Objectivism Vs. Environmentalism?

If you polute, you MAY be initiating force to some people around you, or you may not. The government’s involvement should be limited to those instances where someone has initiated force against someone else, and a case can be made to demonstrate it.

And let me just re-emphasize here that the burden of proof is NOT on the “polluter.”

Is that not rediculous? Capitalism will work, but only when are values aren’t corrupted.

This is false. You have an incorrect definition of “work” in this context. Capitalism can be said to be “working” if nobody initiates force against anyone else. They could all be wasting their money on total garbage or never showering or listening to crummy music or wearing tar and feathers. None of that could be said to be making capitalism qua capitalism “fail.”

You could make the argument that corrupt valued would LEAD to the initiation of force, but so long as nobody is initiating force, then CAPITALISM IS WORKING, no matter how corrupt the values of a society.

This is a technicality, but an important one.

I don’t understand. Than what is the point of capitalism? To fulfill it’s own definition? What progress is being made if there is no progress (except that the rules of capitalism are being followed)? Or is progress being made only when capitalism is being followed? Is the product of capitalism, following capitalism?

In your definition, everybody in the world could be doing absolutely nothing purposeful except not initiating force, and that would make them purposeful?

I don’t understand. Than what is the point of capitalism? To fulfill it’s own definition? What progress is being made if there is no progress (except that the rules of capitalism are being followed)? Or is progress being made only when capitalism is being followed? Is the product of capitalism, following capitalism?

In your definition, everybody in the world could be doing absolutely nothing purposeful except not initiating force, and that would make them purposeful?

What do you mean by “progress?” You can’t FORCE people to be good people. You can only legislate that they not hurt each other. (initiate force) What would be achieved would be JUSTICE, the subordination of might to right, a society which obeys moral law.

The actual achievement of values is up to the individual people. A society cannot and should not force this. If this is not achieved, it is not the fault or even the concern of “capitalism” per se. It is the fault and the concern of the individuals involved.

Thus, even if it is a society of deadbeats… so long as they do not initiate force, capitalism has NOT failed.

NewYorkRoark,

Therefore, as an individual, I would never pollute and I would never abuse a resource so that another individual would be disadvantaged by my abuse. I would attempt to hold resources constant, by not wasting what I use, using what can be used again, and recycling what cannot be used anymore. I would maximize efficiency.

The problem with capitalism right now, is that this moral situation is not the norm. We spend rediculous amounts of money on products that serve nearly no purpose. Think about fashion and think about movies. Our consumer choices represent our values, and our values are rotten. We live in a society where people are so socially aware, that they’ll starve themselves to death (Terry Schaivo)! Is that not rediculous? Capitalism will work, but only when are values aren’t corrupted.

The major point is capitalism will work, but our consumer choices and business will represent our values, and only when are values are righted will unrestricted capitalism be successful.

With this, you’ve gone beyond the problem of how to deal with pollution as an initiation of force in a laissez-faire system and have claimed that the majority of people are ruled by irrational desires, and hence that laissez-faire capitalism will fail, since it depends on rational producers.

If what you say is true, and people are not competent to pursue their own values, how do you plan to correct their “corrupted” values? Who would dictate, amongst the myriad of choices of the innumerable values in each of the innumerable lives you plan to interfere with, what is to be valued, and what is to be considered “wasteful?” And by what standards would these things be valued-- your judgement of their best interests, perhaps? If so, how would you plan to gather the information needed to make such determinations, and then enforce them?

And what of those who disagree?

You can’t enforce morality at the point of a gun; moral actions must be chosen. I sympathize with your judgement of the baffling actions of irrational people, but we must not forget that there are rational people, too-- it would be quite presumptuous to dictate to them how they should live their lives, and quite immoral to attempt to enforce it with force. How would you judge the person who declares that your favorite dessert, your favorite movie, your hobby, your chosen career, or any other value which brings your life joy, is “wasteful” because they do not think you should be valuing it, and then fined you for pursuing it?

The problem with capitalism right now, is that this moral situation is not the norm. We spend rediculous amounts of money on products that serve nearly no purpose. Think about fashion and think about movies. Our consumer choices represent our values, and our values are rotten. We live in a society where people are so socially aware, that they’ll starve themselves to death (Terry Schaivo)! Is that not rediculous? Capitalism will work, but only when are values aren’t corrupted.

