Objectivism Vs. Environmentalism?

Rand, however, does not provide logical backing for certain social constructs.

I take offense to this. Just because you haven’t read all that you bloddy should be reading does not mean that Rand did not explain the things you’re confused about. You shouldn’t assume such things.

If you have a child

Okay, now you’re really pissing me off! :wacko:

There’s already a thread on this and I do NOT accept “changing the rules” for children as you imply. And you are being highly annoying by constantly flitting about bringing up 10,000 issues when you need to stick to ONE until we can hash it out.

And it is a personal pet peeve of mine for a person to bring children into an argument as a means of silencing reason. And you’ve done that TWICE in this thread.

What I’m saying is, if there’s no way to prove whodunnit exactly, a system of “accuse and thou shalt be avenged” doesn’t work.

Not all murders can be proven. By your logic, the government would be justified in calling out the population of every city and decimating them, Roman style, (killing every tenth man) just to keep us “in line.”

You seriously need to examine the ideas that you are advocating. I don’t know about you, but I take ideas seriously and your ideas are seriously insane.

The simple fact is that you cannot and should not punish people without proof. If crimes happen and nobody can prove them, this is unfortunate, but your attempts to stop this creates a MONSTEROUS injustice that is at least ten times as great as the crimes which, in your mind, “necessitate” it.

Therefore it might be necessary to violate certain rights to prevent the violation of other rights.

You are now embracing open contradiction. I hope you’re proud of yourself.

Now come on man! What is your freaking problem? If a source of pollution can be PROVEN to be harming people, the law will step in and prevent it. There’s no reason at that point that the law wouldn’t act to stop, or at least watch, all other people who are using that substance or process. Don’t you have a clue how the law works? It has this thing called precedent…

There’s no possible way to completely prevent corruption from bringing down a government. We accept this as a necessary risk because “empirically, it just works better that way.”

You’re ignoring the fact that Capitalism is, by its nature, the LEAST corruptable form of government, and that corruption is essentially caused by the nature of non-capitalistic government.

But oh wait, you’d know that if you had done your homework instead of coming here and running your mouth off.

You come onto this board all half-cocked, openly attacking the philosophy of Ayn Rand, and you don’t have the common decency to actually READ that philosophy, nor do you do this in the debate forum, where it would at least be halfway appropriate.

If you’re here to debate, do it there. If you’re not, then address your concerns in the form of QUESTIONS and not STATEMENTS.

… you bloddy should be reading …

Did you mean bloddy-with-and-extra-o-and-one-less-d. :wacko:

Suggestion: Seriously though, I have a suggestion about this thread: change it into a debate, in the debate sub-forum. I think having two voices will keep the discussion focused. Just a thought.

Did you mean bloddy-with-and-extra-o-and-one-less-d. :stuck_out_tongue:

Yes… yes, I did. :wacko:

Ok. I’m going to try and settle this down. Feel free to jump down my throat after this.

In terms of things that Rand doesn’t explain…I have read what I bloody well should have. I agree with it almost completely. However, I’m pointing out that certain premises that Rand uses as bases for her arguments are based on values.

Here’s what I mean. The mosquito is an animal that can not survive on its own. It requires the input of other animals to survive. According to logic, the mosquito’s way of life is immoral. The mosquito may utilize a tiger’s blood in order to reproduce, and that tiger might be alive through immoral practices too. The tiger can’t actually produce its own life force, it must feed on animals in order to live. This is immoral, according to logic. The tiger might feed off of a rabbit in order to live (I don’t know if tigers actually eat rabbits…whatever). The rabbit also can not produce what it needs to survive, and must feed off of grass. This, according to logic, is immoral. The plant must use light energy which it didn’t produce, minerals from the soil that it didn’t put there, etc. In fact, nothing that lives can survive without the consumption of something else.

Rand asserts that this type of consumption is not immoral, because it’s a fact of life. That’s fair, but it’s still agreeing that we must violate certain rights in order to achieve other rights. In other words, the life of the rabbit is worth the sacrifice of the plant, and the life of the tiger is worth the sacrifice of the rabbit.

We as humans assert that our lives are worth the sacrifices made by our environments. This is not an objective truth, but because we exist, we must accept this as true in order to continue to exist. It is, as Rand recognizes, a necessary concession, but it is a values statement. We value our lives above the rights of the organisms and bodies that produce the energy that keeps us alive. We can define what “we” are, but that doesn’t give us any objective right to the life of something not “human.”

The point I’m making in this forum is this. I understand that we as Objectivists hold human life as the highest value, but this is not an objective truth, it is a value statement. Thus, we are falsifying reality in a way that is necessary to continue our own existence. What I mean is, if we don’t say “we as humans have the right to the lives of things that aren’t human,” we will die. Because we don’t want to die, this makes sense. We overlook the “monsterous injustice” perpetrated upon the innocent plants, animals, photons, etc because we don’t feel that they have rights in the first place. This isn’t an objective fact, it’s just something we hold to be true in order to survive. Not to mention that we’re the only ones around who actually worry about the rightness or wrongness of the whole arrangement.

