As a separate issue, I have observed on numerous occasions, aspiring Objectivists conflating “Objective” with “Universal”.
This is a BIG mistake.
As a separate issue, I have observed on numerous occasions, aspiring Objectivists conflating “Objective” with “Universal”.
This is a BIG mistake.
On 10/11/2019 at 8:31 AM, whYNOT said:
The error could be made by a failure to discriminate the abstractions “man’s life” and “standard” and “value” - from - one’s individual, concrete life, while connecting them by a conceptual chain. After all, well-assumed to be moral lore in Objectivism is that one’s life is one’s highest and supreme value–so does this not conveniently converge with one’s own life equally being one’s “standard of value”??
Maybe the dispute stems from this issue of failing to discriminate the abstraction from the concrete. Do you accept that there are universal standards of value and particular standards of value? Consider what Rand said about ultimate values.
Quote
An ultimate value is that final goal or end to which all lesser goals are the means—and it sets the standard by which all lesser goals are evaluated. An organism’s life is its standard of value: that which furthers its life is the good, that which threatens it is the evil.
On one hand, she talks about “man’s life” being “the standard of value.” And, on the other hand, she says that “an organism’s life is its standard of value.” You seem to think that the latter, particular formulation pertains only to plants or unconscious organisms. But that isn’t what Rand meant.
Quote
The maintenance of life and the pursuit of happiness are not two separate issues. To hold one’s own life as one’s ultimate value, and one’s own happiness as one’s highest purpose are two aspects of the same achievement. Existentially, the activity of pursuing rational goals is the activity of maintaining one’s life; psychologically, its result, reward and concomitant is an emotional state of happiness.
Because man is a living organism, his own life is his ultimate value, his particular standard of value. But he’s also a conceptual organism, and so he’s capable of also having an abstract standard of value, which takes into account his knowledge of man in general. He can therefore use both to evaluate his goals and actions. If he does something which makes him sick, he can evaluate that as bad based on his particular life, his sensation of pain. And if he’s considering two possible goals or choices for action, he can evaluate them based on his abstract moral standards. Both standards are necessary and reinforcing, but without his particular life he would have no abstract standard. His own life is his primary standard, but it’s not the universal standard, since universals are abstractions.
4 hours ago, MisterSwig said:
Maybe the dispute stems from this issue of failing to discriminate the abstraction from the concrete. Do you accept that there are universal standards of value and particular standards of value? Consider what Rand said about ultimate values.
On one hand, she talks about “man’s life” being “the standard of value.” And, on the other hand, she says that “an organism’s life is its standard of value.” You seem to think that the latter, particular formulation pertains only to plants or unconscious organisms. But that isn’t what Rand meant.
Because man is a living organism, his own life is his ultimate value, his particular standard of value. But he’s also a conceptual organism, and so he’s capable of also having an abstract standard of value, which takes into account his knowledge of man in general. He can therefore use both to evaluate his goals and actions. If he does something which makes him sick, he can evaluate that as bad based on his particular life, his sensation of pain. And if he’s considering two possible goals or choices for action, he can evaluate them based on his abstract moral standards. Both standards are necessary and reinforcing, but without his particular life he would have no abstract standard. His own life is his primary standard, but it’s not the universal standard, since universals are abstractions.
But that IS “what Rand meant”. I’ve been into that, with some extracted quotes. An organism has a standard of value entirely based on its single existence (or death). Good- it flourishes; bad - it dies. Organic/biological life is self-generated, goal-directed action - without ‘purposiveness’. Men’s lives need purposeful, goal-directed action. Men cannot be judged in the binary terms of life-death, they have to do more than merely exist as organisms - by a standard that’s fitting to man’s nature (consciousness) and to existence: “man’s life”.
“…[to] choose his actions, values and goals by the standard of that which is proper to man”.
(On a personal note, I was one of those who were thrown initially by Rand’s - apparent - ambiguity in her preamble, relating first to an “organism’s” life (its own standard of value) and the individual’s life (NOT his own standard of value) It is easy to conflate them).
The Objectivist Ethics:
Only a living entity can have goals or can originate them. And it is only a living organism that has the capacity for self-generated, goal-directed action. On the physical level, the functions of all living organisms, from the simplest to the most complex—from the nutritive function in the single cell of an amoeba to the blood circulation in the body of a man—are actions generated by the organism itself and directed to a single goal: the maintenance of the organism’s life.
