I don’t think so and, as evidence, I’ll cite Sowell’s book, Ethnic America. It is a study of the various ethnic and racial groups in American and solidly based on historical fact. His thesis is that the success of various indigenous and immigrant groups and the speed of their progress is a function of “cultural capital” – i.e., the IDEAS prevalent in their culture.
Sowell holds that certain ideas (valuing education, willingness to work) lead to success while others (irresponsibility, dependence on government handouts, tradition-worship) lead to failure. One example he cites is the difference between welfare-dependent American blacks and recent black immigrants from the Caribbean who hustle to make a living and push their children to get a good education. The latter have an average standard of living higher than that of American whites.
I had written a fantastic response to your post only to have to reboot my PC because of a broken link I had tried to copy and paste from Google.
But, let me try to reproduce it…
As your quotes from Ethnic America demonstrate, Sowell is pro-capitalism. (I am aware of the thread running through his books - I have read a few of them myself.)
But this does not translate to individualism.
I do not believe concepts such as “cultural capital” are valid. Why? Because they do not pertain to fundamentals. I mean, did Aristotle’s “fellow” whites in Ancient Greece help him discover Logic and the innumerable facts of Biology he unearthed? Or did he do it all by himself?
Virtually all the “white” creators in Western Civilization faced rejection, ridicule, and/or martyrdom from their fellow “white” men. Where was “cultural capital” then?
My point: Is achievement individual- or group-based? These “ideas prevalent in [the] culture,” are they produced by racial committee or are they the products of an unacknowledged individual working hard and swimming furiously against the cultural mainstream?
Would the Greeks simply “valuing education” and being “willing to work” have resulted in Western Civilization? Education in what? Work for whom?
Besides, the “group-achievement” theories only serve to sacrifice the best among the “low-achieving” groups. The creator in these groups is beholden to “helping his brothers out.” This means that whatever grand achievement he does have, or plans to fulfill, is sacrificed to the “society’s need to see group X do Y.” His strengths are sacrificed to the weaknesses of others, simply because they possess the same skin color as he does. Plato and Kant would have been proud.
If one focuses on black trash, what about the white trash? Why do they get off easy? Why do they get out of the brow-beating and the tongue-lashing? This is racism: Newton’s intellectual stature is conferred on some undeserving moron, simply because he shared Newton’s skin color. Where is justice?
Sowell often, inadvertently, confesses the effect of the societal strain on him - the creator - when he calls those leftist group-worshippers who claim to want to see blacks succeed, “bean-counters.”
But, even if he doesn’t realize it, so is he.
He too wants to see “blacks succeed.” So, he uses some of the language of the group-worshippers. He gives undeserved air-time to cretins like Pat Buchanan and nobodies like Charles Murray.
If I were him, I wouldn’t even adopt that presumptuous tone which sometimes comes across as ‘speaking for’ blacks or ‘leading’ blacks. Why would he do what [Edit]some[Edit] white people don’t want to do? This type of white person would argue that “if Sowell says it, it wouldn’t be considered racist.” But, why should Sowell sacrifice himself to the sentiments he will and does face? Simply because he’s black?
As Ayn Rand noted, reason is an individual faculty; and this absolute cannot be circumvented: one either preaches this or one doesn’t. Objectivists cannot allow those whom Miss Rand characterized as the “alleged defenders of liberty” to claim holy ground. Objectivists must stand firm on this point or all else is lost.
Sowell gives his enemies some fuel: he feeds the idea that a man must live for certain others, which in his case is those who share his skin color. This is incalculable damage to his cause, although he probably isn’t aware of it.
Just to make sure that you see the banality of preaching “responsibility” and "valuing education, " I ask you to observe the Carribean-immigrant family Farley (the MIT mathematician Jonathan, the TIME music critic Christopher, their parents and siblings) and check out the disastrous views that Jonathan holds and spreads. And they “value education” and are “willing to work,” so what gives?
If one wishes to oppose welfare, the proper attitude is: “Destroy welfare; you have no right to take my money without my consent.” An improper attitude is: “There are too many blacks on welfare.” The latter involves a package deal.
No-one should lose any sleep if some people don’t do their best. Just fight for your rights and all will be well.
I hope I’ve made my case. Please let me know if there are any questions I haven’t answered.