I’m unclear on this point. Are you saying you don’t think penis/vagina interaction is essential to the love-making process?
No, just sharing personal experience. I shared personal experience in the other thread as well.
I have been looking at what Peikoff talks about with the subconscious in OPAR and its relation to value-judgments.
“Ones value judgments, like one’s past knowledge, are present in the subconscious - meaning by this term a store of the mental contents one has acquired by conscious means, but which are not in conscious awareness at a given time. Under the appropriate conditions, the mind applies such contents to a new object automatically and instantaneously, without the need of further conscious consideration. To many people, as a result, it seems a if men perceive and then feel, with no intervening factor. The truth is that a chain of ideas and value-judgments intervened.”
Said “value-judgments do not exist in a vacuum. Value-judgments are formed ultimately on the basis of a philosophic view of man and of life - of oneself of others, of the universe; such a view, therefore, conditions one’s emotions”
“The fact that a man has a certain feeling means merely that, through some kind of process, he earlier reached a certain idea, which is now stored in his subconscious; this leaves completely open the question of the ideas relationship to reality”
So just how does it apply to human sexuality?
Intellectualammo, are you going to answer any of the points raised against your vague arguments? Are you going to clarify your arguments in your own words? Or are you just going to copy-and-paste Objectivist quotes…
I am trying to strengthen them.
Yes, well, several people have pointed out that you’re just rationalizing instead of providing logical basis, and they’ve even quoted examples of you doing this. That would be what I mean when I say you haven’t responded with anything but quotes. A quote alone is no argument if objections have been raised which need explaining.
Rand:
" Romantic love, in the full sense of the term, is an emotion possible only to the man (or woman) of unbreached self-esteem: it is his response to his own highest values in the person of another—an integrated response of mind and body, of love and sexual desire. Such a man (or woman) is incapable of experiencing a sexual desire divorced from spiritual values."
Or divorced from gender, may I add. Only a man and a woman are capable of experiencing this together, not same-sex.
Argh.
I find all of these floating topics on gender and sexuality so very frustrating. But listen, IA, to you or anyone else – if you’d like to establish that homosexuality is morally wrong, I don’t think it should be very hard to do. All that I’d ask is that you take the following and run with it:
“Homosexuality is morally wrong, because for a man to have sex with other men will necessarily destroy his life in the following ways…”
Ideally you complete that sentence with all of the ways in which such behavior will destroy the man, and then offer proof for your claims (or at least plausible-sounding argumentation). And this is the pattern for anything else, as well. If a claim is being made for “masculinity” vs. “femininity,” then I’d like to see how acting in masculine fashion is necessarily better for a man – how it benefits his life in the same way that, say, being productive does – and how to act contrary to this is a self-destructive course.
Because that is the point to the Objectivist Ethics. It is not a game whereby we all strive to tell one another how to live (let alone to tell someone that he is somehow using his penis incorrectly). It is rather a tool that a man uses to try to live the happiest, best life possible. A homosexual Objectivist would also like to be as happy as possible. And if you can make the case that his homosexuality is getting in his way, and is courting pain, unhappiness, death, I am sure that such a man would listen to your well-meaning suggestions on how he can live better.
But if you cannot offer that? If it seems like you’re just making pronouncements on how “things ought to be,” not to improve anybody’s life exactly, or specifically, but just because you’ve come to some general conclusions based on the shape of the vagina, or the proportion of man’s musculature, or something? If it seems like you have no specifics to offer by way of proof or reasoning? If you can offer no actual roadmap by which a homosexual Objectivist can improve his life? And if it seems as though to take you seriously would make such men much less happy and fulfilled in their actual lives?
Then the best course is to treat you (or anyone else making similar presentations) as someone who does not actually understand the Objectivist Ethics, but who instead tries to use it to smuggle in his own vision of “how things ought to be” without regard to actual human happiness, or reason, or reality.