An organism’s life depends on two factors: the material or fuel which it needs from the outside, from its physical background, and the action of its own body, the action of using that fuel properly. What standard determines what is proper in this context? The standard is the organism’s life, or: that which is required for the organism’s survival.
“The Objectivist Ethics,”
The Virtue of Selfishness, 16
[Note - “on the physical level”.]
¶
When applied to physical phenomena, such as the automatic functions of an organism, the term “goal-directed” is not to be taken to mean “purposive” (a concept applicable only to the actions of a consciousness) and is not to imply the existence of any teleological principle operating in insentient nature. I use the term “goal-directed,” in this context, to designate the fact that the automatic functions of living organisms are actions whose nature is such that they result in the preservation of an organism’s life."
What do YOU mean, objectively speaking when you say “fitting to his nature and to existence”. Who judges and by what “standard” do you assess what is “fitting to his nature”?
Defining the proper “standard” as simply one that “fits his nature”, is either circular (the good is what is good) or subjective or both.
This is a distraction from the OP which tries to distinguish between standards based on “Man’s life” (whatever that is) and “Your life”.
On 10/14/2019 at 1:11 PM, StrictlyLogical said:
This is the double standard of logic and straw man in your thinking which you have not shown is true. Not at all.
How do you propose that a rational person with proper concept formation and mastery of abstractions and principles suddenly lose integrity ?
The logical implication you are making is that mere contemplation of any particular existent, automatically is accompanied by some kind of concrete bound psychosis which jettisons principles and concepts for momentary sensation, that contemplation also causing an amnesia surrounding the particular and its whole nature which one had previously grasped through integration and concept formation. This sort of assumption has not here been shown to have any basis.
Again, I ask: suppose that apple tree is (for whatever reason) my greatest joy and I want it to flourish. To that end, how would actions consistent with and defined by a standard of its flourishing, not be conducive to achieving that goal, the good, which IS its flourishing?
Please try not to evade here… let’s hammer it out.
One has no notion of what man/men can do, until one understands what he HAS - i.e., is capable of. That’s understanding the identity of consciousness. Which ~specific~qualities and virtues he needs to promote and maintain, in order to survive and live as man, are contingent on the understanding of existence, of facing reality.
'jettisons principles" and the rest is nonsensical.
On 10/14/2019 at 1:11 PM, StrictlyLogical said:
On 10/14/2019 at 2:27 AM, MisterSwig said:
No, I called your argument rationalistic.
No, without Rand’s evidence and reasoning, I probably couldn’t have worked out the principle. But I definitely couldn’t have worked it out without my personal experiences and observations which allow me to recognize the validity of her argument.
Again, you have it backwards. Values and virtues are not derived from an ethical principle. Your values precede any standard of values. You can’t have a standard of something if that something doesn’t first exist.
There is only conceptual integration between experience (etc.) and principles. Not rationalism, not empiricism. How many times must I endorse that?
I don’t care who one is, it will take any intelligent individual most of his life time to assess that *this* is a virtue - and works, in gaining my values… and that is a vice - immoral and impractical.
Yup, and then we validate the efficacy of our virtues, by their application and further experience.
So what’s your gripe? I have not set a dichotomy, I mentioned integration earlier here.
23 minutes ago, whYNOT said:
One has no notion of what man/men can do, until one understands what he HAS - i.e., is capable of. That’s understanding the identity of consciousness. Which ~specific~qualities and virtues he needs to promote and maintain, in order to survive and live as man, are contingent on the understanding of existence, of facing reality.
'jettisons principles" and the rest is nonsensical.
? When you are ready to stop evading, ready to talk and to think let me know.
15 minutes ago, StrictlyLogical said:
? When you are ready to stop evading, ready to talk and to think let me know.
I’ve no idea what you want.
Question: do you think (in Objectivism or outside of it) an individual’s standard of value is his own life? Yes/no.
1 hour ago, StrictlyLogical said:
“Man’s life” (whatever that is)
There’s the problem. Calls for a refresher reading of The Objectivist Ethics .
My wish is to discuss not simply to engage in didactic pronouncements and quotations absent any thought.
