The standard is Man qua man. Man is, and every is implies an ought. This is applicable to females and males, too.
Slogans are not philosophy.
The standard is Man qua man. Man is, and every is implies an ought. This is applicable to females and males, too.
Slogans are not philosophy.
Homosexual acts fake/evade reality , gender, biological roles, even gender specific sex organs.
This is not normal or natural…
Homosexuality (aka: connecting with another person on an intimate level) is much more normal in my book than the alternative you mention: being alone and having no desire to connect or even try to connect with real people at all.
Slogans are not philosophy.
Do you not recognize it?
every “is” implies and “ought”.
Rand said it.
She applied it to Man. My point, is that male and female, each implies an ought, too. Look at her view on femininity, masculinity, and hero worship.
She also said it this way:
“The fact that a living entity is, determines what it ought to do.”
Btw, you have a thread with the former quote in the title:
http://forum.objectivismonline.com/index.php?showtopic=10399
How does one go from the “is” of “I possess this type of sex organs” to the “ought” of “I should only use them with people who have a different type”? Is implies oughts, yeah, but the oughts of what one ought to do according to the standard of one’s own life qua oneself (including that they are human and have a certain type of genitals among other things) that I see implied by the type of sex organs one has is stuff like, “I’m a male, so I should see a urologist to make sure my plumbing down there is healthy, not a gynecologist” or “I’m a female, I should get pads or tampons to keep from staining all my nice stuff with blood on a regular basis.” Not everything that is true of humans in general is true of every single individual constituent of the group. Most people are heterosexual which can lead to them producing more humans via their sexual activities and this is largely responsible for keeping the species going, especially until artificial insemination came along, yes. However, nobody is obligated to reproduce even if most people do. There are even heterosexuals who cannot or choose not to reproduce. If one isn’t doing it for the sake of reproducing, then what functionality is missing from homosexual sex that heterosexual sex has? Yeah, you can’t do vaginal intercourse without both male and female parts, but that is merely one way among many that one can achieve the goal of creating physical pleasure and having intimate interactions. I’m not aware of any evidence either that vaginal intercourse has a much greater capacity to produce these pleasurable things than any other sexual acts. Furthermore, sex between people of the same sex doesn’t prevent them from reproducing anyway, not any more than masturbation does. The mere fact that one would not exist in the first place without heterosexual sex and reproduction leading the creation of themself and their ancestors I don’t even see any relevance to here either. After all, if somebody was born to a rape victim that wouldn’t mean they were obligated to rape people because they wouldn’t exist without rape.
My point, is that male and female, each implies an ought, too.
What kind of ought is implied by the “is” of homosexual male or homosexual female?
You are taking male and female as observations of “is”. Fair enough.
However, you’re implicitly saying that “homosexual male” is not an “is”.
What about “fat male”, or “thin male” or “black male”… surely you see that these are “is”-es, and they each imply some type of “ought”.
Do you not recognize it?
every “is” implies and “ought”.
Rand said it.
She applied it to Man. My point, is that male and female, each implies an ought, too. Look at her view on femininity, masculinity, and hero worship.
She also said it this way:
“The fact that a living entity is, determines what it ought to do.”
Secondhander dealt with this ‘argument’ thoughtfully and thoroughly here: http://forum.objectivismonline.com/index.php?showtopic=25156&p=308005
Rather than confront this argument, you simply moved to a new thread without those posts in it, and kept repeating the same one-liners.
Considering that you reasserted this argument:
OPAR: “To respect sex means to approach it objectively”
“Sex is the preeminent form of bringing love into physical reality”
“This excludes…any form of…faking”
I would think this is applicable to gender, biological roles of the two sexes qua man, qua woman.
Homosexual acts fake/evade reality, gender, biological roles, even gender specific sex organs.
For example:
Females strapped on a strap-on - faking the role of a man has as penetrator, etc
Male poop chute is faking the role of a vag and a man has become the penetrated, etc.
This is not normal or natural. Human biology, human sexual reproduction evidences that. Man qua man is heterosexual and it’s a concern for psychology to deal with primarily if there is a deviation from that, or for philosophy as in hedonism/subjectivism, or them being “broken units”, etc. It indicates something is not normal, not natural, something is wrong somewhere.