The major point is capitalism will work, but our consumer choices and business will represent our values, and only when are values are righted will unrestricted capitalism be successful.

I don’t hate many things, because hate implies passion, which implies emotion, which tends to lack reason. But I hate fashion.

“Roark,” Until you adress my argument you have pretty much lost the right to talk about capitalism and the environment. Your comments on emotion and fashion are disconcerting, I suggest you read more Ayn Rand. To equate reason with emotionlessness, is to eviscerate reason from the human body. So, you are either not using reason, or you hate life, or you need to clarify.

This conversation was ended succinctly about 15 posts ago. Non-capitalism is universally anti-human value because it renounces the prioritization of values in the reason of the individual. Capitalism is the only environmentalism. Socialism is responsible for a global warming, regardless of whether global warming exists. If you would like to continue talking about Capitalism and the environment, please address my argument.

And let me just re-emphasize here that the burden of proof is NOT on the “polluter.”

*sigh* This is exactly the point that I’m trying to wrestle with. In a perfect world, if someone initiated a force against someone else, and it was possible to know that they did it (factually), no one would need to “prove it” in some sort of court setting. It would simply be a case of “you did this, now deal with the consequences.” This an impossibly hypothetical situation, but what I’m saying is that for an initiation of force to be wrong, it does not need to be complained about if there exists some ability to simply regulate against it.

I think that we have to keep in mind the two things that drive human existence. These are our individual rights, and our existential interrelationships. For example, a child has no implicit right to any of its parents’ property. Objectivism espouses that it’s moral to help someone only as much as it taking them out of harm’s way in an emergency. However, we recognize that allowing a child to starve is bad, so we push to create some mechanism to ensure that we, as a society, care for children until they can fend for themselves. This is not a right in itself granted to the child for being a child, in fact it’s a violation of the philosophy of Objectivism, but because we recognize that children don’t operate by the same rules that we as adults do, we change the rules for them.

The same goes for the environment. Normally, whatever you do to your property is your own business. However, there are some things that you use without paying for. Air, for example. No one owns air, and therefore, if you do something to “your air (which doesn’t exist),” you’re screwing it up for the rest of us. Thus, a mechanism needs to be in place to protect “air” and “water” and all the other things that we use, but do not use up, and don’t belong to us.

I think you’re taking this out of context from what Ayn Rand intended it to be. She uses this to argue for objective reality (that facts are facts and that empirical knowledge is the only knowledge we have of the world - that scientific facts are facts and science is the only knowledge we have of the world).

Scientific facts are not the only kinds of facts. It is not status as empirical or “scientific” that determines whether a fact is a fact, it is reason.

I interpret Objectivism to state that one is free to pursue their own ends so long as they don’t negatively impact anyone else’s ability to pursue their own ends.

Wow what a package-deal. What exactly “negatively impacts” someone’s ability to pursue their own ends?

A more accurate interpretation would be that Objectivism calls upon you to not violate people’s rights, and since the only way to violate someone’s rights is to initiate physical force, this is a general admonishment against initiating physical force. Not a general admonishment against negatively impacting people. Criminy! If I can beat someone out for a job, I will! If I can put a competitor out of business, I will, and so should you!

I really don’t mean offense, but you will probably take it as that, but (and because) I think you are emotionally bound to your arguments.

I would avoid using those kinds of statements to stay out of the lob-and-volley style of debate you find on terrible programs on major news programs. Trying to be offensive is no better than being offended. It’s imperative to emotionally detach yourself from your philosophy.

This is a general trait on this forum, because Objectivists take ideas seriously as applying to their actual life. It’s imperative to get your emotional responses in line with your explicit philosophy. If you detach your emotions from what you think about reality, you have detached your fastest and best method of knowing what is good for you and what is not from reality as well. The consequence is to paralyze you in an emergency, regardless of the nature of your personal philosophy.

As for unskinner’s response, I think most of it was pretty accurate, but I still think it’s naive to think that we have had no negative impact on the earth (or in the future). I proposed that if we are harming it (in any way, or in the future) and the effect was delayed, that capitalism would have a hard time solving a problem that had already been created. Overall, I think it was well thought out.

