First, to address Nate T’s point (which I think was dead on and very problematic to my arguments) (and to an extent this covers Inspector objections), I agree. This is where my argument parts ways with objectivism (to rejoin later). It’s almost Marxism in reverse. I know most of you will despise that. But I believe that there is right in the world and I believe that there is wrong. And I believe we’re been so separated from nature (or the environment, although that seems to be an unwelcome word here), that we’ve lost a sense of what is truly valuable. And I think it’s an enormous problem and that there may not exactly be 1 solution. I guess, before I propose my answer and get tackled, I’d like to know 1.) whether you think there is right and wrong, 2.) do you do nothing when someone is wrong?
As for unskinned, here would be a part of my response:
“Roark,” Until you adress my argument you have pretty much lost the right to talk about capitalism and the environment. Your comments on emotion and fashion are disconcerting, I suggest you read more Ayn Rand. To equate reason with emotionlessness, is to eviscerate reason from the human body. So, you are either not using reason, or you hate life, or you need to clarify.
This conversation was ended succinctly about 15 posts ago. Non-capitalism is universally anti-human value because it renounces the prioritization of values in the reason of the individual. Capitalism is the only environmentalism. Socialism is responsible for a global warming, regardless of whether global warming exists. If you would like to continue talking about Capitalism and the environment, please address my argument.
You said earlier that "an Objectivist government would literally spackle the country with nuclear power plants, which have no effect on the environment as long as there is a capitalist around to watch over the spent rods.
OK, fine. But who’s going to pay the capitalist to watch over the spent rods and why? The owner of the plants. What if he doesn’t think spent rods are harmful? Then what do you do? This, I believe is the problem. First you need right and wrong to develop principles. Then you need near universal acceptance of those principles. Then you need action upon those principles. Then you can say that the owner will pay for to trash the spent rod’s.
As for my distrust of emotion, perhaps I should use a better word, or define what I mean by emotion. When I think of emotion, I think of fleeting happiness. I think of terribly naive adolescent feelings. Feelings might be a better way to describe what I’m objecting to. Not all emotions come from reason. For instance, a man who kills his wife after she cheats on him and he finds out. Unreasonable and emotional, for a variety of reasons. She doesn’t want to be with you? Move on. She cheats? She has poor values. I’m not referring to the kind of emotion expressed by Henry Cameron before he died - “that it was all worth it.”
However, I also object (or caution) against using the kind of emotion I believe you are referring to. It’s OK to have it. But to debate, I think it’s important to set it aside. Otherwise, you can become so locked into your beliefs that - if another possible alternative to those beliefs arises - you’re too narrow-minded to see it it as possible. For instance, I find that racial issues are often products of over-emotional over-identified individuals ( http://www.reasonvsracism.com is a terrific site I think ).
“Passion has helped us; but can do so no more. It will in future be our enemy. Reason, cold, calculating, unimpassioned reason, must furnish all the materials for our future support and defense.” Lincoln
Explain this further, please.
I’m not sure how to explain it. If you are loyal to someone, than you are, in a sense, they’re slave. Of course, this depends on how you define loyalty. For instance, if a member of Bush’s cabinet knew that Bush had done something terribly wrong (I’m not asserting that he did, just proposing it for the sake of argument), he probably would not reveal it if he was loyal to Bush. Loyalty, to me, is when you put another in front of yourself.