You need to confront Secondhander’s reducto ad absurdum here:
To help illustrate where you go wrong with your affirmation of the is-ought problem: Do you think that a woman is morally wrong if she chooses not to have children, because a woman “is” biologically built to get pregnant and have children, so that’s what she “ought” to do? Do you think a man is morally wrong if he chooses not to have sex or not to have children? Do you think anal sex is morally wrong for heterosexual couples, since the rectum “is” meant for waste disposal, therefore it “ought” not be used for anything else? Do you think that wearing a condom is morally wrong, since semen “is” biologically designed to fertilize an egg, so that’s what you “ought” to do in sex? Do you believe that you should not kiss anyone, since the lips, tongue and mouth “is” designed for speaking and tasting and eating food, so you “ought” not touch lips and tongues to someone else’s? Tongues qua tongues are normally and naturally for tasting purposes, after all.
If you affirm the is-ought problem, then you run into all these sorts of problems. And Ayn Rand was not blanketly affirming that an “is” constituted an “ought.”
heh, pseudo monosexuality, mental masturbation
I am very much a mono-homo, exceptionally attracted to macho male homo sapiens. Primarly seeking monogamous mojo with said entities.
  
I am very much a mono-homo, exceptionally attracted to macho male homo sapiens. Primarly seeking monogamous mojo with said entities.
I did not mean to imply anything, just a poor attempt at semantic humor about you not caring about the responses to your posts. I am less objective than Archimedes when it comes to boats and floating, he figured it out , I say whatever
OPAR: “There is no dichotomy between existence and reality. To be, for a man, is to be a man”
Right. I think this is applicable to gender, as well.
I am a man. She is a woman. These are facts of reality, the metaphysically biologically given. Man has a certain nature and should act accordingly, men and women have a certain nature specifically to them, too, one example is gender specific parts.
From my post #124, “How does one go from the ‘is’ of ‘I possess this type of sex organs’ to the ‘ought’ of ‘I should only use them with people who have a different type’?” I went on to more details in that post.
I am a human being, is the biologically given. My feelings do not change that.
I am a man, not a woman- is the biologically given. My feelings do not change that.
I am a man, and so I have a certain biological role in human sexual reproduction. My feelings do not change that role.
A man and a woman have certain biological roles in human sexual reproduction. That is the biologically given. My feelings do not change that.
Both are heterosexual is the biologically given.
Same-sex “sex”, or even with different species (as evidenced by zootube365 site if you don’t believe it occurs), is going against their biologically given roles. Feelings don’t change that.
But, one can have feelings such as “I’m really a woman” while clearly a man. Or I have feelings or an attraction to same-sex. Those feelings don’t change the biologically given.
Is man able to have sex with a man? I don’t think they can, but they can fellate and one can use ones own rectum to stimulate the other guys penis or allow him to, masturbate the other guy with one’s own hand, etc. Their biological role in sex, is sex with a woman. The sex organs evidence that. Human sexual intercourse, copulation, cannot take place between same-sex. Only between penis and vag.
What if they are two consenting males that want to partake in such acts? Legally no one can stop it, because no force is being initiated.
I am a man, and so I have a certain biological role in human sexual reproduction. My feelings do not change that role.
A man and a woman have certain biological roles in human sexual reproduction. That is the biologically given. My feelings do not change that.
Gender roles are societal or cultural, and therefore not metaphysically given. Saying a man has a role in sexual reproduction, while true, doesn’t make him duty bound or morally obligated to fill that role according to Objectivist ethics. Reproduction is not the standard.
I am a human being, is the biologically given. My feelings do not change that.
I am a man, not a woman- is the biologically given. My feelings do not change that.
I am a man, and so I have a certain biological role in human sexual reproduction. My feelings do not change that role.
A man and a woman have certain biological roles in human sexual reproduction. That is the biologically given. My feelings do not change that.
Both are heterosexual is the biologically given.
Actually, just to point out, it doesn’t even follow that both are heterosexual. I don’t think there is a such thing as a heterosexual species. You don’t have evidence that *attraction for humans* is normally heterosexual, but of course it is true society tends to determine prescribe what is appropriate attraction. All you said is the opposite sex is needed to make a baby. Heterosexuality is just a 20th century invention basically, if you want to get specific about it. Cite research if you want any of your claims to matter regarding *sexuality* which is largely a psychological matter.