If we do falsify this part of reality, however, in order to grant ourselves rights that do not exist independently of our recognition of them, we are faced with the consequences of having to shift the rest of our views in order to incorporate this falsification.

Why is anarchy bad? If I do whatever I want for my own benefit, why isn’t that good? Obviously, because then others will do the same, and the result will inevitably be catastrophic. So we AGREE to not have anarchy, and instead put a government in place to make sure that we are all civil. Governments don’t just exist, they are not a necessity of life, but they streamline the process so the empirical result is better.

In the same vein, we have a police force to make sure that we don’t violate these rights that we’ve set up for ourselves. Police forces are not facts of life, they are constructions that are linked back to the idea that people “have” certain rights, and these rights must be protected. Something that violates our conception of what someone deserves to be protected against is “outlawed.” For example, murder, theft, assault, etc are banned from practice because we see that someone only benefits at the cost of someone else, and nothing positive is produced. What about the feeling of happiness from kicking someone’s ass? We know this to be an irrational benefit, and therefore don’t recognize it as a productive end.

But this is a forum for discussion of pollution, and so I’ll get to that point. If someone pollutes, is there any objective truth stating that they shouldn’t? Of course not. If you do something that produces a marginal profit for you (your benefit from polluting is more than the harm it does to you), then there’s nothing that actually will stop you. Just like there’s nothing that will actually stop you from killing someone or stealing their stuff. However, we agree that killing and stealing is wrong, and so we create a mechanism that says, “If you kill, this will be your punishment.” This punishment is not existent by itself, it requires social support to exist. I’m saying, if someone does something that will harm others, they should be stopped.

If you kill someone, they’re not responsible for suing you. They’re too busy being dead. A representative of society says, “Hey, we made a rule against that,” and you are punished by society. Why is there no rule against contributing directly towards someone’s demise? If everyone pollutes, and I lose a year of life because of it, who compensates me for it? I’ve surrendered a year of life, and what have I gained? Apparently very little, except maybe lower prices, because producers won’t be responsible for paying for cleaning things up.

Rand asserts that this type of consumption is not immoral, because it’s a fact of life. That’s fair, but it’s still agreeing that we must violate certain rights in order to achieve other rights.

What you’re saying here is nonsense. Tigers don’t have RIGHTS. Individual Rights are derived from human ability to reason. Animals eating other animals is natural, there is nothing immoral about it. If your example was humans eating humans, it would be immoral – but Rand would never propose it be done. You, on the other hand, are trying to justify such behavior with this line of argument.

What aspect of reason sets it up as the granter of rights? Does a tiger recognize our reason as a reason not to eat us? Is there anything that would actually make a cannibal now want to eat you? Or is it just that we can agree that eating each other is bad, because we’re all of the same type of being, and we use reason to realize that “rights” are beneficial to have?

What aspect of reason sets it up as the granter of rights?

Our defining characteristic as human beings is our faculty of reason, and we must be permitted to use it freely in order for us to survive, which means that other human beings cannot initiate force against us to prevent us from doing so.

Does a tiger recognize our reason as a reason not to eat us?

It doesn’t matter because morality depends on human choice and action, not on the behavior of nature (including animal behavior). A tiger makes no moral choice when it tries to eat us, we cannot charge it with violating our rights.

Or is it just that we can agree that eating each other is bad, because we’re all of the same type of being, and we use reason to realize that “rights” are beneficial to have?

We don’t have rights because they’re beneficial, we have them because they’re part of our nature as human beings.

(P.S. if any of you more articulate Objectivist posters out there can explain this better than I can, feel free to do so, but I think I got the gist of it right)

I would debate whether or not rights are “part of our nature.” I might understand why you would say this; is it because in order to live, we must produce, and no one has the right to what I produce besides me? I mean, I agree with this, but there is no actual mechanism for making someone not simply take something from you besides one constructed by a society. Rights are not simply a fact of existence, they must be agreed on. If someone does not choose to use reason, they can do a bunch of really counterproductive things. For example, “I don’t need to produce something that I can simply steal from someone else.” We, as Objectivists, say, “No, you shouldn’t be able to do that.” Thus, a law is established. Another thing they might do is say, “That person’s existence makes mine more difficult. If I killed him, this would no longer be a problem.” Objectivists find the wrong in this, too. However, what happens when someone says, “Why should I limit the toxic chemicals that I dump? As long as the effects of my pollution don’t begin causing problems until after I’m dead, there’s no reason for me not to dump them.” Apparently Objectivists on this forum don’t see that as wrong. I’m trying to figure out why.

The mosquito is an animal that can not survive on its own. (more plant and animal stuff snipped)

Okay, as Captain Nate pointed out, you have no idea what the Objectivist position is here. Plants and animals do not have rights or morality. Further, it’s becoming clearer the more you speak that you do not understand other parts of Objectivism and it’s principles very well.

Secondly, you need to stop speaking in terms of “we” Objectivists, particularly when discussing values. Objectivists DO NOT intrinsically value human life as their highest value. Rather, most Objectivists specifically value THEIR life as their highest value. I won’t be presumptuous enough to speak for all of them. Any other human life they value is dependent upon CONTEXT.

