Ayn Rand believed that entities are fundamental and that relations are derivative from entities. How do objectivists reconcile that with quantum field theory where excitations of quantum fields (relations) give rise to particles (entities)?
In what sense is a quantum field not an entity?
On 3/12/2026 at 2:09 AM, Jon C said:
In what sense is a quantum field not an entity?
In the sense of a field? Isn’t considering a field as an entity an example of what Whitehead descibed as an example of misplaced concreteness?
It is like considering ‘marriage’ as an entity , like all married people possess a finite entity, instead of understanding the abstraction describes a relation between finite entities?
In O’ism all entities are finite because unfinite is a potentiality alone, yes ?
10 hours ago, Jon C said:
In what sense is a quantum field not an entity?
It depends on your interpretation of QFT, however my understanding is that ontic structural realist interpretations of QFT are relatively the most popular interpretations of QFT
14 hours ago, HappyDays said:
Ayn Rand believed that entities are fundamental and that relations are derivative from entities. How do objectivists reconcile that with quantum field theory where excitations of quantum fields (relations) give rise to particles (entities)?
I doubt objectivists are up to the task , and I’m not sure if Objectivism is either.
Why does Objectivism need to be “reconciled” with quantum field theory?
Quantum field theory, properly interpreted, does not deny the axioms of metaphysics, but even if it did, it would have to use them in order to deny them…
1 hour ago, necrovore said:
Why does Objectivism need to be “reconciled” with quantum field theory?
Quantum field theory, properly interpreted, does not deny the axioms of metaphysics, but even if it did, it would have to use them in order to deny them…
As I understand it, the most straightforward interpretation of QFT is the ontic structural realist interpretation which believes that relations are more ontologically fundemental than standalone entities, how does this use an axiom of metaphysics in order to deny it?
Siva And Shakti not Or ![]()
On 3/12/2026 at 3:27 PM, HappyDays said:
As I understand it, the most straightforward interpretation of QFT is the ontic structural realist interpretation which believes that relations are more ontologically fundemental than standalone entities, how does this use an axiom of metaphysics in order to deny it?
Because a relation is a relation between preexisting things (just as marriage is a relation between people, and cannot exist without them).
I’m not well-versed on QFT in particular, but I used to do a lot of research into and engage heavily in these theoretical physics discussions, back then the forum was a bit more active. You’ve got to pay close attention to the interpretations of the math. The math itself is often beyond any real scientific or philosophical dispute, but how that math is interpreted is where the philosophical problems really crop up.
It’s like the field-particle duality. The math shows that at some times quantum phenomena behave like fields, and at other times they behave like particles. And the math that shows this is solid, and based on rigorously tested and replicable empirical evidence.
Does that duality mean that the Law of Identity does not apply at microscopic levels (as many try to argue)? Or does it mean that our concept of what a “wave” or a “particle” is needs to be adjusted to the things that actually exist at those levels?
This is where the interpretation of the math becomes key, and since the scientific method obviously cannot be valid without the law of identity there is one answer to this dilemma which is automatically false.
Without spending quite a lot of time researching this particular subject for myself, I’m not qualified to say too much.
If the math seems to show that fields are somehow causally prior to and more important than particles then that shouldn’t be dismissed; that matters - but it would indeed be fallacious to declare that a relation between particles is somehow more fundamental than the particles themselves.
On 3/12/2026 at 1:37 PM, tadmjones said:
I doubt objectivists are up to the task , and I’m not sure if Objectivism is either.
Nah. Objectivists nowadays - probably. We’ve gotten very quiet and very epistemically sloppy in the last decade (at least from what I’ve seen on the internet). The core methodology is still there, though, whenever we’re up for it.