Nathaneil Branden often spoke and wrote about intergrating some “positive psychological ideals (read emotions )” into Objevtivist actions,theory and thought. Was he right or wrong-What do you think?.
I think that emotions are real, and emotions are important. However, emotions are not really important in the course of making really important decisions.
Nathaneil Branden often spoke and wrote about intergrating some “positive psychological ideals (read emotions )” into Objevtivist actions,theory and thought. Was he right or wrong-What do you think?.
Where did he say this and can you support equating that term with emotions? Just trying to get a baseline here because i am interested in the question…
Nathaniel Branden said a lot of things after the break, and yes a person with incorrect thinking could use emotions as a starting point to thinking and integrate them heavily, but this is not Objectivism, and leads to a very unhealthy mind. Thought precedes emotion, and before the break, Nathaniel Branden in The Psychology of Self-Esteem, his Basic Principles of Objectivism lecture series, and Barbara Branden’s Princples of Efficient Thinking elucidate this principle.
Historical point: T_he Psychology of Self-Esteem_ came out in 1969, after the break, although most of the material had by then run in The Objectivist or in Branden’s NBI lectures.
Biological point: dogs and babies have emotions without having had thoughts. What do you mean when you say that thought precedes emotion? Certain complex, acquired emotions do, but not all emotions.
Quote
Historical point: T_he Psychology of Self-Esteem_ came out in 1969, after the break, although most of the material had by then run in The Objectivist or in Branden’s NBI lectures.
Yup, written before the break and published after.
Quote
Biological point: dogs and babies have emotions without having had thoughts. What do you mean when you say that thought precedes emotion? Certain complex, acquired emotions do, but not all emotions.
Neither dogs nor babies have the faculty of reason, which is understood when speaking about the philosophy of Objectivism (the nature of man). My response is in context to the original post, “integrating some positive psychological ideals, emotions, into Objectivist actions, theory, and thought.” The phrase I used, thought precedes emotion, is in context to my previous sentence: “… but this is not Objectivism, and leads to a very unhealthy mind.” Then, “Thought precedes emotion <is Objectivism>,..” has an elliptical, but the intent is implied.
Still holding the context about integrating emotions “into Objectivist actions, theory, and thought”, emotions are a result of prior thought. Values and premises are incepted by thought, and these can cause emotions as an effect. Integrating values and premises into one’s thinking integrates them into the subconscious, to which emotions can then happen without conscious thought, but are result of prior thinking.
The principle of thought precedes emotion holds for conscious thought as well, as a standard of Objectivism.
An integrated emotion seems to be something you are not at odds with…
When I used the phrase “integrating emotions”, it was based off of the original post and not my own. I don’t use the phrase “integrating emotions” as I consider it to be an arbitrary. Emotions are effects–psychosomatic effects that are experienced in the body, fundamentally as pleasure/pain. There isn’t any way to integrate something that comes into existence then goes out of existence. The causes of emotions are integrated, but not the emotions themselves. Emotions can be conceptualized (love, hate, anxiety, fear, etc.) and then thought of as effects to causes–and this is a distinction of emotions-as-experience and emotions-as-concepts.
I’m not sure what the original poster was saying, it seems to be ambiguous in terms, or maybe equivocating. As Reasoner has said, it would be nice to have more context to this.
Emotion is a very personal response.
Is this thread trying to make a distinction between the Objectivist view of emotion compared to Nathaniel Branden’s view?
“Neither dogs nor babies have the faculty of reason . . .”
Small point about your wording. Babies can’t reason due to lacking sufficient information - they haven’t had time and experience to really grasp what would be necessary to do reasoning. Their brains may still be in the process of some noteworthy development, but as far as the term “faculty of reason” is generally used in Objectivism, babies do have it.
Babies definitely have some kind of thoughts too, and dogs I think too, they’re just probably not very well formed and precise with lots of concepts involved.
On 12/16/2015 at 0:51 PM, KorbenDallas said:
The principle of thought precedes emotion holds for conscious thought as well, as a standard of Objectivism.
More accurately, emotions are caused by an evaluation, not strictly caused by thinking in the full conceptual sense. How are you justifying it then? To be sure, thoughts cause emotions, but that doesn’t mean thoughts are the only cause. Depends how strictly you define thought.
Quote
Small point about your wording. Babies can’t reason due to lacking sufficient information … but as far as the term “faculty of reason” is generally used in Objectivism, babies do have it.
Thanks, I see the error. I approached it from performing the action, yet the potentiality is still there as an attribute.
Quote
More accurately, emotions are caused by an evaluation, not strictly caused by thinking in the full conceptual sense. How are you justifying it then? To be sure, thoughts cause emotions, but that doesn’t mean thoughts are the only cause. Depends how strictly you define thought.
