"Man's life"? Or, "your life"?

14 hours ago, Eiuol said:

 

 

If you turn it around, that would be rationalism. But what you described isn’t turned around… So I don’t know what you’re talking about.

Yes, ascribing and arrogating to one’s own life the abstraction, “the standard of value”, could well be an outcome of rationalism.

32 minutes ago, Eiuol said:

A dichotomy means that you set it up so there are two distinct options that can’t be unified. It doesn’t mean both options are valid. So… Yeah, you set up a dichotomy.

[Dichotomy: Division into two; binary classification; repeated bifurcation.]

I reject the mistaken premise: “One’s life, the standard of value.” This “option” is an unintelligible non-option.

I uphold the principle: “one’s life one’s supreme value”.

Therefore, I maintain the two cannot even be considered in unity, as some would have it.

No dichotomy and no “division into two”, but a contradiction in terms. 

 

2 hours ago, whYNOT said:

I uphold the principle: “one’s life one’s supreme value”.

You are incoherent. You said this creates a conflict. Now you say it doesn’t. You don’t make any sense. Nothing you write makes any sense. I don’t mean I disagree, I mean it literally doesn’t make sense.

1 Like

1 hour ago, Eiuol said:

You are incoherent. You said this creates a conflict. Now you say it doesn’t. You don’t make any sense. Nothing you write makes any sense. I don’t mean I disagree, I mean it literally doesn’t make sense.

Whew. You can do better.

I said several times, the attempt at holding both “one’s life, one’s highest value” AND one’s life the “standard of value” creates a conflict. (mental and external)

How can one continue to hold the highest objective value in one’s life - by a subjective standard of value? Impossible.

I’m curious: how does all this relate to your stance on abortion? You have said that a viable fetus is a distinct life. Does that mean that its standard of value is man’s life or its own, particular life as a fetus?

46 minutes ago, whYNOT said:

How can one continue to hold the highest objective value in one’s life - by a subjective standard of value? Impossible.

This is a double standard and a straw man.  No one said anything about a “subjective standard”.

Your life is no less objective than the life, survival, and flourishing of an apple tree.

1 hour ago, StrictlyLogical said:

This is a double standard and a straw man.  No one said anything about a “subjective standard”.

Your life is no less objective than the life, survival, and flourishing of an apple tree.

Why is this so hard to understand? OK, once more.

No straw man. *I* identified what’s clearly a subjective ‘standard’ assumed by some O’ists I read and heard.

Man’s life is the standard of value. (Agreed?) As I’ve related in Rand’s view, that was for her, an objective standard. Which is why we have an *objective* and rational ethics. (One isn’t an egoist because one merely *feels* like being one).

IF, however, you take *a* man’s life, an individual’s, or one’s own life - to be the *standard* of value, this ‘standard’ is no longer objective. You’ve now defeated the purpose of and negated an “objective standard”.

An apple tree has an objective *identity*. Its only objective *value* is one given to it by a VALUER.

1 hour ago, MisterSwig said:

I’m curious: how does all this relate to your stance on abortion? You have said that a viable fetus is a distinct life. Does that mean that its standard of value is man’s life or its own, particular life as a fetus?

Good one. I brought that into the abortion topic since I think that extreme term abortion is a rationally-moral, not a rights, concern. Can it be “right and proper” - by the standard of man’s life, qua man - for an individual to abort an already living entity, able to survive independently? So, not by the fetus’ standard of life, by “man’s life” standard of value.

3 hours ago, whYNOT said:

Why is this so hard to understand? OK, once more.

No straw man. *I* identified what’s clearly a subjective ‘standard’ assumed by some O’ists I read and heard.

Man’s life is the standard of value. (Agreed?) As I’ve related in Rand’s view, that was for her, an objective standard. Which is why we have an *objective* and rational ethics. (One isn’t an egoist because one merely *feels* like being one).

IF, however, you take *a* man’s life, an individual’s, or one’s own life - to be the *standard* of value, this ‘standard’ is no longer objective. You’ve now defeated the purpose of and negated an “objective standard”.

This is bald assertion… not an argument.

You do not understand what the word “objective” means.

5 hours ago, whYNOT said:

Whew. You can do better.

