Nathaniel Branden

I don’t remember where I heard it, it was a story about Ayn Rand saying she rarely had an emotion that she couldn’t figure out its source in a short time.  The more abstract the subject the longer it might take. 

Leonard Peikoff remarked that Ayn Rand could respond emotionally to broad abstractions which is very rare. 

When exactly in her life did she organize words into the phrases that resonate so concisely, integrating a process of reasoning with a process of investigating emotional responses. 

I still wonder why the title of this thread is Nathaniel Branden.

1 Like

56 minutes ago, KorbenDallas said:

I used Rand’s definition of thought, as conveyed by Barbara Branden when Barbara was with Rand.  There aren’t any parts that are off, they only seem off to you for the reasons I’ve stated already.

I’m saying that if we talk about thought broadly, that’d be an easier way to talk about how emotions are a consequence of evaluations. But anyway, I was trying to clarify exactly my idea, and also explaining how you can’t say where emotions -should- come from. By nature, our emotions come out of evaluations, regardless of their evaluation’s truth, which needs to happen if we’re to recognize the status of our premises. It would be improper to just wave away “bad” emotions you “shouldn’t” have. Sometimes, the premises are non-conceptual, so it’s a bit more complicated than treating all emotions as caused by only thought defined as reasoning. In other words, there are a some borderline cases for some emotions, maybe for something like panic.

Yes, it’s bad if emotions come out of, say, social metaphysics, but that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t have the emotion or repress it.

Tenderly, I’ll re-title it, just don’t know what to call it yet.

16 hours ago, Eiuol said:

I’m saying that if we talk about thought broadly, that’d be an easier way to talk about how emotions are a consequence of evaluations. But anyway, I was trying to clarify exactly my idea, and also explaining how you can’t say where emotions -should- come from. By nature, our emotions come out of evaluations, regardless of their evaluation’s truth, which needs to happen if we’re to recognize the status of our premises. It would be improper to just wave away “bad” emotions you “shouldn’t” have. Sometimes, the premises are non-conceptual, so it’s a bit more complicated than treating all emotions as caused by only thought defined as reasoning. In other words, there are a some borderline cases for some emotions, maybe for something like panic.

Yes, it’s bad if emotions come out of, say, social metaphysics, but that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t have the emotion or repress it.

Tenderly, I’ll re-title it, just don’t know what to call it yet.

This does nothing to break what I’ve said (which _is_ Objectivism), all you’ve accomplished here is to put all of your misunderstandings in one place.  Check YOUR premises.  Though you have TWO correct statements in there, how you arrived at them is wrong.  I am finished here.

My emotional response to the name Nathaniel Branden is an empathy of loss, betrayal, confusion. 

Is it a breach of privacy to speak of Ayn Rand’s personal life?  Her antagonists have no problem dredging it up.  What is the most enlightened response to them? 

The process by which a strong attraction transforms into a strong repulsion is a subject that has profound implications for any human…   The loss of intimacy.  The disarray of friendships and business arrangements.  The long term repercussions. 

I’d like to throw in my two cents, but I’m a little unclear on exactly what is being disputed here. What are the alternatives? What as opposed to what else? I did read everything, but some of the objections and counters being made were kind of vague and I’m not sure what statements they were made in reference to.

2 hours ago, KorbenDallas said:

Though you have TWO correct statements in there, how you arrived at them is wrong.  I am finished here.

I really don’t think your thoughts are clear, so I was just adding some ideas that you can agree with or dispute. I think the point of the thread is to say what makes for a healthy mindset, and if Branden diverges from or contributes to the Objectivist point of view.

So, to get at your thought, Tenderly, we can talk about what emotions indicate a healthy mindset. What suggests a virtuous frame of mind? Rational thought is crucial, fundamental even. This isn’t to say babies lack emotion, but that as adults, we are especially able to self-reflect and alter emotions. A few emotions may be just pre-cognitive, but as adults, I’d say all emotions are a consequence of thought. Not sure if that addresses things.

On 10/20/2015 at 8:54 PM, Collectivist said:

Nathaneil Branden often spoke and wrote about intergrating some “positive psychological ideals (read emotions )” into Objectivist actions, theory and thought. Was he right or wrong-What do you think?.

According to Wikipedia:

Quote

[Nathaniel Branden] offered criticisms of aspects of [Ayn Rand’s] work, naming as problems a tendency to encourage emotional repression and moralizing, a failure to understand psychology beyond its cognitive aspects, and a failure to appreciate adequately the importance of kindness in human relationships.

 

If these are the sort of criticisms we’re discussing (as I’m going to assume) then I’d say that some of them are valid and probably ought to be reexamined, while some of them are hogwash.

 

Emotional repression does seem to be an issue among novice Objectivists. I don’t believe it’s an actual component of Objectivism per se, but definitely something its practitioners run into.

For example, I’ve enjoyed video games for my whole life. I love them. About two years ago (which was a few months after I started trying to live Objectivism) I found myself wondering whether it was moral for me to play them; even though I enjoyed them immensely, they didn’t serve any practical purpose, which left me wondering what the purpose of playing them was (since the worst thing a man can be is purposeless).

Now, clearly, it is moral to enjoy myself; according to Objectivism, the purpose of life is to enjoy it. However, this is a subtle point which seems to be lost on many who try to apply the philosophy to their own lives.

 

Objectivism’s alleged lack of appreciation for kindness is hogwash.

 

I have to go now but I’ll elaborate in a few hours.