Although Rand never mentions how she reached her theory of art, it’s reasonable to assume that she did it by induction from established and important works of literature, painting etc. Virtually all art up until the late 19th century has been representational. Rand’s contribution is a theory of representational art, so it can be argued that it has little application to alternative frameworks such as non-representational and conceptual art. Whether this is a limitation or not comes down to your personal preferences. If you like non-objective art and want to integrate it with representational theories of art, Rand’s aesthetics will at best give you some hints for your project.
What is art for?
People love to occasionally take a break from the real world and live inside an idealized world. Granted, there are alternative ways to experience a different world: daydreaming, video games, intoxication and even sex come to mind. Art is unique because it’s ready-made; no productive participation is required of the consumer.
Rand stresses in many places that any justification for art other than enjoyment chips away at the very soul of the artistic enterprise:
Quote
“the reason why in reading a story or looking at a painting we feel it is an end in itself is that we don’t want to experience that pleasure for any other purpose but the pleasure itself.” [FW 58] “The simple truth is that I approach literature as a child does: I write—and read—for the sake of the story.” [RM 162]
Why does art portray a total philosophy, and not just a few individual philosophic principles?
Let’s say a novelist writes a novel about a hairdresser for celebrities. If his hero is fictional, the novelist will construct his life according to what he thinks human beings go through in virtue of being human beings: despair, triumph, futility etc. If, on the other hand, his subject is a real historical person, he’ll make it seem as if the events of his life are perfect examples of the despair, triumph or futility of life. This is akin to how religionists take everything to be a proof of god—fortune or misfortune, the existence of the world or the non-existence of the world etc.—it doesn’t matter what you throw at them, they’ll find a way to convert it into evidence for their beliefs.
In art, every action, political rant, brushstroke etc. is in some way consistent with the artist’s basic assumptions. By contrast, the real world contains some degree of randomness, e.g. Peikoff’s example of fumbling while trying to elegantly open a champagne bottle during a date [OPAR 425]. (whether randomness exists outside of human actions is a much-debated philosophical topic).
Some O’ists find it puzzling that a four-line stanza or a statue can hold a total, entire, complete philosophy. This is because they look at the object and not at ‘where it comes from’, i.e. the source of the selections that construct the work. Such a concatenation is supposed to evoke a distinctive kind of world to your consciousness:
Quote
“Metaphysics. . . involves such a vast sum of knowledge and such a long chain of concepts that no man could hold it all in the focus of his immediate conscious awareness. Yet he needs that sum and that awareness to guide him—he needs the power to summon them into full, conscious focus.” [RM 19]
“a novel (like a statue or a symphony) does not require or tolerate an explanatory preface; it is a self-contained universe, aloof from commentary, beckoning the reader to enter, perceive, respond.” [L. Peikoff, preface to Atlas Shrugged)
A person can hardly enter another world by means of a statue if he looks at it the same way he looks at a G.I. Joe action figure. Most of the philosophical sciences look outward to the external world; aesthetics is uniquely tasked with studying man’s inner world in correlation to outward objects of the senses, such as a canvas. Is music a microcosm? Despite being built out of invisible air vibrations, you’d be hard pressed to find a quicker way to tune out of your bus ride and slip straight into another world, than by putting a pair of headphones on.
Is architecture art?
I’m inclined to think that Rand simply commented on the traditional list of fine arts, rather than reconstructing such things from the ground up. In my opinion, architecture doesn’t fit in with her definition of art. If buildings can be art, lunch boxes can be as well. Both are non-representational; both can be either enjoyed for their visual style and significance, or used to enclose people or sandwiches.
Quote
“Art is a selective re-creation of reality according to an artist’s metaphysical value-judgments.” [RM 45]
“Architecture. . . does not re-create reality, but creates a structure for man’s habitation or use, expressing man’s values.” [RM 46 {‘architecture’ is non-existent in the Ayn Rand lexicon}]
Why is aesthetics even a part of philosophy?
Art has existed for much longer than philosophy, so it certainly wasn’t invented by philosophers.
When we describe man, characteristics such as having two eyes and a nose won’t suffice—too many other animals have eyes and noses. By contrast, the moment you mention ‘reason = primary means of survival’ you’ve instantly narrowed the search down to a single entry: man. Likewise, if you want to build a universe in miniature, you have to ignore contingencies and go straight to the essential, important characteristics of earthly existence, i.e. metaphysical features. This is what gives your mini-world an instantly recognizable character, what we refer to when speaking of the world of Rembrandt or Monet.
Quote
“Cognitive abstractions are formed by the criterion of: what is essential?. . . Normative abstractions are formed by the criterion of: what is good? Esthetic abstractions are formed by the criterion of: what is important?” [RM 36]
Theory is hard and makes people’s brains hurt. By contrast, everybody understands what they encounter in the world of the five senses. Philosophy can be downright unintelligible without the superheroes, pop idols and ancient myths that seep into popular culture and act as statements of what human life is all about.
The philosopher, priest and artist deal with the same topics, but in different forms. The philosopher describes the world in a conceptual form, the priest allegedly connects you to the immanent essence of that world, and the artist builds a world for contemplation.