I said several times, the attempt at holding both “one’s life, one’s highest value” AND one’s life the “standard of value” creates a conflict. (mental and external)

I think I understand now, but please realize that you really need to work on your writing style. When you don’t write well, people will misunderstand you. Maybe Grames understood, but he asked for examples, and if you gave some, that would have helped a lot. So, you can ignore the parts where I speak of a dichotomy.

In my second response, it looks like I misread something, you just wanted to say that holding one’s life is the highest value is probably impossible if one’s own life is held as the standard of value. But then the proceeding conversation became even more confusing because of very strange sentences like this: “And - then - if one *also* considers one’s life as the highest value (true, and recognized by every O’ist)) this will clash with one’s life as the standard of value.”  You make it sound like holding one’s life as the highest value is also a problem.

Yeah, your individual life is not the proper standard of value. Swig said originally that your reasoning about it was backwards (rationalism), even if the conclusion was correct. So in a way, it’s not that what you said is wrong, but your reasoning about it isn’t very clear so it sounds like you’re arguing something that you aren’t actually trying to argue.

 

 

 

7 hours ago, StrictlyLogical said:

This is bald assertion… not an argument.

You do not understand what the word “objective” means.

Yeah, that’s metaphysics for you. Bald assertion. This is this. This is not that.

1.Man’s life is the standard of value.

  1. An individual’s life is not an individual’s standard of value.

I’d like to see your explanation of objective and objective value.

8 hours ago, Eiuol said:

I think I understand now, but please realize that you really need to work on your writing style. When you don’t write well, people will misunderstand you. Maybe Grames understood, but he asked for examples, and if you gave some, that would have helped a lot. So, you can ignore the parts where I speak of a dichotomy.

.

 

 

 

Glad that you got it. Why Grames understood early, despite “sty’e”, is because he thinks in principles. Instances of an Objectivist here and there, misstating Rand’s meaning are quite numerous. When I further saw that no one else made a correction, I inferred that the error is wide-spread. Examples of this would take a search into the forums I’m incapable of, and not really indicative of much. They were simply asserted, as matter-of-fact: e.g “The individual’s life is his standard of value”.

3 hours ago, whYNOT said:

Yeah, that’s metaphysics for you. Bald assertion. This is this. This is not that.

1.Man’s life is the standard of value.

  1. An individual’s life is not an individual’s standard of value.

I’d like to see your explanation of objective and objective value.

I’m not going to define anything for you, I’m looking for some independent thought.  The apple tree is a perfect example we could discuss but you continue to evade precisely because it would require independent thought on your part.

I am curious about your psycho epistemology and sense of life.  Is morality primarily and fundamentally individualistic and personal?  or contra is it something possessed and for a society or for any group or collection of people for that matter?

If you are unwilling or unable to think independently, no real discussion of any kind is possible.

 

One more hypothetical to add to the mix.  What if you were a brilliant botanist and geneticist and you were able to create a hybrid apple orange tree … and you created only one.  Now suppose because of your brilliance you could from its unique genetic makeup predict and completely understand its requirements for life, some of which were similar to similar to apple trees others similar to orange trees and yet others new and similar to neither.  Now suppose you write your guide to action, recipe of care, standard practices manual, whatever you call it, for your gardener, using all your knowledge. 

In what way would your utterly unique owners manual for the actual care of this apple orange tree be subjective?

2 hours ago, whYNOT said:

misstating Rand’s meaning are quite numerous

I’ve seen it before, yes. But examples are still important if we want to concretize anything we say.

If someone thinks that their own life is the standard of value, I think it’s usually because it can be difficult to make the conceptual step that an abstract and universal code can be unified with a particular life. 

2 hours ago, whYNOT said:

is because he thinks in principles

it just gets annoying when I’m not the only person who thinks you have poor writing, and you don’t bother to improve it. You use grammar inappropriately, you use punctuation inappropriately. Your transition words are absent when they should be there. Your attempts at clarification usually do the opposite.

3 hours ago, whYNOT said:

Examples of this would take a search into the forums I’m incapable of

Anyone can search.

5 hours ago, StrictlyLogical said:

 

I am curious about your psycho epistemology and sense of life.  Is morality primarily and fundamentally individualistic and personal?  or contra is it something possessed and for a society or for any group or collection of people for that matter?

 

There’s something one takes for granted on an Objectivist forum, that the distinction between an abstraction (man’s life) and the concrete (an individual life) will be grasped. That one makes the conceptual connection from one to the other.