The fact that you think something has no bearing on its truth/falsehood. If this is what you think, present some evidence for it.

Have you ever seen a dead person? Isn’t it surprising how fragile we are physically?

Nice of you to include this emotional appeal, Mr. Detached.

This an impossibly hypothetical situation, but what I’m saying is that for an initiation of force to be wrong, it does not need to be complained about if there exists some ability to simply regulate against it.

The nature of regulatory law is to punish the INNOCENT for crimes they MIGHT commit. In what sort of fantasy realm is it just to punish the innocent? How much of a “negative impact” on their ability to pursue their own ends is that?

Regulations actually make it EASIER for villians to get away with their immoral activities. Look at the FDA, which has formally announced that it is INCAPABLE of doing the job for which it was created, namely ensuring safe and effective food and drugs. It’s not incapable for the reason it claims, that it doesn’t have enough arbitrary power, it’s incapable by virtue of the fact that it exists. NO ONE could ensure 100% safe and effective food and drugs; it is up to the individual to make responsible decisions about where and when and what to buy and who to buy from. Regulations attempt to prevent people from needing to take responsibility for using their judgment, something that NO ONE can escape.

If you fail to seek redress for a wrong committed against you, you are only hurting yourself. It is no one’s responsibility to see to it that the situation is addressed if you can’t muster the desire to care. Your mother doesn’t work here.

The nature of regulatory law is to punish the INNOCENT for crimes they MIGHT commit. In what sort of fantasy realm is it just to punish the innocent?

Precisely! There’s a reason for “innocent until PROVEN guilty” and just because you throw in words like “the environment,” that doesn’t change anything. I note also the attempts to obfuscate the issue by bringing children into the fray.

To begin, let’s keep in mind that any kind of loyalty is a virtue of the enslaved (loyalty to your parents, loyalty to your favorite author, loyalty to Ayn Rand, loyalty to your philosophy yesterday).

Explain this further, please.

First, to address Nate T’s point (which I think was dead on and very problematic to my arguments) (and to an extent this covers Inspector objections), I agree. This is where my argument parts ways with objectivism (to rejoin later). It’s almost Marxism in reverse. I know most of you will despise that. But I believe that there is right in the world and I believe that there is wrong. And I believe we’re been so separated from nature (or the environment, although that seems to be an unwelcome word here), that we’ve lost a sense of what is truly valuable. And I think it’s an enormous problem and that there may not exactly be 1 solution. I guess, before I propose my answer and get tackled, I’d like to know 1.) whether you think there is right and wrong, 2.) do you do nothing when someone is wrong?

As for unskinned, here would be a part of my response:

“Roark,” Until you adress my argument you have pretty much lost the right to talk about capitalism and the environment. Your comments on emotion and fashion are disconcerting, I suggest you read more Ayn Rand. To equate reason with emotionlessness, is to eviscerate reason from the human body. So, you are either not using reason, or you hate life, or you need to clarify.

This conversation was ended succinctly about 15 posts ago. Non-capitalism is universally anti-human value because it renounces the prioritization of values in the reason of the individual. Capitalism is the only environmentalism. Socialism is responsible for a global warming, regardless of whether global warming exists. If you would like to continue talking about Capitalism and the environment, please address my argument.

You said earlier that "an Objectivist government would literally spackle the country with nuclear power plants, which have no effect on the environment as long as there is a capitalist around to watch over the spent rods.

OK, fine. But who’s going to pay the capitalist to watch over the spent rods and why? The owner of the plants. What if he doesn’t think spent rods are harmful? Then what do you do? This, I believe is the problem. First you need right and wrong to develop principles. Then you need near universal acceptance of those principles. Then you need action upon those principles. Then you can say that the owner will pay for to trash the spent rod’s.

As for my distrust of emotion, perhaps I should use a better word, or define what I mean by emotion. When I think of emotion, I think of fleeting happiness. I think of terribly naive adolescent feelings. Feelings might be a better way to describe what I’m objecting to. Not all emotions come from reason. For instance, a man who kills his wife after she cheats on him and he finds out. Unreasonable and emotional, for a variety of reasons. She doesn’t want to be with you? Move on. She cheats? She has poor values. I’m not referring to the kind of emotion expressed by Henry Cameron before he died - “that it was all worth it.”