While I have been looking around on the web some, I found a comment by someone that says:
" You should be happy to know that near the end of her life, Harry Binswanger asked AR if she still believed that homosexuality was immoral. She said, “No.” This is the reason that Robert Mayhew did not include AR’s earlier condemnation of homosexuality. It was a position she no longer held. I learned both of these facts directly from asking HB and RM."
http://www.atlassociety.org/homosexuality-moral
This also has a reference to Binswanger asking Rand and what he say she said:
http://www.noblesoul.com/orc/bio/biofaq.html#Q5.2.6
" Reports of private conversations held before and after these answers were given indicate that she sometimes expressed a more qualified position, stating that because the psychological origins of homosexuality were not clearly understood, blanket moral condemnation would be inappropriate. For example, Harry Binswanger described her attitude thusly:
I asked her privately (circa 1980) specifically whether she thought it was immoral. She said that we didn’t know enough about the development of homosexuality in a person’s psychology to say that it would have to involve immorality.
When I look at reality, only men and women can have sexual intercourse. Same-sex “sex” is merely stimulating same sex partners sexual organs. Being that only men and women can have sexual intercourse, sexual attraction would then be towards opposite sex, not towards same sex, so that’s why we are normally and naturally heterosexual. But I will have to explore that more. As I said I’m trying to look at the facts of reality and go from there, that what Rand did to discover Mans Nature, so I’m trying to do that in regards to male and females.<br /><br />On this site:<br />http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Objectivism_and_homosexuality<br /><br />Binswanger says that Rand when in an especially good mood would adopt a modified view on homosexuality. This strikes me as odd, her judgment is pronounced according to mood?
Being that only men and women can have sexual intercourse, sexual attraction would then be towards opposite sex, not towards same sex, so that’s why we are normally and naturally heterosexual.
This is rationalism.
You still have not confronted the previous dissections of your arguments, or even acknowledged that they exist.
Might not this be a classic case in helping to understanding induction, at what point in human history did man realize sexual intercourse results in reproduction?
(Coming late to this discussion; maybe this is redundant.)
#135 as it stands is, like Branden’s arguments of yore, hopelessly circular. If you start from the premise that heterosexuality is the naturally obligatory and not merely statistical norm, binding on everybody regardless of inclination, the conclusion follows easily enough that homosexuality is - phrase it as you will - sinful, but that doesn’t buy you much.
Such arguments from Objectivists are also internally inconsistent. Nothing is more natural about heterosexual acts than that they conceive children. If you approve of abortion or of masturbation or of contraception, including elective surgery, or of sex between partners who by virtue of age, illness or injury are unable to conceive, then this argument from natural destiny sinks. The traditional Catholic position (abortion, masturbation and contraception are all sins against nature) may not have much going for it, but it’s almost true to itself (except the part about sex acts by couples unable to make babies).
P.S. Add to the above list: non-standard means of ingress by otherwise-qualifying heterosexual couples.
When I look at reality, only men and women can have sexual intercourse. Same-sex “sex” is merely stimulating same sex partners sexual organs. Being that only men and women can have sexual intercourse, sexual attraction would then be towards opposite sex, not towards same sex, so that’s why we are normally and naturally heterosexual.
This seems like a non-sequitur to me. The stimulation of sex organs is precisely the point of sexual intercourse, 9 times out of 10. This serves the life-affirming spiritual purpose of reifying the respect and admiration that two people have for each other. This is the fundamental purpose of sex to most people. Can you please explain why people with matching sex organs can’t do this?
And please consider that you can’t magic away the feelings of sexual attraction that gay people have for each other. You’re treating such concretes as abstract ideas that can be redefined. They can’t; they are very real things of chemistry, physics, mind and spirit. This hormonal attraction is a requirement of any appropriate sexual encounter; homosexual attraction can and does fulfill this requirement.
What kind of ought is implied by the “is” of homosexual male or homosexual female?
You are taking male and female as observations of “is”. Fair enough.
However, you’re implicitly saying that “homosexual male” is not an “is”.
What about “fat male”, or “thin male” or “black male”… surely you see that these are “is”-es, and they each imply some type of “ought”.
Question: How far and wide can a man cast the net of is and out? When do you use is/out?. Can a man decide what his identity is? If man’s life is his standard can he refuse and say his life is not his standard of being? How about someone who modifies or changes their sexuality because of a traumatic event with a certain gender. I know these are basic questions but having this as an example to reflect upon will help me understand it better.