I was not sure where to post this. It isn’t really a question about Objectivism, or even necessarily some Objectivists, but it’s somewhat aimed in the direction of a trend I’ve seen in many O’ists. It’s even a trait I noticed and still do notice in myself.
Why is it we, not as Objectivists but as analyzers of ideas, are not merely critical of the ideas espoused by any given philosopher but also of the moral worth of that philosopher?
Let’s take Bertrand Russell as an example, just because he’s someone I’ve been increasingly interested in. He had some very bad philosophic positions, that I consider to be completely inconsistent with reality. However, as a person I find him to be very admirable. There were, of course, the socialistic tendencies. But are we to judge every philosopher by their system of moral valuation? Is that what makes us not only in contention but oft times repulsed?
I ask, because as Objectivists we take the moral worth of a person to be based on the application of rationality, consistently, in one’s life and thoughts I don. Is it that, if someone disagrees as to just what reason and rationality are, they are acting immorally? I don’t think a man like Russell was ever thinking “To Hell with what is logical, I am going to do whatever it is I want.”. That goes for most philosophers as well.
Philosophers are always willing to accept what reality is.
“There can’t be a practical reason for believing what isn’t true. I rule it out, it’s impossible. Either something is true or it isn’t. If it is true, you should believe. If it isn’t true, you shouldn’t.”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AQ-n3EnM2CA
Just using ol’ Bertrand as an example here. I am wondering what is the line at which we can judge not only a philosophy but the person who advocates it