Aesthetics is an objective science
Creating art is a skill. Natural talent and inclination is crucial, but producing tight artworks requires technical know-how. This technical toolkit removes restrictions to expressive freedom, rather than constraining it with asinine rules:
Quote
“Classicism . . . was a school that had devised a set of arbitrary, concretely detailed rules purporting to represent the final and absolute criteria of esthetic value. In literature, these rules consisted of specific edicts. . . which prescribed every formal aspect of a play (such as the unity of time, place and action) down to the number of acts and the number of verses permitted to a character in every act. . . and can serve as an example of what happens when concrete-bound mentalities, seeking to by-pass the responsibility of thought, attempt to transform abstract principles into concrete prescriptions and to replace creation with imitation.” [RM 104]
Does aesthetics study beauty?
It can be argued that non-beautiful art has little appeal for those who seek art specifically for enjoying themselves. Rand makes no mention of aesthetics as a theory of beauty, but she does discuss a closely related subject: taste. Understanding precisely how taste works can help us identify why combinations that come across as ‘tacky’, ‘sophisticated’, ‘chaotic’ etc. can also come across as beautiful to some people and not to others.
The subconscious mind integrates everything we believe about the world. Thanks to this, we naturally feel the overall context underlying our everyday existence, with no further need to translate this feeling into words. Rand calls this phenomenon a sense of life. In my experience, this sense only comes to the forefront of my conscious attention in moments when something makes me feel that life is amazing, or when I feel that life is offensively not how it ought to be. Those strong reactions are an instance of my sense of life being converted into full-fledged emotions. Artists are so attuned to their sense of life that, during creation, most of their selections are almost forced upon them by their subconscious ‘computer’, as if possesed by a muse. This kind of inspiration works the other way as well: Rand notes how an essentialized fictional character (concretization of ethics) is just like an essentialized world (concretization of metaphysics): it can summon selections to your conscious mind, as if divinely inspired;
Quote
“Many readers of The Fountainhead have told me that the character of Howard Roark helped them to make a decision when they faced a moral dilemma. They asked themselves: “What would Roark do in this situation?”—and, faster than their mind could identify the proper application of all the complex principles involved, the image of Roark gave them the answer. They sensed, almost instantly, what he would or would not do—and this helped them to isolate and to identify the reasons, the moral principles that would have guided him. Such is the psycho-epistemological function of a personified (concretized) human ideal.” [RM ch. 1]
Your sense of life, to be useful, needs to be rekindled constantly, the same way a fire needs a constant stream of logs to remain active. Otherwise it subdues into nothingness, and you’re no longer able to make effortless and ‘inspired decisions’ the same way the artist does while creating. Put differently, you have to work much harder, because the conscious and subconscious are practicing social distancing rather than being a whole. Your brain is famished, and art is what it craves:
Quote
“If art is, as Ayn Rand said, a crucial nourishment of life, then you are engaged in self-imposed malnutrition. If it’s a banquet, you are starving when there are countless courses” (L. Peikoff, "Poems I Like and Why, p. 1 - referring to O’ists who only know Rand’s novels, classics, mystery, adventure and TV).
Sex and art
Quote
“Sense of life is predominant in two realms: sex and art. In sex, sense of life wouldn’t be as clear to you, since it’s harder to identify your own sexual reactions. So the best and perhaps only way to identify sense of life is by observing your reactions to art. (This is not a shortcut; it’s pretty difficult.)” [PO12 76]
Implicit in good (human) sex are two interrelated feelings:
-
That having sex is a special, out-of-the-ordinary activity. Some couples even use stories and role-plays to enhance the feeling that something special is going on. (By ‘special’, many people understand ‘illicit’, e.g. a nurse breaking the code to do naughty stuff with a patient. I’ll leave other possible examples to your imagination.)
-
If sex it that special, then it’s not something open to every Joe or Jane, right? Sex is a response to a person that you feel has a unique ability to navigate life. Both men and women look for strong partners; even if the masculine sex usually takes the lead in a sexual relationship, underlying the woman’s sexual attitude must lie a strenght on par with the man’s. The more flustered, excited and adoring your partner is, the bigger and greater you feel. Sex doesn’t provide self esteem, it merely allows you to enjoy its perks. Branden notes [BPO 58] that no rational person will be motivated to keep himself pristine and admirable if his effort is not rewarded somehow. (It’s even harder if you’re being punished for it by government goons).
Sex is philosophical, just like art, in this manner: no sense of life is involved when you hear somebody say that water is a solid rather a liquid; you just find it goofy. But hearing from somebody that living is a meaningless, futile and mindless ritual?? I’ll have to stop you there, buster. Pleasurable sex only happens when you feel that you’re wholly entitled to that pleasure—as a human being and as this particular individual. If you genuinely feel like you’re a useless blob of determined matter, there’s no adoration to ‘deserve’ and sex is a farce.
Quote
“Sex, in Ayn Rand’s identification, is. . . a celebration of one’s power to gain values and of the world in which one gains them” [OPAR 344]
BPO 58 - Nathaniel Branden’s taped lectures on the “Basic Principles of Objectivism” Lecture 16 (1958)
FW 58 - Ayn Rand’s 1958 fiction-writing recorded course
PO12 76 - Leonard Peikoff, “Philosophy of Objectivism” Lecture 12 (1976)
RM - Ayn Rand, The Romantic Manifesto