Sorry about my spelling it is the bane of my existence.
Question: How far and wide can a man cast the net of is and out?
When it comes to concretes, we have to discover what we are and what is good for us, through all sorts of knowledge-gaining techniques. Even on something as fundamental as food, science has changed so much (and is still unsettled) on the question of “what is good for us”? Some rules (“eat this, don’t eat that”) may not apply universally to all humans. Perhaps one day we’ll be able to understand a particular human being and say “You should eat more bacon and less eggs”, while giving the exact opposite advice to someone else.
On the topic of homosexuality, I really have no well-developed opinion on its causes or nature. I only posted to this thread because I noticed a post saying that Objectivism was negative toward homosexuality, and providing no evidence for this. Anyone arguing against homosexuality needs to provide some evidence and some argument. Saying that “is implies an ought” or that “man must live qua man” is not an argument. Anyone making an “argument” like that is simply begging the question. He has already decided that homosexuality is either bad, or is less than the ideal good; but, this is the point to be proven, not to be assumed away. One cannot discover a concrete like that from philosophical principles, any more than one can discover what foods are nutritious. (In general, starting from broad abstractions and trying to fit concretes into them with scant evidence that they belong is the core of dogmatism – or, more technically – intrinsicism.)
Now, when the person arguing against homosexuality talks about the evolutionary importance of sex, that finally starts to be in the right ballpark as far as the *type* of argument goes. At least now we’re starting to examine facts rather than simply shove a concrete into an extremely broad philosophical principle, with scant evidence. Similarly, asking whether people are born homosexual or not is also a proper attempt to get knowledge; but, even if we discover that people are always born heterosexual, that – on its own – would not be all we need to know.
An individual does not have to wait around until science is conclusive. He has to decide if he is going to eat pasta, legumes, bacon, tuna… etc. When there’s so much conflicting evidence around, he has to figure out a way in which he will judge its validity, and has to proceed with the understanding that he could be wrong. In the case of homosexuality, I do not know of any strong evidence one way or the other. What is a person to do in such a case? The rational approach is to start by asking “Does this make me happy?”. In other words, ask what value you gain from something. Do not ask “what does a human being gain”, ask “what do I gain?” This is how one *starts* the process inductively, rather than dogmatically. One starts from the concrete: which is YOU, the individual (or a particular friend who is homosexual, etc.), and then one expands out from there. Of course, you must also ask: “does this harm me in any way?”, “what am I losing from this?”, “Is there some other value that would give me more?”.
If something makes you happy, then you can probably also tie it back to your overall values, in a more abstract way. One does not need much thought for every tiny thing, but definitely for important values, or things on which one is spending a lot of resources. As humans we need to understand how it fits into our life… into our overall hierarchy of values. Have you read Rand’s essay on stamp-collecting? Stamp collecting obviously made her happy, and she gave it some thought to understand why. The essay is her explanation. If something makes you happy and is not harmful, nor is taking up valuable time and resources that are better spent on other pursuits, then what’s left to ask?
Question: How far and wide can a man cast the net of is and out? When do you use is/out?
Well, “X is therefor X(or something associated with X) ought” is not logical. It’s an arbitrary statement. When Ayn Rand says “The fact that a living entity is, determines what it ought to do.”, that’s not the claim she is making.
She is saying that there are certain conditions required for life. That, if we choose values based on what those conditions are, then there is no such thing as an is-ought dichotomy.
But that’s it: life. Specifically, an individual’s own life. That is the only IS she is referring to. She isn’t referring to anyone’s penis, or a chair, or a species, or any other random object or concept as the reasoning behing her OUGHTs. In fact, she makes it very clear that the ONE AND ONLY PREMISE it is appropriate to deduce any OUGHTs from is “whatever is required to further one’s own life”.
When someone says that a penis ought to only go into a vagina, because of the way penises and vaginas are shaped, or because of how a species reproduces, or whatever other reason they list, that’s not Objectivist Ethics (it’s obviously not selfishness, where one’s own life is the only source of one’s values). According to Objectivism, the only valid reason for any OUGHT is “because it furthers an individual’s life”. Not the shape of the penis, not the species, not society, not fellow man, not God, not your cat, not your whims, etc. etc.
As to whether acting on and embracing being gay does or does not further one’s life, that must be settled through the study of facts. I would think that there are plenty of happy, accomplished gay people around so that we can, at this point, conclude that embracing homosexuality can in fact be a rational, moral choice. It’s a choice that can indeed further an individual’s life, and therefor it is perfectly logical to say that gay people ought to be gay, not straight. In fact, whether being gay comes from nature or nurture is also irrelevant to the validity of that statement.
