There is such a thing as the study of the human mind, just like there is such a thing as the study of the human body.
Could you offer an example of your study of the human mind, not including your own, please?
There is such a thing as the study of the human mind, just like there is such a thing as the study of the human body.
Could you offer an example of your study of the human mind, not including your own, please?
On a quick scan of this, am I correct in surmizing that Howardofski is berating Objectivists at large for not being Objectivist ‘enough’? That’s a fresh approach. But I’m in danger of psycho-babbling, so should stop here.
(Nice new look, O.O Admin!)
Yes, I am. It’s good you stopped before psycho-babbling.
Could you offer an example of your study of the human mind, not including your own, please?
Which part of “don’t expect to be taken seriously” suggests that I’m gonna take you up on this?
Obviously, such a blatantly anti-science attitude is met with varying levels of hostility…
I say psychology is not science and you say I am anti-science. That does not follow at all. It would be more reasonable to guess that I am anti-psychology because I am pro-science. And that would be correct.
Which part of “don’t expect to be taken seriously” suggests that I’m gonna take you up on this?
I never expect to be taken seriously or otherwise since I don’t engage in psychobabble and can have no idea how you might take anything I say. My purpose is to say what I think is true, clearly and briefly and offer evidence when it is requested. If you have time to tell me how you’re not taking me seriously, but don’t have time to offer evidence for your claims to be able to study the minds of others, then so be it, but I suspect you don’t have any such evidence.
I read thorugh this the best I can and frankly I have no idea what the hell it is supposed to be about.
Are we discussing…
Are we discussing…
- Psychology as a non-science (which makes no sense unless you assume conciousness does not exist and therefor cannot be studied like every other existent so I have no idea what this is supposed to mean)
Let us just deal with this one point you raise. Consciousness is not an existent, it is mental action; it is that for which existents are the subject. Ayn began her thinking with Conciousness AND Existence. I can be conscious of existence, but cannot be conscious of another consciousness. The fact of consciousness certainly does not lead to the conclusion that I can study any consciousness other than my own.
I have consistently been criticizing the non-science of studying “the” mind, meaning more than one mind. I have been consistently saying that I can only “study” my own and this does not amount to a science in any conventional sense of the term. Ayn said that a consciousness aware of nothing but itself is a contradiction in terms.
How do you make a science out of one consciousness referring to itself?
How do you make a science out of that which you can not be conscious of (other minds)?
All you will ever be conscious of are objects, their actions, and the contents of your own mind.
How do you make a science out of that which you can not be conscious of (other minds)?
I might be a zombie! Or maybe you are? I’ll never know I guess.
I might be a zombie! Or maybe you are? I’ll never know I guess.
Maybe the way you see red is the way I see green. Of course, that’s completely arbitrary, but if it’s impossible to know anything about a consciousness you don’t experience yourself, why not?
Let us just deal with this one point you raise. Consciousness is not an existent, it is mental action; it is that for which existents are the subject. Ayn began her thinking with Conciousness AND Existence. I can be conscious of existence, but cannot be conscious of another consciousness. The fact of consciousness certainly does not lead to the conclusion that I can study any consciousness other than my own.
I have consistently been criticizing the non-science of studying “the” mind, meaning more than one mind. I have been consistently saying that I can only “study” my own and this does not amount to a science in any conventional sense of the term. Ayn said that a consciousness aware of nothing but itself is a contradiction in terms.
How do you make a science out of one consciousness referring to itself?
How do you make a science out of that which you can not be conscious of (other minds)?
All you will ever be conscious of are objects, their actions, and the contents of your own mind.
Wait a minute - You cannot be concious of another concious. Your not aware of us or our conversation?
Is this conversation just going on in your head and my answers a product of your concious mind talking to itself?
Conciousness does not exist? It is seperate and outside? I don’t know if that is the Primacy of Conciousness of some imposed segregation.
“All you will ever be conscious of are objects, their actions, and the contents of your own mind.”
Wait a minute - I’m not aware of your mind either? Are your ideas just products of my mind?
I’m lost. My mind does not exist or it does exist but not as part of existence and so does yours (or not) but we don’t know that since we are not aware of each other being aware, only that a body exists doing something we grasp somehow but we cannot study the relationship since we only know our conciousness which does not exist. Or exists somehow outside of existence seperate but equal to existence.
Seriously. I’m even more confused.
Plus your misrepresenting Objectivism on this but I can’t even get into that since I have yet to untangel the above.
“All you will ever be conscious of are objects, their actions, and the contents of your own mind.”
Wait a minute - I’m not aware of your mind either? Are your ideas just products of my mind?
I’m lost.
You do not know the content of my mind. You may know my written words (if you read carefully). I am not misrepresenting Objectivism. The very name refers to objects. Do you really believe you are reading minds when you are reading words? If so, you are indeed lost.
I’m lost. My mind does not exist or it does exist but not as part of existence and so does yours (or not) but we don’t know that since we are not aware of each other being aware, only that a body exists doing something we grasp somehow but we cannot study the relationship since we only know our conciousness which does not exist. Or exists somehow outside of existence seperate but equal to existence…I have yet to untangel the above.
I can’t help you untangle that mess - you made it. If you would like to understand what I am writing, it is to be found in my several posts above.
…if it’s impossible to know anything about a consciousness you don’t experience yourself, why not?
