Rand, however, does not provide logical backing for certain social constructs.
I take offense to this. Just because you haven’t read all that you bloddy should be reading does not mean that Rand did not explain the things you’re confused about. You shouldn’t assume such things.
If you have a child
Okay, now you’re really pissing me off! :wacko:
There’s already a thread on this and I do NOT accept “changing the rules” for children as you imply. And you are being highly annoying by constantly flitting about bringing up 10,000 issues when you need to stick to ONE until we can hash it out.
And it is a personal pet peeve of mine for a person to bring children into an argument as a means of silencing reason. And you’ve done that TWICE in this thread.
What I’m saying is, if there’s no way to prove whodunnit exactly, a system of “accuse and thou shalt be avenged” doesn’t work.
Not all murders can be proven. By your logic, the government would be justified in calling out the population of every city and decimating them, Roman style, (killing every tenth man) just to keep us “in line.”
You seriously need to examine the ideas that you are advocating. I don’t know about you, but I take ideas seriously and your ideas are seriously insane.
The simple fact is that you cannot and should not punish people without proof. If crimes happen and nobody can prove them, this is unfortunate, but your attempts to stop this creates a MONSTEROUS injustice that is at least ten times as great as the crimes which, in your mind, “necessitate” it.
Therefore it might be necessary to violate certain rights to prevent the violation of other rights.
You are now embracing open contradiction. I hope you’re proud of yourself.
Now come on man! What is your freaking problem? If a source of pollution can be PROVEN to be harming people, the law will step in and prevent it. There’s no reason at that point that the law wouldn’t act to stop, or at least watch, all other people who are using that substance or process. Don’t you have a clue how the law works? It has this thing called precedent…
There’s no possible way to completely prevent corruption from bringing down a government. We accept this as a necessary risk because “empirically, it just works better that way.”
You’re ignoring the fact that Capitalism is, by its nature, the LEAST corruptable form of government, and that corruption is essentially caused by the nature of non-capitalistic government.
But oh wait, you’d know that if you had done your homework instead of coming here and running your mouth off.
You come onto this board all half-cocked, openly attacking the philosophy of Ayn Rand, and you don’t have the common decency to actually READ that philosophy, nor do you do this in the debate forum, where it would at least be halfway appropriate.
If you’re here to debate, do it there. If you’re not, then address your concerns in the form of QUESTIONS and not STATEMENTS.