Regarding the trans-sexuality question, again: we must look at the facts. I have not seen the kind of evidence that it works that I’ve seen regarding being gay, but that’s because it’s a rare, new phenomenon. It remains to be seen.
Same-sex are biologically sexually incompatible because they have the same sex organs, etc. So they improvise. Nature be damned.
Just how “normal and natural” is that?
Just how moral is that?
Just how much like sexual hedonism does it sound like?
I don’t care if we are biologically sexually incompatible, I have feelings for same-sex, or I have feelings for different species. Nature be damned. I’ll fellate same-sex, or fellate different species (horse, dog) because I have feelings for them.
Homosexuals can only be said to be “sexually incompatible” if you are talking about reproduction. But we’ve already dispensed with the myth that sex is primarily about reproduction. I’ll continue to take your silence on that point as acceptance of it.
The only sexual compatibility that matters is a mutual combination of sexual arousal, respect and admiration. Fellating a different species couldn’t fulfill the purpose of reifying a mutual respect and admiration. Fellating a human being can serve that purpose, as evidenced by heterosexual couples. To my knowledge, men and women have the same mouths. Ergo, homosexuals can reify respect and admiration through fellatio.
It seems that your task, if you disagree, is to show why penis-vagina penetration is necessary to reify love. I’m willing to listen to that argument.
I don’t regard oral stimulation of a penis as sex. Using one’s own anal cavity to stimulate a penis, I do not regard as sex. I do not regard such oral or anal activity as sex, regardless if its occurring between same-sex or opposite gender. Human sex only can take place between a man and a woman. Human sexuality is heterosexual in nature, human biology evidences this. Just because same-sex partners can stimulate their partners sex organs various ways, does not mean it’s normal and natural. Sex is bringing love into physical reality, as OPAR says. How can same-sex bring that into physical reality, when they cannot physically have sex to begin with?
Homosexuality, bisexuality are not sexual orientations. They are hedonism, they are psychological issues, etc.
…, … etc.
Your post contains a series of assertions and one appeal to authority. No scintilla of an argument.
I don’t regard oral stimulation of a penis as sex. Using one’s own anal cavity to stimulate a penis, I do not regard as sex. I do not regard such oral or anal activity as sex, regardless if its occurring between same-sex or opposite gender. Human sex only can take place between a man and a woman. Human sexuality is heterosexual in nature, human biology evidences this. Just because same-sex partners can stimulate their partners sex organs various ways, does not mean it’s normal and natural. Sex is bringing love into physical reality, as OPAR says. How can same-sex bring that into physical reality, when they cannot physically have sex to begin with?
Homosexuality, bisexuality are not sexual orientations. They are hedonism, they are psychological issues, etc.
As to your working definition of sex, that’s what Bill C said.
Personally I think the definition of sex has to include the idea of stimulation of the sex organs with the intent of acheiving orgasm.
It seems also you are trying to stay with the is/ought argument as it applies to your use of the terms normal and natural. How would ‘normal’ behaviour be understood without accepting the notion of innate ideas?
Nicky wrote: “homosexuality can in fact be a rational, moral choice”
What is so rational and moral about it?
How is one able to have sexual desire towards someone they cannot even physically have sex with?
Sexual desire, sexual attraction, sexual orientation, romantic love, are only possible between opposite genders. All the rest are hedonism, psychological issues.
If one shares common interest and core values with same-sex that is a great basis for a friendship, not a trip to the bedroom together.
IntellectualAmmo,
You’ve said human sex can only occur between a man and a woman. You’ve also shown some knowledge about Objectivism’s take on sex. You’ve basically offered two descriptions:
1)Sex is, physically speaking, a penis penetrating a vagina and nothing else.
2)Sex is the act of bringing love into reality.
Now, which one hits closer to the definition? Biologically speaking, I’d say #1 - so long as the act culminates in conception… But we’ve already dispensed with baby-making as the purpose of sex; we certainly can’t use it to deduce the second statement.
So what if we’re not talking about making babies, but rather the role of sex in the life of a rational being? Which statement is closer to the definition of sex? I think the answer is clearly #2. Working from that description, can you please show me (step by step) how you deduce that penile penetration of the vagina is necessary?
Edit: I ask because if one statement implies the other, you should be able to induce or deduce freely between them. So far you’ve failed to show the connection from 1 to 2. Maybe you’ll have better luck showing the connection from 2 to 1.
This thread is a revealing display of the utter lack of intellectual justification for the position that homosexuality is immoral. It doesn’t get more rationalistic than this:
I don’t regard oral stimulation of a penis as sex. Using one’s own anal cavity to stimulate a penis, I do not regard as sex. I do not regard such oral or anal activity as sex, regardless if its occurring between same-sex or opposite gender. Human sex only can take place between a man and a woman. Human sexuality is heterosexual in nature, human biology evidences this.