Because you don’t experience it. Objectivism is about experiencing objects and their actions and reasoning from there. You do not read minds. You observe behavior. There is an important difference.
In obvious examples, you can say “I know he has a mind and it is capable of playing the piano because he is playing one now” or “I know he has a mind because he is conversing”, but you cannot know a person’s beliefs or motives or feelings, or methods of reasoning, only what they say about such matters. That is why addressing such matters - especially in a debate - is both presumptuous and irrelevant. That presumption is what is often referred to as “psychobabble” - the art of pretending to see into the mind of another. You can’t.
Objectivism is about experiencing objects and their actions and reasoning from there. You do not read minds. You observe behavior.
You observe behavior; true. However, knowing human behavior, you can reason from that behavior to infer motive. Nobody will say you can do this unerringly every time, or with any sliver of behavior. Nevertheless, everyone does it all the time, including you. Are you unable to say with any degree of confidence that someone, sometime felt love for you? or respect for you? or anger at you? or fear of you?
This is not Objectivism message, but it is implicit in much of Rand’s writing nevertheless. Regardless of whether it is Objectivism, it is simply true that human beings have motives and emotions, and these influence their actions. Thus there is a basis, however imperfect, to work backwards from actions. In addition, people often explain their own thinking, either explicitly of implicitly. This adds to the evidence that one can use to infer what they are thinking.
It is easy to jump the gun and assume all sorts about people’s motives. However, that does not mean that one has to give it up as invalid because it is imperfect.
In an earlier post, you explained that you could call a post “humiliating” because that describes the post, not the state of the potential reader. That’s a pretty meaningless thing. What does “humiliating” mean without a consciousness? What consciousness-free attribute of the post does it describe? Implicit in the concept of “humiliating” is your guess that the reader will feel humiliated; otherwise, the concept is meaningless.
Because you don’t experience it. Objectivism is about experiencing objects and their actions and reasoning from there. You do not read minds. You observe behavior. There is an important difference.
…Nevertheless, everyone does it all the time, including you. Are you unable to say with any degree of confidence that someone, sometime felt love for you? or respect for you? or anger at you? or fear of you?
This is not Objectivism message, but it is implicit in much of Rand’s writing nevertheless. Regardless of whether it is Objectivism, it is simply true that human beings have motives and emotions, and these influence their actions. Thus there is a basis, however imperfect, to work backwards from actions. In addition, people often explain their own thinking, either explicitly of implicitly. This adds to the evidence that one can use to infer what they are thinking.
It is easy to jump the gun and assume all sorts about people’s motives. However, that does not mean that one has to give it up as invalid because it is imperfect.
In an earlier post, you explained that you could call a post “humiliating” because that describes the post, not the state of the potential reader. That’s a pretty meaningless thing. What does “humiliating” mean without a consciousness? What consciousness-free attribute of the post does it describe? Implicit in the concept of “humiliating” is your guess that the reader will feel humiliated; otherwise, the concept is meaningless.
It is obviously silly for you to tell me that I make the same error that you do all the time. No, I don’t. I see that I am loved when someone treats me so. For me love is their behavior. I don’t pretend to know their feelings and I don’t need to. If someone posts that someone else is an idiot - I say that is a humiliating post. The poster may not have meant it and the postee may not have read it. It is humiliating objectively - by its nature.
You are arguing that because you and others have the habit of reasoning backwards from behavior to an imagined mental state, your habit is a valid science. I don’t agree. You argue that it is “simply true that human beings have motives and emotions, and these influence their actions.” Perhaps so, but you do not have any way to know what their motives and emotions are, nor which of those are associated with which of their actions. Surely you know of acting, sad clowns, Hollywood.
You also argue that people explain their own thinking and this is further evidence. No it isn’t. You are making a mistake common to prosecutors trying to convince a jury that testimony is evidence. It isn’t.
You do not need to read minds to live happily with others, and you will understand them more accurately when you stop thinking you can read their minds. You can judge their behavior and observe their patterns of behavior without the unnecessary and error-prone step of pretending to see within them. When it comes to mind, we are surrounded by strangers and it is best (and most courteous) to act accordingly and not presume.
Cute, but not accurate. Read the Wikipedia entry more carefully.
Surely you know of acting, sad clowns, Hollywood.
You think they’re acting?
Cute, but not accurate. Read the Wikipedia entry more carefully.
Yup, but it is just the logical conclusion you’d reach. It’s reductio ad absurdum. If the only mind you can know about is your own… then you don’t even know other minds exist except your own. While epistemological solipsism isn’t your exact view, it’s pretty close.
Just as alchemy is not chemistry, psychology is far from an exact science. In this, I agree with Howardoski. However, alchemy was a study that lead to the more exact science of chemistry, and should therefore be granted some degree legitimacy. Furthermore, modern psychiatric studies may be as accurate as meteorology or economics, and just as helpful when approaching real solutions to real problems. Howardoski, I agree with your argument that psychology is a non-science at this point of its development. That is, a non-science in that it is imperfect and extremely difficult to yield empirical evidence. And yet, there has been serious research and concrete evidence that has lead to benefits for some people with very serious mental problems. Once again, psychology is a great deal closer to understanding human behavior than astrology, but given, time more people could understand their own behavior, their own motivation, and perhaps their own happiness.