Please comment on this article and what the Objectivist answer to this will be:
http://www.advocate.com/commentary/2013/04/01/op-ed-guess-what-%E2%80%94-were-oppressors
Please comment on this article and what the Objectivist answer to this will be:
http://www.advocate.com/commentary/2013/04/01/op-ed-guess-what-—-were-oppressors
Face value, Christians are using bad laws to their advantage just as gays and countless other people do. Ideally, there wouldn’t be laws restricting employers’ business decisions about employment incentives like healthcare. Ideally, government wouldn’t have a big, heavy hand in the healthcare industry creating false incentives for employers to offer healthcare packages – then prompting yet more bad laws and restrictions. But reality is currently not ideal, so the best course of action is blurred.
The same goes for hate crime laws and civil rights laws and anti-descrimination laws. Law should be limited and precise and based on promoting freedom of individuals, no matter how nice or terrible the individuals may be. But laws aren’t always like that currently, and religion has a strong influence on government, and for those reasons I am tentatively for laws which protect gays in particular and which keep church out of government. So, I would side against the religious group in this case. And if the choice is to support a less than ideal law, an Objectivist would provide his reasons and also make it clear that he is actually for the strict protection of individual rights, and nothing more.
I find understanding things very important. So important that I do not care so much that I agree or disagree with something as long as I can understand it. I sincerely appreciate your posts softwareNerd & Nicky. I had the experience similar to a lens which were out of focus but then suddenly the picture came into view.
Very interesting post JASKN. I sometime imagine the experience that I can almost taste words. Odd experience really. And you always use the most delightful words. In this case I rather enjoyed the words ‘Ideally’, ‘tentatively’ and ‘strict’ which had the most peculiar taste, very peculiar. But thank you for the reply and I enjoyed the understanding.
The article uses the example of a business owner refusing service and treats the refusal as wrong on the face of it. I would support his right to operate his business, even if he refused myself or people like me. The refusal of services is not a rights violation. Equality before the law should be a fundamental principle in a civilised society. When the article speaks to equality I wholeheartedly agree, but service refusal is being smuggled in as a rights violation, those who argue on principles of recognising and protecting individual rights have my full support and agreement but this article blurs that distinction. I doubt the author sees the distinction but blurs in nonetheless.
I didn’t read it but on the top of the page the link directs you to is an article about a florist being sued for a similar sounding action.
Wikipedia for the rescue - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Objectivism_and_homosexuality - namely, as I recalled, Ayn Rand personally considered homosexuality as “disgusting”, but did not condone taking government action against homesexual intercourse between two consenting adults.
Regarding gay marriage - I think the main issue here is the fact that the law treats married couples differently than non-married ones (as someone told me in a chat I had on http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freenode ), and that in countries such as Denmark the number of children born among non-married couples has exceeded the number of children born under an oath of marriage (and life there happily goes on). The law should not care whether two adults are married or not, or just living together and having a relationship, and marriage can be just a standard civil and/or religious ceremony which only symbolises a couple’s long-term commitment for one another.
That’s not all marriage is; it’s also an enforceable contract for sexual exclusivity, the pooling of financial resources, inheritance rights, responsibility for children and more; it grants the partners privilege in court. Thus, like the formalization of any contract, it’s the state’s business.
(How much that contract ought to look like the one couples make today is a separate question.)
Every Objectivist I’ve met in real life has been rather homophobic. I was just wondering what (if anything) Ayn Rand said about homosexuality. What is Objectivism’s views on gays/gay rights in general?
Queen Capitalist,
While I can’t speak to what may have shaped the views of the unknown number of “rather homophobic” Objectivists you met in ‘real live’, I have an idea about what might have heavily influenced Ayn Rand’s view on the topic as well as the views of many from her generation.
While the dynamics of heterosexual relationships have been continuously written about, in one form or another, since the beginning of human history, homosexual relationships, and opinions about them, were largely “closeted” since Classical Greco-Roman times. This is likely the cause of any perceived conflict people from AR’s generation would have seen between homosexuality and Objectivism.