In response to my asking if you wish to talk and think… you ask me to stop thinking and essentially not engage in a real conversation.
I am asking if you are willing to discuss the hierarchy of knowledge and how that would apply to any rational application of a standard, and yes I think using the apple tree as an example will help clarify thinking on the subject… precisely because it is unpolluted by all the baggage associated with human social interaction.
Can we discuss this?
I was struck thinking about this, about how remarkable was Rand’s accomplishment in her ethics. She recognized, identified and placed --objective–value in man, mankind, the individual, in oneself - when all else has been a. intrinsic value and/or b. subjective value. Objective value: Of value to whom - and for what purpose? The alternatives in human valuing were and are, automatic value, revealed value, mystical value, emotional value,… all fake. No wonder ethical philosophers have not come to grips with Rand’s rational selfishness, the premises are hardly comparable with any they know. That one regards *objective* value in one’s own life and self (by an objective standard…) is too revolutionary: Of value? to one, and his purpose.
9 hours ago, whYNOT said:
So what’s your gripe? I have not set a dichotomy, I mentioned integration earlier here.
I think the title for this thread represents the dichotomy you’ve set here. I don’t see a clear attempt to integrate anything. Frankly, I find your replies to be unfocused, evasive, and poorly written. I’ve made a real effort to contribute something, because you’re investigating a very tough and fundamental question. But it doesn’t seem like you’re actually interested in criticism (“gripes”?!). It sounds like you want to rant. So I’ll leave you to it.
18 hours ago, MisterSwig said:
I think the title for this thread represents the dichotomy you’ve set here. I don’t see a clear attempt to integrate anything. Frankly, I find your replies to be unfocused, evasive, and poorly written. I’ve made a real effort to contribute something, because you’re investigating a very tough and fundamental question. But it doesn’t seem like you’re actually interested in criticism (“gripes”?!). It sounds like you want to rant. So I’ll leave you to it.
Man’s life (as the standard if value) - or one’s own?
That is not a dichotomy. One statement is true, one is false. It’s a metaphysical proposition: Pursuing empirical validation, as some appear to want, is barking up the wrong tree.
The explanations by Rand should suffice.
And if my style of communication doesn’t suit you, instead, argue with Rand’s formulation - but to reject the substance out of hand is your evasion, not mine.
One’s life, clearly, is not the *standard* of value. Even the definition of standard tells one that. One’s life as a “standard” to one’s own life is self-referencing, leaving nothing else to measure oneself by. End of standard. And - one’s acquired individual standards for gaining values and living (the virtues) follow from “man’s life”. The misinterpretation of this key principle, will eventually compromise the supreme value which rests in one’s own life: “The capacity to value and the source of value” – by THE standard of value, man’s life.
On 10/17/2019 at 12:47 AM, whYNOT said:
. The misinterpretation of this key principle, will eventually compromise the supreme value which rests in one’s own life:
The two must conflict: One’s life as being the ultimate value vs. One’s life as being the standard of value. They can’t coexist long in a consciousness nor in action. This self-contradiction, I think will play out for the individual to the detriment of his “ultimate value”, widening the gap, as contradictions do.
They could be phrased by the causal statements, A.“It is good, therefore I chose it”, or, B.“I chose it therefore it is good”.
The proper order: perception-identification-evaluation - could easily be turned around. A thing, a fact, an entity, person, or issue, all need to be assessed or judged - after knowing their identity. Follows then… is this “thing” good for my life, or not? Set against the persisting background of - “good” for “man’s life”?
I venture that “man’s life” (existence and consciousness) is the ethical standard of value precisely as reality is the “standard” of reason. What do I know and how do I know it? Inseparable from, What is “good” for my life and how do I gauge the “good”?
(Nature to be *enjoyed* must be obeyed…;))
Not to go so far as suggesting this (i.e. "Objectivist ethics holds man’s life as …"etc.) to be the … ‘ethical axiom’. But I’m considering the statement to be the ~corollary~ of the Objectivist axioms applied in ethics. Any thoughts welcomed.
“Man’s life is the standard of morality, but your own life is its purpose.”
Is the objective to set man’s life as the consideration for both or your own life in as the consideration for both? A code of values sets the code of morality. From the values that are eligible to be part of the code of morality, it is your own life to which you must set purpose.