However, I also object (or caution) against using the kind of emotion I believe you are referring to. It’s OK to have it. But to debate, I think it’s important to set it aside. Otherwise, you can become so locked into your beliefs that - if another possible alternative to those beliefs arises - you’re too narrow-minded to see it it as possible. For instance, I find that racial issues are often products of over-emotional over-identified individuals ( http://www.reasonvsracism.com is a terrific site I think ).

“Passion has helped us; but can do so no more. It will in future be our enemy. Reason, cold, calculating, unimpassioned reason, must furnish all the materials for our future support and defense.” Lincoln

Explain this further, please.

I’m not sure how to explain it. If you are loyal to someone, than you are, in a sense, they’re slave. Of course, this depends on how you define loyalty. For instance, if a member of Bush’s cabinet knew that Bush had done something terribly wrong (I’m not asserting that he did, just proposing it for the sake of argument), he probably would not reveal it if he was loyal to Bush. Loyalty, to me, is when you put another in front of yourself.

NewYorkRoark,

I think that there are so many small issues with what you are saying that you would be better served by educating yourself with the nonfiction works of Ayn Rand than by posting here. Try Philosophy: Who Needs it?, The Virtue of Selfishness, Capitalism: The Unknown Ideal, and The New Left: The Anti-Industrial Revolution.

In the meantime, if you’re going to post here, then do so on very specific issues and limit your context to only those issues. Be an asker of questions, not a stater of opinions… this forum is a place to learn and practice Objectivism, not a place to post ideas counter to Objectivism (although there is a debate forum for that…). Until you learn enough to even know what we are talking about, there is going to be a LOT of confusion here. That’s why I say to post in the form of questions and take the learning process more slowly.

Suffice to say, people DO have morals backwards and contemporary values are empty and nonsensical. However, the PROPER morals and values are NOT what you think they are. It’s okay, you’re just on the verge of discovering the truth on this. I don’t mean to discourage you, but you’re going to look back at these posts and feel pretty silly. An example of this is your idea of “loyalty” is a little weird; what you’re actually against isn’t “loyalty,” but “altruism” and the sacrifice of one’s inviolate judgment.

But there’s enough of the RIGHT idea in what you’re saying that you will greatly enjoy the benefit of the wisdom found in the sources I mentioned.

First, to address Nate T’s point (which I think was dead on and very problematic to my arguments) (and to an extent this covers Inspector objections), I agree. This is where my argument parts ways with [O]bjectivism (to rejoin later). It’s almost Marxism in reverse. I know most of you will despise that. But I believe that there is right in the world and I believe that there is wrong. And I believe we’re been so separated from nature (or the environment, although that seems to be an unwelcome word here), that we’ve lost a sense of what is truly valuable. And I think it’s an enormous problem and that there may not exactly be 1 solution. I guess, before I propose my answer and get tackled, I’d like to know 1.) whether you think there is right and wrong, 2.) do you do nothing when someone is wrong?

To address your first question: There is right and wrong in the world-- specifically, any given individual’s actions can be moral or immoral. The crucial question is: right and wrong for whom? Rand held (and I agree) that each individual’s life is to be the standard of morality (the measure by which one judges one’s actions as good or bad), with the ultimate goal of morality (the motivation behind acting morally) being to enjoy life and live happily, as is fitting human beings. Do you agree with this? If not, what do you think the standard of morality is, and what are your reasons?

I’m puzzled by your belief that “we’re been so separated from nature … that we’ve lost a sense of what is truly valuable.” I really can’t comment on this without knowing what you mean by “separated from nature.” Also, what does degree of separation from nature have to do with pursuing and achieving one’s values?

In any case, to answer your other question, it depends a lot on the context in which you ask. Are you asking how I would act when I see someone acting immorally, or illegally? For example, if I see someone doing something which is clearly not in their best interests (such as smoking outside) but is not initiating force against others, it gives me no reason to interfere with that person. However, if I’m being mugged, I will summon the police if I can, and failing that, do whatever is necessary to defend myself and my property.

Edit: Hooray! I finally got my 3rd dot!

