Objectivism Vs. Environmentalism?

We murder. That’s a fact. Murder is harmful to others in ways that can’t be necessarily traced back to one person and proven in a court of law. Also, murder’s effects can often be delayed and go unsolved, and therefore by the time someone is “caught”, the damage is impossible to reverse.

I suggest we regulate any activity or item that could lead to murder or be used to murder someone. Can’t you see how helpful and good it would be to try to prevent all murders before they occur? It’s not important how this impinges on the rights of other people who would never murder anyone. The end justifies the means.

The above is merely an example, not my actual position on how to handle murder. It’s an example of the thought process you are using to justify denying the rights of others. Yes, you are clearly advocating the denial of rights to people who have done no wrong, or would do no wrong. I understand that you are okay with that. It’s not that I don’t understand that you think it’s better to deny the rights of the innocent in order to ATTEMPT to protect other innocents, it’s that I don’t agree with that position. See, I believe someone should actually be responsible for doing something wrong before they are held accountable for doing something wrong. I realize that all potential harmful behavior can not, and should not be banned or regulated just because it may allow some people to get away with harming others. The actual damage that WILL be done by the protection is most likely more far-reaching than the potential undetected damage that might POSSIBLY be diverted through the protection.

I still would like to know who is going to judge who is responsible for what (a judge?), what the remedy is for offenses (a payment?), who gives that individual [judge] authority (?), and how that authority remains pure and uncorrupted(?)?

The thing is, you have to look at this from a marginal benefit standpoint. We can’t take preventative action against murder because it would require everyone’s thoughts be monitored. The cost would be higher than the benefit. However, the benefit of preventing pollution would outweigh the cost. And where it didn’t, it wouldn’t be done.

You will say, benefit to who? And I will preemptively counter with a simple illustration of Nash equilibrium. According to Nash’s theory, if it’s easier to pollute than not, it’s in everyone’s best interest to pollute. If you want a better explanation, I can give it, but I’ll assume you’re familiar with the prisoner’s dilemma. However, as we see in Nash’s illustration, it’s more beneficial to everyone to “agree” to not pollute. This agreement, however, hinges on no one “cheating.” If there’s no reason not to cheat, everyone will, and we will be driven towards the Nash equilibrium. This is why I would propose a real penalty for cheating. Everyone, including the regulated, benefits from no one cheating, but only if NO ONE cheats.

Yes, this is a violation of rights, and the main tenet for Socialism, but pollution is something that works against our main value of life. Is it more beneficial to trade the right to do whatever you want, in terms of pollution, for the assurance that individuals everywhere will be doing the same? I would posit that it is.

Now, I understand that this is not the place to be contradicting Objectivism, but one of Objectivism’s main pillars is that its philosophy is not based on, “We say this,” but on, “We say this because.” Now, I’m claiming that pollution has a negative impact on life that outweighs the positive impact that the right to pollute may have on anyone. Although your polluting act will benefit you, the polluting acts of others will harm you more. Thus, if we all agree not to pollute, we all win. We have to enforce this agreement, however, and the best way to do this is with a penalty system. The only entity with the implicit right to impose a penalty is the government. Do you see where I’m going with this, or am I being ridiculous?

The thing is, you have to look at this from a marginal benefit standpoint.

No I don’t, I have to look at it in terms of priniciples.

We can’t take preventative action against murder because it would require everyone’s thoughts be monitored. The cost would be higher than the benefit.

What is the “cost” of one human life? What is the cost of the denial of rights to one hundred human beings to protect that one life? 1000? 1,000,000? My analogy no more “requires” everyone’s thoughts to be monitored any more than regulating pollution from industry. That’s an absurd statement. Products and behavior, not thoughts, could be regulated, just as they are or would be in your concept of “protecting” us from pollution.

Yes, this is a violation of rights, and the main tenet for Socialism, but pollution is something that works against our main value of life.

