5 hours ago, StrictlyLogical said:
I am curious about your psycho epistemology and sense of life. Is morality primarily and fundamentally individualistic and personal? or contra is it something possessed and for a society or for any group or collection of people for that matter?
There’s something one takes for granted on an Objectivist forum, that the distinction between an abstraction (man’s life) and the concrete (an individual life) will be grasped. That one makes the conceptual connection from one to the other.
*Of course* one’s morality is individualistic and real to one, as one’s life and being is real and concrete; arbitrarily throwing in “fundamentally” and your comments raises the doubt you know what metaphysical fundamentality means.
“Man’s life” = Fundamental to man and man’s existence, according to the nature of his consciousness (consciousness, too, has identity) and the nature of existence.
That’s my (independent) assessment of the phrase, open to criticism.
Therefore - fundamental to ALL men and all individuals.
You, otoh, think that “morality” relates to either the individual or the group of people and society. (Even implying altruism…). So you pose a false dichotomy in your question. I suggest the social conception of “men” and “society” stems from universalism rather than a proper metaphysics of man.
Before you irrelevantly get down to anyone’s “psycho-epistemology and sense of life” you need to understand the abstractions involved here. I have been accurate to Objectivism, I think, but I don’t see you being critical of Rand’s “sense of life” in her ethics conception.
Where do you believe Rand has her ethics wrong? More likely, where do you think you’ve misinterpreted her? I’ll give it again: “The Objectivist ethics holds man’s life as the STANDARD of value–and HIS OWN LIFE as the ETHICAL PURPOSE of every individual man”. (AR’s italics).