To begin, let’s keep in mind that any kind of loyalty is a virtue of the enslaved (loyalty to your parents, loyalty to your favorite author, loyalty to Ayn Rand, loyalty to your philosophy yesterday). That being said, there have been enormous sceintific progress in recent years - providing information that perhaps Ayn Rand might never have anticipated.
Because global climate change is such a debatable issue (but I think it’s impossible to assert that humans have had absolutely zero effect on the climate), how about we concentrate on acid rain in the Adirondacks. Here are the facts:
-
Adirondack water has become highly acidic in the last century, killing fish and wiping out local ecosystems.
-
The acidity results from two things: a. granitic bedrock inhibiting the natural filtering process and b. acid rain. Without the acid rain, the environments remain healthy. I’m sure the opposite is true for the bedrock (although obviously, that’s impossible to test).
-
The acid rain is directly related to the production of chemical pollutants in midwest plants (Chicago, Detroit, etc.)
I think that objectivism works only when the world is held constant (when resources are equally available). For instance, every peice of rock that Howard Roark takes out of the ground and uses to build is a peice of rock that I won’t be able to use .
With that in mind, Overpopulation will drastically reduce the quality of life in the next century. Should we have the right to overpopulate? Should we have the right to waste? And if we can’t help it in our present society, when the ability to waste is as almost as accessible as the ability to breathe, might it be the governments responsibility to represent the capitalist interests of those that cannot represent themselves (the environment, for example).
In this way, might it be the responsibility of the government to manage the pollutants of midwest plants (surely, we cannot expect that their individualistic principles to solve the problem)? Might it not also be the responsibility of the government to clean up the problem that resulted from the abuse of environmental power?
Two relative Ayn Rand quotes:
“I swear by my life and my love of it that I will never live for the sake of another man, nor ask another man to live for mine.” (The individualistic principles that are absent in our culture)
“Nature, to be commanded, must be obeyed.” (The lesson we should be taking more notice of)