Here you clearly step across the line. This is an admission that you actively support the violations of people’s rights who have done no wrong. Also, your presumption is erroneous that you think OUR main value is life. I’m not sure who else you are speaking for, but as an Objectivist, my main value is MY life, not JUST life, and not simply my physical existence, but that which makes my life worth living.

Now, I understand that this is not the place to be contradicting Objectivism, but one of Objectivism’s main pillars is that its philosophy is not based on, “We say this,” but on, “We say this because.”

Yes, you are contradicting Objectivism, and as a moderator, I must caution you at this point that further statements in support of either Socialism or the denial of rights will not be tolerated. We say Socialism is evil, because it’s “virtues” have already been examined, as well as it’s results. That’s the reason support of Socialism or the violation of individual rights is not permitted on this board, not simply because we don’t want to hear it.

Now, I’m claiming that pollution has a negative impact on life that outweighs the positive impact that the right to pollute may have on anyone. Although your polluting act will benefit you, the polluting acts of others will harm you more. Thus, if we all agree not to pollute, we all win. We have to enforce this agreement, however, and the best way to do this is with a penalty system. The only entity with the implicit right to impose a penalty is the government.

We all win when a system is in place that protects the rights of individuals, and punishes those who violates the rights of individuals. When you support and encourage the government being a body to actively violate those rights, we all lose.

Do you see where I’m going with this, or am I being ridiculous?

If I were to engage in a personal attack on you, I would say, “I see where you are going, AND I think you are being ridiculous.” Since I endeavor to avoid personal attacks, I’m simply answering the question as put forth.

I still would like to know who is going to judge who is responsible for what (a judge?), what the remedy is for offenses (a payment?), who gives that individual [judge] authority (?), and how that authority remains pure and uncorrupted(?)?

That question has nothing to do with capitalism, unless you’re comparing it to anarchy for some reason. Why is that so important to you? There’s no such thing as a social system that will work if its laws are not enforced…

I still would like to know who is going to judge who is responsible for what (a judge?), what the remedy is for offenses (a payment?), who gives that individual [judge] authority (?), and how that authority remains pure and uncorrupted(?)?

These questions can be redirected to the bureaucrats that dream up environmental regulation also. So what is the point? We already know human beings are volitional and fallible. What is the guarantee that an eco-statist isn’t going to remain uncorrupted?

There is no guarantee for the eco-statist, and there is no guarantee for the capitalist judge. But there are safeguards. The best safeguard is a body of law that protects individual rights. By setting up regulatory laws that damage the protection of rights – and when we talk about polution, we are talking about property rights – we are acting contrary to our goals.

The thing is, you have to look at this from a marginal benefit standpoint.

AisA already responded to this. But I think it is worth responding to again, so: No, I don’t. I have to look at it from a principled standpoint. There is no practical benifit of trying to protect property rights by denying property rights.

Now, I’m claiming that pollution has a negative impact on life that outweighs the positive impact that the right to pollute may have on anyone. Although your polluting act will benefit you, the polluting acts of others will harm you more. Thus, if we all agree not to pollute, we all win. We have to enforce this agreement, however, and the best way to do this is with a penalty system. The only entity with the implicit right to impose a penalty is the government. Do you see where I’m going with this, or am I being ridiculous?

If I pollute on my property, and everyone else pollutes on their own property, and we all take precautions to ensure that the pollution does not damage any one else’s property, then nobody is being harmed.

An extreme example: We pollute the moon. Who is harmed? (nobody)

A more realistic example: We transport nuclear fuel to Yucca mountain, which is surrounded by military bases and in the center of a spot where nobody is allowed to live anyway. Who is harmed? (nobody)

To follow up the last example: The truck driver from one of the nuclear plants falls asleep at the wheel, crashes his car and spills nuclear waste all over the center of a major metropolitan area. Who is harmed? (get your calculator) What happens then? The insurance company compensates the victims, and raises the freight company’s rates. A truck driver loses his job. The freight company changes its hiring practices. A repeat of the incident is less likely to occur. In otherwords, the same thing that happens when any other accident occurs that harms someone. – This is “the penalty system” at work. Only now it isn’t violating anyone’s rights.

