I’ve been arguing for a while now, as some people in chat know, with a bunch of Christians on Facebook. Basically, Facebook has a blogging utility, which I’ve been using to flesh out my thoughts on Objectivism. I figured, sure, it’s one thing to read ITOE and kind of mostly understand it - it’s another thing to coherently and originally recreate the main points on your own, without just quoting ITOE. Consider it part of the learning process for me.
However, I’ve had to contend furiously with some Christian ‘friends’ of mine who have gone so far as to call me arrogant for holding that my position was right:
you can hardly say my opinion is wrong, so much as i can say that yours is. please refrain from this sort of thing, its annoying and arrogant.
However, one guy has been posting about miracles. I’ve had to reiterate the laws of identity, causality; the axiom of existence; what morality means - over and over and over again, to try and get it into their thick skulls. As such, I’ve said many times that miracles don’t happen, that things don’t contradict their nature, that A never equals B, that a Horse never turns into a chicken, and that things never fall up (they might float, but they can’t, by definition, ‘fall’ up). Now he’s claiming to have seen many miracles in his life time.
Now, some are just anecdotal, but he claims that nearly 500 people out of a group of 5000 were healed. I’ve explained why no claims of miraculous events is ever going to convince me, because no matter how unlikely, a miracle is still logically impossible.
His response?
God acts according to His nature, therefore healings happen.
The above statement I can take down on my own - what I wanted was something more concrete to attack his claims with. I know the stuff about placebo effects and subjective validation, but he’s claiming 500 people simultatenously cured of afflictions. I was just wondering if there’s a good, solid answer? I know miracles can’t happen by their very definition, but are there any documented cases I can throw in his face to back up how miracles are disproved?
The thing is, this debate isn’t about the arguments. I mean, I’m staying perfectly rational and logic in my arguments, but we’re not arguing for the sake of examining one another’s beliefs - it’s me trying to defend what I believe. It’s the fact that out of all the people I know who do or can read my Notes, I want at least one of them to see past the usual Subjectivist and Theistic bullshit. I want one of them to realise that all this nonsense which they’ve probably picked up too, is actually easily dispelled, but it’s so easy to be undermined when your enemy is basically going to flaunt how ‘rationalistic’ you are, and what a ‘slave to logic’ you are, because you’re claiming even the wildly improbable to still be possible.
Edit: Some quotes from his comments:
“On the subject of prayer which you brought up before, it seems that you believe that answered prayer is simply chance. How does it work then, that 230ish people were healed of various diseases, allergies and other stuff within the space of 5 minutes, in a group of about 5000 people in a meeting I was at the other day?”
, This one is actually something what he heard, not actually saw proof for:
"One girl was unable to read due to dyslexia and had another eye problem which was to do with the connections it had with her brain. She went into the meeting with a reading age of 6 and was seeing a specialist. After she was prayed for, she was able to read whole chunks of text without any problem. She then went back to the specialist and she was stunned and confused as she realised that her patient’s reading age had increased by ten years in a week!
Another example is a girl who had allergies to nuts, rubber and fruit. Even being in a room with balloons would be life threatening. However, when she was prayed for she ate some fruit, peanut butter and blew up a balloon and didn’t die or feel any symptoms whatsoever. Again, doctors couldn’t understand it."
"I haven’t, sadly seen anyone’s limbs grown back, although I’ve spoken to people who’ve witnessed it. However, since I wasn’t actually there, I won’t use it as an example. However, there was someone at the meeting whose fingers were not the right length proportionally due to a calcium and bone problem. Again, when she was prayed for, she was healed and her hands were back to normal.
Some of the healings were pretty minor. Some were major. It ranged from simple aches and pains to actual disabilities, as I’ve given a few examples of. 230 was the minimum number, some people needed actual blood tests to find out whether they had been healed or not, so that number could rise. The speaker was Adrian Holloway and the doctor there was a bloke called Pete Carter. Yes, the people did want to get better, which is why they responded and got prayed for. I’ll give a few more examples if you like."
Unrelated to the event I was at, I know a bloke who’s son had fluid on his brain when he was born. He was prayed for, went back for brain scans and the fluid was gone. Needless to say, the doctors were confused. Also, I was playing cricket on the beach once and a bloke dived for a catch and broke his collar bone. He had an x-ray which clearly showed it was broken, then he was prayed for, felt fine afterwards, had another x-ray which showed no fracture at all. Do bones mend themselves in the space of a week unaided?