*** Mod’s note: Split from a related topic on Kant’s influence on modern art. - sN ***
OK, I’ll bite. What is the Objectivist theory of music? As opposed to the Objectivist theory of art. A reference would be handy.
The Objectivist theory is that music is art, despite not complying with Rand’s definition and requirements of art.
I asked:
Shouldn’t music be removed from the realm of legitimate art forms until the time that there is a theory of music which meets the Objectivist requirements for all art forms, i.e., a theory that is a least as objective and detailed as, say, Kandinsky’s theory of color?
Kendall replied:
Only if you’re a rationalist, and definitions determine reality.
Why would a person be a “rationalist” if he expected music to fit within the Objectivist definition of art and to comply with Rand’s statements about which characteristics something must have in order to qualify as art according to Objectivism?
Music is pretty ostensibly an art form.
“Pretty ostensibly”? Does that mean that music is “seemingly” or “superficially” an art form?
It’s issue is how it functions as representational.
Now you seem to be using the word “representational” in a different way than what Objectivism uses it as the basis for rejecting abstract visual art. Objectivism considers abstract paintings and other forms of abstract art to be non-art because they are not representational in the sense that they do not contain semblances of identifiable objects.
Representational paintings contain images of objects and people. Representational novels include descriptions of people, things and events. There is no need to assert that people will some day discover in what way such art forms “function as representational.” No future research and exploration is required.
On the other hand, music and abstract paintings do not contain such semblances of identifiable objects, and, therefore, are not representational, and they will never become representational in the same sense that art works which contain semblences of identifiable objects are representational.
If music gets a break in the name of future discoveries which will explain how music affects us, then abstract art should get the same break (and, as I’ve been saying, about one hundred years ago Kandinsky had already been much more objective and detailed in exploring the “language” of abstract color and form than any Objectivist, or anyone else, has been in exploring the “language” of music).
This is a bit like claiming that goats should be removed from the classification of valid animal forms until such time as we’ve mapped it’s genome.
No. The Objecivist position that music and architecture are valid art forms, and that abstract painting and sculpture are not, is like defining “goat” as “a horned, bearded, cloven-hoofed mammal,” and then claiming that a horse is a type of goat despite its not having horns, a beard or cloven hooves, and asserting that it will be up to future zoologists to discover why horses are goats, and then saying that a donkey is most definitely not a type goat, since it doesn’t have horns, a beard or cloven hooves, and anyone who thinks that a donkey is a type of goat is accepting a contradiction, trying to destroy man’s mind, and he’s doing so because Kant was the father of modern biological taxonomy.
J