For anyone who is interested in this topic, I suggest the book The Skeptical Environmentalist: Measuring the Real State of the World by Bjorn Lomborg. It doesn’t cover the legal/political side of environmentalism, but it is a refreshing and informative perspective on countless doomsday scenarios.

NewYorkRoark, Speaking of doomsday scenarios, what makes you think we are going to overpopulate? Have you been channeling Thomas Malthus? (I’m joking).

Seriously, though, there is one resource that only grows with the population: the human resource. It is what has shattered every overpopulation theory ever dreamt up, and it will continue to do so. Every time humans are deprived of something (food, space, etc) somebody puts their mind to solving the problem.

There was a great link on one of these threads, I don’t remember where. It concerned the problem of horseshit in the 1900’s and what on earth people would do about it in the year 2000. That doesn’t seem to be an issue anymore. Why? The human resource.

Again on the topic of overpopulation, the birth rates are lowest in the more developed and capitalistic countries. In these countries, children become more expensive because they cannot be used as farm hands. they have to be educated to be productive, and by that time they are out on their own anyway.

Look, I want to be civil about this, but I think this comes down to whether or not you are willing to question your interpretation of Objectivism as not necessarily being the correct one.

Rand’s philosophy claims to be based around the individual’s life, but it could be looked at from an economic standpoint. I’m an economics major, this is how I do things. Rand explicitly, and correctly, condemns the idea of sacrifice. It is from this idea that her philosophy goes forth. She points out that any system rooted in the idea of sacrifice (she loves the term self immolation…I’ll avoid it) is doomed to fail.

She points out that certain actions violate the rights of individuals, and must be condemned. She claims that no one has the right to violate the rights of another, but the problem is that while this can be logically shown, this concept is not an automatic condition of life. That’s why we have to have laws, to take away someone’s ability to violate someone else’s rights without consequence.

Now, this idea could be rephrased to say that no one has the right to force someone to make a sacrifice.

To pollute one’s own property doesn’t require anyone else to make a sacrifice. When one’s pollution impacts someone else, which it does in almost every case, you are requiring someone to sacrifice the quality of their life for nothing. This is wrong.

It’s not a matter of whether or not you can be prosecuted. You don’t have the right to do it in the first place. Because it’s relatively easy to monitor someone polluting, the enforcer of “you can’t do that” has every right to punish you for it. If you taxed a producer based on the pollution he produced, he could raise prices to compensate for it. In fact, the consumer would be the one paying for the manufacturing process, like it is anyway, and one of the costs of producing something is pollution.

This idea of externalities is well documented in economics. The idea that externalities are the burden of someone other than the creator of those externalities is perposterous. You honestly think that everyone impacted by pollution would sue? I don’t know about you, but I don’t have time for that. Why is it my problem? They’re the one in the wrong.

Look, I want to be civil about this,

That’s a good thing, because uncivil behavior will not be tolerated.

but I think this comes down to whether or not you are willing to question your interpretation of Objectivism as not necessarily being the correct one.

Yes, I think that is what several people are trying to suggest to you.

Rand’s philosophy claims to be based around the individual’s life, but it could be looked at from an economic standpoint.

It could be looked at from any number of different views, but the correct view is the issue of rights, not economics.

She points out that certain actions violate the rights of individuals, and must be condemned.

I believe this is where you engage in the fallacy of the stolen concept. You say the violation of rights should be condemned, but then you ignore that when you support the government violating people’s rights. You can’t legitimately say that the government should protect rights by violating rights. You can assert it, but it doesn’t hold water.

That’s why we have to have laws, to take away someone’s ability to violate someone else’s rights without consequence.

