Objectivism and Psychology

Yup, but it is just the logical conclusion you’d reach. It’s reductio ad absurdum. If the only mind you can know about is your own… then you don’t even know other minds exist except your own. While epistemological solipsism isn’t your exact view, it’s pretty close.

No, it isn’t. I have made clear more than once in my posts that there is no doubt that other minds exist - the evidence is obvious and ubiquitous. What I said is that you cannot know their contents. For instance I know you have a mind because you are communicating. I have no idea what you think or what your motives are. You may agree with me and are playing devil’s advocate. Or perhaps you don’t comprehend what you read very well, but love to argue anyway. I have no way of knowing what’s going on in there and I don’t pretend I do.

You do not know the content of my mind. You may know my written words (if you read carefully). I am not misrepresenting Objectivism. The very name refers to objects. Do you really believe you are reading minds when you are reading words? If so, you are indeed lost.

If I know youre written word then I know what you are thinking, unless you are lying but that is a different problem.  We are assuming honest communication here.

 

Objectivism refers to objectively gaining knowledge, which means mind-body integration - Not simply objects.   

 

Words represent concepts and sentinces represt ideas. I’m not lost in my thinking - I just don’t get how you can say your mind exists outside of reality.

I can’t help you untangle that mess - you made it. If you would like to understand what I am writing, it is to be found in my several posts above.

 

Your the one who said your conciousness does not exist.  I’m trying to digest the consequences of that statement in order to understand your opinion.  Perhaps if you can clarify how your conciousness does not exist or at least does not exist to others that would help. 

Just as alchemy is not chemistry, psychology is far from an exact science. In this, I agree with Howardoski. However, alchemy was a study that lead to the more exact science of chemistry, and should therefore be granted some degree legitimacy. Furthermore, modern psychiatric studies may be as accurate as meteorology or economics, and just as helpful when approaching real solutions to real problems. Howardoski, I agree with your argument that psychology is a non-science at this point of its development. That is, a non-science in that it is imperfect and extremely difficult to yield empirical evidence. And yet, there has been serious research and concrete evidence that has lead to benefits for some people with very serious mental problems. Once again, psychology is a great deal closer to understanding human behavior than astrology, but given, time more people could understand their own behavior, their own motivation, and perhaps their own happiness.

Whether Psychology as it exists today is science or not is irrelevant to his point. He’s claiming that one CANNOT generalize about the human mind, at all. Not that some specific person is wrong in his generalizations.

Just as alchemy is not chemistry, psychology is far from an exact science. In this, I agree with Howardoski. However, alchemy was a study that lead to the more exact science of chemistry, and should therefore be granted some degree legitimacy. Furthermore, modern psychiatric studies may be as accurate as meteorology or economics, and just as helpful when approaching real solutions to real problems. Howardoski, I agree with your argument that psychology is a non-science at this point of its development. That is, a non-science in that it is imperfect and extremely difficult to yield empirical evidence. And yet, there has been serious research and concrete evidence that has lead to benefits for some people with very serious mental problems. Once again, psychology is a great deal closer to understanding human behavior than astrology, but given, time more people could understand their own behavior, their own motivation, and perhaps their own happiness.

Repairman, I don’t discount the possibility that someday there might be a technology of mind reading - a method for one mind to look from the outside into the contents (thoughts - not brain waves)of another.

The epistemological problem occurs when the techs try to verify the accuracy of their mind-reading technology. They will have to rely on the testimony of their subject and testimony is not evidence.

I believe consciousness is - by its very nature - an extremely private and individualistic phenomenon, and would probably be best left that way. For now I see no evidence at all that two minds can share awareness, only information. Awareness is an axiom of Objectivism and objectivism - the awareness of objects and their actions is the starting point for each mind.

My objection here in this forum has been to those debaters who argue as if they can know the contents of the minds of others. This is a lie, in my opinion (leaving aside the possibility that they really can). I think psychobabble is a form of rudeness and that it serves to wreck honest debate because it is irrelevant nonsense.

You’re the one who said your conciousness does not exist.

I said no such thing. Perhaps you should read more carefully what I did say. Most of it has been repeated now several times. I said consciousness is an activity, not a thing. That does not mean non-existence. An action requires an entity to act.

No, it isn’t. I have made clear more than once in my posts that there is no doubt that other minds exist - the evidence is obvious and ubiquitous. What I said is that you cannot know their contents. For instance I know you have a mind because you are communicating. I have no idea what you think or what your motives are. You may agree with me and are playing devil’s advocate. Or perhaps you don’t comprehend what you read very well, but love to argue anyway. I have no way of knowing what’s going on in there and I don’t pretend I do.

