Test of Stochastic Collapse-of-the-Wave-Function Models
Probing the Quantum Interface with the Classical and How the Q-Regime yields the C-Regime
Test of Stochastic Collapse-of-the-Wave-Function Models
Probing the Quantum Interface with the Classical and How the Q-Regime yields the C-Regime
.
Indefinite Causal Order in a Quantum Switch
I hope to return to the paper linked in this post, as well as to those in the previous post to specify their relations to physical principles in the everyday, non-quantum regime of our experience. I conjecture for now that the paper of the present post is talking of causality in the secondary, diluted sense which it is talked of by Kant in the Second Analogy of Experience of Critique of Pure Reason. There he tried to defend a principle that āall changes occur according to the law of the connection of cause and effect.ā But the primary sense of causality is not that dilute one, and anyway his proposed principle is false even in classical regimes (which is what Kant was talking about because that was all that was known of at that time). That a body is moving with no net force applied to it, hence moving in a straight line and at a constant speed, which is a rule of its change of location, does not entail some underlying cause to explain the rule. My conjecture, without having dug into the paper yet, is that the causal order it speaks of is that thin sort that Kant was grappling with and not the stronger, primary sense of cause. The primary sense of cause is one thing making some change in another thing occur. It matters for me which sort of causality is being talked about in the paper because a metaphysics should be formulated to assimilate the entire firm scientific findings of oneās era, as Kant tried for in his era and Aristotle tried for in his era.
1 hour ago, Boydstun said:
.
Indefinite Causal Order in a Quantum Switch
I hope to return to the paper linked in this post, as well as to those in the previous post to specify their relations to physical principles in the everyday, non-quantum regime of our experience. I conjecture for now that the paper of the present post is talking of causality in the secondary, diluted sense which it is talked of by Kant in the Second Analogy of Experience of Critique of Pure Reason. There he tried to defend a principle that āall changes occur according to the law of the connection of cause and effect.ā But the primary sense of causality is not that dilute one, and anyway his proposed principle is false even in classical regimes (which is what Kant was talking about because that was all that was known of at that time). That a body is moving with no net force applied to it, hence moving in a straight line and at a constant speed, which is a rule of its change of location, does not entail some underlying cause to explain the rule. My conjecture, without having dug into the paper yet, is that the causal order it speaks of is that thin sort that Kant was grappling with and not the stronger, primary sense of cause. The primary sense of cause is one thing making some change in another thing occur. It matters for me which sort of causality is being talked about in the paper because a metaphysics should be formulated to assimilate the entire firm scientific findings of oneās era, as Kant tried for in his era and Aristotle tried for in his era.
Observe the illustrations in Fig. 1. There are two distinct and separate causal chains, which diverge due to the application of the control qubit (in a superposition), and the two separate chains are in superposition, see 1(d). The A that ācausesā a B is not the same A ācausedā by a B, the As and Bs are not the same: A1 causes B1 is superposed with B2 causes A2. As such the title would appear to be misleading, the ācausal orderā is not indefinite, what is āindefiniteā is which of two different causal chains was followed.
Such titles lead to all sorts of pop science misunderstandingsā¦
Rather than make a new thread I thought I would tack this entry onto this existing thread.
quantamagazine.org: Quantum Leaps, Long Assumed to Be Instantaneous, Take Time
nature.com Letter: To catch and reverse a quantum jump mid-flight
Picture of Particle AND Wave (at the same time!)
(Although likely we should be saying particle-like AND wave-like: a wavicle.)
HT - Dan Edge
Arrival-time distribution experiments being designed for deciding between Bohmian QM and Standard QM
On 10/11/2021 at 12:33 PM, Boydstun said:
Picture of Particle AND Wave (at the same time!)
(Although likely we should be saying particle-like AND wave-like: a wavicle.)
HT - Dan Edge
10 hours ago, tadmjones said:
This article offers a different frame of interpretation of what was ācapturedā. It seems a better view of the image is to see at as capturing the interactions between lightās āenergyā and target particles , the light isnāt āseenā or imaged as exhibiting dual aspects as much as what is depicted in the image is the history of the reactions between particles and light as akin to an interference pattern.
Charmonium
This month November 2024 is the fiftieth anniversary of the discovery of the particle consisting of a charm quark with a charm anti-quark in bound states with each other.1, 2 I had completed my B.Sci. degree in physics a couple of years before, and I was delighted to see that the phenomenon of such stationary states of electrons with nuclei of the atom I had been trained in occurs also on down to sub-nuclear particles. More recently, quantum entanglement and violation of the Bell Inequality (violation implies reality of QM-spin of distinct particles in direct coordination at a distance) have also been experimentally demonstrated for charmonium (Sci. News 10/19/24, p.16).3, 4
A new accomplishment in showing how atomic quantum mechanics gives rise to ordinary macroscopic materials: showing that quantum mechanics yields the 3D relative locations of nuclei in molecules. Thanks to Prof. Eric Scerri for bringing this development to attention of attendees* at the biennial meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association last week in New Orleans.