Absent from this discussion was an explicit definition of “environment.” Immediately, I don’t have one to offer. But its important to point out that the concept “environment” depends on another concept; whoever or whatever lives in said environment. To make any statement involving an environment one begs, “who’s environment.”

I haven’t witnessed anyone here state the opinion that nature has some sort of intrinsic value that needs to be protected from man’s actions. If this were the case (I’m glad it isn’t) it would only be proper for everyone to starve themselves.

The general consensus in this thread seems to be, “man’s environment.” So, the only way to have progress in this discussion is to transfer it to morality and the nature of rights and the nature of government. This has already been done.

Regarding property disputes: What fundamental difference is involved in lakes and air and ozone as opposed to other property? I propose that there isn’t one, but someone else has proposed the fundamental difference is time. I am not convinced that this is fundamental.

The brand of environmentalism, or ecothiesm, that is pervasive today has no regard for the rights of individuals. This how many justify passing Kyoto protocols (legislation) to prevent anthropomorphic global warming (a baseless doomsday scenario). They are simply protecting the environment (who’s?).

Therefore, as an individual, I would never pollute …

No organism can live without polluting its environment. To survive, grow, or reproduce, it must reduce its own entropy. This can only be accomplished by increasing the entropy of other things.

As a human being, you must: exhale carbon dioxide and ammonia; urinate; defecate; shed hair; shed skin cells; and cut, file, or otherwise remove fingernails and toenails. You probably also: spit occasionally; ride in motor vehicles or on horses; discard packaging; convert clothing into lint and rags; etc..

NewYorkRoark,

I think that there are so many small issues with what you are saying that you would be better served by educating yourself with the nonfiction works of Ayn Rand than by posting here. Try Philosophy: Who Needs it?, The Virtue of Selfishness, Capitalism: The Unknown Ideal, and The New Left: The Anti-Industrial Revolution.

In the meantime, if you’re going to post here, then do so on very specific issues and limit your context to only those issues. Be an asker of questions, not a stater of opinions… this forum is a place to learn and practice Objectivism, not a place to post ideas counter to Objectivism (although there is a debate forum for that…). Until you learn enough to even know what we are talking about, there is going to be a LOT of confusion here. That’s why I say to post in the form of questions and take the learning process more slowly.

Suffice to say, people DO have morals backwards and contemporary values are empty and nonsensical. However, the PROPER morals and values are NOT what you think they are. It’s okay, you’re just on the verge of discovering the truth on this. I don’t mean to discourage you, but you’re going to look back at these posts and feel pretty silly. An example of this is your idea of “loyalty” is a little weird; what you’re actually against isn’t “loyalty,” but “altruism” and the sacrifice of one’s inviolate judgment.

But there’s enough of the RIGHT idea in what you’re saying that you will greatly enjoy the benefit of the wisdom found in the sources I mentioned.

I agree. I thought about unskinned’s example last night (regarding pollution caused by transportation and the government’s hand in that pollution) and I must agree with that argument. But in my defense to Inspector, I do believe that my problem here was largely because I was far too broad, which you mentioned. I would be able to better explain myself, had I stayed on specific topics. So let me ask three question’s, because I still am unclear on certain topics (obviously).

  1. A lot of you have mentioned that you’d seek a payment from anyone who pollutes the land that you own, if that pollution is harmful. If the polluter says, “you’re land is polluted,” or “it wasn’t me” do you go to a judge? Who decides whether you’re right or not? And how does this judge come to be? Is he elected? Is it his business? And if it’s his business, or if he’s elected, who gives him his authority?

Seperately, how do you stop financial corruption in a capitalist society? For instance, what if that polluter makes a large profit and he gives the judge a ton of money to rule in his favor. Who do you go to if you find out? Do you go to another judge that can be paid off? Nobody is physically initiating force against you.

  1. Everyone seems to tout individual rights, and I think that’s fine, but it seems that what isn’t getting as much attention is individual responsibility NOT to interfere with another individuals rights, which I think is just as important. And who’s to judge whether something will or does or will not or does not interfere with another’s individual rights. My pollution might affect a chromosome and cause genetic damage 2, 3 generations down the road. What if nobody figures it out until it’s too late and the damage has already been done? Isn’t better safe than sorry (in other words, to punish the potentially innocent for the crimes they might commit, until it’s certain that those crimes won’t be commited).