What is so rational and moral about it?
How is one able to have sexual desire towards someone they cannot even physically have sex with?
Sexual desire, sexual attraction, sexual orientation, romantic love, are only possible between opposite genders. All the rest are hedonism, psychological issues.
‘I define sex as only between a man and a woman… so how could same-sex couples possibly have sexual desire for one another? I’ve defined it away!’
The best part is pretending to cite evidence by simply referencing ‘human biology.’ Quality, in-depth support that.
Rand:
" Romantic love, in the full sense of the term, is an emotion possible only to the man (or woman) of unbreached self-esteem: it is his response to his own highest values in the person of another—an integrated response of mind and body, of love and sexual desire. Such a man (or woman) is incapable of experiencing a sexual desire divorced from spiritual values."
Or divorced from gender, may I add. Only a man and a woman are capable of experiencing this together, not same-sex.
Rand:
" Romantic love, in the full sense of the term, is an emotion possible only to the man (or woman) of unbreached self-esteem: it is his response to his own highest values in the person of another—an integrated response of mind and body, of love and sexual desire. Such a man (or woman) is incapable of experiencing a sexual desire divorced from spiritual values."
Or divorced from gender, may I add. Only a man and a woman are capable of experiencing this together, not same-sex.
An appeal to authority on one subject, to rationalize a different topic.
IntellectualAmmo, if you have not listened to the “Understanding Objectivism” lectures, I strongly recommend them. I would say, drop everything else Objectivism-related and study those.
Nicky wrote: “homosexuality can in fact be a rational, moral choice”
What is so rational and moral about it?
Wasn’t it Rand who said that moral issues presuppose a choice? That’s relevant here because if sexual orientation is not a choice, it cannot be considered moral or immoral- it just is. So that is the first question to answer, before making any moral judgments: is homosexuality a choice? From what I’ve read, sexual orientation has a genetic and hormonal basis. (Maybe others who have researched this more will be able to provide individual research links.) If this assertion is true, there can be no debate about the morality of sexual orientation- but what we can discuss is the morality of acting on these feelings.
If sexual orientation is not a choice, it’s not a moral issue- meaning, ‘heterosexuality’ and ‘homosexuality’ are not equivalent to ‘right’ and ‘wrong.’ However, the choices you make about your sexual partners is a moral issue, and is context dependent. To me, it makes sense to act according to your nature and do what makes you happy. If you’re only attracted to people of the same gender, why would you force yourself to sleep with someone of the opposite sex? Similarly, if you’re only attracted to people of the opposite gender, why would you sleep with someone of the same sex? There’s no reason for either one- no reason to force yourself to be a square when you are, in fact, a circle. It’s in this sense that we can make moral judgments: is pursuing X or Y moral? If so, why? If not, why not? It should be done on a case by case basis, and context will always matter.
It’s in these case by case situations that moral judgments can be made- and Rand’s texts about romantic love and sex can be very valuable.
Or divorced from gender, may I add.
Does not follow. You’re skipping steps… What are they, please?
Wasn’t it Rand who said that moral issues presuppose a choice? That’s relevant here because if sexual orientation is not a choice, it cannot be considered moral or immoral- it just is. So that is the first question to answer, before making any moral judgments: is homosexuality a choice? From what I’ve read, sexual orientation has a genetic and hormonal basis. (Maybe others who have researched this more will be able to provide individual research links.) If this assertion is true, there can be no debate about the morality of sexual orientation- but what we can discuss is the morality of acting on these feelings.
Well, personally I would say any psychological matter has choice involved. So, to that extent, sexuality of any kind is a choice, just a great many choices involved to end up as one sexuality or the other. Genetics and hormones probably have a notable impact on the psychology of sexuality, but that won’t mean there is no choice whatsoever. The more important point is that it isn’t immoral anyway. In fact, to look at history. the ancient Greeks didn’t have a word for homosexuality, and love between the same sex wasn’t seen as abnormal at least. Sexuality as a subject is not so simple as to even talk about what is biologically normal or typical, because sexuality is only really relevant to who you choose to have a relationship with. Sexuality simply doesn’t apply to frogs, or insects, or birds, sex for them is only a function of procreation even if sex can and does happen outside of that for any animal. Humans too. But add in conceptual thought and human emotion, there is even less reason to suggest sexual relationships are immoral or bad. Stated another way, sexuality doesn’t have to be connected to procreation, even if it does have implications on procreation.