This is a shame too. Drug laws are another prime example of this. Laws should be there to punish actual right’s violators, not preempt actions which may or may not be rights violations. The sad affect of these laws is the that they do violate the rights of others, and with government doing the violating, they don’t have to suffer consequence.

It’s not a matter of whether or not you can be prosecuted. You don’t have the right to do it in the first place.

Yes, it is a matter of prosecution, and due process (legally speaking). What people don’t have the right to do, is violate the rights of others. What people do have the right to do is engage in activities that don’t violate the rights of others. It is the government’s burden to demonstrate that rights have been violating before punishing people, not to punish them regardless of whether a right has been violated. The government must assume at first that rights have NOT been violated, until just cause (or probable cause, legally speaking) is presented that rights have been violated.

Because it’s relatively easy to monitor someone polluting, the enforcer of “you can’t do that” has every right to punish you for it.

The convenience of “protection” does not justify the violation of rights.

The idea that externalities are the burden of someone other than the creator of those externalities is perposterous

Guilty until proven innocent. I see.

You honestly think that everyone impacted by pollution would sue? I don’t know about you, but I don’t have time for that. Why is it my problem? They’re the one in the wrong.

I honestly don’t care who chooses to sue and who does not. That’s their choice. I don’t care what values or priorities you have that dictate what you have time for and what you don’t have time for. It’s your responsibility to act in your best interest, regardless of whether or not it involves someone ACTUALLY violating your rights. If you can make the case that they have ACTUALLY violated your rights, you have my fullest support. If you want to protect your rights by violating the rights of others, I will oppose you in any way I find of value.

Just wanted to apologize to Rational Cop… I attributed something of his to someone else. I was mystified by the avatar.

Just wanted to apologize to Rational Cop… I attributed something of his to someone else. I was mystified by the avatar.

No problem. That actually came up before in theory, and I consulted with AisA to see if he minded. He did not.

To pollute one’s own property doesn’t require anyone else to make a sacrifice. When one’s pollution impacts someone else, which it does in almost every case, you are requiring someone to sacrifice the quality of their life for nothing. This is wrong.

I think the point you are confused about is the environmentalist notion that “pollution” is invariably bad. “Pollution” is probably an invalid concept, when you get right down to it. It package deals the notion that *anything* produced by Man is destructive. If that’s true, you should die right now, because no way are you, or anybody else, going to survive at all without “pollution”, including exhaling CO2. But that conveniently fits the environmentalist agenda too - the most consistent ones do identify that only without humanity would their “ideal” world be possible. (I’m not saying that you’re a deliberate environmentalist.)

The real issue is showing objective harm to somebody else. If somebody dumped a cyanide solution into a stream that left their property and went on to yours, and poisoned you as a result, you most certainly do have a right to sue them, and it might also be a criminal matter. They *are* violating your rights. On the other hand if somebody is careful to keep it on their own property, it is indeed their own business. This is not just a hypothetical, cyanide solutions are routinely used to leech out gold in low grade gold ore in otherwise marginal mines in sparsely populated areas.

So think: Objective harm, not: “Pollution”. And keep it in context. If you build your house next to a freeway that has lots of carbon monoxide during rush hour, the freeway was there first, you didn’t have to live there, and the CO levels are not lethal either.

Let me get something straight. If ten people dump cyanide into a river, and I die from it, do I have the right to sue all of them? Who’s to know whose cyanide did me in? Is it the person who happened to add the cyanide that pushed it above a lethal level?

If a nuclear power plant radiates a stream, and I eat a radiated fish and give birth to a deformed child, how do I know who to sue? I could have been radiated at any point in my life. How would I know that the fish caused it? How could I prove it?

If I developed lung cancer from carcenogenic chemicals in the air released from thirty factories in my city, can I sue all of them? I mean, whose carcenogens actually incited the mutation? How do I prove that it was actually the chemicals that caused the cancer and not just some coincidence? To paraphrase an argument Rand uses against socialism, how many corpses must pile up before we can conduct the proper correlational studies?