Specifically, Greco-Roman philosophers tended to describe ALL sexual relationships in terms of power, which one partner dominating the other and expressing his (always his) power over the other. In many cases sex was not even described as being enjoyable for either party, but merely as a way for the “dominant” party to express his power over the submissive man or woman.
Following the Greco-Roman period, more enlightened views on relationships emerged which were more in line with the ‘relationship between equals, done for mutual enjoyment’ that Dagny Taggart and other Objectivist heroines engaged in.
Unfortunately, Homosexuality became “closeted” shortly after the end of the Greco-Roman period and remained so until after Ayn Rand’s death. Therefore, the only philosophy Ayn Rand, and others from her generation would have been exposed to on the subject of homosexuality would have been coming from the Greeks and Romans and would have involved such things as philosophical justifications for essentially raping male subordinates to maintain the masters dominance. As this is completely incompatible with Enlightenment Morality, Western thought, and Objectivism, it’s no wonder that many from Rand’s generation formed negative opinions of homosexuality.
Hopefully, now that homosexuality is no longer “closeted”, more modern thoughts can be formed on these relationships and the perception regarding them will change.
BTW; I’m a heterosexual who’s engaged to the love of his life…
Unfortunately, Homosexuality became “closeted” shortly after the end of the Greco-Roman period and remained so until after Ayn Rand’s death. Therefore, the only philosophy Ayn Rand, and others from her generation would have been exposed to on the subject of homosexuality would have been coming from the Greeks and Romans and would have involved such things as philosophical justifications for essentially raping male subordinates to maintain the masters dominance. As this is completely incompatible with Enlightenment Morality, Western thought, and Objectivism, it’s no wonder that many from Rand’s generation formed negative opinions of homosexuality.
Rand has a reputation for “cutting the crap” to get to the heart of ideas. She meticulously dissects and proves, followed by refuting any objections with hard fast reason. This is why people give her the benefit of the doubt on the subject of sexuality. Unfortunately, rationalism tends to trump the recognition that she, too, was only human and capable of overlooking something, or capable of just plain error in thinking. It’s unfortunate that she didn’t live long enough to develop an interest in homosexuality, so as to later go on the record opposing her few comments on it – or to even later throw out her whole “masculine/feminine” theory altogether. Still, this is a single error in a mountain of excellent thinking output for all to benefit for generations.
Rand has a reputation for “cutting the crap” to get to the heart of ideas.
Jaskn,
Regardless of her ability to “get to the heart of ideas”, Rand, her generation, and every other thinking person needs information upon which to formulate those ideas/philosophies.
Unfortunately, at the time AR was composing her ideas, the last acknowledged homosexuals were contemporaries of Caligula and, like Caligula himself, these men had some truly disgusting and predatory sexual habits, such as the desire to essentially rape their male and female subordinates as a way to assert their “power”.
Of course Caligula, and his contemporaries treated women (including their own relatives) just as poorly as they did subordinate men. However, because homosexuals became closeted after the Greco-Roman period during which men like Caligula stood out, men like Caligula remained the archetype upon which public perception of homosexuals was based, while heterosexuals remained in public view and produced more chivalrous examples of heterosexual behavior to counter any negative mark men like Caligula might have left on the image of heterosexuality.
Peikoff said in a podcast on homosexuality that he thinks sexuality was formed subconsciously during early childhood. Not sure of just how much of a choice then he thinks a person has in the matter.
That would make absolute sense. That’s actually what I’ve been thinking it is; a subconscious value-judgment, like one’s sense of life.
I find it immensely improbable that it would be genetic- wouldn’t a “gay gene” necessarily remove itself from the gene pool? It seems to blatantly violate the mechanics of evolution, as far as I can imagine.
On the other hand, given our culture’s estimation and treatment of gays today (not to mention under Shuria law!!) I find it even more improbable that anyone would volunteer for that.