But how can you know that other’s minds are conciousness? How do you know they aren’t like robots, taking in information, processing or “thinking”, and behaving, but without any awareness? 

 

My answer that I can see that I and others possess basically the same faculties of thinking (a human brain), and since I experience consciousness and my brain is clearly the faculty that gives rise to that consciousness, others must experience consciousness in a similar way that I do. They aren’t just complex robots. I can’t make a conclusion that something else is conscious just based upon it’s behaviour as demonstrated by the Chinese room thought experiment. There’s certainly an entity acting in the Chinese room, but I don’t know that it is conscious. 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room

But how can you know that other’s minds are conciousness? How do you know they aren’t like robots, taking in information, processing or “thinking” and behaving, but without any awareness? 

 

My answer that I can see that I and others possess basically the same faculties of thinking (a human brain), and since I experience consciousness and my brain is clearly the faculty that gives rise to that consciousness, others must experience consciousness in a similar way that I do. I can’t make a conclusion that something else is conscious just based upon it’s behaviour as demonstrated by the Chinese room thought experiment.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room

I don’t disagree with this. We can know that we all have brains and we can know that we all are conscious, but you will never be able to see the contents of my brain, so you would be presumptuous to discuss them. You do not know how my brain is organized or how I have chosen or will choose to use it. You do not share my consciousness, and you have no way to verify any of my statements about it. So you really do not know how similar our minds are, no matter how similar our physical brains are.

My own purpose is to eliminate psychobabble from debate. I want to save debate since I see it as the only alternative to violence. And I find that those most enthusiastic about violence are the most prone to dismissive psychobabble aimed at anyone who disagrees. Listen to Karl Rove tell us all about how Muslims think. Listen to the Global Warming crowd tell us how skeptics are “in denial”. Dismissing other minds is a way to ignore other arguments.

Whether Psychology as it exists today is science or not is irrelevant to his point. He’s claiming that one CANNOT generalize about the human mind, at all. Not that some specific person is wrong in his generalizations.

This is almost correct. I’m sure we can generalize about the human mind to some shallow degree, but such generalizations are pretty useless. Allow me an analogy: I see from the outside that you have a home, but I do not presume to know what is in it or what you do in there.

My own purpose is to eliminate psychobabble from debate. I want to save debate since I see it as the only alternative to violence. And I find that those most enthusiastic about violence are the most prone to dismissive psychobabble aimed at anyone who disagrees. Listen to Karl Rove tell us all about how Muslims think. Listen to the Global Warming crowd tell us how skeptics are “in denial”. Dismissing other minds is a way to ignore other arguments.

How do you know my mind even has contents? That’s the relevant question that I’d like answered. Look, I’m not saying it’s valid for anyone to say that they know how Muslims think, but it’s worlds apart from saying that it’s impossible to know about mental states. Cognitive psychology has come far in the past 20 years in making scientific conclusions about mental states. That does not mean that the goal is mindreading, it only means that people study how the mind works. No one tries to replicate your exact feelings and say what your private experience is like - not anyone studying the brain. Please don’t equivocate between private experience and mental states.

 

The analogy is more like: I see a home, but how do I know anything is inside? “What’s inside” is what cognitive psychology studies indirectly, figuring out how mental states operate by observing behaviors.

I don’t disagree with this. We can know that we all have brains and we can know that we all are conscious, but you will never be able to see the contents of my brain, so you would be presumptuous to discuss them. You do not know how my brain is organized or how I have chosen or will choose to use it. You do not share my consciousness, and you have no way to verify any of my statements about it. So you really do not know how similar our minds are, no matter how similar our physical brains are.

My own purpose is to eliminate psychobabble from debate. I want to save debate since I see it as the only alternative to violence. And I find that those most enthusiastic about violence are the most prone to dismissive psychobabble aimed at anyone who disagrees. Listen to Karl Rove tell us all about how Muslims think. Listen to the Global Warming crowd tell us how skeptics are “in denial”. Dismissing other minds is a way to ignore other arguments.

What we don’t seem to agree upon is that concluding that someone else is conscious and not just a robot is a conclusion about the contents of their mind. I can make that conclusion about the content of their brain through deduction, I don’t need to actually see or experience it and it’s not axiomatic. This is only the most basic deduction I can make about the contents of the brains of others.

