Isn’t Objectivism supposed to be reached through research, understanding, and acceptance? I think what you’re suggesting here is a form of “converting,” but I don’t find this to be the right approach.
I think I was pretty clear that I was talking about people who have read Ayn Rand and in their sincere desire to learn more are reaching out to people with more experience and knowledge in Objectivist principle to help expand and/or clarify what they’ve read.
An example as I stated above:
"three people (just in the past month, many more over the years) who said they enjoyed the ideas put forth in AS and/or TF but when they tried to involve themselves w/Objectivism through groups or online they were treated like idiots for not already knowing what they came to have clarified for them.
One in particular said that when they were being attacked for not already “knowing it all” they said I don’t know, that’s why I’m here- to learn from you. Then they got attacked for being “second-handers”."
Like I said, while I believe that my posts were clear about the nature of the people I’m suggesting it behooves “us” to be more civil to I will state it emphatically and very clearly now:
People who have read Ayn Rand and sincerely want to know more but have misgivings and/or misunderstandings.
I don’t think it is in our rational self interest to treat them like spastic mongoloids for not understanding after a single reading of AS and TF what many of “us” have to understand over the course of many years.
Is that really so unreasonable?
Even the heroes of AR’s books needed things clarified for them by others, clung to long held contradictions, made bad choices.
Even The Wet Nurse came to understand.
Sometimes it seems to me that if one isn’t as fully formed and integrated as a John Galt when they first make contact with other Objectivists they get descended upon as though by ravening wolves.
I guess the attacks (on persons of average to above average intelligence, who have read at least one AR book and who are sincere in seeking clarification) seem irrational to me for these reasons:
a) if you’re sick of seeing the same question asked over&over by several new people why not ignore it?
if you’re angry feeling somehow their question wasted your time then why waste MORE of your time attacking them?
b ) if contradiction and misinformation piss you off why be counterproductive? Better to light a candle than to curse the darkness?
Example:
newbie: I really liked alot of what AS had to say about individualism but it just seemed too harsh at times for me? What about people who are disabled? What if their own family can’t take care of them… are we really supposed to just let people suffer?
-
ObjectivistWhoApparentlyWokeUpOnWrongSideOfTheBed: Perhaps if your snaggle-toothed crack whore of a mother’s pre-natal alcoholism hadn’t left you developmentally disabled you would’ve seen that all that has already been answered. In several of AR’s books, and in several other posts here. Now kindly get back to drooling malt-liquor in an alleyway onto your urine-soaked Salvation Army pants so that we, the enlightened, may get back to preaching to the choir.
-
ObjectivistWhoEnjoysLivingInThisWorldAndThereforeWouldLikeToSeePeopleUnderstandHowToLiveInIt: there’s a lot of information for you on that here already.. check forum a/b/c. Since you’ve only read AS, you should check book **. Those explain it pretty clearly so please read them and then ask for any further clarification.
Ok..obviously example one is meant to be an exaggeration for the sake of humor. But the reality is that there really is a fair amount of hostility to newbies (gack I hate that term).
If you couch an answer within insults all someone hears is the insult. That just tends to be human nature.
Insult my mother I didn’t hear the directions to the gas station.
I can understand and wholly agree with flogging trolls, idiots and persons with obviously anti-AR agendas. That isn’t what I’m talking about. I’m talking about sincere individuals who have a flawed premise, incomplete information or are just too inexperienced to grasp certain things.
I am incorrect that part of the purpose of philosophical forums is to share information?
Am I coming from a faulty premise on that?
If I am not then I have to wonder what is gained by only including a bunch of people who already know everything you know and think everything you think. That almost seems masturbatory to me.
Sure “we” all want to be surrounded by people to look up to so when there’s a spate of 16-20 YOs who just read TF or AS it can get tedious. But can anyone here claim to have been born full-formed..with no questions to ask? No faulty premises? No need of clarification, instruction or teaching?
What I’m saying is.. if you don’t want to be the one to do the instructing or teaching when someone posts a question to which the answer is seemingly self evident that is perfectly valid. There is nothing wrong with choosing where and how you will spend your knowledge.
What I cannot understand is this: if it is a waste of your time to answer the question why is it not a waste of your time to insult the asker?
By all means ignore those you feel are beneath you.. but if you feel the need to insult them doesn’t that betray a certain perversity?
Edited to correct some glaring typos..alas, probably not all of them