Rand set order to her own mind before she asked others to consider the selective content she poured out onto paper.
9 minutes ago, dream_weaver said:
“Man’s life is the standard of morality, but your own life is its purpose.”
Is the objective to set man’s life as the consideration for both or your own life in as the consideration for both? A code of values sets the code of morality. From the values that are eligible to be part of the code of morality, it is your own life to which you must set purpose.
Rand set order to her own mind before she asked others to consider the selective content she poured out onto paper.
Right, setting the “order” is critical. “Man’s life” is a metaphysical abstract, one’s life is the solid, “concrete” purpose. Ie.: Which specific values? (Goals, etc.) The hierarchy needs to be observed conceptually and acted upon, personally in one’s real life.
What’s problematic, I clearly stated, is presuming on one’s own life “the standard of value”. In which case the hierarchy breaks down.
Anyone who prefers to think I made a dichotomy will have to re-read what I said.
1 hour ago, whYNOT said:
Right, setting the “order” is critical. “Man’s life” is a metaphysical abstract, one’s life is the solid, “concrete” purpose. Ie.: Which specific values? (Goals, etc.) The hierarchy needs to be observed conceptually and acted upon, personally in one’s real life.
What’s problematic, I clearly stated, is presuming on one’s own life “the standard of value”. In which case the hierarchy breaks down.
Anyone who prefers to think I made a dichotomy will have to re-read what I said.
What is it about the apple tree example which scares you?
If I err, why not show how I would be wrong in that case?
11 hours ago, whYNOT said:
Anyone who prefers to think I made a dichotomy will have to re-read what I said.
12 hours ago, whYNOT said:
The two must conflict: One’s life as being the ultimate value vs. One’s life as being the standard of value.
If they must conflict, then you set up a dichotomy. If they oppose each other, then they are separate and distinct things. They don’t actually conflict, they are just different aspects of the same question (“how do we measure value objectively?”). You can’t really separate life (the particular life you lead) from life (the thing all people do).
12 hours ago, whYNOT said:
The proper order: perception-identification-evaluation - could easily be turned around.
If you turn it around, that would be rationalism. But what you described isn’t turned around… So I don’t know what you’re talking about.
14 hours ago, Eiuol said:
If they must conflict, then you set up a dichotomy. If they oppose each other, then they are separate and distinct things. They don’t actually conflict, they are just different aspects of the same question (“how do we measure value objectively?”). You can’t really separate life (the particular life you lead) from life (the thing all people do).
If you turn it around, that would be rationalism. But what you described isn’t turned around… So I don’t know what you’re talking about.
I’ve repeated, one’s life can NOT be the “standard of value”. That’s the preserve of “man’s life”. So, no dichotomy - it is a false notion in every way. And - then - if one *also* considers one’s life as the highest value (true, and recognized by every O’ist)) this will clash with one’s life as the standard of value. No dichotomy, a contradiction.
“Standard” ( in my own life) -contra- “highest” (my own life). One is true, the other false, and trying to hold both together, an impossible feat in the end, is self-defeating (and harmful).
“Highest value” - must be objectively be met with: by what standard? If one believes the standard is oneself or one’s own life, this nullifies an objective “standard”, and the result would negate one’s objective conviction, “highest value”, too, and one will likely end up with neither.
Just because men exist does not automatically, from Nature, entitle us to being granted value as a species, as mankind nor as an individual. We lack any ‘instincts’ and built-in tools for the simplest survival-value, and especially for knowing and asserting one’s self-value. Nature and the universe doesn’t know mankind and individuals exist, nor care. And there’s no god who knows and cares either. These realizations eliminate man’s intrinsic value (which seems to hang around, even with Objectivists).
But man has consciousness and it is by that mind that one comprehends the need for objective value in one’s own life, in order to live and live well … through one’s mind. This is what is man’s metaphysical nature (and a man’s single advantage, if he knows and applies it).
Conclusion: an individual’s standard of value is ~man’s life~ i.e. living in accordance with the above and dedicated to his unique purpose and his specific values.
A dichotomy means that you set it up so there are two distinct options that can’t be unified. It doesn’t mean both options are valid. So… Yeah, you set up a dichotomy.