong, and I’d love to know what others think. Can’t we all just get along?

To me, it sounds as if you are confused about the differences between libertarians and Oists (and their similarities). Most libertarians I’ve met are very focused on philosphical principles, and often on a much deeper level than the average young Objectivist who has accepted others’ mischaracterizations of libertarians without investigating the matter for him or herself. May I politely suggest that you familiarize yourself with the depth and breadth of the history of libertarian philosophical thought before buying into the caricature that they are all of one collective mind and are “hippies of the right”?

J

he’ll make some much needed improvements over at Cato and transition the place towards greater acceptance of and appreciation for Ayn Rand’s philosophy.

Cato doesn’t need transitioning toward greater acceptance or appreciation of Ayn Rand. They’ve partnered with the Atlas Society repeatedly. Swapping out TAS for ARI is hardly a change in that respect. Or is it? Jennifer Burns and Anne Heller both appeared at Cato, will “independent” writers like them still be welcome? The reviews of their books by ARI people were hostile, to put it mildly, and I haven’t heard of either appearing at ARI affiliated events. I’m sure it’s not that they refused invitations, with the opportunity to sell more books.

Jonathan,

I didn’t mean to imply that libertarians as a group are disinterested or ignorant of philosophical principles. But there are real differences between many who label themselves libertarian and those associated with Objectivism. And there are some pretty serious philosophical and policy-oriented differences between ARI and Cato. What interests me at the moment (at least in this thread) is how/if the larger of those differences will be reconciled under Mr. Allison’s leadership. The history of libertarian philosophical thought does have great depth, but it’s also incredibly wide (from natural rights, consequentialism, anarchism, contractarianism, and on and on). But some of those supposed philosophical underpinnings of liberty contradict one another, or at the very least do not square with an Objectivist framework. Acknowledging critiques leveled against libertarianism by Dr. Brook, Dr. Peikoff, Mr. Schwartz, Diana Hsieh, etc., how as Objectivists should we view Mr. Allison’s new gig as head of a libertarian organization?

Acknowledging critiques leveled against libertarianism by Dr. Brook, Dr. Peikoff, Mr. Schwartz, Diana Hsieh, etc., how as Objectivists should we view Mr. Allison’s new gig as head of a libertarian organization?

I would hope that Allison would encourage open criticism and debate of any and all ideas, and not take a defensive, cloistered approach in which dialogue is stifled or silenced. Cato currently has a certain degree of respect. If a mindset of banishing criticism of certain people or ideas is established there (including constructive criticism a la the McCaskey ordeal), Cato will very quickly damage its reputation and lose all respect. Should libertarians address Objectivists’ critiques of libertarainism? Absolutely. And then the same Objectivists should address the libertarains’ responses, as well as their criticisms of Objectivism.

J

Should libertarians address Objectivists’ critiques of libertarainism? Absolutely. And then the same Objectivists should address the libertarains’ responses, as well as their criticisms of Objectivism.

It’s not so well known that back when Peter Schwartz’s Libertarianism essay came out, Walter Block challenged him to a public debate. What do you think was the reply?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A9peZ5WOtL0

The second half of this has David Boaz talking about John Allison coming on board at Cato. Sounds like he doesn’t know what’s coming, and seems justifiably hopeful.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ymrox\_2S\_OI