I also thought of IA’s post suggesting non-vaginal sex isn’t “really” sex. That’s basically making sex between, say, two men by definition is immoral and faking reality before even defining our terms and reasoning. The conclusion has been made, and any evidence is ad-hoc rationalism. I was listening to Peikoff’s “Unity in Ethics and Epistemology” and he discussed anyone who may say altruist morality isn’t “really” morality. You know how the idea goes - if morality is acting in your self-interest, then a altruism can’t be morality in any sense! But this totally ignores how one reaches a concept of morality. Your inductive material has to include any means or belief to be good, even altruism. Later though, you can figure out what is a proper morality, yet that doesn’t mean altruism ceases to be a morality. If anything, any argument of “it’s not really X” is an epistemological nightmare. All it does is suggest a dogmatism of declaring your definitions to be the only ones that should be discussed, everyone else is simply wrong and pursuing “fake” morality. Just change it to “fake” sexuality, and you’ve got the same thing. The issue is there is not even a half-decent argument to suggest there is a proper sexuality in the first place.
But jeez, I’m glad writer1972’s post was deleted. That was just… wildly over the top.
Rand:
“Intellectually and morally, I.e, as a human being, she has to be his equal; then the object of her worship is specifically his masculinity”
“Her worship is an abstract emotion for the metaphysical concept of masculinity itself”
His gender, his maleness, his masculinity, his manhood - a man!
Not another woman, not womanness, not femininity, not womanhood - a man!
Not another species’ male- not big thick horse cock, not dog dick, but a man’s dick!
To a female a woman qua woman whose essence is femininity, a male a man qua man, him being a male his masculinity, is of such value significance to her it’s indispensable in romantic love and of course sex.
Female with male, woman qua woman with man qua man - is normal, natural, and proper for Man. Same-sex together and different species together are both psychologically improper, immoral. And if its hedonism, it’s immoral.
Human sexuality has a biological basis as evidenced by the gender specific sex organs and their purpose and function in human sexual reproduction, copulation. This does not change on the conceptual level. Masculinity is “male” writ large and femininity is “female” writ large. Male should want female, a man qua man should want a woman qua woman. Gender/Sex/sexual identity of a human does not “disappear” on the conceptual level, it’s writ large, it’s a higher view of the biologically given the metaphysically given, not a disposing of it altogether. But even more demanding of it. Never losing awareness of one’s sex and the sex of others.
Rands novels all had such human sexuality in them. Man and woman, male and female.
Leo:
[…]he glanced at a woman his eyes told her that he was a man and she was a woman and he remembered it.
Eiul wrote: " I also thought of IA’s post suggesting non-vaginal sex isn’t “really” sex."
Only men and women are sexually compatible. Their sex organs, their gender were biologically made for one another, not for same-sex. Just because you can put a mouth around a penis, or cram it up a poop chute, or use one’s tongue on clit/vulva, etc does not mean that that is sex. It should not be considered that. I think it would be a stolen concept. A mouth, a tongue, hand, ass, etc are not technically sexually compatible. Only a penis and vagina are. Sex is short for sexual intercourse. Calling anything else that is fallacy of the stolen concept. Stimulating a penis by hand, mouth, ass is not sex.
Peikoff regards masturbation as sex.
I think we need to look at that more closely epistemologically, define terms correctly.
You haven’t shown the steps, sir. You’ve repeated the assertions of an authority along with your own. I will grant you that Rand’s descriptions of this type of relationship jive perfectly with the idea that proper human sexuality is about reifying respect and admiration. Her example of masculinity/femininity serves as a concrete example. She has not, to my knowledge, shown why she thinks this is the only way to do that. Your task, then, is still to show your work. You’re not getting credit for this assignment without it.
And I didn’t want to have to get this personal, but goddammit, I’ve accomplished this type of reification without strict biological intercourse. Sometimes you just don’t have protection at hand, and the result can be just as satisfying - physically, hormonally, emotionally, spiritually.
Edit2: PS: Rand never herself went as far as saying you needed the papa bits to enter the mama bits.
I admittedly have had my dick up two women’s poop chutes before, and the best sex I ever had was with a married female from Myanmar (who I was having sex with over a period of weeks) because of how sweet and petite her sexy little body was and had a pretty face and best kisser I have ever had the pleasure of being with, she’d latch on, and… anyways, that was in my 20’s and it didn’t have much to do with her as a person, just her body. One can be in romantic love and not have good sex. It’s an integration of mind and body. But it makes sense that the best sex I had body wise could have been even more pleasurable if I would have taken The Selfish Path to Romance with her, instead of the path that led to it initially. I guess that would mean it was disintegrated then. No wonder it didn’t work.
Mdegges: Peikoff said in a podcast on homosexuality that he thinks sexuality was formed subconsciously during early childhood. Not sure of just how much of a choice then he thinks a person has in the matter.