*Of course* one’s morality is individualistic and real to one, as one’s life and being is real and concrete; arbitrarily throwing in “fundamentally” and your comments raises the doubt you know what metaphysical fundamentality means.

“Man’s life” = Fundamental to man and man’s existence, according to the nature of his consciousness (consciousness, too, has identity) and the nature of existence.

That’s my (independent) assessment of the phrase, open to criticism.

Therefore - fundamental to ALL men and all individuals. 

You, otoh, think that “morality” relates to either the individual or the group of people and society. (Even implying altruism…). So you pose a false dichotomy in your question. I suggest the social conception of “men” and “society” stems from universalism rather than a proper metaphysics of man.

Before you irrelevantly get down to anyone’s “psycho-epistemology and sense of life” you need to understand the abstractions involved here. I have been accurate to Objectivism, I think, but I don’t see you being critical of Rand’s “sense of life” in her ethics conception.

Where do you believe Rand has her ethics wrong? More likely, where do you think you’ve misinterpreted her? I’ll give it again: “The Objectivist ethics holds man’s life as the STANDARD of value–and HIS OWN LIFE as the ETHICAL PURPOSE of every individual man”. (AR’s italics).

1 hour ago, Eiuol said:

I’ve seen it before, yes. But examples are still important if we want to concretize anything we say.

If someone thinks that their own life is the standard of value, I think it’s usually because it can be difficult to make the conceptual step that an abstract and universal code can be unified with a particular life. 

it just gets annoying when I’m not the only person who thinks you have poor writing, and you don’t bother to improve it. You use grammar inappropriately, you use punctuation inappropriately. Your transition words are absent when they should be there. Your attempts at clarification usually do the opposite.

Anyone can search.

I don’t need to search for previous examples of that erroneous interpretation. You are seeing them here.

And it’s increasingly clear that I have been quite well understood. The reactions demonstrate this.  

Thank you for the writing advice. You always did worry too much about style over substance. 

5 hours ago, StrictlyLogical said:

 

 

One more hypothetical to add to the mix.  What if you were a brilliant botanist and geneticist and you were able to create a hybrid apple orange tree … and you created only one.  Now suppose because of your brilliance you could from its unique genetic makeup predict and completely understand its requirements for life, some of which were similar to similar to apple trees others similar to orange trees and yet others new and similar to neither.  Now suppose you write your guide to action, recipe of care, standard practices manual, whatever you call it, for your gardener, using all your knowledge. 

In what way would your utterly unique owners manual for the actual care of this apple orange tree be subjective?

This topic concerns “objective value” - derived from objective reality. *Which* value-system is the essential grounds for defining and creating a morality. I.E. Of value to whom?

(The three theories of value you should know). Your tree theory is fine as far as objective fact goes; apparently you think the O’ist ethical theory offends or contradicts the utter uniqueness of every individual (which he/she is). That’s badly mistaken, and a metaphysical -> individual error again.

Further, you are seemingly confusing “personal” with “subjective”. 

 

30 minutes ago, whYNOT said:

This topic concerns “objective value” - derived from objective reality. *Which* value-system is the essential grounds for defining and creating a morality. I.E. Of value to whom?

(The three theories of value you should know). Your tree theory is fine as far as objective fact goes; apparently you think the O’ist ethical theory offends or contradicts the utter uniqueness of every individual (which he/she is). That’s badly mistaken, and a metaphysical -> individual error again.

Further, you are seemingly confusing “personal” with “subjective”. 

 

Lets stop trying to characterize each other and deal with my example using independent thought.   

What is inappropriate or subjective with using “this apple tree” or “this apple orange tree” and all the knowledge that comes with it, (please see my above examples) as the standard to use in its care?

56 minutes ago, whYNOT said:

“Man’s life” = Fundamental to man and man’s existence, according to the nature of his consciousness (consciousness, too, has identity) and the nature of existence.

Man’s life is his process of self-generated and self-sustaining action. You appear to be focusing on only one aspect of man, his existence, and dropping the context of his action. Man’s life is not that which is fundamental to his existence, it’s that which is his existence. A man acting to stay alive (to continue existing) is his life. Of course, a man can also act to end his life (to stop existing), which is his death. Therefore, each individual man must form a concept of his own life and death, and the actions which will produce either result. This is the sense in which his own life is his standard of value, and his own death is his standard of vice.