The car industry conducts recalls in a manner similar to that which you are suggesting. If there’s a defective part, they calculate how much it would cost to perform the recall, and then they calculate how much they would probably have to pay in settlements to people who sued. Only if it’s less damaging to do the recall does the company actually do it.

Now, no one’s forcing you to buy cars, so you don’t have to be impacted by this practice if you object. However, if someone’s polluting the air, I still have to breathe. Because of biological ties that reality thrusts upon us, the rules should not be the same for something which I have no choice but to consume.

I don’t understand why everyone’s acting like I’m saying Marx is right here, I’m just saying that you guys have interpreted certain things in a way that I don’t agree with.

As for unskinned, here would be a part of my response:

You said earlier that "an Objectivist government would literally spackle the country with nuclear power plants, which have no effect on the environment as long as there is a capitalist around to watch over the spent rods.

OK, fine. But who’s going to pay the capitalist to watch over the spent rods and why? The owner of the plants. What if he doesn’t think spent rods are harmful? Then what do you do? This, I believe is the problem. First you need right and wrong to develop principles. Then you need near universal acceptance of those principles. Then you need action upon those principles. Then you can say that the owner will pay for to trash the spent rod’s.

http://chemcases.com/nuclear/nc-13.htm

http://www.ncpa.org/iss/bud/pd112801b.html

Here are two sites that give an interesting idea. The unmanagability of radioactive waste comes from the fact that it should not be considered waste at all, but more fuel to be recycled. There are sites in England, France, and soon in Japan that are producing energy this way. The articles seem to suggest that the new wastes will be much less radioactive as they have been processed several times. One site even says that these materials will be so neutralized that they can be encased in class and stored the way more traditional hazmats are stored at sites such as Concord in Colorado. Furthermore, their volume will have been drastically reduced. This is experimental, but it is not pie in the sky.

Asking why it is still experimental, we are told that Jimmy Carter mandated the end of this research while he was riding the peace train. Again, socialist intervention is the problem. Noticing a pattern yet?

Another idea is that the issue of leakage from the “dry” slugs stored at places like Yucca can be stored in specially prepared facilities on frozen tundra in Greenland, where the water contamination issue is less important.

All these little issues can best be solved by capitalism. No matter how complicated a piece of praxis you toss at capitalism as a supposed proof of it’s naivete, the issue is ultimately best handled by capitalism. It isn’t a battle by battle thing, these victories represent a deeper issue. Here is a moral right: in any society the mind must be left free. The individual uses his mind to deal with a complex world. Capitalism isn’t about some ideal world, it’s that this is the ideal world for Capitalism. And we’re talking about El Dorado.

Let me get something straight. If ten people dump cyanide into a river, and I die from it, do I have the right to sue all of them? Who’s to know whose cyanide did me in? Is it the person who happened to add the cyanide that pushed it above a lethal level?

Under capitalism, someone has a right to fish the stream. Presumably the fish will die before you do. THis will happen the first time someone dumps and it will be put in the papers: “Local stream has been poisoned, fisherman pissed.”

Or, were you implying a scenario in which 10 different companies all dump cyanide on the same day at the same time, let’s call it the witching hour on Cyanide Dumping Day. If that is your argument, you have truly stumped me.

Of course, you get your water from the water company, don’t you? I don’t think I need to explain that one.

"If I developed lung cancer from carcenogenic chemicals in the air released from thirty factories in my city, can I sue all of them? I mean, whose carcenogens actually incited the mutation? How do I prove that it was actually the chemicals that caused the cancer and not just some coincidence? To paraphrase an argument Rand uses against socialism, how many corpses must pile up before we can conduct the proper correlational studies?

The car industry conducts recalls in a manner similar to that which you are suggesting. If there’s a defective part, they calculate how much it would cost to perform the recall, and then they calculate how much they would probably have to pay in settlements to people who sued. Only if it’s less damaging to do the recall does the company actually do it.