The objective truth (that you refer to) is that we NEED the environment to survive. We NEED to make use of the environment to produce things that allow us to live our lives as human beings. This doesn’t mean living to the minimal standard of simply staying alive, although we need it on a rudimentary level too, but rather we need it to live fruitful, productive lives meeting higher level needs and desires. This means industry and pollution are necessary, at least until manufacturing means are developed to eliminate pollution.

Moderator Mode: ON

No further discussion will be tolerated in this thread advocating the government violating the rights of individuals under the guise of protecting other people’s rights. I, and I assume others, understand that you think this is okay, but it’s discussion on this forum IS NOT. It doesn’t matter how you rephrase it, it all comes out the same. You want to violate the rights of some people without the burden of actually demonstrating that they have done anything to violate the rights of others, because you see it as an inconvenient or impractical to be burdened with proof. Also, if you want to discuss the benefits of Socialism, do it specifically in the Debate forum, or find a Socialist forum. The only place these discussion will permissible is in the Debate forum, under the rules and guidelines set up between the debate participants.

Moderator Mode: OFF

I would debate whether or not rights are “part of our nature.”

Then perhaps you did not really understand Ayn Rand’s writings as you claimed.

I might understand why you would say this; is it because in order to live, we must produce, and no one has the right to what I produce besides me? I mean, I agree with this, but there is no actual mechanism for making someone not simply take something from you besides one constructed by a society.

What are you saying here? That without a lawful society, very little (except your own use of retaliatory force) stops someone from violating your rights? This is true, but it does not nullify your rights. Rights don’t come into existence as a result of laws, laws should come into existance as a result of our rights – to protect our rights, not to create them.

In terms of things that Rand doesn’t explain…I have read what I bloody well should have.

No you clearly, by your statements, have NOT.

I agree with it almost completely. However, I’m pointing out that certain premises that Rand uses as bases for her arguments are based on values.

And she traces every last one of those values back to reality, making them proven facts.

According to logic, the mosquito’s way of life is immoral.

According to WHAT logic?

You couldn’t have this more backwards if you were trying. Morality is a concept which applies to humans because of our essential nature. Animals don’t have volition; and aren’t CAPABLE of making choices as such… therefore a concept such as morality (i.e. choosing between right and wrong) doesn’t APPLY to them.

Rand asserts that this type of consumption is not immoral, because it’s a fact of life.

She asserts nothing of the sort. You’re obviously extremely confused!

We as humans assert that our lives are worth the sacrifices made by our environments.

You’ve taken those words so far out of their contexts that all you’re left with is nonsense. Literally, your statements may as well be gibberish. I’m not saying this to insult you; I mean that literally. I don’t even know where to start! :wacko: That goes for the other statements you made following that one as well.

For some reason you’re starting from the unstated premise that nature or animals posess rights for some reason… when they do NOT and by definition CANNOT. “Rights” is a concept that applies to rational, volitional beings due to their essemtial nature. Inanimate matter, mindless plants, and nonrational animals could not by definition posess rights. You think that you can get away with your contradictory attempts to violate rights by accusing Objectivism of the same, but you won’t get away with it. Your nonsensical definition-switching, context-dropping, concept-stealing illogic doesn’t hold water.

I’m not even going to quote your madness about “innocent” plants and animals. Put down the hippie pipe. Animals and plants do not and cannot posess rights. Nor can they posess “guilt” or “innocence.”

Your accusations of Objectivism “falsifying reality” is an insult and a joke. You have much to learn.

Your subjectivist rant about how it is in peoples’ interests to murder and steal and “pollute” is telling of your character I am sure. Maybe you would do those things. However if you actually apply REASON and think in terms of PRINCIPLES and realize the essential nature of man, then you would see that it is NOT in anyone’s selfish interest to violate rights.

Why is there no rule against contributing directly towards someone’s demise?

There would be. If you could PROVE it. Why are you so afraid of this? By your logic, you sound like you’re just going to grab a gun and start shooting people that look at you cockeyed because the law might not recognize that they’re all conspiring to kill you… you paranoid lunatic.

Now…

I don’t want a reply to this. I want you to understand and admit that you DON’T understand the Objectivist position and that you are handily throttling a straw man. The more you speak, the more confused the issue gets. Take my well-intentioned advice and SHUT UP.

I mean that. Shut your metaphorical mouth and go to the library and LEARN the Objectivist position. If you can’t be bothered to do that, then start new threads elsewhere where you ask SPECIFIC questions about ESSENTIAL issues and DO NOT be stating your ignorant opinions.

I think the moderators have been more than patient enough with you and it’s time this thread was closed.

Okay, that was a little mean, Danny. I got a bit frustrated because you are making this a game of whack-a-mole. You raise up ten derivative issues and won’t stick to one issue so that someone can answer you. You claim to understand Objectivism when you clearly don’t, and you brought in my personal pet peeve by trying to use “children” in a debate.

But I hope that I at least showed that you DON’T understand the Objectivist position. Please, PLEASE just accept that and do your best to learn the truth.

Inspector’s right. I have been too patient, and now this is whirlpooling out of control.

Thread Closed.