[Mod’s note: Split from an earlier topic. -sN]
As for the so-called critics - they seem to come and go.
In 5years of foruming I have yet to see a convincing assault on Objectivism. The intellectuals who do try, either misunderstand it, or deliberately misinterpret it. Others with honesty and knowledge have questioned or fine-tuned deep abstractions I can barely grasp, but it all only serves to strengthen conviction in the “immutable core” of the philosophy.
(Now I actively seek out criticism : Bring it on! But at least come with an original or challenging argument this time…)
An argument which is original or challenging to you? How is anyone to know what you know? A forum which seeks new members should expect them to ask old questions and should be prepared to offer brief and respectful replies, otherwise it becomes a hangout for a gang of good old boys and girls who know the jargon, the pat answers, and are prepared to slap down anyone who dares to ask a naive question.
After many decades of Objectivism and objectivism, I have drawn the conclusion that philosophy is a short subject, suitable to a small pamphlet (economics is a brochure, politics is a poster) and the art of philosophy includes the virtue of brevity. Ayn reduced her philosophy to a paragraph.
My main objection to most of Objectivism’s adherents is their habit of shaming and humiliating anyone who questions them. This is hardly a vice exclusive to them, of course, but as a group, they seem to relish this approach to debate far more than, say, Christians (present day) or Libertarians. I blame Ayn and Nathaniel for setting this tone, along with many of their early followers. It was their standard practice to make psychological / epistemological diagnosis of anyone who opposed them (although on TV, I once watched Nathaniel say “In a debate between gentlemen, one does not question the motives of one’s opponents”).
Psychobabble is bad philosophy. Psychology is not a science, it is a guessing game. We can blab all day about what we think is going on in the minds of others, but we will never actually know. That is a fact. Psychology is almost always used as a means to insult others. Accusing others of “psycho-epistemological” sins such as “evasion” is guaranteed to offend, not convince, and it is an utterly unprovable accusation. Telling others who they should be sexually attracted to is utterly offensive and invalid.
I wonder if this bad habit is more easily developed by writers of fiction. They tell us, in their stories, all about what is going on in the minds of their characters. Perhaps they mistakenly assume that they can see into the minds of real people. They cannot.
I am here because I just got an email inviting me to check out this newly formatted forum. But already I see signs of what I call the Objectivist Tone: Beware! We do Not Sanction those who Disagree. However, anyone who cares about your sanction or lack thereof, is a fool, which makes it foolish to post such warnings.
After more than 50 years of pondering Ayn, I have come to these conclusions:
Psychology is an intellectual fraud.
Insults are anti-debate - meaning that they function to end debate.
Coercive monopoly is evil.
And since Ayn included these errors in her philosophy, I now call myself an objectivist. I still love and respect her memory. She was a great thinker and artist and I am convinced that her heart was in the right place. But she was mistaken about some important philosophical questions.
John Howard