Check out the paragraph before the sentence “The principle of thought precedes emotion holds for conscious thought as well, as a standard of Objectivism,” which was: “..emotions are a result of prior thought. Values and premises are incepted by thought, and these can cause emotions as an effect. Integrating values and premises into one’s thinking integrates them into the subconscious, to which emotions can then happen without conscious thought, but are result of prior thinking.” So the principle of thought precedes emotion still holds. I do want to clarify that there are a great many ways to incorrectly experience emotion, first that comes to mind is social metaphysics, but that would be off-principle and not what I’m speaking of here.
2 hours ago, KorbenDallas said:
I do want to clarify that there are a great many ways to incorrectly experience emotion, first that comes to mind is social metaphysics, but that would be off-principle and not what I’m speaking of here.
Yes, but you seem to be saying -all- emotions are a result of thinking in the conceptual way, and that there are “correct” ways to experience an emotion. The only “wrong” part is if you evaluated wrong, but you’d need to recognize the emotion first to find out your evaluation. Evaluations are right or wrong, so what you should say is that emotions themselves are not where the whole cognitive process gets its start when developing. Sometimes, evaluations will be non-conceptual, and this is perfectly fine, it just means not all thoughts are conceptual. This is important, if you want to know how to establish a healthy emotional state, then you need to be precise about what a thought is.
I already said that emotions themselves are not where the whole cognitive process gets its start by saying they are effects from antecedental causes–causes that are based from a person’s values and premises. And to address the last statement, thought is the process of identifying that which exists.
Other than that, I’m not saying that in all cases it takes active conceptualization to have an emotion, which was something I described earlier when I wrote about integrating values and premises and the subconscious. Edit: Also, saying “..it just means not all thoughts are conceptual” would be better stated as, “not all mental activity is conceptual.”
1 hour ago, KorbenDallas said:
I already said that emotions themselves are not where the whole cognitive process gets its start by saying they are effects from antecedental causes
Right, and that’s all you can say. I just can’t tell if you’re making a normative claim that emotion -ought- to only be caused by prior thoughts, or if it’s a descriptive claim. I don’t think it’s possible to say where emotions should come from, they’re important to getting a sense of what’s going on especially to reveal possible errors.
2 hours ago, Eiuol said:
Right, and that’s all you can say. I just can’t tell if you’re making a normative claim that emotion -ought- to only be caused by prior thoughts, or if it’s a descriptive claim. I don’t think it’s possible to say where emotions should come from, they’re important to getting a sense of what’s going on especially to reveal possible errors.
Huh? You said, “I just can’t tell if you’re making a normative claim that emotion -ought- to only be caused by prior thoughts, or if it’s a descriptive claim.” I think you need to read VOS again to answer your own question. You said, “I don’t think it’s possible to say where emotions should come from.” VOS can help you here, too. The Romantic Manifesto. The Psychology of Self-Esteem. etc. (.. your statement is false, it _is_ possible to say where emotions should come from: Reason. In fact, that is one of the main integrations of Objectivism.)
7 hours ago, KorbenDallas said:
your statement is false, it _is_ possible to say where emotions should come from: Reason. In fact, that is one of the main integrations of Objectivism.
I’m talking about you, though. My thought there was if you had a bad or wrong evaluation, it is good to have emotions. The ethical implication of emotion being caused by thinking loosely defined isn’t that there are wrong or right emotions, it’s that you should respond to or understand the emotion.
4 hours ago, Eiuol said:
I’m talking about you, though. My thought there was if you had a bad or wrong evaluation, it is good to have emotions. The ethical implication of emotion being caused by thinking loosely defined isn’t that there are wrong or right emotions, it’s that you should respond to or understand the emotion.
Oh, I certainly missed your empathy through your polemical approach, then. (Your committing yet again another straw man fallacy in the above.) It’s clear you don’t understand some of the Objectivist principles I have been speaking of.
Thinking was not loosely defined, it was defined precisely and being used on principle. The problem here is you do not understand the hierarchy between the subconscious, thinking, and emotions, which I have touched on, using Objectivist principles, and from readily available texts, but you have rejected those–rejected them then acknowledged the context of conscious mental activity, thinking, and emotions.
Existence exists, man is man, and man has a subconscious, he thinks, and has emotions. It’s up to you if you want to understand relationship of all of that–or not–it’s your choice. But arguing about it here by dropping that context does not drop it out of reality. They exist, and it’s up to you if you want to learn them. That is all.
59 minutes ago, KorbenDallas said:
Thinking was not loosely defined, it was defined precisely and being used on principle. The problem here is you do not understand the hierarchy between the subconscious, thinking, and emotions, which I have touched on, using Objectivist principles, and from readily available texts, but you have rejected those
Okay… I’ll still say you are defining -thought- too strictly, as I said already. You’ve said a lot so it’s hard to sort out all the parts that seem off, and what you mean to say.
On 12/18/2015 at 3:48 PM, Eiuol said:
Okay… I’ll still say you are defining -thought- too strictly, as I said already. You’ve said a lot so it’s hard to sort out all the parts that seem off, and what you mean to say.
I used Rand’s definition of thought, as conveyed by Barbara Branden when Barbara was with Rand. There aren’t any parts that are off, they only seem off to you for the reasons I’ve stated already.