I still would like to know who is going to judge who is responsible for what (a judge?), what the remedy is for offenses (a payment?), who gives that individual [judge] authority (?), and how that authority remains pure and uncorrupted(?)?
These questions can be redirected to the bureaucrats that dream up environmental regulation also. So what is the point? We already know human beings are volitional and fallible. What is the guarantee that an eco-statist isn’t going to remain uncorrupted?
There is no guarantee for the eco-statist, and there is no guarantee for the capitalist judge. But there are safeguards. The best safeguard is a body of law that protects individual rights. By setting up regulatory laws that damage the protection of rights – and when we talk about polution, we are talking about property rights – we are acting contrary to our goals.
The thing is, you have to look at this from a marginal benefit standpoint.
AisA already responded to this. But I think it is worth responding to again, so: No, I don’t. I have to look at it from a principled standpoint. There is no practical benifit of trying to protect property rights by denying property rights.
Now, I’m claiming that pollution has a negative impact on life that outweighs the positive impact that the right to pollute may have on anyone. Although your polluting act will benefit you, the polluting acts of others will harm you more. Thus, if we all agree not to pollute, we all win. We have to enforce this agreement, however, and the best way to do this is with a penalty system. The only entity with the implicit right to impose a penalty is the government. Do you see where I’m going with this, or am I being ridiculous?
If I pollute on my property, and everyone else pollutes on their own property, and we all take precautions to ensure that the pollution does not damage any one else’s property, then nobody is being harmed.
An extreme example: We pollute the moon. Who is harmed? (nobody)
A more realistic example: We transport nuclear fuel to Yucca mountain, which is surrounded by military bases and in the center of a spot where nobody is allowed to live anyway. Who is harmed? (nobody)
To follow up the last example: The truck driver from one of the nuclear plants falls asleep at the wheel, crashes his car and spills nuclear waste all over the center of a major metropolitan area. Who is harmed? (get your calculator) What happens then? The insurance company compensates the victims, and raises the freight company’s rates. A truck driver loses his job. The freight company changes its hiring practices. A repeat of the incident is less likely to occur. In otherwords, the same thing that happens when any other accident occurs that harms someone. – This is “the penalty system” at work. Only now it isn’t violating anyone’s rights.
For anyone who is interested in this topic, I suggest the book The Skeptical Environmentalist: Measuring the Real State of the World by Bjorn Lomborg. It doesn’t cover the legal/political side of environmentalism, but it is a refreshing and informative perspective on countless doomsday scenarios.
NewYorkRoark, Speaking of doomsday scenarios, what makes you think we are going to overpopulate? Have you been channeling Thomas Malthus? (I’m joking).
Seriously, though, there is one resource that only grows with the population: the human resource. It is what has shattered every overpopulation theory ever dreamt up, and it will continue to do so. Every time humans are deprived of something (food, space, etc) somebody puts their mind to solving the problem.
There was a great link on one of these threads, I don’t remember where. It concerned the problem of horseshit in the 1900’s and what on earth people would do about it in the year 2000. That doesn’t seem to be an issue anymore. Why? The human resource.
Again on the topic of overpopulation, the birth rates are lowest in the more developed and capitalistic countries. In these countries, children become more expensive because they cannot be used as farm hands. they have to be educated to be productive, and by that time they are out on their own anyway.