 

As for what your purpose is, it doesn’t matter. Eliminating what you call psychobabble may or may not be a worthy goal, but if your arguments against it are flawed, they need to be attacked.

I said no such thing. Perhaps you should read more carefully what I did say. Most of it has been repeated now several times. I said consciousness is an activity, not a thing. That does not mean non-existence. An action requires an entity to act.

 

If your conciousness exists then it has an identity.  Having identity means it can be identified. 

 

That is what science does - study (identify) what exists.

 

I did read what you said and took you at your word - Trying to understand it involved unraveling the consequences.  Now you’ve stated the exact opposite.    

 

Does conciousness exist and have an identity, or does it lack an identity which means it does not exist? 

If your conciousness exists then it has an identity.  Having identity means it can be identified. 

 

That is what science does - study (identify) what exists.

 

I did read what you said and took you at your word - Trying to understand it involved unraveling the consequences.  Now you’ve stated the exact opposite.    

 

Does conciousness exist and have an identity, or does it lack an identity which means it does not exist?

Of course it can be identified. I have identified it as an action as opposed to an object, but that is still an identification. I resist calling it an existent because I use that word to identify objects. Actions do not exist independent of the objects that act, so consciousness does not exist independent of the body (object) which acts. Would you say that running exists - all by itself? Or would you say that runners exist and running is an attribute? Consciousness is an attribute, not a thing. If you wish to use words differently, I might go along with you temporarily, but I think it is confusing to refer to an attribute as an existent. Simply put: I think existents are nouns, not adjectives or verbs, which refer to attributes of objects. Consciousness, though a noun in form, is a verb in fact.

And though science does indeed study that which exists, my point is that you cannot study consciousness in two senses of the term “study”: 1) you have no verifiable information about any minds other than your own and 2) to “study” means to use your mind - but it can’t study itself as if it is a separate object any more than a camera can photograph itself. You can use your mind and organize it as you wish, but it will never be a suitable subject of any science, for it is the means of science itself and it cannot separate itself from its own nature or function for the purpose of study. It cannot become its own subject, other than rhetorically.

If you believe otherwise, why not offer some examples of what you think are scientific statements about the human mind?

What we don’t seem to agree upon is that concluding that someone else is conscious and not just a robot is a conclusion about the contents of their mind.

You make my point. I am not concluding anything about the minds of others. I do not see (sic) the difference between them and your hypothetical robot. It does not matter to me what their internal state is, since I have no way to know it. I say they have a mind because they are debating with me. But if they are cleverly made robots debating with me, mind is still the source back there somewhere. To make the point with different words, I am agnostic about the inner experience of anyone or anything other than myself for the simple reason that I lack information on the subject of inner experiences beyond my own.

Cognitive psychology has come far in the past 20 years in making scientific conclusions about mental states… Please don’t equivocate between private experience and mental states…

 

“What’s inside” is what cognitive psychology studies indirectly, figuring out how mental states operate by observing behaviors.

This is exactly what I am challanging. I am convinced that no valid examples can be found to support what you have written above. We can have hunches about inner states based on behavior all day long, but they are unprovable, and therefore invalid. There is no evidence to support them. They are superstitions.

Of course it can be identified. I have identified it as an action as opposed to an object, but that is still an identification. I resist calling it an existent because I use that word to identify objects. Actions do not exist independent of the objects that act, so consciousness does not exist independent of the body (object) which acts. Would you say that running exists - all by itself? Or would you say that runners exist and running is an attribute? Consciousness is an attribute, not a thing. If you wish to use words differently, I might go along with you temporarily, but I think it is confusing to refer to an attribute as an existent. Simply put: I think existents are nouns, not adjectives or verbs, which refer to attributes of objects. Consciousness, though a noun in form, is a verb in fact.

And though science does indeed study that which exists, my point is that you cannot study consciousness in two senses of the term “study”: 1) you have no verifiable information about any minds other than your own and 2) to “study” means to use your mind - but it can’t study itself as if it is a separate object any more than a camera can photograph itself. You can use your mind and organize it as you wish, but it will never be a suitable subject of any science, for it is the means of science itself and it cannot separate itself from its own nature or function for the purpose of study. It cannot become its own subject, other than rhetorically.

If you believe otherwise, why not offer some examples of what you think are scientific statements about the human mind?

 

Ok - That breaks it down nicely.  You think conciouness is a unique entity that exists but only as action since it’s form is within an existing entity (us).