  2. How does a capitalist society curb overpopulation? This is contingent upon overpopulation being a problem. Of course, it seems obvious. We largely live in a world with fixed amounts of resources (minus hydropower, solar power, etc.). So if there’s too many people and not enough resources, who’s to tell someone not to have more children? Why do they stop on their own?

How does a capitalist society curb overpopulation? This is contingent upon overpopulation being a problem. Of course, it seems obvious. We largely live in a world with fixed amounts of resources (minus hydropower, solar power, etc.). So if there’s too many people and not enough resources, who’s to tell someone not to have more children? Why do they stop on their own?

One reason why people would stop breeding would be that they cannot afford to feed their children, which results in either a really miserable life where you are just barely surviving due to the dozen offspring that you have to feed, or, in the extreme case, they are actually dying because you cannot provide for the children. This consideration wiould be dispositive in a capitalist society, though of course socialism dictates that you aren’t responsible for your family so socialism removes one of the rational safety valves on the population vs. resources question. In primitive agrarian societies it may be necessary to breed excessively in order to create farm hands, who tend to die off, but capitalism counters that tendency by encouraging the spread of technology that eliminates the need for lots of manual labor. Overpopulation only result from mindlessly following tradition (such as the 10-child family) simply because it is tradition, and not because there is a reason to have 10 children. But whatever your reason is, society (i.e. the government) should not be controlling population. Really, it’s my business if I want to try to take care of a dozen people on my crummy salary. The one way in which you might argue for some state involvement would be that parental neglect of a particular level might be properly against the law (for example, simply refusing to feed a child because you can’t afford to).

The corruption thing is something that probably would be better in its own topic, it’s a bigger discussion than we can have on the side of this one.

Regarding property rights, the fundamental difference between air and other property is that you can’t own air. You can own airspace, sure, but the individual molecules of air can not belong to you.

We pollute. That’s a fact. Pollution is harmful to others in ways that can’t be necessarily traced back to one person and proven in a court of law. Also, pollution’s effects can often be delayed, and therefore by the time someone is “caught” doing something wrong, the damage might be very difficult to reverse.

For example, I’m a nuclear plant operator. I store my spent rods on my property unsafely. Radiation seeps into the ground water and flows into a nearby lake on someone else’s property. By the time fish start dying, we’ve already got a huge problem. But what if someone’s been running a fish market selling fish from, among other places, that lake. Now we have all sorts of people eating radiated fish. Not to mention the entire fish market staff who’s been chillin’ around them. Do you understand how it’s much better to ensure that the rods are contained properly even if it means forcing the plant operator to do something not in his best interest?

We pollute. That’s a fact. Pollution is harmful to others in ways that can’t be necessarily traced back to one person and proven in a court of law. Also, pollution’s effects can often be delayed, and therefore by the time someone is “caught” doing something wrong, the damage might be very difficult to reverse.

We murder. That’s a fact. Murder is harmful to others in ways that can’t be necessarily traced back to one person and proven in a court of law. Also, murder’s effects can often be delayed and go unsolved, and therefore by the time someone is “caught”, the damage is impossible to reverse.

I suggest we regulate any activity or item that could lead to murder or be used to murder someone. Can’t you see how helpful and good it would be to try to prevent all murders before they occur? It’s not important how this impinges on the rights of other people who would never murder anyone. The end justifies the means.

The above is merely an example, not my actual position on how to handle murder. It’s an example of the thought process you are using to justify denying the rights of others. Yes, you are clearly advocating the denial of rights to people who have done no wrong, or would do no wrong. I understand that you are okay with that. It’s not that I don’t understand that you think it’s better to deny the rights of the innocent in order to ATTEMPT to protect other innocents, it’s that I don’t agree with that position. See, I believe someone should actually be responsible for doing something wrong before they are held accountable for doing something wrong. I realize that all potential harmful behavior can not, and should not be banned or regulated just because it may allow some people to get away with harming others. The actual damage that WILL be done by the protection is most likely more far-reaching than the potential undetected damage that might POSSIBLY be diverted through the protection.