Now, no one’s forcing you to buy cars, so you don’t have to be impacted by this practice if you object. However, if someone’s polluting the air, I still have to breathe. Because of biological ties that reality thrusts upon us, the rules should not be the same for something which I have no choice but to consume.

I don’t understand why everyone’s acting like I’m saying Marx is right here, I’m just saying that you guys have interpreted certain things in a way that I don’t agree with."

It is inappropriate to compare products with pollutants for the reasons you have suggested. You can’t recall air. I think that if science demonstrates objectively that certain air pollutants cause lung cancer then it shouldn’t be difficult to establish a causal link between incidents of lung cancer and a factory that produces them. That is negligence or possibly manslaughter. I’m not sure. If this law is established and a company knows it might be doing something that would kill someone, then it won’t do it. Or it will lose a lot of money or the people in charge might be arrested.

But correlation is not sufficient. Example: “Power lines cause cancer! How many bodies have to pile up before we will acknowledge it.” And of course the correlation in the stats are very convincing to a socialist. Then we read that powerlines are generally over poorer neighborhoods and occupants of poorer neighborhoods generally smoke more or eat burnt fatty barbeque foods more often, the two main causes of cancer.

What I’m saying is, if there’s no way to prove whodunnit exactly, a system of “accuse and thou shalt be avenged” doesn’t work. Therefore it might be necessary to violate certain rights to prevent the violation of other rights. For example, if someone wrongs me, why shouldn’t it be in my hands to avenge the wrong? I am to turn the case over to the police because “it works out a lot better, empirically, that way.” The same thing comes into play in this discussion. Ideally, no one would pollute because it represents a tort. However, if people do pollute (and I’m talking about the negative kind), they should have to recompense those damaged by it. Because, empirically, it’s impractical to set the system up where people have to individually “sue” the polluter, it’s better, empirically, to say, “if you pollute, you must contribute towards the cleaning of your mess.” Even this isn’t a perfect solution, but because we’re dealing with a necessary imperfection (the destruction certain elements of the big picture environment as a consequence of human existence, or any existence) we have to set up a “common law” type of thing to make sure that this problem is addressed.

People’s rights are going to be violated when pollution is necessary. When you say, “we shouldn’t make the polluter pay, because they don’t choose to,” you are okaying the violation of the affected’s rights. If rights are going to be violated, therefore, it’s up to the government to create a mechanism that will limit the damage. I would propose a mechanism of penalizing polluters proportionally to their contribution to the problem, and applying this penalty money towards the fixing of the problem. Please stop implying my blasphemy. By raising questions, I’m following in the spirit of what created this philosophy. By saying that my questions are stupid without explaining your points in any way but a regurgitation of something I’ve already read, you’re not proving anything. I’ve read it. I understand what Ayn Rand said about the general principals.

Rand, however, does not provide logical backing for certain social constructs. For example, as I refered to earlier, she provides a somewhat empirically based argument for a police force (in The Virtue of Selfishness), but doesn’t drag out a long logical explanation. This might be because the idea of a police force is a social construct. An example of why this is NOT logical, as alluded to (possibly unintentionally) by NYRourk, is the fact that a society places a trust in the government that would imply that it is not corrupt. What if it is? There’s no possible way to completely prevent corruption from bringing down a government. We accept this as a necessary risk because “empirically, it just works better that way.” I apply this train of thought to the problem of pollution that has earned our philosophy ridicule outside of its own circle. I hear the arguments, and I don’t see adequate reasoning supporting our side. Call it devil’s advocate, but until I can figure it out myself, or one of you can, I can’t just posit that “we are right because we tend to be right about other things.”

Also, to be fair, Rand herself said that people who violate the rights of others can’t claim possession of rights of their own.

I don’t understand why everyone’s acting like I’m saying Marx is right here, I’m just saying that you guys have interpreted certain things in a way that I don’t agree with.