 

Running is something an object does in the same way being aware is something our conciousness does. 

 

Consiousness is an attribute of certain living entities but it is a thing - we can identity it since everything that exists can be identified. 

 

Now if you want to say we are at the stage that we are poorly equiped to do it or have done a fantastically bad job of doing that so far, I could get behind that, but not whipping out the Law of Identity simply because we have approached it wrong in current scientific theory. 

 

Studying something basic, like chemistry requires you to observe and integrate data.  Somthing like nuclear physics is unseen and requires  vast abstractions to proof such data back to visual sense perception, but the fact it is unseen or hard to get at outside of the consequences of it’s actions does not invalidate it.  It simply ment we had to have advanced knowledge, wide abstractions, and the tools to work through it.  Conciousness is much the same.  We have to accumilate what we do observe, integrate data, create abstractions, deduce from known proof, etc. 

 

As for one simple example of scientific determnations of conciousess, you have the laws of logic that tells us how to use our awareness to integrate and deduce data.   Another would be volition.  Another would be habit formation. Another would be theories on concept formation.  Or if you want psychology then there is vast integrations based on various mental illnesses which works  here since you can also point to how we have done that poorly (but is still measurable).

I think I like the “Art of Psychology”

Ok - That breaks it down nicely.  You think conciouness is a unique entity that exists but only as action since it’s form is within an existing entity (us).

 

Running is something an object does in the same way being aware is something our conciousness does. 

 

Consiousness is an attribute of certain living entities but it is a thing - we can identity it since everything that exists can be identified. 

 

Now if you want to say we are at the stage that we are poorly equiped to do it or have done a fantastically bad job of doing that so far, I could get behind that, but not whipping out the Law of Identity simply because we have approached it wrong in current scientific theory. 

 

Studying something basic, like chemistry requires you to observe and integrate data.  Somthing like nuclear physics is unseen and requires  vast abstractions to proof such data back to visual sense perception, but the fact it is unseen or hard to get at outside of the consequences of it’s actions does not invalidate it.  It simply ment we had to have advanced knowledge, wide abstractions, and the tools to work through it.  Conciousness is much the same.  We have to accumilate what we do observe, integrate data, create abstractions, deduce from known proof, etc. 

 

As for one simple example of scientific determnations of conciousess, you have the laws of logic that tells us how to use our awareness to integrate and deduce data.   Another would be volition.  Another would be habit formation. Another would be theories on concept formation.  Or if you want psychology then there is vast integrations based on various mental illnesses which works  here since you can also point to how we have done that poorly (but is still measurable).

By way of reply, I would refer you to my 2nd paragraph, post #69, above. Also, to be precise about terms, I would not write, as you have, that being aware is something our conciousness does. Consciousness is not an object with being aware its action. Consciousness and being aware mean the same thing. The object acting is our body. The action is being aware or being conscious, whichever term you prefer. Consciousness is a specific kind of motion, not an object.

As for one simple example of scientific determnations of conciousess, you have the laws of logic that tells us how to use our awareness to integrate and deduce data.

The laws of logic are linguistic rules for the non-contradictory naming (identification) of objects and their attributes. They are verbal rules our minds can choose to follow or not. They are not evidence of our inner state. The are recommendations for ordering our inner state. We observe logic and its lack only in words. We are not observing minds, merely one of their products.

The laws of logic are linguistic rules for the non-contradictory naming (identification) of objects and their attributes. They are verbal rules our minds can choose to follow or not. They are not evidence of our inner state. The are recommendations for ordering our inner state. We observe logic and its lack only in words. We are not observing minds, merely one of their products.

 

The laws of logic are epistomological devices neccessary to think properly in addition to there metaphysical neccessity - We wouldn’t care if they did not surve a human purpose, which is allowing our concious to take perception and make sense of it.  This is something we know from studying how human conciouness works.  In fact you can say this about the whole field of philosophy which  is very wide abstractions that are unseen but can be studied since it is built from integrating data.   

 

But even if you want to dispute that then you have the other examples I gave.

 

This is moot.  If it exists, then it has an identity which means it can be identified. If it cannot be identified, then it doesn’t exist. 

 

You cannot whip out identity.  No one can.

 

In fact you are identifying facts about conciouness to tell be it cannot be identified.  Making the argument proves it can be studied and discussed. 

 

Like I said - I can accept the idea that we are not doing it well but not that conciousness exists but doesn’t at the same time.