Will some of you go to OCON?
I wonât be attending, but I recently got an email saying Jordan Peterson is going to appear. Heâs to do a panel with Dave Rubin, Yaron Brook, and Onkar Ghate. That session will probably make its way to YouTube. I find Peterson interesting. Iâd characterize him as a cross between Joseph Campbell and Dr. Laura. Heâs certainly not an Objectivist.
7 hours ago, Ninth Doctor said:
I find Peterson interesting. Iâd characterize him as a cross between Joseph Campbell and Dr. Laura. Heâs certainly not an Objectivist.
Carl Jung more so.
From what I gather, he was only invited because of his free speech position. But his viewpoint isnât particularly special, and he doesnât offer any new approach. Certainly nothing from an egoistic perspective on rights.
7 minutes ago, Eiuol said:
Carl Jung more so.
From what I gather, he was only invited because of his free speech position. But his viewpoint isnât particularly special, and he doesnât offer any new approach. Certainly nothing from an egoistic perspective on rights.
Jung was one of Campbellâs primary influences, so weâre on the same page. Unless you meant to swap out Dr. Laura. Petersonâs view on religious belief reminds me of her. I recall a quote from her, paraphrasing it amounted to: everyone needs a religion, so pick one.
That was a good panel-discussion. It was interesting to see the differences between the two sides get highlighted so clearly, to hear Petersen make counter-arguments on core topics that would be familiar to most of an OCON audience, and to see people debating things with civility.
I was there. It was a great week.
I havenât check yet if we can see me in this video. At least the back of my head. đ
A funny segment is 30:20 to 30:58. At the end Jordan Peterson says, âThe rumor is that finance guys have no soul.â
That reminded me of an actuarial joke: What is an actuary? A mathematician without a personality. đ
On 7/3/2018 at 5:25 AM, softwareNerd said:
to hear Petersen make counter-arguments on core topics that would be familiar to most of an OCON audience
When he talks about philosophy, he says a whole lot in order to say nothing at all. âTheyâre some other form of truthâ. 1:04:00 - 1:05:35. It sounds like heâs trying to be profound, but doesnât have a point.
Itâs unfortunate he was there. He only muddied the discussion.
Salmieri was very articulate and brought clarity.
2 hours ago, Eiuol said:
Itâs unfortunate he was there. He only muddied the discussion.
There wouldnât have been a real discussion without him. It would have been Disneyworld, where everyone agrees with everyone else and never learns much new.
Itâs fine if he disagrees. But there are much better options than a psychologist trying to talk as if he were a philosopher and ends up saying a whole lot of nothing. He was basically talking to himself the whole time - a very opaque way of speaking that requires having already studied other things he has said. Iâm fine when he talks about his knowledge gained as a practicing therapist, as he did with his recent book, but past thatâŚ
If he had good counter arguments, or spoke clearly, Iâd have a different opinion.
In other words, I donât know what he was supposed to bring to the table.
His âway of speakingâ I think youâre referring to his literary/Freudian approach to philosophy. While one might criticize it as being a flawed epistemology to bring to philosophy, it does have its place, and is actually the more common way day-to-day people get philosophy: from tales. Objectivists would do well to learn the approach and counters to the approach.
On âwhat he bringsâ, a speaker often needs a foil. Salmieri could have stood up and given a lecture with only his own content and it would have been far more bland, and he likely would not have made all the points he ended up making. A socratic approach can can bring out points that a lecture wouldnât; but, more importantly, the âdramaâ and tension is engaging. Most of the day-to-day dispersion of philosophy is done by the socratic approach: families and friends just chatting about stuff (not to mention TV). Objectivists would do well to practice the approach.
Finally, Peterson is the âintellectual of the momentâ. I know Hillary supporters, who did not know he was associated with the right, but had read his NY Time bestseller book and loved/recommended it. To have him on the stage, to present some of his opinions (as weak as they may be), to an audience interested in intellectual trends, is a value in itself. The fact that many in that audience like some aspects about Petersen makes it even more valuable to see how his ground is so shaky on some topics.
With that said, tastes differ. I suppose some in that paying audience âwanted their money backâ. I would guess that the majority thought it was worth the price of admission.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4lp\_raQtc1Q
Yaron Brook Show with Greg Salmieri & Onkar Ghate Discussing Conversation with Jordan Peterson
8 hours ago, softwareNerd said:
His âway of speakingâ I think youâre referring to his literary/Freudian approach to philosophy
Not exactly. I didnât have any particular issue with him in the earlier portions. He wasnât trying to be a philosopher, mostly just discussing ideas relevant to his professional expertise. But when he was getting into a discussion of objectivity, notions of truth, it turned into a lot of jargon that wouldnât even resemble day-to-day discussion, and not even the jargon a philosopher uses. Brook isnât a philosopher himself either, and offered some ideas, but he doesnât try to talk beyond his expertise.
8 hours ago, softwareNerd said:
Salmieri could have stood up and given a lecture with only his own content and it would have been far more bland, and he likely would not have made all the points he ended up making.
Youâre right, it should be a discussion, not some kind of lecture. But thatâs how Peterson talked. He was talking as if it were a lecture.
8 hours ago, softwareNerd said:
to an audience interested in intellectual trends, is a value in itself.
There are plenty of people available who are part of ongoing intellectual trends. Why Peterson specifically? Forget if heâs right or wrong, his importance has been vastly inflated. From what I can tell, itâs just because Rubin asked to bring Peterson. I donât know if itâs true, but they already know each other.
On 7/10/2018 at 7:54 AM, merjet said:
A funny segment is 30:20 to 30:58. At the end Jordan Peterson says, âThe rumor is that finance guys have no soul.â
That reminded me of an actuarial joke: What is an actuary? A mathematician without a personality. đ
Good one.
On â7â/â10â/â2018 at 7:54 AM, merjet said:
A funny segment is 30:20 to 30:58. At the end Jordan Peterson says, âThe rumor is that finance guys have no soul.â
That reminded me of an actuarial joke: What is an actuary? A mathematician without a personality. đ
I think it is funnier (and more likely true) the other way around. ![]()