It’s because you forget whose “house” you are in. This board has a specific purpose, and a specific focus, that involves the discussion and promotion of Objectivism and it’s principles. That purpose and that focus DO NOT involve spreading socialist tenets, or advocating that the government should be violating the rights of innocent people in order to “protect” rights.

donnywithana,

Therefore it might be necessary to violate certain rights to prevent the violation of other rights.

If you’re really talking about rights here, that the rights of rational men in a free society cannot conflict with each other. So, if you’re okay with violating some “rights” to uphold other “rights”, by what means do you choose which “rights” are okay to violate for the sake of which other “rights”? Perhaps, because any business may be defrauding the public, we should tax every business who may be defrauding the public (i.e., any business), to protect people’s right against being defrauded? Or perhaps, since every customer of every store might be shoplifting, we should impose a fine on anyone who has ever walked in a store to protect the rights of the store owners to keep their property?

For example, if someone wrongs me, why shouldn’t it be in my hands to avenge the wrong? I am to turn the case over to the police because “it works out a lot better, empirically, that way.”

No, the real reason that we must defer our moral right of retaliatory force to the government is to uphold the Rule of Law, which is a principle. Without this, society would devolve into anarchy, with vigalante gangs roaming around dispensing whatever twisted versions of law and justice they might accept. I’m surprised that you missed that point in your reading of Rand.

However, if people do pollute (and I’m talking about the negative kind), they should have to recompense those damaged by it. Because, empirically, it’s impractical to set the system up where people have to individually “sue” the polluter, it’s better, empirically, to say, “if you pollute, you must contribute towards the cleaning of your mess.”

How does this follow? Why does the “impracticality” of a huge number of individual suits necessitate empowering the government with the power to tax all companies that “pollute”, regardless of whether their pollution is actually hurting others? A flurry of individual lawsuits is not necessary-- if the pollution affects a wide number of people, one can always bring a class action suit against the company in question. Maybe you meant something else by this passage, but as it is, I can’t make sense of it.

To everyone else,

Could nuisance laws be used in some way to address this problem?

Ok, let me try to make a parallel to what I’m advocating here.

If you have a child and don’t want to take care of it, do you have to? Is it your responsibility? Objectivists point out that people could donate towards helping these children voluntarily, but Rand says that we should only help people if an emergency situation puts them in immediate harm.

Now, if you follow Objectivism to its end, you would find that because no one actually has any “responsibility” towards anyone else, the “best” possible solution would be simply letting these children starve, because what right do they have to something they did not produce? To help them would be altruistic.

Do you agree with this paradigm? Or would it be possible that since children don’t operate under the same rules that adults do, we might consider changing the rules for them?

Critics of Objectivism say that we dream of a world of belching smoke stacks. I’m trying to find out if this is an accurate assessment. When I say people should be taxed for pollution, I’m saying that they should be fined based on how much they actually pollute. This isn’t saying they should be fined for something they did not do. It’s just saying that we shouldn’t wait until someone gets hurt to penalize them for it. Do you believe that someone needs to be hurt before negligence can be pointed out? Is attempted murder alright if no one actually gets hurt? Pollution doesn’t operate under the same rules that assault or murder do. The same rules that apply to those things don’t work with pollution. Because pollution is different, it should be subject to different rules. Can someone argue with that assertion without bringing in the fact that I’m advocating oppression? I’m not! I’m saying that if someone DOES something wrong, they should be penalized accordingly. Someone shouldn’t have to sue them personally.

You (donny) apparently ignored most of what I said, so I am not inclined to continue this, but I will try once more: Define the concept “pollution”. And explain how there can be *anything whatsoever* emitted by human beings or their creations that doesn’t fall under this (putative) concept.

Do you believe that someone needs to be hurt before negligence can be pointed out?

Do you ‘believe’ that punishment should be administered before a crime is commited?