“Yes, they’ll stone me to death now for my cocklust and, by Alleh, was that the wrong decision! Ha-ha!” Yeah; I don’t buy that.
So a subconscious value-judgment seems like the best explanation, by far.
Thus, like the formalization of any contract, it’s the state’s business.
Uh-huh.
So then the antitrust laws are perfectly moral, right? Because all that involves are formal contracts, so why shouldn’t the state dictate which companies can or cannot marry each other?
Homosexuality is a sexual preference. If it is a choice then all sexual preferences are choices.
To say that homosexuality is a choice, but heterosexuality isn’t, is just plain silly. To say that it’s a choice while other preferences (height, weight, skin color, hair color) aren’t, is silly.
If being attracted to people with your own type of genitals is a choice, then so is being attracted to blondes, brunettes, biker chicks, et cetera.
So when someone says that homosexuality is a choice, just ask them why they chose THEIR preferences (or have some fun with it and try to explain the immorality of having sex with [insert their desires]).
I’m not gay, personally, but my wife is bi and by Galt I support that! B)
It’s funny, though, the number of guys nowadays who are completely gung-ho for lesbians but despise gay men. Never have understood that.
What Ayn Rand said, and Objectivism, are not interchangeable. Just because Ayn Rand liked cats, doesn’t mean Objectivists have to like cats.
Well, I also ‘like cats’, and have rescued five of the cuties (Double, Trouble, Chaos, Kylie, and Sang [Korean for ‘Twin’]), who subquently ‘adopted’ me.
So, since I ‘like cats’, my girlfriend ‘likes cats’, and Rand ‘likes cats’, then all the Objectivists I know or know of ‘like cats’, which makes sence since cats are the feircly indpendent ‘Objectivists’ of the animal world (I remember the History Channel show ‘Life After People’ stating that cats are the ONLY domesticated animal that would survive unchanged if people were to vanish/die off)…
Our best measure of Rand’s scientific interest in homosexuality is a story Joan Blumenthal told to Anne Heller. Rand was a great fan of Rudolf Nureyev, and Blumenthal remarked casually that he was gay and that everybody knew this. Rand refused to believe her, insisting that he was too well hung to be a homosexual.
She must have been looking at a very old edition of the DSM.
So, since I ‘like cats’, my girlfriend ‘likes cats’, and Rand ‘likes cats’, then all the Objectivists I know or know of ‘like cats’, which makes sence since cats are the feircly indpendent ‘Objectivists’ of the animal world (I remember the History Channel show ‘Life After People’ stating that cats are the ONLY domesticated animal that would survive unchanged if people were to vanish/die off)…
That would actually make sense.
I’m rather fond of cats, myself. I like any animal that can walk up to you for affection and then walk away again, without any hostility, simply to go do its own thing.
Still, while it does relate to the philosophy (everything ties back into philosophy) I wouldn’t consider it by any means essential.
You cannot call yourself an Objectivist if you consider reason to be impotent, selfishness immoral or Capitalism unjust. You can hate cats and still consider yourself an Objectivist (which is what I mean by non-essential).
Our best measure of Rand’s scientific interest in homosexuality is a story Joan Blumenthal told to Anne Heller. Rand was a great fan of Rudolf Nureyev, and Blumenthal remarked casually that he was gay and that everybody knew this. Rand refused to believe her, insisting that he was too well hung to be a homosexual.
That would explain a lot, if it’s true.
Because if that’s the case then we can conclude that Rand saw homosexuality as a symptom of low self-esteem; i.e. “I like boys because girls don’t like me.” Which wouldn’t be a very farfetched hypothesis, given the time period and the information she had available.
And if someone were to choose their sexual preferences, based on a low sense of self-worth and attractiveness, then that WOULD be immoral by the standard of rational selfishness. I think it logically follows.
So that premise, right there, might be the cause of her erroneous judgment therein.